Epic takedown of liberal 'fact checker'
We tip our AT caps to Sean Davis of The Federalist for his superb takedown of a so-called fact checker from PunditFact , a nonprofit, tax exempt organization that pretends to investigate claims found in journalism and render a fact-based judgment on their accuracy.
There are a number of leftist fact-checkers that function as arms of the Democrats, debunking conservative critics. Davis and the Federalist drew the attention of PunditFact because Rush Limbaugh quoted their work:
Between 2009 and 2012, the Clinton Foundation raised over $500 million dollars according to a review of IRS documents by The Federalist (2012, 2011, 2010, 2009, 2008). A measly 15 percent of that, or $75 million, went towards programmatic grants.
Davis explains what happened:
PunditFact just declared that a demonstrably true fact was false because, according to PunditFact, the factual claim ignores critical facts that would give a different impression. Facts are strange that way. They do tend to give an impression of the truth, even if some people find that impression discomfiting.
It gets more embarrassing than that, though. In an unsolicited April 28 e-mail to me, PunditFact author Louis Jacobson told me unequivocally that the demonstrably factual claim he was examining was clearly accurate and technically true. But today, Jacobson declares, that fact is suddenly Mostly False.
Last month, I wrote a meticulously researched article examining several years worth of financial data from the Clinton Foundation. What I found was that of the roughly $500 million raised by the Clinton Foundation from 2009 through 2012, barely 15 percent of its expenditures were charitable grants to other organizations. (snip)
The Mostly False declaration of PunditFacts Louis Jacobson is even more fascinating given that he was not aware until I told him so that the Clinton Foundation annual report and the Clinton Foundations tax filings are not apples-to-apples comparisons. A researcher familiar with the subject material he was researching would have known that, but Jacobson did not. The annual report lumps together numerous distinct non-profit entities, whereas the tax filings were related to a single tax-exempt entity, the Clinton Foundation, also referred to as the Bill, Hillary, & Chelsea Clinton Foundation.
I didnt re-run your calculations, but I entirely agree that the 990s paint a different picture than what the foundation says (such as in its annual report), Jacobson told me in his initial e-mail to me. Its such a yawning gap that there has to be some sort of explanation, and thats what Im looking for.
I gave Jacobson multiple explanations as to the source of that yawning gap. Well set aside for the moment that a decent journalist shouldve been able to figure out those gaps on his own by simply examining the annual report and the tax filings. Were not talking rocket science here. Jacobson is not that journalist. Jacobsons issue wasnt with a lack of explanations. His issue was that the actual explanations didnt jibe with the story he wanted to tell.
Read more: http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2015/05/epic_takedown_of_liberal_fact_checker.html#ixzz3ZBCJcZ5R
