╌>

What draws people to anarchy? Left-wing extremism and smashing stuff but mostly smashing stuff

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  redding-shasta-jefferson-usa  •  9 years ago  •  7 comments

What draws people to anarchy? Left-wing extremism and smashing stuff but mostly smashing stuff
The Washington Post published a piece today titled “What draws Americans to anarchy? It’s more than just smashing windows.” The story itself isn’t as dumb as the headline suggests, but it never does demonstrate that what draws people to anarchism is anything beyond a kind of left-wing outlaw chic.



Legba Carrefour was one of the organizers behind Disrupt J20, the group of black bloc anarchists who created hassles at inauguration checkpoints and riots through parts of Washington, D.C. Carrefour tells the Post he became an anarchist after watching the G20 protests in Seattle on television. He knows smashing things turns people off but tells the Post, “The notion of convincing people is a liberal idea.” He adds, “I also think it’s important to attack the symbols of capitalism. It’s just property at the end of the day.”

One of those symbols of capitalism which got destroyed during the inauguration riots Carrefour helped plan was a 2015 stretch limo belonging to Muhammad Ashraf.

SEE ALSO:
Bananas: Princeton philosopher explains why it's okay to abort babies who don't have a "future" or something
Ashraf, 52, owner of Virginia-based Nationwide Chauffeured Services, watched on television as his limo was engulfed in flames. The vehicle was a total loss. After insurance payments, it cost him $60,000 out of pocket to replace, he said.

“When that car becomes a source of your livelihood, it becomes a part of your life. I don’t know if the protesters understand that when they destroy something — the way I felt when I saw my car burning, it really hurt me deeply even though it’s just a car,” he said. “Six months later, I still want to know, did that accomplish anything?”
There’s no answer to that question in the piece. It’s not clear if the author ever asked Carrefour to justify the destruction of the limo, though it seems like the most obvious question to ask. Another anarchist featured in the piece is Sammi LeMaster, a 22-year-old American University graduate who considered herself a “far-left Democrat” before getting involved with anarchists in Washington, D.C.:

On Inauguration Day, she joined a group of LGBT activists and blocked Trump supporters from entering the Mall through a security checkpoint. Later, she said, she saw the brawl between D.C. police and the black-masked protesters and watched as police doused people around her with pepper spray.

The next day, she and dozens of other activists — mostly anarchists — rallied at D.C. Superior Court, offering rides, food and cigarettes to protesters who were arrested and held overnight. LeMaster stood with the group, chanting “anti, anti-capitalista” as each person walked out. It was then she realized this community of anarchists was her own.
And that’s it. LeMaster did some rioting and anti-capitalist chanting and felt at home. Again, there’s no justification for the “diversity of tactics” approach to protesting (smashing and burning things). LeMaster seems concerned about the “baggage” anarchism has but she’s not asked to justify her decision to align herself with that baggage. Again, this seems like the obvious question to ask but it doesn’t get asked for some reason.

There’s more in the piece, including one anarchist who took it up after attending a punk rock show, but the article never does offer much of a justification for the violence which is the main distinctive of anarchist protests. As a reader, you’re left with the impression that participants feel there’s a certain outlaw romance to the whole thing, i.e. dressing in black, wearing a mask, breaking windows and breaking the law, running from police, etc. That kind of excitement tinged with the risk of being arrested must create a real adrenaline rush and some group solidarity among those who do it. You can imagine them sitting around later talking about all the chaos and replaying their role in it for friends.



Does any of that justify destroying Muhammad Ashraf’s limo or doing $100,000 worth of damage to buildings in the form of broken glass? I don’t think so but clearly, the anarchists must. So why not ask them to explain it. It’s the only question really worth asking these people: What appeals to you about breaking things? But the Post sidesteps the question by suggesting there are other reasons for being an anarchist and then doesn’t deliver much in the way of other reasons.

This is one of those stories where the desire to write a Vox-style “but actually” piece just gets in the way of telling it. Here’s a reminder of what these people actually did back in January: http://hotair.com/archives/2017/08/10/draws-people-anarchy-left-wing-extremism-smashing-stuff-mostly-smashing-stuff/

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Atheist יוחנן בן אברהם אבינו
Junior Quiet
link   Atheist יוחנן בן אברהם אבינו    9 years ago

Fuck this self-serving rightwing bullshit projection. 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Atheist יוחנן בן אברהם אבינו   9 years ago

Cogent argument. I'm sure it will sway hearts and minds.

