╌>

When Economics Failed

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  9 years ago  •  23 comments

When Economics Failed

Original article by Noah Smith - BloombergView
-------------------------------------

AT LEAST WE KNOW WHEN HURRICANES WILL HIT.
PHOTOGRAPHER: MARK WILSON/GETTY IMAGES

When people come up to me and declare that economists are charlatans, they usually mention how economists failed to predict the Great Recession. This is true. No mainstream macroeconomic model of the day managed to anticipate that the largest, longest economic downturn since the Great Depression was imminent, until it was already under way.

Macroeconomists typically respond that forecasting isn’t their job. The economy has all kinds of things going on at any given time, they say -- too much randomness and noise to allow a reliable forecast. The best they can do, macroeconomists will say, is to predict the effects of specific policies.

This defense is weak. If the economy is dominated by random noise, that noise will also permeate the data that is used to validate macroeconomic models. If forecasting is impossible, then picking the right policy-evaluation model will also be impossible. Also, the inability to forecast is often a clue that a model is just plain wrong .

So forecasting actually is important, and macroeconomic models are bad at it. There’s even a whole line of research dedicated to showing just how bad even the most advanced models are at predicting things like output and inflation.

My favorite paper in this literature is by Refet Gurkaynak, Burcin Kisacikoglu, and Barbara Rossi. In 2013, they took some of the most advanced modern macroeconomic models then available -- called DSGE, for dynamic stochastic general equilibrium -- and tested them against some very simple models called autoregressive (AR) models. DSGE models are very big, complicated things -- they rely on tons of assumptions about consumers, companies, technology and the government. An AR model is just a single equation -- just about the simplest forecasting model you can possibly imagine. In principle, the sheer complexity of the DSGE models should make them better at forecasting the macroeconomy.

But as it turned out, the super-simple AR models won as many comparisons as they lost. That means that top-of-the-line macroeconomic models, for all their complexity and difficulty, were close to useless for forecasting, at least as recently as four years ago.

In the intervening years, macroeconomists have been working hard to augment DSGE models with new elements that make them better at fitting past data. But macroeconomists are also increasingly experimenting with forecasting models that don’t make so many assumptions about economic relationships. In an interesting and highly sophisticated new paper , economists Andrea Carriero, Ana Galvao and George Kapetanios examined a wide class of macro forecasting models to understand how best to predict the economy.

Carriero et al. don’t just test a wide array of models. They also look at multiple developed countries -- something that relatively few macroeconomists, especially those based in the U.S., tend to do. The authors focus on predicting just two things -- output and inflation.

Their findings are discouraging. There is no type of model that is clearly the best. Different models work better at different time horizons, for different historical time periods, and for different variables. That implies that forecasting successes are mostly due to luck. Economists’ favorite models, such as DSGE, seem to be better at forecasting inflation at a few time horizons, but even this modest victory is probably accidental.

The good old super-simple AR model, as in past studies, wins about as much as it loses, despite going up against fearsomely sophisticated competitors. As the forecasting horizons get longer, the simplest models start to do just as well or better than the others.

What’s more, adding more than a few predictors doesn’t really improve forecasts. That’s discouraging, because it means that macroeconomic data just doesn’t have much useful information in it. The old Wall Street joke that “all financially useful data costs money, which is why macro data is free” seems to hold true.

All this adds up to a pessimistic conclusion -- recessions just aren’t very predictable from economic data. The reason economists couldn’t foresee the Great Recession isn’t that they’re blinkered or closed-minded or arrogant or stupid -- it’s because no one could predict it, at least not with the kind of macroeconomic data that now exist.

That in turn implies that much of macroeconomics itself, as currently practiced, is a dead-end pursuit.

But I’m not ready to subscribe to that level of pessimism just yet. Although recessions are difficult or impossible to spot in the near term, there might still be ways to see some warning signs developing a few years out. Research by some economists at the Federal Reserve Board has found that certain characteristics of debt markets -- credit spreads and the share of junk bonds in total debt -- can give warnings of recessions two years in the future.

