Dynamic Scoring Of Tax Cuts Is A No-Brainer
T he appointment of Keith Hall as director of the Congressional Budget Office coincides with the adoption by Congress of legislation that requires "dynamic scoring" of proposed tax law changes.
It appears Dr. Hall's appointment signifies an intention to make sure that, going forward, the CBO will adhere to the spirit, as well as the letter, of the new mandate from Congress.
What is important is that he not be distracted from this effort by politically driven gripes from economists who should know better than to question the congressional intention behind that mandate.
The only question that Hall or any competent economist might ask in considering the question of dynamic scoring is, "Why would we do it any other way?" Dynamic scoring means measuring the impact on tax revenues of a change in tax law by taking into account how that change will affect the base on which the tax is imposed.
Because changing a tax law will always change the base on which the tax is imposed, it would be nonsensical to assume that the base will remain fixed under a new law. Yet that is exactly what the proponents of "static scoring" want to assume. And it is static scoring that dynamic scoring is intended to replace.
Suppose that someone committed to the idea of static scoring thinks that income taxes are too low. Well, if the combined federal and state income tax applicable to the top federal tax bracket is 50% (as it is in some states), then, under the canons of static scoring, we might as well double the rate and double the amount of revenue collected from that tax bracket.
Dynamic scoring would produce the obvious conclusion that the amount of revenue collected would go to zero, inasmuch as no one will bother to earn (or report) any income that is taxed at 100%.
Actual proposed tax changes are seldom so drastic (even though the top federal rate was 91% when Kennedy took office and 70% for Reagan). But the principle always holds: If the government increases the tax rate by 10%, revenues will rise by less than 10%, since the base will shrink in response to the higher tax rate.
Similarly, if it cuts the tax rate by 10%, revenues will fall by less than 10%, since the base will expand. Anyone who took Economics 101 had to understand that principle in order to get a passing grade.
Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials-perspective/050115-750620-cbo-must-use-dynamic-scoring-when-measuring-revenue-effects-of-tax-cuts.htm#ixzz3Z8qqa7uY

XX, what is dynamic scoring? I don't understand.
Thanks!