The French, Ourselves
Original article by Paul Krugman - The Opinion Pages, NYT
-------------------------------------
Still thinking about the upcoming French election. Will Le Pen be the next Trump? I have no idea. But I’ve been interested to note how little resemblance there is between the underlying economics in France and here, which in turn raises further doubts about how far “economic anxiety” goes toward explaining the faux-populist surge.
One thing you have to bear in mind is that the French economy gets terrible press — some combination of conservative bias (with such a generous welfare state they *should* be a disaster, dammit) and cultural envy/annoyance. A few years back Roger Cohen quoted himself about how there is a
pervasive sense that not only jobs — but also power, wealth, ideas and national identity itself — are migrating, permanently and at disarming speed, to leave a vapid grandeur on the banks of the Seine
then noted wryly that he wrote that in 1997; and somehow France is still there.
In fact, the 1990s were something of a low point; in a number of key ways France has done better since then, especially compared with the United States. Official unemployment is high, but that’s somewhat misleading. If you look at adults in their prime working years, they’re actually more likely to be employed in France than they are here:
French productivity has gone from slightly above to slightly below the US level, perhaps because more people are employed; but anyway, given the wiggle room in such numbers, we’re basically looking at a country that is at the technological frontier:
OECD
And France has, so far at least, been spared the Case-Deaton epidemic of “deaths of despair”:
If very low inflation is any indicator, the French economy does appear to be operating somewhat below potential. But it’s not in macroeconomic crisis.
And as I wrote yesterday , France is not Greece: the euro was a bad idea, but France is not a nation currently suffering severely from lack of an independent currency, so there is no urgency about exit — and hence no obvious reason to incur the huge costs euro exit would impose.
So what’s it all about? Presumably it’s about identity politics, French style. But my point is that the economic anxiety trope works even worse for France than it does here.
Oh, and let me repeat: Le Pen does not offer any answer to the problems of the EU.
-----------------------------------
RED RULES apply:
Be polite
No insults whatsoever. No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ... None!
Be smart and stay on-topic
Contribute substantive thought. Facts and/or reasoning.
One-line zingers and bumper-sticker mantras are by definition off-topic and will be deleted.
-----------------------------------
The topic is France's economy, and the myths Americans share about it...

RED RULES apply:
- Be polite. No insults whatsoever. No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ... None!
- Be smart and stay on topic. Contribute substantive thought. Facts and/or reasoning. One-line zingers and bumper-sticker mantras are by definition off-topic, and will be deleted.
I was born and raised in the US; and have lived in France for most of my adult life. I have both passports. When I first arrived in France in the early 70s, the material standard of living (as measured very unscientifically in terms of color TVs per household) was moderately behind the American.
I was more deeply surprised by the lack of multi-lane highways. America was just finishing the Interstate system (so there were almost no pot-holes... yet ...), while in France a five hundred mile trip from our home in Lorraine to my mother-in-law's home in Brittany was a twelve-to-fourteen-hour over-night drive... despite 90 mph out-of-town speeds -- no speed limits back then!.
For forty-five years, every year, the newspapers said that America's GDP grew by a point or two more than France's GDP. I'm no mathematician... but the little calculator program that lives on one corner of my computer desktop says that 1,5% compounded over forty-five years should just about raise the American economy to the double of the French.
Today, France's material standard of living (as measured very unscientifically in terms of big flat-screen TVs) is, still, moderately behind the American. Same as forty-five years ago.
And during these forty-five years... France has built -- and maintained (cough, cough) -- its highway network. And also built a high-speed rail network. And also built nuclear power plants that cover 80% of needs. And... and... and...
Basically, it seems to me that France has done better, fundamentally, than the US. Contrary to the numbers .
I tried to understand. For some years, I imagined that perhaps "socially stimulative investments" such as highways, bullet trains, health-care, unemployment benefits, and so on (which are indisputably better in Europe than in the US) carry some sort of "social return on investment" that augmented French/European competitivity without appearing in those manifestly misleading GDP numbers.
Then, a number of years ago, an excellent article by an economist named Zencey gave me a better explanation: GDP is simply... false . GDP measures turnover, not added value. If I sell you my house for a million dollars, and then you sell it back to me for exactly the same amount, GDP has gone up by two million dollars, despite there being no added value at all.
... All those gazillion dollars sloshing around Wall Street, for no added value at all... While China actually makes stuff, and Germany actually makes stuff... and even France actually makes stuff! You know: those bullet trains, and Airbus, and those nuclear plants, and......
Using GDP to measure a nation's progress is like using a ship's wake to measure its progress. More "churn" does not necessarily mean more speed...
If GDP is not a valid instrument... then what? Well... let's go back to the beginning: "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness". To me "life" in an advanced society means far more than "birth". "Life" means things like a minimum wage... whether employed or not. "Life" is good health-care, accessible for everyone. "Life" is leisure time, with family and friends or just by myself... but my time, not some boss's! "Life" is each person being able to fulfill whatever their capabilities may be, through good education opportunities at all ages. Or we could put all these same items in the category "the pursuit of happiness". Indeed, there are quite a few attempts these days to quantify "happiness".
America never leads the "happiness" indexes...
More recently, I asked the same question ("Where did the difference in GDP growth between the US and France go?") of Brad DeLong, a leading Keynesian economist and professor at UCal Berkeley. He answered that it was almost entirely captured by the 1%, and thus never appeared in any average American's life.
That is a very depressing idea... and the data show it to be depressingly likely to be true...
''Churning'' is what Wall Street does the best.
Interesting article and the value of ''things''....
When is enough money, enough. In America it seems that we must have more and more money, and seem to think of things like vacations, family time, down time as of no value.
When I lived in Australia, a months holiday was standard for employees. In the U.S. it takes 20 years of being employed by a single employer to reach that level of holiday.
Sadly, it's probably true that the 1% have enjoyed the fruits of others people labor.
Some years ago, a conservative French government passed a law that permitted employees (NOT employers) to trade vacation time for extra pay. There were so few takers that the law was rescinded.