Do liberals use the expectation of climate change to push other agendas?
LINK :
http://www.rtcc.org/2015/05/04/mexico-uses-climate-threat-to-justify-slum-clearance/
Mexico uses climate threat to justify slum clearance
Last updated on 4 May 2015, 8:21 am
Official plans to relocate residents of shanty towns braced for future landslides and floods spark human rights fears
Houses in Pachuca, in Hidalgo state, Mexico (Photo: wikimedia commons)
By Alex Pashley
Slums hem Mexico Citys margins blanketing the contours of Latin Americas biggest metropolis.
The hillsides of Xochimilco, the third largest of the capitals 16 delegaciones or boroughs, are a melee of densely packed dwellings stacked high by successive waves of migrants.
But in staking out their patch in the valley mega-city, some residents live in the path of floods and mudslides.
That risk is set to amplify as global warming pummels the country harder each decade.
In an unprecedented move, the government has drawn up a strategy to clear slums at risk of climate change-induced natural disasters.
As part of its contribution to a UN global climate pact, the worlds 13th largest emitter of greenhouse gases in March outlined its climate change adaptation strategy until 2030.
It aims to guarantee food and water security for its 122 million citizens, as well as halve the number of municipalities classed as most vulnerable to climate impacts through the prism of human rights and gender.
But one line of the document, namely action number 9 for adaptation in the social sector, is causing concern.
Relocate irregular human settlements in zones prone to disasters through land use regulations, it reads.
Slum clearance?
Translated, that means only one thing for Maria Jose Veramendi, a senior attorney at environmental law group AIDA Americas: slum clearance.
As far as she knows, it is the first time climate change has been used to justify such a policy.
I think it is a dangerous thing to put in there, she tells RTCC.Its clear it is needed but you cannot use human rights and the protection of people in the face of climate change to enforce zoning regulations.
If the issue is vulnerability to climate change, she asks, why is it only irregular settlements that have to move?
Seven in ten Mexicans live in urban areas, a trend that has surged since the 1960s as cities absorbed job seekers and the displaced.
Nowhere is that clearer than in the capital, where settlements have sprung up to devour the unclaimed countryside.
Mexico City (Photo: UN)
A fourth of its estimated 22 million population live in unauthorised housing on conservation land, according to the citys environment watchdog PAOT.
Xochimilco in turn holds 300 of the citys 835 unauthorised slums, with nearly 80% of the borough sitting on an ecological reserve.
That puts it in the line of waterways supplying the city, while urban transformation has led to soil erosion encouraging landslides. Add that to seismic activity in the zone, and the picture darkens.
Unauthorised buildings
Amparo Martinez, a senior official who drafted the adaptation plans tells RTCC 250,000 unauthorised households sprung up between 2000 and 2007, a mark of the citys expansion.
Although Mexico isnt a big emitter, it does have a geographical situation marked by vulnerability.We have to strengthen the high reservoirs so we dont have landslides,says the director general at the National Institute of Ecology and Climate Change (INECC).
We at INECC are planning the scientific and technical process to strengthen capacity and lower their vulnerability.
Mexicos urban pollution is set to soar from 80 million in 2010 to 103 million in 2030, Martinez adds. Growing demand for water has led to over-extraction of groundwater, causing the city to sink and putting strain on the valleys drainage system. That widens the risk.
Luis Herrera, a Mexican urban planner at the United Nations Human Settlements Program , says relocation is an incredibly sensitive and complicated issue. He prefers to talk about improvements than clearances.
Though access to running water and sewerage systems has soared lowering the amount of unauthorised slums, Herrera says. Plus communication between communities and the state is better now, in the case of relocations.
Its a new idea which hasnt entered the culture, he says of moves to treat such projects as climate adaptation, adding: Im not suspicious.
Climate vulnerability
Mexico has suffered increasingly frequent tropical cyclones, floods and droughts in the last 50 years, according to its intended nationally determined contribution (INDC). Such extreme weather events cost the country an annual $1.4 billion between 2000 and 2012.
Its INDC submission made it the first developing country to volunteer emissions goals towards an international deal.
Observers hailed the plan as ambitious, with its target to peak emissions in 2026 and cut heat-trapping gases 25% in 2030 compared to its current trajectory.
It really blazes the path for others developed and developing if Mexico can do this so can other major economies like Japan and Brazil, said Jennifer Morgan at the World Resources Institute.
Still, its plans are just a statement of intentions.
Joel Audefroy, a sociologist at the National Polytechnic Institute in Mexico City says the government lacks the funds or political will to successfully uproot settlements.
People wont want to change their places despite it being in crisis. They have their work, their livelihoods, Audefroy adds.
