╌>

Deep Medicaid Cuts Drive Backlash to House Health Care Bill

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  randy  •  9 years ago  •  8 comments

Deep Medicaid Cuts Drive Backlash to House Health Care Bill

 

 

The House Republican health care bill's massive cuts to Medicaid, often skimmed over in the last-minute drama over pre-existing conditions, are fast emerging as a critical source of opposition in the Senate.

President Donald Trump said in his speech announcing his 2016 campaign that he would not cut Medicaid and bragged on Twitter that he was the first candidate to do so. He didn't keep that promise: The bill's Medicaid cuts, which the Congressional Budget Office estimates at $839 billion over 10 years, are arguably its most sweeping change. They're also critical to financing the bill's tax cuts for high-income Americans and medical industries, which require the savings to offset the loss in revenue.

Leading patient advocacy groups are warning the combination of less spending and a restructuring of the program will threaten coverage for millions of vulnerable Americans, including seniors, people with disabilities, and children. The top medical industry groups representing doctors, hospitals, and insurers are raising similar concerns, along with key Republican senators whose support will be needed to pass a bill.

Cuts could force tough choices

About 73 million people receive coverage through Medicaid. The program covers low-income Americans and was expanded under the Affordable Care Act. All but 19 states have accepted the additional federal funding, which covers people with incomes up to 138% of the federal poverty line.

The House bill would gradually do away with the expansion, but would go much further than simply rolling back Obamacare's changes. It would also transform Medicaid from a program that provides guaranteed matching funds to states to one that provides a fixed per-capita amount for every recipient or a block grant to cover total spending. The Congressional Budget Office has estimated these changes will leave 14 million fewer people covered by the program after a decade.

Conservative supporters argue the caps on spending will encourage states to find more efficient ways to deliver care. But the scale of cuts will inevitably force tough choices: With fewer funds available states could be forced to reduce eligibility, scale back payments to providers, or provide fewer benefits.

"You could have tens of millions of people removed from the program or entire classes of services eliminated from the program or both," Sara Rosenbaum, a professor of health law and policy at George Washington University, told NBC News.

Medicaid serves more functions than is often realized, and affected groups are rushing to publicize them now that the health care bill is back in play.

AARP is concerned the cuts could jeopardize approximately 10 million people who are eligible for both Medicare and Medicaid. Medicaid notably covers long-term care services, including home aides and nursing facilities, that Medicare does not. Thirty-six percent of total Medicaid spending goes to patients who also have Medicare, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation .

"The impact of such a huge loss of federal Medicaid funds on people with disabilities and poor seniors will be devastating," Lynda Flowers, a Senior Strategic Policy Adviser with the AARP Public Policy Institute, wrote in a post for the group's website.

The disability community has responded fiercely as well, highlighting potential cuts to special education programs at schools and to services that help Medicaid recipients — about 10 million of whom qualify due to disability — live and work independently. The bill, National Disability Rights Network executive Director Curt Decker warned in a statement, "will compel States to ration health care for children, including important mental health services."

Unexpected obstacles


While per-capita Medicaid spending rises with enrollment under the House plan, health experts warn it could create difficulties for states if they have to respond to a health crisis or account for new treatments that raise the average costs per person.

One example is the recent opioid epidemic. Sen. Rob Portman (R-OH), whose state has been among the hardest hit, said Thursday in a statement that he opposed the House's bill because he feared its Medicaid rollback would affect treatment for drug abuse.

Sens. Shelley Moore-Capito (R-WV), Dean Heller (R-NV), Susan Collins (R-ME), Cory Gardner (R-CO), and Lisa Murkowski (R-AK), among others, also have raised concerns about the impact on their constituents and their state's budgets.

Supporters of the House plan argue that the bill smooths the transition by grandfathering people who received Medicaid through the expansion until they leave the program. "Nobody on Medicaid is going to be taken away," House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy said on CNN Thursday. But Medicaid has a high turnover rate, meaning their eligibility is likely to lapse quickly.

Conservative health experts supportive of transforming Medicaid into a per-capita or block grant program argue these recipients should be on private insurance instead. But there's concern even among some advocates of this approach that the bill's other provisions, namely its steep reductions in subsidies to help older low-income customers afford insurance, will leave them without any options.

