House Votes to End N.S.A.’s Bulk Phone Data Collection
Speaker John A. Boehner, at right, strongly supports the measure to end the governments bulk collection of phone records, which puts him at odds with the Senate majority leader, Mitch McConnell. Credit Stephen Crowley/The New York Times
WASHINGTON The House on Wednesday overwhelmingly approved legislation to end the federal governments bulk collection of phone records, exerting enormous pressure on Senator Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, the Senate majority leader, who insists that dragnet sweeps continue in defiance of many of those in his Republican Party.
Under the bipartisan bill, which passed 338 to 88 , the Patriot Act would be changed to prohibit bulk collection by the National Security Agency of metadata charting telephone calls made by Americans. However, while the House version of the bill would take the government out of the collection business, it would not deny it access to the information. It would be in the hands of the private sector almost certainly telecommunications companies like AT&T, Verizon and Sprint, which already keep the records for billing purposes and hold on to them from 18 months to five years.
Related Coverage
-
N.S.A. Collection of Bulk Call Data Is Ruled Illegal MAY 7, 2015
-
Declassified Report Shows Doubts About Value of N.S.A.s Warrantless Spying APRIL 24, 2015
So for the N.S.A., which has been internally questioning the cost effectiveness of bulk collection for years, the bill would make the agencys searches somewhat less efficient, but it would not wipe them out. With the approval of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, the spy agencies or the F.B.I. could request data relevant to an investigation. Corporate executives have said that while they would have to reformat some data to satisfy government search requirements, they could most likely provide data quickly.
The legislation would also bar bulk collection of records using other tools like so-called national security letters, which are a kind of administrative subpoena.
The near unanimity in the House is not reflected in the Senate, where a bipartisan group that backs the House bill faces opposition from Mr. McConnell and a small but powerful group of defense hawks who want no change, and from another faction led by Senator Rand Paul, Republican of Kentucky, that is pressing for even greater restrictions of data collection.
A compromise of some form must be reached before June 1, when the provision of the Patriot Act that allows the N.S.A. dragnet expires.
I think we have found an equilibrium on how to protect both security and privacy, said Representative Adam B. Schiff of California, the ranking Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee. These issues are not going away. I think the fact that the public is becoming much more united on how we balance these dual imperatives has ripened in a very constructive way.
The debate over the issue, which intensified after the surveillance efforts were exposed by Edward J. Snowden, was complicated by a federal appeals court ruling last week that found the National Security Agency s bulk collection of phone records illegal, and by the coming expiration of the Patriot Act at the end of the month.
In a demonstration of the complexity of the dynamics among Republicans, three of the partys contenders for the White House hold disparate positions on the bill.
Mr. McConnell has proclaimed that the legislation that passed the House, with strong support from Speaker John A. Boehner, will neither keep us safe nor protect our privacy.
However, it is clear that Mr. McConnell, whose efforts to advance President Obamas trade agenda fell flat this week on a procedural vote, does not have enough support in the Senate to pass a straight reauthorization of the Patriot Act. The House bill, however, could well have a filibuster -proof majority in the Senate.
We have an obligation to protect the constitutional rights of every American, said Senator Ted Cruz, Republican of Texas. The USA Freedom Act ends the federal governments bulk collection of phone metadata from millions of law-abiding citizens. Thats the right thing to do.
Democrats almost uniformly support a Senate bill that mirrors that passed by the House, as do at least 10 Republicans. While some Republicans support Mr. McConnells efforts, which were advanced without the support of the Senate Intelligence Committee, at least a dozen would not commit either way on Wednesday, underscoring Mr. McConnells challenge.
I am trying to find a balance between protecting national security and individual liberty, which is one of the things I ran on, said Senator David Perdue, a Republican freshman from Georgia. This is not as black and white as everyone seems to think, and Im trying to be very thoughtful with my vote on this.
Among the likely Republican presidential contenders, while Mr. Cruz favors the bill passed by the House, Senator Marco Rubio of Florida supports Mr. McConnells approach. Mr. Paul said the reform bill did not go far enough, a position now posited by some privacy groups in light of the court decision.
Some House Republicans were vexed that Mr. Boehner would not permit amendments to the bill on the House floor, but the speaker said, This is a very delicate issue, adding that the floor was not a place for people to bring out the wrecking ball.
Continue reading the main storyRecent Comments
- See All Comments
- Write a comment
Many members of the House from both parties came to the floor to support the bill Wednesday. Americans have long grappled with the need for security and their innate desire to protect their personal lives from government intrusion, said Representative Robert W. Goodlatte, Republican of Virginia and chairman of the House Judiciary Committee.
Noting that the Patriot Act was born out of the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, Mr. Goodlatte added that while the law helped keep us safe from implacable enemies, the nation must always be what it always has been, a beacon of freedom to the world.
