╌>

Don't Bail Out Failing States Like Illinois

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  9 years ago  •  9 comments

Don't Bail Out Failing States Like Illinois
EDITORIALS
Don't Bail Out Failing States Like Illinois
6/19/2017
FacebookLinkedInPrintTwitterShare Reprints
State Bankruptcy: First Puerto Rico into bankruptcy, next Illinois? Don't laugh. In some ways, Illinois' fiscal crisis is just as bad as bankrupt Puerto Rico's. And it's going to get a lot worse before it gets better.

Illinois is nearly $15 billion in arrears on its bills and really has no way to pay up. It already has the lowest credit rating of any state, and could become the first state ever to get a "junk" rating on its debt, which would make borrowing to address its problems very difficult at best, and prohibitively costly at worst.


Even so, the Democrat-controlled legislature can't bring itself to agree with Republican Gov. Bruce Rauner about anything.

"I don't know what part of 'We are in massive crisis mode' the General Assembly and the governor don't understand," said Comptroller Susana Mendoza, a Democrat. "This is not a false alarm. The magic tricks run out after a while, and that's where we're at."


Politico sums it up nicely: "Illinois has compiled $14.6 billion in unpaid bills. It's running a deficit of $6 billion and its pension liability has soared to $130 billion."

Meanwhile, the state is already under several court orders to pay certain bills, so as others come due the money won't be there. It's a severe problem.

Not surprisingly, the Democrats would like higher taxes to fill the budget holes. Republican Rauner wants a variety of changes, intended to make the state more appealing to investors and less vulnerable to its abysmal political class, including term limits, a temporary property-tax freeze and workers' compensation reform.

The sad thing is, other states are also struggling to pay their bills. A 2016 study by the Mercatus Center at George Mason University named four other states, in addition to Illinois, that were in particularly bad fiscal shape: Kentucky, New Jersey, Massachusetts and Connecticut, "largely owing to the low amounts of cash they have on hand and their large debt obligations."

"Each of the bottom five states exhibits serious signs of fiscal distress," the Mercatus report said. "Though their economies may be stronger than Puerto Rico's, allowing them to better navigate fis­cal crises, their large liabilities still raise serious concerns."

At the heart of it all is the so-called Blue State model of governance of the Democratic Party. It views government as an ever-expanding and always-available ATM to meet all needs, social and otherwise, with a ready supply of taxpayer cash.

This includes lavish underfunded public-employee pensions, which have created massive fiscal problems for many states across the country.

A study by Moody's Investors Service last year found that net pension liabilities continued to soar in 2015, the latest year for which data are available.

"Total U.S. state aggregate adjusted net pension liabilities totaled $1.25 trillion, or 119% of revenue for the 2015 fiscal year," the report said. As bad as that is, Moody's also predicted that the amount of unfunded liabilities at the state level would soar 40% to $1.75 trillion this year.

It wouldn't be so bad if the states were responsibly addressing the problem. But they aren't. A new study out this month from North Carolina State University finds that states are using a variety of tricks and gimmicks to paper over their financial liabilities and to fool taxpayers about the true extent of what they owe. It's a dangerous game.

And it's unsustainable. To paraphrase the late economist Herb Stein: If something can't continue, it won't.

The problem is, an implicit part of the Blue State model of governance is that it's never anyone's fault, other than stingy taxpayers, when a state falls into arrears or begins showing chronic deficits. It won't take long for states to adopt the same attitude that some banks have had: "We're too big to fail. Time for a federal bailout."

Sorry, but that would be a major mistake.

Bailing out failure only leads to more failure. While it is horribly run, Illinois is a wealthy state that can't make up its mind about its priorities. But that's what budgeting and taxing are about: priorities. State politicians need to sit down and get real about their difficulties and learn what every family learns: You can't have everything you want, and you have to live within your means.