So the future of macroeconomic forecasting -- and of macroeconomics itself -- might lie in a different direction than the one most researchers have been pursuing. Instead of focusing on consumption, investment and other easily measurable things, economists might try thinking more about subtle, long-term buildups of problems in financial markets.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    9 years ago

For wonks!!

... and Perrie...

That in turn implies that much of macroeconomics itself, as currently practiced, is a dead-end pursuit.

Ouch!!

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    9 years ago

In the long term economics as currently valued and understood is DOA. The true value of money is evaluated by how much nutrition, warmth or shelter it can provide; and, in that, paper/coinage or digital currency is actually quite worthless.

It's time to start looking at the long haul, and planning for an economy that reflects the true value of food, and shelter, and relationship with the rest of the planet's creatures. Until we do that, we will continue to value pieces of paper, and blocks of metal, more than we do each other, and the other residence of planet earth.

Economics is a fairy tale built on our own grandiose attempt at control, a fantasy we will be woken from sooner or later.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Larry Hampton   9 years ago

No one is shocked that the weatherman can only predict a few days accurately. Everyone understands that weather is just too complex to be modeled over a long period. 

Does anyone imagine that the economy is simpler? 

Economists kid themselves, and the rest of us, when they fly too close to the sun. 

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

The problem is this Bob, and I do mean this respectfully because I do value that you and other readers have greater knowledge than I about Economics and theory, is that, the equation I purpose is that money, Currency as we currently understand it, as well as global economics, will be done on a global scale, within just a generation or two. 

What are economists predicting/planning for considering that?

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Larry Hampton   9 years ago

Economics is a lot better at examining particular topics, and estimating the impact of that topic on the overall economy, according to different scenarios. When they can isolate a portion of the economy, they can be quite accurate.

But the overall economy is subject to the butterfly effect -- small events can have great consequences.

As for "money"... as I understand it, the economy is not much affected by relocating financial centers, or evolving monetary instruments. If the City is hurt by Brexit (for example), its losses will be mirrored by gains in Paris and Frankfort. Worldwide, nada.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

Some time ago i had a friend who had an advanced degree in Economics from Stanford. (It was so long ago I don't remember f it was an M.A. or a PhD.). I had never been interested in economics before, & new next to nothing about it. But we discussed it a lot. I asked him how good were economists at predicting depressions/recessions? Since economics was his field, I had assumed that he would say that economists have got it all figured out.

But he surprised me. He admitted that, basically-- they can't! 

And after centuries of studying economic theories-- the "experts" really don't understand much about the economy. (They're fairly good at explaining why recessions & depressions happen-- but only after the fact. LOL!)

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

I believe that. Everything I have read researching the topic resolves to that same account.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Larry Hampton   9 years ago

I believe that. Everything I have read researching the topic resolves to that same account

As mentioned in a previous comment-- they are a few few people who are extremely brilliant and who can outperform the stock market significantly over time. But most of us will never be able to afford their services.

And while it difficult to become extremely wealthy, what many smart investors hope to do is to consistently beat the averages (DOW, S&P, etc) over time. (You can buy a fund that moves with, say, the S&P 500. It may go down in any given year, but over the long run it goes up).

Here's a chart for Maximum period of the S&P 500. It starts at january 1950. While it has dips (they're unpredictable) notice the long term trend. If you had put money into it consistantly (say every quarter, or even every month-- over time you'd have a nice profit. 

And BTW-- that just the appreciation in the prices of stocks-- if you had stocks that also paid a reasonable dividend, maybe 3%, and reinvested it you'd have a lot more!

Some folks buy individual stocks and funds, in hopes of beating those averages by even a few percentage points each year.

And there are fairly lo-risk stocks you can buy that pay good dividends-- say 3% or more a year. Then reinvest the dividends.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

Depressions occur when something doesn't happen "as usual". The 2008 meltdown occurred because a great deal of actual banking had slid over to entities that were not formally banks, and thus not regulated as banks. They were too highly leveraged, and when credit went away, those quasi-banks went away, too.