Last year, the same measure passed 303 to 121, with substantially less Democratic support.
There was some suggestion on Wednesday that senators were laboring to come up with a compromise that would allow Mr. McConnell to offer his bill, but with a generous amendment process that could essentially transform it into the House bill.
I think that could happen, said Senator James Lankford, Republican of Oklahoma and a member of the Intelligence Committee.
Senator Patrick J. Leahy, Democrat of Vermont and the co-sponsor of the bill with Senator Mike Lee, Republican of Utah, said he knew of no such negotiations. Nobody has talked to me about my bill, he said. Im in the book.
Some senators would prefer that the Patriot Act be extended for a short period while the Senate works its way through the issue, but it is not at all clear the House or Senate would let that happen. I dont think it is going to fly with those who want reform, Mr. Schiff said.
The speaker understands the pulse of the House, he added. I think the Senate will see what an overwhelming vote it was in the House, and as we creep toward the deadline, they will have to figure something else out.
Republican senators appeared to largely agree. I dont think we can have a straight-up authorization for long term, said Senator Cory Gardner, Republican of Colorado. If there has to be some kind of short-term provision put in place, we can have those conversations, but I do not believe we should have an authorization without changes.
Tags
seeder
sixpick
11 years agoSpeaker John A. Boehner, at right, strongly supports the measure to end the governments bulk collection of phone records
What's the catch? There has to be some kind of deception hidden in this somewhere. Boehner is a POS and anything he does has to be under the table in my opinion.
Although the votes seem to express what I think most Americans feel about the bulk collection of phone data, McConnell is having breakfast with Obama <sarc>. What's with that?
FLYNAVY1
11 years agoOne chamber down, one to go.
If you extrapolate the math, the bill could pass the senate with 79-80 votes making it veto proof. At that point things should take care of itself.
seeder
sixpick
11 years agoFly.... Let's hope so, but McConnell isn't in line with the House. These leaders whether they are Republican or Democrat seem to have their own ideas on what we the people would like for them to do and seem to have little black books on the members of Congress in their back pockets.
seeder
sixpick
11 years agoTop senator: Domestic surveillance needs to be ramped up
WASHINGTON (AP) -- The chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee says he is shocked at how little information the National Security Agency is collecting through American phone records. He says the American public should be less worried about privacy and should back increased collection as a means of foiling terrorist attacks.
Republican Sen. Bob Corker of Tennessee said Wednesday that "it's beyond belief how little data is a part of the program."
House leaders have reached a bipartisan compromise on a bill that seeks to codify President Barack Obama's proposal to end the NSA's collection of domestic calling records, but it would allow the agency to request certain phone records under a court order.
Senate leaders have introduced a bill that would allow the NSA to continue collecting phone records.
Remember Corker was having dinner with Obama while Ted Cruz was filibustering Obamacare.
FLYNAVY1
11 years agoWith the type of passage in the house, this one might have legs that will stomp on those that would oppose it in the senate. We'll have to see.
You Have to wonder if McConnell refuses to bring it to the floor for a vote.....? What does he have to gain, or worse, which of his puppet-masters has the most to gain?
seeder
sixpick
11 years agoMcConnell refuses to bring it to the floor for a vote
That would be my guest is what he'll do.
seeder
sixpick
11 years agoRobert, I tend to go with your question. The whole thing is a dog and pony show.
Hal A. Lujah
11 years ago
Nowhere Man
11 years agoThey want to arrest him cause of the information he still has and hasn't released yet.
That's the only way they figure they can stop him short of assassination, but that doesn't work unless they get possession of his cache of data....
That is what they really want, the information.
They couldn't care less about him..
Nowhere Man
11 years agonot a place for people to bring out the wrecking ball.
Absolute bullshite!
It's where the Founders put the public wrecking ball, and expected them to use it when the people demand it!
And there is no doubt that it is being demanded here.
Boehner is trying to maintain what little control he still has.
Good position for Rand Paul to take.
One thing that is coming out, you are seeing the establishment separate itself from the real peoples representatives, that is always a good thing.
But like Hal says, the system has been built, you can expect nothing less than for them to use it.
No matter what the people want.
Randy
11 years agoI couldn't agree more. The Patriot Act needs wrecking ball type changes in order to at least bring it back being Constitutional, if not gotten rid of altogether.
Who is online
115 visitors

Bill
2 hours agoRep. Scruff from Ca got it right. There is a need to balance civil liberties versus the very real threats. Most of the comments here...
David Gregory
2 hours agoThe whole misnamed Patriot Act should be trashed. This is a sorry compromise, but is better than nothing.
ndbza
2 hours agoI wish someone would show me who has been hurt by the intrusion of privacy other than the bad guys