"By repealing Obamacare's Medicaid expansion and replacing it with a flat tax credit that doesn't provide enough assistance to the working poor, millions with incomes above the poverty line are going to lose their insurance..." Avik Roy, who advised Mitt Romney's presidential campaign, wrote in a column for Forbes.

http://www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/deep-medicaid-cuts-drive-backlash-house-health-care-bill-n755626


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    9 years ago

The bill's Medicaid cuts, which the Congressional Budget Office estimates at $839 billion over 10 years, are arguably its most sweeping change. They're also critical to financing the bill's tax cuts for high-income Americans and medical industries, which require the savings to offset the loss in revenue.

Which is exactly why what the Republicans in Congress passed the other day was not really so much a Health Bill as much as it was a tax cut for the rich bill. It was a fuck the poor to give more money to the rich bill.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    9 years ago

What I don't understand is why they feel so emboldened to be so open about this? About purposely taking health coverage away from poor people for the express purpose of giving huge tax breaks to rich people? I mean they usually at least try to hide it in some manner, but no this time? They are just openly saying we want to screw the sick and poor for the benefit of the rich. Do they really think that most American people have become as much of hardhearted pricks as Paul Ryan?

Are they determined to commit some sort of mass political suicide? The must know that the scene of them celebrating in the Rose Garden is going to be in just about every Democratic Congressional campaign ad in 2018, both for the House and Senate? Do they WANT the Democrats to take over control of Congress again? I just don't get it?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     9 years ago

Buffett calls Obamacare replacement 'a huge tax cut for guys like me'

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Kavika   9 years ago

He's right and he is also right about medical costs, but also we need to get a grip, a near death grip, on the cost of pharmaceutical drugs. Yesterday I stopped by our local Rite Aid drug store to pick up by wife's blood pressure medicine. We are both on Medicare and one of the smart things about Medicare Part D is that they provide BP meds for free if your have high blood pressure, because it's cheaper to do so then for them to pay for the hospitalization costs of if you have a stroke and possibly nursing home care for you for the rest of your life. However when George W. Bush introduced Part D it didn't just help people on Medicare, though it sure does. Along with help for seniors was a present he tossed to the pharmaceutical companies. Written into the law was a provision that forbid the U.S. government from negotiating the costs of drugs, like the VA can, so the pharmaceutical companies can pretty much charge the government anything they want for the meds.

Now I don't know how it is where you get your prescriptions filled, but at Rite Aid the paperwork you get shows both the cost you pay (your co-pay, which is usually $7 for most of the generics we get) which for BP meds shows $0 and it also shows the actual cost of the drugs the pharmaceutical company is charging your provider, in our case Medicare. Well the pharmaceutical company is charging Medicare $230.99 for one months supply! And this is for the lowest cost generic! That's obscene! They can NOT be allowed to do this any longer! The Congress MUST change the laws so that the government can negotiate prices for prescription drugs, just like the VA does, so the pharmaceutical companies stop stealing from the government! It's price gouging! The law was written to help seniors sure (and man did they need it!) and that is great, but it was also written to be a huge give away to the drug companies! This is just one example of what we need to do to bring down health care costs before we can put together a sensible healthcare (hopefully single payer) policy.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  Randy   9 years ago

I agree Randy, it's time that the administration addresses this and is allowed to start negotiating the drug companies.

If the administration wants to cut waste, they only have to look at what they handed Big Pharma.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Kavika   9 years ago

I have no problem with pharmaceutical companies making a decent profit. the same way I have no problem with doctors getting good pay (after all, they put in a lot of work to get where they got) and such. What I have a problem with is price gouging. I have no doubt at all that the meds my wife uses (I'm not going to wake her up by going into her room and wake her up to see what they are or I'll need more then my usual meds Happy ) have been on the market for many years and that the generics costs a few pennies a piece in say Canada or Mexico. I'll bet I can get the same bottle of 30 in Cabo for about $20.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     9 years ago

We're lucky, my wife takes no meds and I only take one and it's a generic.

I have friends that take a number of different drugs for various aliments, and it is costly.

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Kavika   9 years ago

My wife only takes one med for her BP. I, on the other hand, take 3 meds once a day and 5 meds twice a day. Fortunately I am on Medicare even though I am only 60 because I am on Social Security Disability. I also see a Clinical Psychologist for an hour every two weeks and a Nurse Practitioner (who is sort of a fill in for a Psychiatrist) every 6 weeks. When I turn 65 I will be transferred to regular Social Security but as far as the government is concerned I am considered permanently retired and unable to work. Which is really boring.

 
 

Who is online