A bailout should be out of the question. As Ted Dabrowski, vice president of policy for the Illinois Policy Institute, argued last week in IBD, "A federal intervention on that scale would permanently damage healthy competition among states for people, jobs and ideas."

Those politicians who don't get their fiscal acts together shouldn't be objects of national pity or of federal charity from Congress. They should be scorned for their irresponsibility. And their citizens should understand that they are in large part to blame for electing promise-you-everything politicians who have turned their states into fiscal hellholes.

RELATED:

Are States The Next 'Too Big To Fail'?

Forget Puerto Rico, What About States' Soaring Pension Debts?

What Do Broke Illinois And Bankrupt Puerto Rico Have In Common? Big, Bad Government http://www.investors.com/politics/editorials/dont-bail-out-failing-states-like-illinois/

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    9 years ago

Cut em off and let them go belly up. 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    9 years ago

It is not the fault of the public employees that the states underfunded the employees pensions, so cutting them should be out of the question. They were part of union or union style contracts and must be protected. The employees performed their part of the contract. They did what was asked of them to fulfill their obligations, so the state must fulfill it's obligations to them. Any fix must include saving the pensions as they are now.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    9 years ago

hard to fathom how corrupt Illinois is. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  Sean Treacy   9 years ago

Detroit was the Democrats proving grounds for bankrupting the country. Then Obama did his best at the national level burying us under a mountain of debt and now we see the states preparing for bankruptcy. 

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Dean Moriarty   9 years ago

Well, Chicago is the powerhouse in Illinois and it is also the sucking sound you hear when you pass through the state.  This might be why...

Chicago aldermen

Ward Name Took Office Party
1 Proco Joe Moreno 2010* Dem
2 Brian Hopkins 2015 Dem
3 Pat Dowell 2007 Dem
4 Sophia King 2016* Dem
5 Leslie Hairston 1999 Dem
6 Roderick Sawyer 2011 Dem
7 Gregory Mitchell 2015 Dem
8 Michelle A. Harris 2006* Dem
9 Anthony Beale 1999 Dem
10 Susie Sadlowski Garza 2015 Dem
11 Patrick Daley Thompson 2015 Dem
12 George Cardenas 2003 Dem
13 Marty Quinn 2011 Dem
14 Edward M. Burke 1969 Dem
15 Raymond Lopez 2015 Dem
16 Toni Foulkes 2007 Dem
17 David H. Moore 2015 Dem
18 Derrick Curtis 2015 Dem
19 Matthew O'Shea 2011 Dem
20 Willie Cochran 2007 Dem
21 Howard Brookins Jr. 2003 Dem
22 Ricardo Muñoz 1993* Dem
23 Michael Zalewski 1995 Dem
24 Michael Scott, Jr. 2015 Dem
25 Daniel Solis 1996* Dem
26 Roberto Maldonado 2009* Dem
27 Walter Burnett, Jr. 1995 Dem
28 Jason Ervin 2011* Dem
29 Chris Taliaferro 2015 Dem
30 Ariel Reboyras 2003 Dem
31 Milly Santiago 2015 Dem
32 Scott Waguespack 2007 Dem
33 Deb Mell 2013* Dem
34 Carrie Austin 1994* Dem
35 Carlos Ramirez-Rosa 2015 Dem
36 Gilbert Villegas 2015 Dem
37 Emma Mitts 2000* Dem
38 Nicholas Sposato 2011 Dem
39 Margaret Laurino 1994* Dem
40 Patrick J. O'Connor 1983 Dem
41 Anthony Napolitano 2015 Rep
42 Brendan Reilly 2007 Dem
43 Michele Smith 2011 Dem
44 Thomas M. Tunney 2002* Dem
45 John Arena 2011 Dem
46 James Cappleman 2011 Dem
47 Ameya Pawar 2011 Dem
48 Harry Osterman 2011 Dem
49 Joe Moore 1991 Dem
50 Debra Silverstein 2011 Dem

 
 

Who is online





132 visitors