ACLU Lawyer Says Travel Ban ‘Could Be Constitutional’ if Enacted by Hillary Clinton
Omar Jadwat, arguing before the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, admitted that President Trump’s order could be constitutional if Hillary Clinton had enacted the same order.
ACLU Lawyer Omar Jadwat, arguing against President Trump’s travel ban before the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday, admitted that the same exact travel ban “could be” constitutional if it were enacted by Hillary Clinton.
Jadwat argued that Trump’s campaign animus motivated the order, making it illegitimate. This claim was challenged by the Fourth Circuit’s Judge Paul Niemeyer.
“If a different candidate had won the election and then issued this order, I gather you wouldn’t have any problem with that?” Niemeyer asked.
Jadwat dodged on directly answering the question at first, but Niemeyer persisted, asking the question again.
Jadwat again tried to avoid the question, asking for clarification on the hypothetical, but Niemeyer once again demanded an answer.
“We have a candidate who won the presidency, some candidate other than President Trump won the presidency and then chose to issue this particular order, with whatever counsel he took,” Niemeyer said. “Do I understand that just in that circumstance, the executive order should be honored?”
“Yes, your honor, I think in that case, it could be constitutional,” Jadwat admitted.
Jadwat also denied that presidents’ actions should be nullified by campaign statements, despite the fact that his entire argument seemed to rest on that claim.
The ACLU lawyer also tried to claim that the order was illegitimate due to its being “unprecedented,” but this point also crumbled under a quick cross-examination.
Tags
Who is online
111 visitors

ACLU Lawyer Says Travel Ban ‘Could Be Constitutional’ if Enacted by Hillary Clinton
Well, everyone knows that whether they admit it or not.
I mean Hillary Clinton can destroy states evidence and it's just fine, but if Trump would have done the same thing, he'd be in jail, where she should be.
It's refreshing that this ACLU hack was forced to admit his political motivation.
It's hard to exaggerate how much damage liberal judges have done to the rule of law. The idea that the constitutionality of an executive order depends, not on the Content of the order, but on the identity of the issuer is too stupid and dangerous for words.
Well, I think in this case, the lawyer is an idiot. No wonder he works for the ACLU, instead of a law firm. I wonder how many swings he had to take at the bar exam?
And he's a law professor corrupting the minds of our nations youth.
I listened to the entire 3:12 exchange and never heard the name Clinton mentioned. I guess you guys are mind readers.
But leaving that aside, his statement is complete BS. An action is either Constitutional or not.
Clinton is a substitute for the theoretical President they are discussing.
That isn't what the title of the article says.
ACLU Lawyer Says Travel Ban ‘Could Be Constitutional’ If Enacted By Hillary Clinton
The title would lead you to believe that the lawyer actually said it would be constitutional if enacted by Hillary Clinton.
If she had been elected and been the president instead of Trump Steve is what it is referring to in this case.
Is my reply so obtuse? The substitute could have been Johnson. Why doesn't the title say that?
Johnson? Lol...