The 2008 collapse was very easy to parse... in hindsight... because the "unexpected" has already occurred.

Historians cannot predict the future, either...

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

No one is shocked that the weatherman can only predict a few days accurately. Everyone understands that weather is just too complex to be modeled over a long period. 

Does anyone imagine that the economy is simpler? 

Economists kid themselves, and the rest of us, when they fly too close to the sun. 

The vast majority of them, yes. Bus as with any profession, there's a range of abilities. its a bell curve-- at either extreme are a few individuals-- on one side professionals who are totally incompetent, but on the other extreme a few individuals who are absolutely brilliant!

But those few rare individuals are rare-- and know that the information and analysis they can provide is extremely valuable for an investor. They find wealthy people who pay them  YUGE amounts of money for it.

But we'll never hear about it. They don't write books or newspaper columns or appear or TV stock market shows on TV. 

Rather, they only take on extremely wealthy clients, who pay them amazingly large fees for advice-- the clients they take can afford to hire them.

Some investors lose a lot of money in the stock market. Some do fairly well. But very few people actually become wealthy in the stock market. .

However some do. 

In some cases its actually just luck-- they bought Microsoft or Apple or some other stock at the right time-- they might not even realized it was a good time to buy it. . But there are a very few individuals who are geniuses-- and who have found how to "beat the market'. And some millionaires hired brilliant people who helped turn their millions into billions. Its rare-- but it does happen.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

Investment pros are not "economists" in the Yellen sense of the word. I had an aunt and uncle (gone now) who played the stock market. They did their homework rigorously, and made a VERY tidy living. It's like playing the horses: there are so many idiots playing their birthdays and so on, that anyone who is careful can beat the odds.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    9 years ago

My wife is the world greatest economist. If I have any doubts all I have to do is to ask her whenever I transfer nearly all of my Social Security money over to her bank account every month. I have actually asked her why I can't keep more of it and she says that if I kept more of it all I'd do is just spend it? Huh? She'd better hope all of the bills always get paid!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Randy   9 years ago

Does she invest it-- put the money to work to earn more money? Or just make sure the bills are paid and merely keep what's left? 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

Well I know that the bills are paid, she saves for us to go on a cruise once per year and the rest goes into a savings account that when she gets to $5,000 in it (fairly often surprisingly since she also puts her excess SS money in it) she invests it into some type of government insured bank bonds. To tell the truth I don't know what kind and only know that the amount is somewhere north of very low 6 figures. I also know we are the only beneficiaries in each other wills and our house is worth twice what we owe on it (we bought it two years before she retired, right after the bubble burst and right at the very bottom (my idea, she wanted to wait to buy until she retired!). Almost stole it!) after only owning it for 5 years. Once we are both gone it all goes to charity, which is sure to piss off some of our kids who never call.laughing dude

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Randy   9 years ago

If the bonds are safe it should be OK. But usually bonds don't pay much interest. 

(Generally speaking, the higher the interest paid by any financial instrument (Bonds, stocks, etc) the higher the risk. So if you want very low risk, youll get lower interest-- if you can handle higher risk you get higher interest or dividend. 

Also there are municipal and other government bonds. These pay lower interest, but the interest on gov't bonds is tax free (usually higher net worth individuals buy them, because they are in higher tax brackets-- a primary concern for them is tax avoidance. 

You can find stocks that py dividends of 15%year or more-- but that should be a red flag-- thos companies are likely to go bankrupt and after a few dividend checks-- the stock will be worthless!many very safe stocks pay no dividends or maybe 1%.year. 

I mostly buy stocks that pay about 4%-- a nice compromise. If youn ook carfully you can find stocks that pay 4% or so that are pretty safe. And of course reinvest the dividend so you get compound interest. (Sometimesyou can go a high as maybe5% and still be fairly lo risk.

