╌>

'Fair' wealth surcharges penalize hard work, success

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  9 years ago  •  4 comments

'Fair' wealth surcharges penalize hard work, success
Local lawmakers in Seattle, Washington and state lawmakers in Massachusetts are considering or have passed new surcharges on higher-income households in their jurisdictions, squeezing successful members of society even more in the name of “fairness.”

On June 14, Massachusetts House and Senate lawmakers took another step toward asking voters in 2018 to approve a new wealth surcharge on high-income households, approving a referendum petition placing the question on next year’s ballot. If passed by the state’s voters, individuals and households with more than $1 million in annual income -- adjusted annually for inflation -- will be taxed at a 9.1 percent rate, instead of the current 5.1 percent income tax rate.


In July, on the opposite side of the country, Seattle City Council members approved a new ordinance that added 2.25 percentage points to the tax burden of individuals earning more than $250,000 and households earning more than $500,000. The tax rate will be applied to total income, not net income.

“Our goal is to replace our regressive tax system with a new formula for fairness,” Seattle Mayor Ed Murray told Reuters reporter Eric Johnson on July 10.

Instead of being “a new formula for fairness,” these wealth surcharges are patently unfair, punishing people for being successful and discouraging productive work.

Soaking the rich, as it’s called, creates a disincentive for small business owners to expand their businesses and purchase new capital and creates an incentive for skilled workers to move elsewhere, creating a regional “brain drain.”

Small business owners unlucky enough to be caught in the crosshairs of such tax schemes will either scale back their businesses so they come in just under the threshold for enhanced taxation or move to jurisdictions less hostile to business development and expansion. This inevitably leads to there being fewer intermediate goods and raw materials purchased and transformed into consumer-ready goods and services, which in turn means consumers will have a smaller number of products and services available for purchase and many jobs will be lost because not as many raw resources will be needed to be transformed into finished products.

Research shows punitive taxes on the wealthy cause the very people targeted by these levies to relocate, defeating the stated purpose of the tax. University of Illinois-Chicago economics professor Erik Hembre found evidence that income tax rates imposed by states and cities had an effect on the success of sports teams, because teams in high-tax states and/or cities have a more difficult time attracting the highest-priced professional athletes.

“The income tax rate effect varies by league, with the largest effect in professional basketball, where teams in states without income tax win 4.5 more games each year relative to high-tax states,” Hembre wrote.

Why would professional athletes care about tax rates? Because these highly talented, extremely wealthy earners, like everyone else, want to live somewhere in which they can keep more of the benefits given to them for their talent and hard work.

Instead of trying to search for a “new formula for fairness” -- whatever that’s supposed to mean -- and penalizing success, Murray and other lawmakers, in every city council hall and statehouse in the country, should promote pro-growth policies that incentivize the formation of new capital and innovation.



Read more: http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2017/08/fair_wealth_surcharges_penalize_hard_work_success.html#ixzz4oUDk1Ydz
Follow us: @AmericanThinker on Twitter | AmericanThinker on Facebook

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
jarandhel
Freshman Silent
link   jarandhel    9 years ago

Instead of being “a new formula for fairness,” these wealth surcharges are patently unfair, punishing people for being successful and discouraging productive work.


Just a reminder that from 1932 through 1983 the federal tax rate for the top income bracket never fell below 50%, and in fact averaged 77.29% over that 51 year period .  Today the top rate is a mere  39.6%, almost half of its historic levels.  Yet we are supposed to believe that increases of 4% and 2.25% are too much to bear, and are simply unfair and punishing success?  The truth is that the wealthy have, in the past few decades, been given unprecedented tax breaks and we have seen that it simply does not create jobs.  In the past, when businesses were taxed at higher rates, there was motivation for owners to reinvest in the business and use those investments as a tax deduction.  These lower rates only motivate business owners to pocket the profits.  That's why, in the same time period since the upper tax rate was lowered below 50%, we see CEO pay ballooning from an average of 20-30 times that of the average worker , to more than 300 times that of the average worker today .



 
 
 
oldcrankyman
Freshman Silent
link   oldcrankyman    9 years ago

A progressive income tax is necessary to keep money flowing in our economy.  Every time taxes are cut, we see a bigger disparity between the ultra rich and the rest of society.  It's simply a matter of survival.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  oldcrankyman   9 years ago

What makes you think money didn't flow before we had an income tax?

 
 

Who is online






127 visitors