What’s Next for Progressives?
For now, at least, the attempt to repeal the Affordable Care Act appears dead. Sabotage by a spiteful Trump administration is still a risk, but there is — gasp! — a bipartisan push to limit the damage, with Democrats who want to preserve recent gains allying with Republicans who fear that the public will blame them for declining coverage and rising premiums.
This represents a huge victory for progressives, who did a startlingly good job of marshaling facts, mobilizing public opinion, and pressuring politicians to stand their ground. But where do they go from here? If Democrats regain control of Congress and the White House, what will they do with the opportunity?
Well, some progressives — by and large people who supported Bernie Sanders in the primaries — are already trying to revive one of his signature proposals: expanding Medicare to cover everyone. Some even want to make support for single-payer a litmus test for Democratic candidates.
So it’s time for a little pushback. A commitment to universal health coverage — bringing in the people currently falling through Obamacare’s cracks — should definitely be a litmus test. But single-payer, while it has many virtues, isn’t the only way to get there; it would be much harder politically than its advocates acknowledge; and there are more important priorities.
The key point to understand about universal coverage is that we know a lot about what it takes, because every other wealthy country has it. How do they do it? Actually, lots of different ways.
Look at the latest report by the nonpartisan Commonwealth Fund, comparing health care performance among advanced nations. America is at the bottom; the top three performers are Britain, Australia, and the Netherlands. And the thing is, these three leaders have very different systems.
Britain has true socialized medicine: The government provides health care directly through the National Health Service. Australia has a single-payer system, basically Medicare for All — it’s even called Medicare. But the Dutch have what we might call Obamacare done right: individuals are required to buy coverage from regulated private insurers, with subsidies to help them afford the premiums.
And the Dutch system works, which suggests that a lot could be accomplished via incremental improvements in the A.C.A., rather than radical change. Further evidence for this view is how relatively well Obamacare, imperfect as it is, already works in states that try to make it work — did you know that only 5.4 percent of New Yorkers are now uninsured?
Meanwhile, the political logic that led to Obamacare rather than Medicare for all still applies.
It’s not just about paying off the insurance industry, although getting insurers to buy in to health reform wasn’t foolish, and arguably helped save the A.C.A.: At a crucial moment America’s Health Insurance Plans, the industry lobbying organization, and Blue Cross Blue Shield intervened to denounce Republican plans.
A far more important consideration is minimizing disruption to the 156 million people who currently get insurance through their employers, and are largely satisfied with their coverage. Moving to single-payer would mean taking away this coverage and imposing new taxes; to make it fly politically you’d have to convince most of these people both that they would save more in premiums than they pay in additional taxes, and that their new coverage would be just as good as the old.
This might in fact be true, but it would be one heck of a hard sell. Is this really where progressives want to spend their political capital?
What would I do instead? I’d enhance the A.C.A., not replace it, although I would strongly support reintroducing some form of public option — a way for people to buy into public insurance — that could eventually lead to single-payer.
Meanwhile, progressives should move beyond health care and focus on other holes in the U.S. safety net.
When you compare the U.S. social welfare system with those of other wealthy countries, what really stands out now is our neglect of children. Other countries provide new parents with extensive paid leave, provide high-quality, subsidized day care for children with working parents and make pre-K available to everyone or almost everyone; we do none of these things. Our spending on families is a third of the advanced-country average, putting us down there with Mexico and Turkey.
Demonstrating in support of
a paid parental leave bill
in San Francisco last year.
Beyond health care,
the American safety net
has major holes, especially
when it comes to children
Credit Jim Wilson The New York Times
So if it were up to me, I’d talk about improving the A.C.A., not ripping it up and starting over, while opening up a new progressive front on child care.
I have nothing against single-payer; it’s what I’d support if we were starting fresh. But we aren’t: Getting there from here would be very hard, and might not accomplish much more than a more modest, incremental approach. Even idealists need to set priorities, and Medicare-for-all shouldn’t be at the top of the list.
-------------------------------
Original article https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/07/opinion/healthcare-single-payer-children.html by Paul Krugman NY Times https://www.nytimes.com/
There may be links in the Original Article that have not been reproduced here.
Tags
Who is online
73 visitors

This is a few days old, and since it appeared, Krugman has taken some flak for not toeing the single-payer line.
Progressives are ticked that the mainstream Democrats were totally uncompromising on their platform - mostly because the party is crack addicted to corporate contributions and saddled with the obligations that creates.
But what I find in turn lately is progressives are becoming at least as hard line.
There's no reason for any of that. I'd say the mainstream party has to detox from contributions somewhat and get a platform and candidates that give us confidence they're going to do something for us. And at least adopt a few items that are on Sanders' platform.
Progressives have to realize that they won't get everything and for heaven's sake stop whining about Sanders losing the primary. Clinton won that thing.
For progressives, I'd say being uncompromising is exactly what Sanders does not want. If Sanders wanted things his way, he could do third party tomorrow and he's easily got the movement and the support to pull it off. But he realizes how damaging that would be and what a free ride the GOP would get out of it.
It's essential right now for progressives and the mainstream party to unify for real. And it's actually what Sanders wants. Sanders clearly demonstrated that he won't compromise with the Democratic party just because they asked him to - they have to make some clear reforms. We should get on that.
So... You didn't read the seed, either...
You don't think the hard line differences between mainstream Democrats and Sanders' progressives is at the heart of it?
I appreciate your attempt to unify somewhat - yes it's very well possible that reforming ACA is better and a good compromise over trying for single payer. I see at least the effort to compromise and unify as a step in the right direction.