Consultation failure
Andrea Rodriguez, a lawyer at AIDA Americas, is suspicious of the plans, citing the states precedents in shifting communities aside to build wind farms or dams for hydroelectric power.
Despite being signatory to international treaties enshrining citizens right to housing, the state had failed to carry out prior consultations with indigenous groups before appropriating land in certain cases, she said.
The dilemma from a legal point is up to what degree you can use climate change as a national exercise to give permission to move people, Rodriguez says.
That remains to be seen as officials flesh out the policy to take effect from 2020.
All will be given better conditions and better opportunities, says policymaker Martinez.
Theres a lot of mistrust at the root of this, but with the strengthening of institutions and organising by the populations themselves to find alternatives, the problems can be resolved.
Tags
Who is online
136 visitors

It must be confusing to be a liberal ... so many causes to support . How do they decide when there are conflicting issues such as what is happening in Mexico City ?
It must be confusing to be a liberal ... so many causes to support .
Unlike conservatives we have the ability to think of more then just one thing at a time.
How do they decide when there are conflicting issues such as what is happening in Mexico City ?
I don't live in Mexico City.
What makes you think they won't go to Texas? Or the mid-west. I'm betting Minnesota. Though to tell the truth I don't think they'll be coming up here all that much. It's not likely Mexico wants to lose all that cheap labor, no matter how much GOP big business wants them up here and keeps inviting them in.
Perhaps the problem is one of perception . Moving one's mouth is not the same thing as thinking . When you start to actually think , you are inclined to shut your mouth and evaluate before you open your mouth and pontificate .
I'm starting to suspect you are not a "real" liberal . If you were you wouldn't let geography get in the way of your pontificating ...
I can still think about many things at the same time (unlike it seems many conservatives can) and I still don't live in Mexico City, so what does that have to do with being a liberal? Liberals don't pontificate at all. We just point out obvious truths to the intentionally blind. We can't happen if they won't open their eyes and just keep repeating the same right wing mantras over and over again. And since a lot of conservatives love rich people, you'd think they'd get some of them to buy them some wit and humor? But nooooooooo...........
You are quite the humorist ... Ohh , was that supposed to be serious ??
It's all about controlling the "thought" processes of women . Would there even be an environmental movement without the vast input of women ? I don't think so ...
That is the most ridiculous thing I've seen you post Petey.. (I'm sure there are others)
Roe vs. Wade... Hmmm, guess whom is against a woman's right to choose?
Do I need to get out the statements of female republican congressmen that also have the GOP being against women?
...
Kay Bailey Hutchison: GOP cant throw away women
Read more:
Olympia Snowe Quit Senate to Protest GOP Agenda
...
The subject is not Roe v Wade . It is climate change "attitude" , an unproven concept which is advanced strictly by attitude , mostly from women and their leader Al Gore . But soon their leader will be Hillary . What a time wasting main issue to pursue ... for the leader of the free world .
Yawn ... that's not what I've said here . But have fun throwing out topic derails . I guess focusing on the issue [ liberal tricks using climate "theory" as an excuse ] is too hard to keep in your mind . What does that say about your mind ... a one subject brain ? Seems that way .
No . I'm a skeptic . Are you an AGW worshipper ?
As I expected liberals are unable to come up with real arguments to oppose the contention of this seed . All they can do is throw out meaningless derails and straw-men . Can any libs respond to my counter arguments ? Doesn't seem that way . Thanks for demonstrating that the initial perception [in the title] was correct .
Now that is pretty good Hal!!! At least you don't slur when you type.
But it was good. I liked it, even though you had to fudge a little.
A more shallow thinker would think everything you said was true.
Of course they do. They are a collective bunch much like ants and bees except too many of them don't work.
You brought up the point of "Controlling women's thoughts", not me.
Your EXACT quote is...
So you want us all to think that one instance is OKAY, but another ISN'T?
Think about it Petey......or don't which is your expected norm.
Hmmmmm.
Am I off base to consider the Bible, Torah, and Qur'an all forms of written mind control?
"Praise the Lord, and pass the fracking pumps."
OK, I think liberals stir the pot to push their agendas no matter whether it is climate change, nationalizing the police force or fundamentally transforming the United States and they are very collective such as all political idiocies that have existed and who promise a Utopia and only delivers an anarchy.
Seems that there are a lot of problems in Florida with rising sea levels. No plan to address them.
People like the classic climate change deniers here on NT are going to stay that way until the water reaches their lower lip....... simply out of principle.
Kavika ,
The US coast has been replete with low lying areas for a long time . Look at New Orleans . Look at NYC ! All it takes is a severe storm to cause problems . But that article was about a dire warning that is repeated often for effect . It is all about scare tactics to get action on CO2 levels .
