A Crucial Lesson Learned from Digging Trenches in the Rain
As related by Stan McChrystal, Retired General U.S. Army
The cold fall evening felt more like winter as our over-loaded mules pulled up onto the west side of the North Carolina hill and we dismounted. Packs, ammunition, and weapons were quickly unloaded from the curious Vietnam-era vehicles that looked like an oversized childs wagon and pull-started (and often didnt) with a lawnmower lanyard. I surveyed my command, 20 or so vintage 1977 paratroopers, three 81 mm mortars, and enough ammunition (some of it vintage 1943) to conduct gunnery training for two full days.
As a still-new 2nd Lieutenant I knew that while gunnery (essentially mortar marksmanship) was our primary objective, standards mattered, and I directed my Platoon Sergeant to have the paratroopers dig pits for the mortars to fire from. In peacetime gunnery, digging in was largely superfluous to developing skills, but Id been taught that in combat it was key for survival. And digging would mark me as a leader with unwaveringly high standards.
When youre wielding a shovel, mortar pits are nothing more than big holes, which after a couple of hours, is what I suspected the troopers considered me. But the task was finite and as the evening grew late, we neared completion with a certain element of relief and pride. The rest of the field time would be relatively easy, and because few other platoons dug in regularly, the troopers could take perverse pride in the effort expended.
As the time to begin live firing approached, I got on the PRC-77 radio and called Range Control, the administrative element that coordinated training on Fort Bragg to ensure safety, and requested approval to begin firing. After a moment of silence, the request was denied. Weapons Platoon of Charlie Company, under my apparently incompetent leadership, had set up at the wrong firing point several kilometers off course.
To avoid moving to a new location (mortar pits dont move), but more than anything to save face, my Platoon Sergeant and I drove to Range Control to plead with them in person to correct my mistake by reassigning us to the Firing Point wed just finished digging in on. But we got nowhere. Soon we were driving back to the platoon to tell them we were moving.
My paratroopers were probably disgusted at the news, but hid it admirably, and began the laborious task of reloading the mules and filling in each of the mortar pits with Staff Sergeant Porter and I simultaneously supervising and shoveling. Around midnight, we were done and after a time the recalcitrant mules started, and we headed to the new site.
It wasnt far, but by the time we pulled in a light but steady rain was accompanying the frigid evening. The platoon was dirty, tired, and now, increasingly wet. As I walked the new firing point, selecting locations for each of the mortars, the paratroopers quietly unloaded the mules, periodically glancing toward me. The next command was important. Would we dig-in again?
There were powerful arguments against it. Wed already trained that skill earlier in the evening; it would take precious time from night firing; we were getting wetter by the minute; and after all, it had been my mistake. Why punish the many for the foul-up of the one, particularly if the one is a 2nd Lieutenant? For a few long moments, I pondered the issue.
Few decisions in my life were as starkly clear as this one. A decision that in the grand scheme of things had almost no importance to anyone, anywhere, was now very important to 20 soggy paratroopers and me. Although no lives were at stake and no fortunes in the balance, a complicated intersection of pride, standards, credibility, and consideration for the welfare of soldiers produced an agonizingly uncomfortable moment that I remembered for the next 33 years of my career.
A couple of hours later, we were almost finished. The rain had beaten steadily down, transforming each shovel full of dirt into heavier mud. But the pits were as Id ordered, and more importantly, as they should have been.
Like my paratroopers, I was muddy and exhausted from digging, but it felt right.
In the years that followed there were countless opportunities to dig, or not to dig. On more than one occasion, my mistake caused soldiers to dig, move, and then dig again. On hills far from North Carolina, some of my mistakes resulted in the digging of graves. But when the choice arose, there was always a sense of what was right whether or not it was safer, easier, or more popular.
If I were 22 again, I hope Id dig.
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/i-were-22-dont-take-shortcuts-even-when-one-looking-stan-mcchrystal

General McChrystal's anecdote relates a very important life lesson that sadly seems largely lost in today's society.
If you were 22 again, what would you do differently, if anything?
For me, I would focus less on career and more on family and friends - there would be a deeper relationship with extended family and old friends which is something I miss as I grow older.
There are a few things I would change, but nothing major!
Nona
That is likely true of most folks
Thanks for the feedback
I think it is the sum of all our experiences that leads us to where we are today. There are decisions that I made that I would like to change, but if I hadn't made them, and learned from my mistakes, I would never have learned some important life's lessons. So, the heartache and soul searching was worth it.
Frankly, I wouldn't go back to that age for all the tea in China. Nor would I go back to those times, again... Perhaps I am focusing too much on what is happening today, and looking for a better future.
Dowser
Thanks for the perspective
I am also happy with my current life, but sometimes think "what if" - not productive perhaps, but it makes me think about choices I made
jennilee
True for me as well, and likely for most everyone, it is those decisions that didn't quite turn out as we expected that tend to mold us and our character more than when things turn out perfectly as planned.
Thanks for the feedback
A perfect example of why ''troopers'' don't usually allow 2nd Looies to make decisions.
Yup, there are some things I would change, but it is, what it is.
The old saying, ''never look over your shoulder, someone or something may be catching up.''
Curahee!!!!
Way too many things going on today and tomorrow that need my attention.
In short, I really can't afford to think about yesterday too much except to try and learn from the multitude of mistakes I made.
Kavika
I remember a couple of my Lt's, who became excellent officers) who would look for a nod or advice from me (PSG) when a decision was needed but not being hesitant to make a decision on their own if they disagreed.
And I always supported their decisions.
As to your adage - true very true!
A good approach for all of us
I got to watch a couple of LTJGs (O2) spend the day washing our aircraft on the flight line under the watchful eye of one of our CPOs. Rumor had it that the skipper overheard them say something to the effect that "they didn't feel the squadron enlisted personnel were working hard or fast enough suit them.".
As such, these junior officers helped us out with our work load. Somewhere in the afternoon, the skipper put on some coveralls, and went out and spent some time washing next to them for a few minutes clarifying his views on how his squadron worked.
Yes, this was the same CO I've mentioned that was out helping change out an engine when we were at sea as our maintenance load that was balling up on us due to operational requirements. He didn't care about rank, only that we as a squadron met our mission tasking requirements without fail.
FLY
Not sure I agree with the CO's approach but I have heard similar stories from members of the other branches and it likely got the message across.
Thanks for sharing the story
Our CO believed in teamwork through and through... period! He was God..... and we followed his leadership.
In the 30 months I was with the squadron back in 82-84, we managed to capture "Golden Wrench" award for superior squadron maintenance, a Battle "E", the Jimmy Thatch and Arnold Isabel awards for ASW excellence.
Kind of hard to argue with the man's results. I'm sure many of us would have followed him into a burning house without hesitation.
FLY
I am not questioning him as a leader
I served under some good ones as well, but the best of them would not put a junior officer in a position that embarrassed or belittled them in the eyes of subordinates.
They might have been strongly urged in private to get dirty and do the work along with the men and then have it seen as their own initiative, which would generate more respect from the men in my view.
I would have never put a PSG or senior NonCom in such a position either, but I encouraged my subordinate leaders to be there with their men in the good and the bad and it worked that way as well.
Different roads to the same place I guess.