╌>

What Pittsburghers Know About the Environment That Trump Still Needs to Learn

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  9 years ago  •  10 comments

What Pittsburghers Know About the Environment That Trump Still Needs to Learn

Pittsburgh (Hazelwood) in 1940.
Photo by Jack Delano

In his speech announcing that he intends to pull the US out of the Paris climate accord, President Trump said that he was “elected to represent the citizens of Pittsburgh, not Paris.” And yet, as I sit here just outside Pittsburgh, I get this feeling that he’s not acting in my and my neighbors’ best interests.

Memo to Trump: Hillary won Pittsburgh.

Somehow my hometown, the good old Steel City, has been saddled with a reputation it doesn’t really have: that of factory workers, of coal miners, of people who don’t care if the air is smoky. You can find pictures of a Pittsburgh with a nearly black atmosphere—but none were taken in recent years. My parents used to take me to the Carnegie Library, built a century earlier with the steel magnate’s money. I thought it was made of some kind of black stone, and one day in 1990 I was shocked to see it being painted white. Why are they doing that? I asked.

My mom and dad both laughed. “They’re cleaning off the soot!”

Steel is our history, not our future. Pittsburgh wasn’t choked with smoke in my lifetime, thanks to the Clean Air act of 1963 and the collapse of the steel industry in the 1970s. President Trump is half a century too late; steel manufacturing isn’t coming back.

Coal mining is even older; there are mines in other parts of Pennsylvania but the ones in our city are abandoned. In the neighborhood where I grew up, many of the houses had cracks in their brickwork because the ground underneath us included spent coal mines. One house on my street had to have its basement rebuilt. Another time, a sinkhole opened up just a few blocks from home.

Pittsburghers have plenty of experience with the attitude that goes “screw the environment, let’s do whatever makes money.” It’s what we’ve been working for decades to clean up. Pittsburgh is a poster city for how to recover after coal and steel and manufacturing have fucked everything up.

Look at us now. Who are the biggest employers in Pittsburgh? Not mills, not factories. Our biggest employers are a hospital and a university. In fact, seven of the top 10 are in the health care industry. United States Steel, squeezed between Walmart and the City of Pittsburgh itself, does make number 13 on the list. But that’s its corporate headquarters. Browse their listings for hourly jobs, and there’s only one at the moment: a railway car repair person.

Pittsburgh is a poster city for how to recover after coal and steel and manufacturing have fucked everything up.

The city itself is all about services, health care, technology, and the like. Eight years ago, we had a different guy as our brand-new president, and he said “Pittsburgh stands as a bold example of how to create new jobs and industries while transitioning to a 21st century economy.” Heck, we already have self-driving cars.

I’m not saying we’re perfect. Fracking is big business in our rural surrounding areas, and poses its own environmental issues that need to be taken care of. Meanwhile, the Pennsylvania Environmental Council just held a summit here to discuss how to reduce our dependence on coal-fired power plants. Our state produces a lot of greenhouse gases, and exports a lot of the country’s electricity. We’re on track to reduce emissions by a third by 2030, but need to go much farther. And so does the rest of the country.

We have a lot in common with the rest of the US on that count. Check out this data from Yale’s Climate Communication project on how people feel about reducing CO2 as a pollutant. A majority of us, in every single state, think this is something we need to do. And check out Pittsburgh’s color on the map: we’re not yellow or peach or orange. Pittsburgh pops out in cherry red. We know what’s up.

Pittsburgh has its Trump voters, to be sure, but when people here go to the voting booth, there’s no mandate for officials who will take us back to Smoky City days. Take our mayor, for example, who tweeted this in reaction to the Paris news:

Allegheny County, which contains Pittsburgh,
is the red spot in southwestern Pennsylvania.

Map from Yale Climate Change Communication

 So, Mr. President, if you want to represent the people of Pittsburgh, you’ll need to re-think your stance on Paris.

----------------------------------------------

Original article by Beth Skwarecki , lifehacker

There are lots of links in the original article, for readers who want more detail. 


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    9 years ago

"Pittsburgh not Paris" is another unforced error, due to Trump not knowing what he is talking about.

Which is apt, when you think about it, because the decision to leave the Paris agreement is also due to Trump not knowing what he is talking about...

     anger

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

Bob- I believe Trump made this decision for several reasons.  One you touched on.  He doesn't know what he's talking about but I don't think that's one of the primary reasons.  Imo, he did this because this is his way of throwing a temper tantrum.  He's mad about the Russian investigation.  He's being vindictive.  I also believe he's trying to undo anything with Obama's name on it.  Hilary was right when she said that Donald is a child and we should all be wary of what will set him off to push that button.  

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  PJ   9 years ago

You're probably right. I didn't mean that Trump has only one motivation. In fact... the childish aspect of his behavior is the basis for the other article I posted today... 

     confused

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

I didn't mean that Trump has only one motivation

Oh, I know you weren't trying to chalk it up to one reason.  I assumed you were leading off so that members could add to the motivation.  hahahaha

I did love that President Macron delivered his message in English.  But I disagree with the media that he was speaking to Trump.  I think he was speaking to the American people or those in this country that still care about our allies.  I'm pretty sure the European leaders have realized that they are dealing with an American President that is not interested in hearing what they have to say or in maintaining good relations.  

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  PJ   9 years ago

I think he was speaking to the American people ...

That's how French media perceived it. It is assumed that Macron has already consigned Trump to the trash heap of history.

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

That's how French media perceived it

Last night the American media was framing it as President Macron slamming Trump but I took it as him reaching out to the American people and using Trump's words against him.

It's pretty sad when there is a large faction of Americans rooting for Germany and France and many other European leaders in their dealings with Trump.  He can't even get his own people to stand behind him and that's because he's NEVER made an attempt to rally the country.  He continues to speak only to his base.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  PJ   9 years ago

French media have pretty much integrated the fact that Trump is... unstable. So Macron would be unwise to let himself be seen as having any sort of rapport with Trump. Therefore he addressed himself to the American people. 

French media is quite different from American. There are left and right, but no alt-right. No Breitbart. No anti-reality. Anyone who denies AGW is seen as a dangerous nut-case. 

The French in general are not much better informed about Americans than vice-versa. When told that one of America's two major parties denies AGW, they are struck speechless: they don't know what to say. They suspect that they are being put on. 

 
 

Who is online





106 visitors