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

Well she is a dedicated stickler for government insurance. Her parents, though I never met them, were the same way. Before her and her children got together and broke up her parents trust to get their money early I used to read the Financial reports every quarter when the bank would send them. They were very heavily invested in very secure government insured bank bonds and municipal bonds. Safe, but not very exciting or high returns. Very, very conservative. I always told my wife that I wish I had control over her parents portfolio (about $1.3 million) as there were several fairly safe investments in the market to put some of the money in and up the return significantly.

For instance If I had control when the market collapsed in 2008 I would have taken easily half of the money and bought like crazy when it bottomed out (when the government stepped in) and we would have made out like bandits, especially in automotive stocks and some of the more solid tech stocks (Apple, Microsoft). I was drooling over the chance to buy Ford and GM at the bottom of the market because there was no way Obama was going to let GM go bankrupt. My grandfather made the same gamble with Chrysler stocks in the late 70's just before the government bailed them out and made some serious cash. Even if I had bought before the collapse all I had to do was wait it out a few years because the market WAS going to come back and look at it now. Like grandpa used to say, if you have good stocks, never panic.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  Randy   9 years ago

GM did go bankrupt and the stock went to zero. When the new GM emerged from bankruptcy new stock was issued for the new company. Chrysler also went bankrupt and bonds lost all value.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    9 years ago

No mainstream macroeconomic model of the day managed to anticipate that the largest, longest economic downturn since the Great Depression was imminent, until it was already under way.

If an economist couldn't figure that out, they need to get out of the field of economics.  There were plenty of people who made billions leading up to the Great Recession and they knew when to get out of the profit markets before they lost everything they had made.

Also there were plenty of warnings all along the way.

It's no different today with a $20 trillion dollar National Debt or a $200 trillion dollar debt of unfunded liabilities.  You may not be able to predict the day or the hour when the cows come home, but you do know they are coming home, or maybe you don't.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

If an economist couldn't figure that out, they need to get out of the field of economics.

That's a silly thing to say.

Should a vulcanologist leave the field if she doesn't correctly predict an eruption?

Should a weatherman quit if he doesn't predict a tornado?

Should a NASA engineer quit if he doesn't predict the consequences of extreme cold on a seal?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

If an economist couldn't figure that out, they need to get out of the field of economics.

That's a silly thing to say

 

Not quite so silly if you have your eyes open and as I said "You may not be able to predict the day or the hour when the cows come home, but you do know they are coming home". 

Many times the warnings of what was inevitable if things continued the way they were going were ignored. 

I hope you don't think I mean the economist can predict the recession is going to be at 8am tomorrow morning, although the volcanologist can say with pretty good accuracy a volcano will erupt sometime in the future based on studying that volcano.  Not apples to apples.

The weatherman can predict a tornado will be possible with the current weather conditions.  They do it every day when the weather is right for one.  A weatherman doesn't forecast predict you will have a tornado unless he already knows one is on the ground not far from you and then it may turn, but that isn't anything like the Housing Bust which led to the

Your NASA is completely apples to oranges.

The Housing Bust was inevitable as the cost of homes were greatly over inflated.  Variable interest loans were being given to people who should not have qualified for them and for an economist to not be able to see the result of that, not the day and hour, but predict we were in for a financial crisis would have been ludicrous.

Like I said, there were those who saw it coming.  They didn't have to be economists.  Many made a fortune before it started to unfold and then turned around and made another fortune after it unfolded by buying up foreclosures.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

The Housing Bust was inevitable as the cost of homes were greatly over inflated.  Variable interest loans were being given to people who should not have qualified for them and for an economist to not be able to see the result of that, not the day and hour, but predict we were in for a financial crisis would have been ludicrous.

True... but fatally incomplete.

Lots of people saw the housing bubble and of course it is the nature o bubbles to burst. Quite a few worried about easy credit, too.

But what nobody saw -- because the banks were hiding it as deep and dark as they possibly could -- was the way those junk house loans were being sliced and diced into AAA-rated instruments, and the absurd amount of leverage that resulted. It was the collapse of that leverage that no one saw... because it was being hidden.

So we should fire all the cops who don't prevent crime from happening...

 
 

Who is online



77 visitors