In Tuesday’s briefing, press secretary Sean Spicer said something astounding — that Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad compared unfavorably, at least in one respect, to Adolf Hitler.
"Hitler didn't even sink to the level of using chemical weapons,” Spicer said.
You’re probably spotting at least one obvious problem here: The Nazis used poison gas as one of the principal means of exterminating the Jewish people. At one point, 6,000 Jews were gassed to death every day in Auschwitz alone, according to the US Holocaust Museum .
Surely, Sean Spicer knows this. He has to know this. Yet when a reporter asked Spicer to clarify his comments later in the briefing, he just dug himself a deeper hole:
I think when you come to sarin gas, there was no … he was not using the gas on his own people in the same way that Assad is doing. There was not … he brought them into the Holocaust centers, I understand that. But what I’m saying is the way that Assad used them, where he went into towns, dropped them, the use of it — I appreciate the clarification, [denying that Hitler used gas] was not the intent.
So, according to Spicer, Hitler only gassed people in “Holocaust centers” — not a term used by anyone in the history of ever — but didn’t “drop” the gas on “his own people” in towns.
This is mostly false. Prior to the construction of gas chambers, SS soldiers would drive around so-called “gas vans” — vehicles with hermetically sealed compartments that could be flooded with poison gas — and used them to execute Jews in, yes, their towns .
So Spicer released a second clarification in a statement to press, saying that he was just trying to say that Hitler never airdropped chemical weapons on his victims:
This is, finally, true. But the error pales in comparison to the main issue, which is that Spicer said that Assad compared unfavorably to Hitler — and still has not apologized for it!
The thrust of his initial point, which has not been withdrawn, is that Assad crossed some kind of moral line that Hitler did not. Saying that Hitler “didn’t sink to the level” of Assad is a form of whitewashing Hitler’s crimes against the Jews. Spicer’s second statement tries to sort of walk this back — but without admitting any error, which makes the whole thing seem shallow at best.
And he said this on the first day of Passover, one of the most important Jewish holidays that happens to celebrate Jews’ freedom from oppression.
This is not the first time that the White House has engaged in a kind of petty Holocaust denial — not a sentence I ever thought I’d type. On Holocaust Remembrance Day in January, the White House issued a statement that did not mention Jews once. When Spicer was asked about this omission , he slammed the media for engaging in “pathetic,” “ridiculous … nitpicking.”
Nor is it the first time that Spicer has screwed up massively when talking about Syria this week. In yesterday’s briefing, he invented a new Trump policy on Syria whole cloth, one that would require a prolonged US war against Assad — forcing the White House to walk it back ( twice ). Earlier in the week, he claimed that Trump’s cruise missiles had taken out 20 percent of Syria’s entire air force , when it had actually taken out 20 percent of one wing (something like 12 planes out of a total of several hundred).
All of this begs the question: If the press secretary can’t talk about what’s currently the biggest policy issue in the news without making massive errors and saying deeply offensive stuff about the Holocaust, how good of a press secretary is he?
-----------------------------------
RED RULES apply:
Be polite No insults whatsoever. No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ... None!
Be smart and stay on-topic Contribute substantive thought. Facts and/or reasoning. One-line zingers and bumper-sticker mantras are by definition off-topic and will be deleted.
-----------------------------------
The topic is Sean Spicer's competence/incompetence as Press Secretary.
- Be polite. No insults whatsoever. No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ... None!
- Be smart and stay on topic. Contribute substantive thought. Facts and/or reasoning. One-line zingers and bumper-sticker mantras are by definition off-topic, and will be deleted.
I'm not a fan of employing heavy-weight adjectives lightly. "Antisemitism" is pretty heavy, and should not be bandied about. So... after the Holocaust Remembrance Day quack, I wasn't going to presume the worst. But I was going to be attentive...
Now we have Sean Spicer... and another round of discounting Jewish deaths. Strike two!!
What bothers me here is that this was an unforced error. Why bring up the Holocaust? And after the previous quack, you'd think Spicer would be very, very careful. Nope.
There was a time, during the campaign, when a casual antisemite throwaway line might have been useful. A portion of Trump's base is... "anti-others", for want of a better expression, and would be pleased by such remarks. At the same time, such remarks might well not be noticed at all by most of the media, and thus never heard by the solid majority of Americans who would be offended. Overall, such remarks might have been "useful".
But not now! Anything anyone in the Administration says is noted and analyzed by the media. After that Holocaust Memorial without any mention of Jews, the media is on the lookout for other signs of possible antisemitism in the White House. Spicer's casual throwaway was stupid! Which is not good, coming from the Press Secretary...