 
 
 
Jeremy Retired in NC
Professor Guide
link   Jeremy Retired in NC    9 years ago

          “I also think it’s important to attack the symbols of capitalism. It’s just property at the end of the day.”

Until that property is his.  This clowns perception is seriously flawed.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  Jeremy Retired in NC   9 years ago

Someone who lives off the dole, no doubt. 

 

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    9 years ago

There is only one kind of anarchist. Not two. Just one. An anarchist, the only kind, as defined by the long tradition and literature of the position itself, is a person in opposition to authority imposed through the hierarchical power of the state. The only expansion of this that seems to me reasonable is to say that an anarchist stands in opposition to any imposed authority.

An anarchist is a voluntarist.

- Advertisement - name="aswift_1" width="468" height="60" frameborder="0" marginwidth="0" marginheight="0"> Now, beyond that, anarchists also are people and, as such, contain the billion-faceted varieties of human reference. Some are anarchists who march, voluntarily, to the Cross of Christ. Some are anarchists who flock, voluntarily, to the communes of beloved, inspirational father figures. Some are anarchists who seek to establish the syndics of voluntary industrial production. Some are anarchists who voluntary seek to establish the rural production of the kibbutzim. Some are anarchists who, voluntarily, seek to disestablish everything including their own association with other people; the hermits. Some are anarchists who will deal, voluntarily, only in gold, will never co-operate, and swirl their capes. Some are anarchists who, voluntarily, worship the sun and its energy, build domes, eat only vegetables, and play the dulcimer. Some are anarchists who worship the power of algorithms, play strange games, and infiltrate strange temples. Some are anarchists who see only the stars. Some are anarchists who see only the mud. They spring from a single seed, no matter the flowering of their ideas. The seed is liberty. And that is all it is. It is not a socialist seed. It is not a capitalist seed. It is not a mystical seed. It is not a determinist seed. It is simply a statement.  We can  be free. After that it’s all choice and chance. Anarchism, liberty, does not tell you a thing about how free people will behave or what arrangements they will make. It simply says that people have the capacity  to  make the arrangements. Anarchism is not normative. It does not say how to be free. It says only that freedom, liberty, can exist Recently, in a libertarian journal, I read the statement that libertarianism is an ideological movement. It may well be. In a concept of freedom it, they, you, or we, anyone, has the liberty to engage in ideology or anything else that does not coerce others, denying their liberty. But anarchism is not an ideological movement. It is an ideological statement. It says that all people have a capacity for liberty. It says that all anarchists want liberty. And then it is silent. After the pause of that silence, anarchists then mount the stages of their own communities and history and proclaim their, not anarchism’s, ideologies—they say how they, how they as anarchists, will make arrangements, describe events, celebrate life, work. Anarchism is the hammer-idea, smashing the chains. Liberty is what results and, in liberty, everything else is up to people and their ideologies. It is not up to THE ideology. Anarchism says, in effect, there is no such upper case, dominating ideology. It says that people who live in liberty make their own histories and their own deals with and within it. A person who describes a world in which everyone must or should behave in a single way, marching to a single drummer, is simply not an anarchist. A person who says that they prefer this way, even wishing that all would prefer that way, but who then says that all must decide, may certainly be an anarchist. Probably is. Liberty is liberty. Anarchism is anarchism. Neither is Swiss cheese or anything else. They are not property. They are not copyrighted. They are old, available ideas, part of human culture. They may be hyphenated but they are not in fact hyphenated. They exist on their own. People add hyphens, and supplemental ideologies. I am an anarchist. I need to know that, and you should know it. After that, I am a writer and a welder who lives in a certain place, by certain lights, and with certain people. And that you may know also. But there is no hyphen after the anarchist. Liberty, finally, is not a box into which people are to be forced. Liberty is a space in which people may live. It does not tell you how they will live. It says, eternally, only that we  can. Originally published in  the dandelion , Spring 1980 https://www.libertarianinstitute.org/libertarianism/anarchism-without-hyphens/  
 
 

Who is online





69 visitors