NATO starts anti submarine exercise in North Sea as tension with Russia rise
Reuters) - NATO launched one of its biggest-ever anti-submarine exercises in the North Sea on Monday, inviting non-member Sweden for the first time, amid increasing tensions between Russia and its northern neighbors.
More than a dozen vessels from 11 countries are participating in the "Dynamic Mongoose" exercise. NATO will simulate detecting and attacking submarines in one of the most hostile seas, with rugged but shallow underwater canyons, rapid currents and unusually high sound pollution from freshwater pouring in from Norway's fjords.
Tensions have run high since Russia annexed part of Ukraine last year, with the three small Baltic states, who also rely on the Nordics for defense, fearing they may be next as they are home to big Russian minorities.
Finland detected an unidentified submarine along its coast last week, firing depth charges at the vessel, while NATO-member Latvia, a former Soviet state, last month said it detected a Russian submarine near its waters.
Russian aircraft have also repeatedly approached and even violated Nordic and Baltic airspace in recent months, challenging air defenses and triggering allied responses.
"Russia has a right to be at sea, just as we do," Rear Admiral Brad Williamson, the commander of the exercise said. "But the incidents we have seen are not in line with international regulations... and that's been the cause of concern."
"This is not a response to that... but provides relevance to the exercise," Williamson said on board the USS Vicksburg, the lead vessel in the exercise.
Nordic defense ministers issued a strongly worded condemnation of Russia last month, calling it the biggest threat to security, prompting Russia to say that Finland's and Sweden's closer ties with NATO were of "special concern".
"The Russians have increased their activity a lot and so have we," said Kai Nickelsdorf, the commander of Germany's U33 submarine, which is playing the role of an enemy in the exercise.
The four submarines involved, including a Swedish one, will be tasked to approach and target the ships undetected, simulating an attack on surface ships.
Although Norway shares a long maritime border with Russia in the Arctic, it played down the recent increase in activity.
"We saw a drop in activity level a few years ago and it's now back to where it was, the normal level," Ole Morten Sandqvist, the commander of the Norwegian fleet said. "The number of ships, aircraft in the air and so forth.. has become more frequent than it used to be."
http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/05/04/us-nato-submarine-idUSKBN0NP12820150504

Damn! I'm missing all the fun!
From some of my other readings, our surface and air units are pretty rusty when it comes to ASW. The sub community is still very capable, but I'd bet their game is off from what it was in the late 1980s.
Acoustically, the North Sea is a pretty nasty environment if you're trying to locate and track a sub.
Back to the future!!!
Last week Finland was dropping charges on a suspected sub in their waters....
Let the good times roll!
Good for Finland.
I guess the Cold War is back on... SIGH!
Finns have a tremendous national pride, and unlike many they still have a requirement for military service for ALL young men. They have kept their military sharp and equipped. (they really don't like the Russians)
I'm curious to see if Bruce T. has kept up on the status of US Submarine forces like I have with our aviation units. Does the Bear really have the subs to put to sea to worry about?
This is an article from Proceedings (Naval Institute) from a couple of years ago that outlined what our friends in Moscow have been up to.....
Thanks for the link! I'll go check it out!
Pointless saber rattling. Crimea will continue to be part of Russia, Russia will continue to undermine any effort to bring Ukraine into NATO or the EU (for its own security reasons), and NATO isn't going to do any more about it in the future than it's doing now . . . so marching armies around and sailing ships back and forth is purely for show.
I am sure this did not sound so disingenuous in his head, before it came out of his mouth
Pretty much...
Germany and France have no stomach for it.
At least it is a much needed exercise. We have really degraded as far as our surface and air ASW capabilities over the last couple of decades.
I'm going to say it's been 15 years since the Navy did any real ASW operations in the North Sea. ASW skills are perishable. You can have the best equipment in the world, but unless your sonar techs know what they are listening too, and the tactical officers know what subs are likely to do...
Face it, subs already have 90% of the advantage in the game of cat-n-mouse. That's why hunting with other subs is important.
That's why ASW detection and ranging is so important, once discovered they are dead meat. I don't suspect right now the Russians have sufficient submarine forces to pose a dominant threat, but enough of a threat to cause concern.
Finland getting all up in a sonar contacts face is nothing unusual, they do it all the time in fact. What is unusual is the depth charges. If they felt the incursion was strong enough to attack, whatever or whomever it was was somewhere the Finns really didn't like such to be.
That is unusual and represents an escalation given the Finns pushing towards closer ties to Nato....
Little baby steps taken lead to larger steps....
Still on course for a confrontation come some time next year.
I would say the cold war is definitely back "ON" and a bit warmer than before.
Their stuff is getting quieter too.
Back years ago when we trained against the Ohio's (they defined to term "quiet"), we didn't so much look for sound, but for an absence of sound. The proverbial "hole in the water". I would guess newer signal processors are doing that and more. I know that MAD detection systems have gotten better. I just hope the kids are good.
FLY
I have no doubt that training is important and training against a live opposing force is the best training of all
But I stand by my diagnosis of disingenuousness on the part of the Admiral on the timing of this training
So noted Robert..... Have the Quartermaster make a log entry to the same.
I thought that they were working on a system to detect magnetic anomalies such as you would find with a large mass of steel pushing through brine. Moving towards sonar being more of a confirmation system rather than a detection system, I'll have to look that up again and see if it went anywhere.
When I read it it seemed like a promising technology...
I know the "Hole in the water" the sub masks background noise so the loss of it means an area for more and much closer scrutiny. I suspect the Russians are on to that by now...
But like anything, there are those who are very adept at it as in have a talent for it. I hope we still have some of them around. We are going to need them.
Improving MAD ranges is bumping up against the laws of physics. It is technically feasible, but not really all that productive.
You remember enough of you physics to remember that a magnetic field source (like a sub) drops off as the third power of the distance. In short, we have to have a sensor eight times as sensitive to double our range.
Back in the day our slant range for MAD was around 500-600 meters. If I had to guess with the newer detectors that may be up to 750-800 meters slant range. Hardly a primary means of detection.
They're working hard on airborne blue light lasers, but that technology is still years away. Some of the newest items include fiber-optic towed arrays which are lighter, stronger, thus can be made longer with higher data rate transfers.
But again..... it's going to come down to the kids operating the systems. They've got to be good.
Unless that is underwater physics , power is proportional to the inverse 2nd power of distance .
We have a right to conduct training exercises in any international waters and in the waters of any ally of ours that wants to allow it or who wants to train with us. If any other nation, including Russia, doesn't like it, tough shit.
You are correct Petey in all regards to with that statement.
Yes, also taking into account density, which does change rather frequently under water.
Sorry I didn't get back sooner, was gone for a day..
I think you can safely say that the EU and NATO expansion had a thing or two to do with it as well.
I think you can safely say that the EU and NATO expansion had a thing or two to do with it as well.
As well as Vladimir Putin.
The current administration's foreign policy has brought American into another cold war.
How? Specifically.