Here's a thought : suppose the problem is not CO2 levels . What if it's something else ?!
Some silly shiite causes more chaos than other silly shiite . Unprove climate theory is loaded with potential chaos .
All of those sources are not part of US legislation . Climate "protection" may soon be , unfortunately especially if Hillary gets elected .
Petey, rising sea level are having an effect world wide. There is plenty of proof of that.
Whether it's CO2 levels or not, it's happening. The question really is, are we going to keep denying it or face the problem.
Are you saying there is data to support that position ? By all means post a link .
Damage due to flooding does not reflect sea level rises . It reflects things like the size of coastal populations and coastal buildings more .
Oil is pretty much tantamount to god in the US ...
Flame ,
Perhaps you would care to explain how they measure a 128 mm rise over 2 years when the tidal variation amounts to meters per day . every day . Also there is a substantial local variation in sea level between different regions . If one region rises it could mean other regions are falling ...
I have the solution......
Take the money and the control out of climate change and the oceans will stop rising and climate change will stop being important.
No different than turn every illegal immigrant into a Republican and all of a sudden amnesty will lose its value.
All I've heard and experienced all my life is the east coast is being taken by the ocean a little each year.
The currents are not moving away from the east coast but sweeping it away and with every storm we have. Beach front property moves back a little until in some places it has moved past the homes, across the street and now the people who own beach homes that were across the street from the beach front homes are the new beach front homes. I can verify this from my life's experiences.
During the last few days there has been a tropical storm which just arrived on shore last night but was stationary out in the Atlantic for several days sweeping high tides along the east coast. Early this morning it moved onto land near Myrtle Beach and is presently moving over Fayetteville, NC as a tropical depression. The main threats going forward today and tonight will be downpours producing flooding, large swell along the coast and dangerous rip currents. So in the morning a little more of the east coast will be gone.
So all the lower east coast has been experiencing higher than normal waves and tides from this tropical storm sitting out in the ocean for several days.
Six , that is beach erosion , not rising tides . The sand removed by the wave action in one location gets deposited in another .
I couldn't help but notice that you didn't respond to any of the links Kavika posted over nine hours ago.
How about some others if you don't want to have to consider your position
U.S. Navy bracing for climate change
Good overview for those with blinders on.....
Hmmmmm..... do kangaroos hibernate? It would appear so.
Actually, they have been measuring it at the Bay of Fundy for decades....
{Chuckle}
Don't have the link but I do remember reading an article a couple of months ago about some Inuit villages, old and well established ones, that had to move further inland on the ice because rising sea levels had begun to threaten the villages which had been located on the same spots for centuries.
Kavika from here :
The following is an excerpt from your 1st link :
As you can see , the EPA [which is largely a political organization ] is talking about RELATIVE sea level rise not absolute rise . Bottom line , that is NOT a global issue , only a local issue . You're leading off with a strawman & that is a weak to non-existent argument about AGW issues .
Petey, if you read all the articles you'll see that it is not only a local issue. The Maldives, Alaska, Canada and areas of the South Pacific. I guess that it's local to those areas, if you choose to believe that it is.
Petey you can call anything you want a strawman argument, but it's simply your opinion, nothing more.
Reasoning from the particular to the general is one of the classical errors people make about complex issues . And that's what you did there . Do you think your dismissal of "Whatever Petey" is going to cover up your mistake ?
I see you altered your reply . Let me know when you have settled on what you actually want to say instead of the summary dismissal you initially chose .
LOLOL, Petey, WHATEVER.
I was giving you some links for debate, if you choose to be an attack kangaroo, have at it.
Next time I suggest you lead with your real argument instead of a data rich strawman .
Maybe you don't take data very seriously Petey, but the Pentagon has for the last 30 years... Simple things like even slightly warmer, more humid conditions mean that aircraft require more power to get off the ground. Higher water levels mean the Navy has more areas of brown water operation to be concerned with.
...
U.S. Navy bracing for climate change
Good overview for those with blinders on.....
...
Anyone who uses an article on Rolling tone for empirical data is the one with blinders on ...
In other words you surrender the point being made that the information on climate changes IS important, especially if the DoD has been looking at it from a national security standpoint for thirty years.
Is that what you are saying?
Or are you saying that the DoD shouldn't be worried about climate change related to national security?
When the DoD starts taking action instead of just "looking at it" I'll take notice . Until then , yawn .
Actually we already have... From my background in ASW.
Yes , variability , not a fixed extreme . And I have no idea what ASW means .
Anti-Submarine Warfare (AKA... Awfully Slow Warfare)
A truism in the art of war...
As such, with a change in technology comes a change in tactics.