Original article by Zack Beauchamp - Vox
-------------------------------------
(Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
In Tuesday’s briefing, press secretary Sean Spicer said something astounding — that Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad compared unfavorably, at least in one respect, to Adolf Hitler.
"Hitler didn't even sink to the level of using chemical weapons,” Spicer said.
You’re probably spotting at least one obvious problem here: The Nazis used poison gas as one of the principal means of exterminating the Jewish people. At one point, 6,000 Jews were gassed to death every day in Auschwitz alone, according to the US Holocaust Museum .
Surely, Sean Spicer knows this. He has to know this. Yet when a reporter asked Spicer to clarify his comments later in the briefing, he just dug himself a deeper hole:
I think when you come to sarin gas, there was no … he was not using the gas on his own people in the same way that Assad is doing. There was not … he brought them into the Holocaust centers, I understand that. But what I’m saying is the way that Assad used them, where he went into towns, dropped them, the use of it — I appreciate the clarification, [denying that Hitler used gas] was not the intent.
So, according to Spicer, Hitler only gassed people in “Holocaust centers” — not a term used by anyone in the history of ever — but didn’t “drop” the gas on “his own people” in towns.
This is mostly false. Prior to the construction of gas chambers, SS soldiers would drive around so-called “gas vans” — vehicles with hermetically sealed compartments that could be flooded with poison gas — and used them to execute Jews in, yes, their towns .
So Spicer released a second clarification in a statement to press, saying that he was just trying to say that Hitler never airdropped chemical weapons on his victims:
This is, finally, true. But the error pales in comparison to the main issue, which is that Spicer said that Assad compared unfavorably to Hitler — and still has not apologized for it!
The thrust of his initial point, which has not been withdrawn, is that Assad crossed some kind of moral line that Hitler did not. Saying that Hitler “didn’t sink to the level” of Assad is a form of whitewashing Hitler’s crimes against the Jews. Spicer’s second statement tries to sort of walk this back — but without admitting any error, which makes the whole thing seem shallow at best.
And he said this on the first day of Passover, one of the most important Jewish holidays that happens to celebrate Jews’ freedom from oppression.
This is not the first time that the White House has engaged in a kind of petty Holocaust denial — not a sentence I ever thought I’d type. On Holocaust Remembrance Day in January, the White House issued a statement that did not mention Jews once. When Spicer was asked about this omission , he slammed the media for engaging in “pathetic,” “ridiculous … nitpicking.”
Nor is it the first time that Spicer has screwed up massively when talking about Syria this week. In yesterday’s briefing, he invented a new Trump policy on Syria whole cloth, one that would require a prolonged US war against Assad — forcing the White House to walk it back ( twice ). Earlier in the week, he claimed that Trump’s cruise missiles had taken out 20 percent of Syria’s entire air force , when it had actually taken out 20 percent of one wing (something like 12 planes out of a total of several hundred).
All of this begs the question: If the press secretary can’t talk about what’s currently the biggest policy issue in the news without making massive errors and saying deeply offensive stuff about the Holocaust, how good of a press secretary is he?
-----------------------------------
RED RULES apply:
Be polite
No insults whatsoever. No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ... None!
Be smart and stay on-topic
Contribute substantive thought. Facts and/or reasoning.
One-line zingers and bumper-sticker mantras are by definition off-topic and will be deleted.
-----------------------------------
The topic is Sean Spicer's competence/incompetence as Press Secretary.
RED RULES apply:
- Be polite. No insults whatsoever. No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ... None!
- Be smart and stay on topic. Contribute substantive thought. Facts and/or reasoning. One-line zingers and bumper-sticker mantras are by definition off-topic, and will be deleted.
I'm not a fan of employing heavy-weight adjectives lightly. "Antisemitism" is pretty heavy, and should not be bandied about. So... after the Holocaust Remembrance Day quack, I wasn't going to presume the worst. But I was going to be attentive...
Now we have Sean Spicer... and another round of discounting Jewish deaths. Strike two!!
What bothers me here is that this was an unforced error. Why bring up the Holocaust? And after the previous quack, you'd think Spicer would be very, very careful. Nope.
These people do not know what they are doing!
He was a fool.....
There was a time, during the campaign, when a casual antisemite throwaway line might have been useful. A portion of Trump's base is... "anti-others", for want of a better expression, and would be pleased by such remarks. At the same time, such remarks might well not be noticed at all by most of the media, and thus never heard by the solid majority of Americans who would be offended. Overall, such remarks might have been "useful".
But not now! Anything anyone in the Administration says is noted and analyzed by the media. After that Holocaust Memorial without any mention of Jews, the media is on the lookout for other signs of possible antisemitism in the White House. Spicer's casual throwaway was stupid! Which is not good, coming from the Press Secretary...