It might even be affordable. I'd like to see a few things on the progressive agenda happen, but one of my biggest objections is the go-to answer is always tax the rich and they'll pay for all this. If you're middle class and you think your taxes won't go up sharply to pay for free college and single payer, you're utterly delusional.
I remember working with a young man from Germany and his taxes all rolled up is about 60%. I have roughly the same income and mine would be about 45%. So the question is - is it worth it to pay 15% of your income more but in exchange have totally free health care, college, subsidized or free child care, good retirement and perhaps other benefits?
For some people this exchange works. And for others it does not.
Subsidized child care - a debate for another time perhaps. We all have our ideas on what works best but the left is experiencing real damage based on the schism between mainstream Democrats and Sanders' progressives and in my view, it shouldn't be that hard to unify for real and come up with something good.
Well... If you hadn't read it before, you have now... and that's a good thing!
Subsidized child care - a debate for another time perhaps.
Krugman's point in this article (Paul Krugman wrote it, not I) is that, in his opinion, now is very much the moment to put policies like child care on the table. Fixing health care is not a particularly progressive topic any more -- it has become a GOP problem that the Dems will be happy to assist on, if the call for collaboration is in good faith.
It's time for progressives to consider that health care is a done deal, and to start ringing the bells for other social progress.
Onward!
There's absolutely no chance the GOP's going to do anything with health care other than to try again to kill it but I appreciate your positive attitude.
It's somewhat off the rail, but what I'd like to see is a form of "Medicare for all" that is high deductible and designed to very well cover anyone that has a major medical incident and we all pay into that. In my view, if you run up 2-3K because you had a skiing accident or some such thing, you can pay for that yourself unless you're indigent or very poor. The thing in my mind we absolutely have to get away from is the idea you can get money from other taxpayers for things you can pay yourself.
I agree with Sanders that health care is a right. Everyone gets treated when they need help. But that doesn't remotely equate in my mind to the idea that you can get everything paid for on other people's money when you have the means to pay for it.
There's absolutely no chance the GOP's going to do anything with health care other than to try again to kill it but I appreciate your positive attitude.
Oh, I agree... at least for the moment... I did not say that the GOP thinks that health-care is its problem. But all the polls say that Americans -- we the people -- now consider it the GOP's problem, so I agree with Krugman that is is time to put other stuff on the table.
The Dems cannot do health-care because they are the minority. They must wait until the GOP realizes how disastrous it would be for them to preside over a collapse of health-care, and then maybe improvements may be made. The important point is that the health-care ball is in the GOP's camp.
Your skiing accident example is a very good one. I would like to see EMT and evac costs charged to the skier, as well as medical costs. The result, of course, would be generalization of "ski-trip insurance". The poor, who don't go skiing, would not be required (as they now are) to participate in skiers' risk pool.
More generally, I would like to see insurance premiums adjusted to the risks taken by the insured. If a motorcyclist doesn't want to wear a helmet... that OK with me... but I don't want to pay for his brain trauma.
... and so on...
At this point, I think the GOP's just going to muddle through with ACA and all as it is. They're not going to address anything.
Backing up a moment, to me a disappointment is that Trump had all kinds of rhetoric about providing health care and really he owes the GOP absolutely nothing. He had the chance to be independent and score some points, but he turned into the GOP's biatch. I'd like to dream that it's still not too late - Sanders and Trump could work together. The result probably won't be single payer or even close, but I can easily see it as much better than what we have now especially if you believe something is better than nothing.
On the no helmet and brain trauma thing - good point and I'd like to agree. But in the real world, if there's tens of thousands of dollars worth of medical and surgery because of head trauma and the idiot didn't wear a helmet and has no savings or insurance, we will not turn him out on the street. We don't do that. What I'd like to do with someone like that is determine what we can get - if it's 100 dollars a month, then so be it. Right now we collect nothing and that 100 dollars a month is something. And it makes the point - if that money is important to the idiot, it's perhaps some additional incentive to wear the %)(_U helmet next time. And the principle is that you pay in what you can afford to pay for your medical - you do your best.
But if you're still short, you still get treated and we pay. That's the right thing to do. Just get past the mentality that it's a 100% handout.
And on the high end, that's what I want the national insurance to be for. Stop this deranged idiocy of not covering things that aren't totally in the "reasonable and customary" slot - if you're out of options but there's a treatment you can try that's succeeded for others, you do it at any cost. And no max either.
I'm reiterating, but this whole diatribe is that we grossly overinsure on the bottom but grossly underinsure at the top. Whether we do ACA, single payer, socialized, or nothing we need to fix that.
At this point, I think the GOP's just going to muddle through with ACA and all as it is. They're not going to address anything.
Could be. Your crystal ball is as good as mine...
But in the real world, if there's tens of thousands of dollars worth of medical and surgery because of head trauma and the idiot didn't wear a helmet and has no savings or insurance, we will not turn him out on the street.
I would stick to the law. We have to have car/bike insurance. I would simply add a clause about helmets, and adjust the premium according to what the customer wants. If the customer says he'll wear a helmet... and then doesn't... I think the lawyers will take his house and everything else he owns. And he'll deserve it!
I'm reiterating, but this whole diatribe is that we grossly overinsure on the bottom but grossly underinsure at the top.
Totally agree... and when I'm waxing cynical, I imagine that this is entirely in the interest of the Big Dogs... as usual. They have us all paying into a risk pool from which they profit.