Federal judge issues temporary stay for California's high-capacity magazine ban
A federal judge in San Diego has issued a temporary stay against a new California law that bans high-capacity magazines.
U.S. district judge Roger Benitez issued the preliminary injunction against the voter-approved law, writing that the law is likely to be unconstitutional because it prevents citizens from purchasing "whatever common magazine size [they judge] best suits the situation."
Sacramento Bee:
"The State of California's desire to criminalize simple possession of a firearm magazine able to hold more than 10 rounds is precisely the type of policy choice that the Constitution takes off the table," the injunction read.
Benitez added that "a final decision will take too long to offer relief, and because the statute will soon visit irrevocable harm on Plaintiffs and all those similarly situated a state-wide preliminary injunction is necessary and justified to maintain the status quo."
The judge granted the request of attorneys from the National Rifle Association-affiliated California Rifle & Pistol Association to temporarily block the law.
In the days leading up to the ban, some California gun owners, pro-gun sheriffs and sellers have been reluctant to give up their magazines. Some gun owners have previously said that they were hoping pending court challenges would block the ban.
"We're not going to be knocking on anybody's door looking for them," said Shasta County Sheriff Tom Bosenko in an earlier interview with The Bee. "We're essentially making law-abiding citizens into criminals with this new law."
Kudos to the judge for some first-class reasoning. We now know there is at least one federal judge who has read and understood the Second Amendment.
And Sheriff Bosenko has it exactly right. The notion that this would make anybody in California safer is absurd. Are proponents of the ban arguing that criminals will also turn in their illegal magazines and promise not to buy any more?
Like almost all gun control measures, the high-capacity magazine ban was designed to make it appear that politicians are "doing something" about crimes committed with guns, despite the fact that there is zero chance and zero evidence that it will reduce violence. Criminals don't need permission to purchase any weapon or magazine they want to, and they certainly won't be deterred by laws that end up "making law-abiding citizens into criminals."
Read more: http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2017/06/federal_judge_issues_temporary_stay_for_californias_high_capacity_magazine_ban.html#ixzz4lYJtiMo7
Follow us: @AmericanThinker on Twitter | AmericanThinker on FacebookF
U.S. district judge Roger Benitez issued the preliminary injunction against the voter-approved law, writing that the law is likely to be unconstitutional because it prevents citizens from purchasing "whatever common magazine size [they judge] best suits the situation."
Sacramento Bee:
"The State of California's desire to criminalize simple possession of a firearm magazine able to hold more than 10 rounds is precisely the type of policy choice that the Constitution takes off the table," the injunction read.
Benitez added that "a final decision will take too long to offer relief, and because the statute will soon visit irrevocable harm on Plaintiffs and all those similarly situated a state-wide preliminary injunction is necessary and justified to maintain the status quo."
The judge granted the request of attorneys from the National Rifle Association-affiliated California Rifle & Pistol Association to temporarily block the law.
In the days leading up to the ban, some California gun owners, pro-gun sheriffs and sellers have been reluctant to give up their magazines. Some gun owners have previously said that they were hoping pending court challenges would block the ban.
"We're not going to be knocking on anybody's door looking for them," said Shasta County Sheriff Tom Bosenko in an earlier interview with The Bee. "We're essentially making law-abiding citizens into criminals with this new law."
Kudos to the judge for some first-class reasoning. We now know there is at least one federal judge who has read and understood the Second Amendment.
And Sheriff Bosenko has it exactly right. The notion that this would make anybody in California safer is absurd. Are proponents of the ban arguing that criminals will also turn in their illegal magazines and promise not to buy any more?
Like almost all gun control measures, the high-capacity magazine ban was designed to make it appear that politicians are "doing something" about crimes committed with guns, despite the fact that there is zero chance and zero evidence that it will reduce violence. Criminals don't need permission to purchase any weapon or magazine they want to, and they certainly won't be deterred by laws that end up "making law-abiding citizens into criminals."
Read more: http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2017/06/federal_judge_issues_temporary_stay_for_californias_high_capacity_magazine_ban.html#ixzz4lYJtiMo7
Follow us: @AmericanThinker on Twitter | AmericanThinker on FacebookF
Tags
Who is online
94 visitors

We have one here too and it's unenforceable and many of our sheriffs also promised not to enforce it.
It did cause Magpul to move out of state causing a loss of five hundred jobs.
While the law, which went into effect last summer, makes it illegal to buy or sell typical 30-round magazines, some sellers have found creative ways around the law that render it all but meaningless.
At one gun store, an undercover producer for Denver’s CBS4 bought a “kit” for a 30-round magazine, which was essentially all its parts that simply hadn’t been assembled. It took the clerk less than 30 seconds to put it together, the station reported.
And at a gun show, the producer bought a magazine retrofitted so that it would only accept 15 bullets in order to comply with the new law. That retrofit is easily undone, however, allowing the magazine to hold up to 30 rounds.
An even simpler work-around is to buy the magazines in neighboring states, where their sale and possession is legal.
The investigation comes as little surprise to law enforcement officers. Colorado’s elected sheriffs opposed the bill from its inception, saying it would be unenforceable because magazines sold before the law went into effect are still legal to possess. Since they don’t have manufacturing dates stamped on them, it’s impossible for officers to tell when the magazines were bought and sold.
You just never know when you're going to need to have enough fire power to destroy a small army that is invading your castle. Happens all the time.
I feel sorry for the states that don't have a make my day law when it comes to protecting our castles.
how many times has your free speech saved your life?