Analysis: In Baltimore unrest, liberalism on trial?
"Then, as now, one can observe in the commentary on Baltimore the emergence of two distinct camps: the Literalists and the Impressionists. As in art, the Literalists embrace realism and regard both life and the larger universe as reducible to particulars: Objective facts can be established, any scene can be rendered in minute and unfailingly accurate detail.
In the theater of sadness that was West Baltimore this week, the Literalist camp paradoxically united two rather disparate groups of onlookers: those who remained fixed on the facts surrounding the death of Freddie Gray in police custody, including chief prosecutor Marilyn Mosby, a Democrat, and many activists in the African-American community; and those who, like former New York City Mayor Rudolph Giuliani, a Republican, vocally decried the lawlessness in the streets and demanded a more robust response by law enforcement.
It is my job to examine and investigate the evidence of each case, Mosby said when, on Friday, she announced the indictment of six Baltimore police officers in Grays death.
Here is the rule I had with my police department and my police commissioner, Giuliani recalled on Hannity on April 28. First rock, get arrested. Second rock, get arrested. Despite their divergent worldviews, both Mosby and Giuliani, himself a former prosecutor, adopted the strict Literalist view, in the sense that they were apt to see the action unfolding in Baltimore in concrete, factual, even numerical terms. Every victim of police brutality and every lawbreaker in the rioting each case, as Mosby put it, and the thrower of even a single rock, as Giuliani put it must swiftly be brought before the bar of justice.
The Impressionists on the scene in Baltimore, however, are more inclined to move beyond the specifics, to see before their eyes something more than a demolished CVS. The Impressionists eschew the particular for generalization; they paint in broad strokes and speak not of specific cases but of sweeping historical dynamics and trends.
It has nothing to do with West Baltimore or this particular corner in Baltimore, said Democratic City Councilman Nick Mosby, husband of Marilyn, to my intrepid Fox News colleague Leland Vittert, amid the final flashes of smoke and looting on Monday night. What it is, is young folks of the community showing decades old anger, frustration, for a system that's failed them. I mean, it's bigger than Freddie Gray. This is about the social economics of poor urban America.
Both sets of onlookers of the moral decay on display this week, the Literalists and the Impressionists, are indeed recording the Baltimore Riots of 2015 with strong doses of accuracy. Where some see the commission of thousands of discrete criminal acts, many captured on video, others peer through an invisible veil to glimpse the effects, as Mosby put it, of a system thats failed.
If the Impressionists are correct, then those interested in redress of Baltimores multiple ills will show a keen interest in more information about how and why the system that failed wound up doing so in such spectacular fashion. Once again, the enterprise could be guided by a Literalist point of view or by a more Impressionist sensibility; but in the more neutral terms of political science a discipline that employs a blend of science and art, and in which this writer earned his bachelors degree at The Johns Hopkins University in 1980s Baltimore a natural starting point for investigation would be the governments of Baltimore and Maryland.
Of those governments, perhaps the most salient fact to the objective political scientist, tasked with anatomizing the failed system, would be that both governments have long effectively functioned as one-party systems. Baltimore last had a Republican mayor, Theodore M. McKeldin, in 1967. (A wire photograph from April 1966 captured McKeldin, a bear of a man, chatting amiably with Dr. King in Baltimore, two years before the civil rights leaders assassination in Memphis.) Maryland elected its incumbent Republican governor, Larry Hogan, in November but that made Hogan only the second GOP governor in the Old Line State since 1969.
Incumbent mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake, a Democrat, deals with a city council comprised 100 percent of fellow Democrats. Other important power blocs in the political and civic life of Baltimore are likewise controlled by Democrats, such as educational institutions and public-sector unions.
In systemic terms, one-party control is generally considered unhealthy and to many eyes the record of one-party government in Baltimore, measured in the usual societal metrics, demonstrates as much with crystalline clarity." http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2015/05/01/analysis-in-baltimore-unrest-liberalism-on-trial/
In the theater of sadness that was West Baltimore this week, the Literalist camp paradoxically united two rather disparate groups of onlookers: those who remained fixed on the facts surrounding the death of Freddie Gray in police custody, including chief prosecutor Marilyn Mosby, a Democrat, and many activists in the African-American community; and those who, like former New York City Mayor Rudolph Giuliani, a Republican, vocally decried the lawlessness in the streets and demanded a more robust response by law enforcement.
It is my job to examine and investigate the evidence of each case, Mosby said when, on Friday, she announced the indictment of six Baltimore police officers in Grays death.
Here is the rule I had with my police department and my police commissioner, Giuliani recalled on Hannity on April 28. First rock, get arrested. Second rock, get arrested. Despite their divergent worldviews, both Mosby and Giuliani, himself a former prosecutor, adopted the strict Literalist view, in the sense that they were apt to see the action unfolding in Baltimore in concrete, factual, even numerical terms. Every victim of police brutality and every lawbreaker in the rioting each case, as Mosby put it, and the thrower of even a single rock, as Giuliani put it must swiftly be brought before the bar of justice.
The Impressionists on the scene in Baltimore, however, are more inclined to move beyond the specifics, to see before their eyes something more than a demolished CVS. The Impressionists eschew the particular for generalization; they paint in broad strokes and speak not of specific cases but of sweeping historical dynamics and trends.
It has nothing to do with West Baltimore or this particular corner in Baltimore, said Democratic City Councilman Nick Mosby, husband of Marilyn, to my intrepid Fox News colleague Leland Vittert, amid the final flashes of smoke and looting on Monday night. What it is, is young folks of the community showing decades old anger, frustration, for a system that's failed them. I mean, it's bigger than Freddie Gray. This is about the social economics of poor urban America.
Both sets of onlookers of the moral decay on display this week, the Literalists and the Impressionists, are indeed recording the Baltimore Riots of 2015 with strong doses of accuracy. Where some see the commission of thousands of discrete criminal acts, many captured on video, others peer through an invisible veil to glimpse the effects, as Mosby put it, of a system thats failed.
If the Impressionists are correct, then those interested in redress of Baltimores multiple ills will show a keen interest in more information about how and why the system that failed wound up doing so in such spectacular fashion. Once again, the enterprise could be guided by a Literalist point of view or by a more Impressionist sensibility; but in the more neutral terms of political science a discipline that employs a blend of science and art, and in which this writer earned his bachelors degree at The Johns Hopkins University in 1980s Baltimore a natural starting point for investigation would be the governments of Baltimore and Maryland.
Of those governments, perhaps the most salient fact to the objective political scientist, tasked with anatomizing the failed system, would be that both governments have long effectively functioned as one-party systems. Baltimore last had a Republican mayor, Theodore M. McKeldin, in 1967. (A wire photograph from April 1966 captured McKeldin, a bear of a man, chatting amiably with Dr. King in Baltimore, two years before the civil rights leaders assassination in Memphis.) Maryland elected its incumbent Republican governor, Larry Hogan, in November but that made Hogan only the second GOP governor in the Old Line State since 1969.
Incumbent mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake, a Democrat, deals with a city council comprised 100 percent of fellow Democrats. Other important power blocs in the political and civic life of Baltimore are likewise controlled by Democrats, such as educational institutions and public-sector unions.
In systemic terms, one-party control is generally considered unhealthy and to many eyes the record of one-party government in Baltimore, measured in the usual societal metrics, demonstrates as much with crystalline clarity." http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2015/05/01/analysis-in-baltimore-unrest-liberalism-on-trial/
