In this Wednesday, July 29, 2015 photo, a Des Moines Water Works employee works to fix a water main break on a street in Des Moines, Iowa. The Des Moines water utility is confronting an array of problems including water mains that are cracking open hundreds of times every year and increasing costs associated with treating water from polluted rivers.
Drinking water systems imperiled by failing infrastructure
Drinking water systems imperiled by failing infrastructure
AP Photo/Charlie Neibergall In this Wednesday, July 29, 2015 photo, Des Moines Water Works employees walk past water bubbling through a hole in a street following a water main break in Des
DES MOINES, Iowa (AP) Deep inside a complex of huge tanks, drinking water for Iowa's capital city is constantly cleansed of the harmful nitrates that come from the state's famously rich farmland.
Without Des Moines Water Works, the region of 500,000 people that it serves wouldn't have a thriving economy that has become a magnet for tech companies such as Microsoft. But after decades of ceaseless service, the utility is confronting an array of problems: Water mains are cracking open hundreds of times every year. Rivers that provide its water are more polluted than ever. And the city doesn't know how it will afford a $150 million treatment plant at a time when revenues are down and maintenance costs are up?
"We're reaching the end of the life cycle of some of the most critical assets we've got," said Bill Stowe, CEO and general manager of the utility, which has a downtown treatment plant that was built in the 1940s, long before nitrates, which can harm infants, became a pressing concern. He said the industry is getting "all kinds of these warning alarms that we haven't heard before."
A similar crisis is unfolding in cities across the country. After decades of keeping water rates low and deferring maintenance, scores of drinking water systems built around the time of World War II and earlier are in need of replacement. The costs to rebuild will be staggering. The costs of inaction are already piling up. The challenge is deepened by drought conditions in some regions and government mandates to remove more contaminants.
At stake is the continued availability of clean, cheap drinking water a public health achievement that has fueled the nation's growth for generations and that most Americans take for granted.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency projects that it will cost $384 billion over 20 years to maintain the nation's existing drinking water systems, which will require tens of thousands of miles of replacement pipe and thousands of new or renovated plants. The American Water Works Association, an industry-backed group, puts the price even higher $1 trillion to replace all outdated pipes and meet growth over the next quarter-century.
"The future is getting a little dark for something as basic and fundamental as water," said Adam Krantz of the Water Infrastructure Network, a lobbying group that is fighting cuts to key federal water programs.
A HIDDEN CRISIS, A SHORTAGE OF MONEY
Unlike pothole-scarred roads or crumbling bridges, decaying water systems often go unnoticed until they fail.
"Buried infrastructure is out of sight, out of mind. We take it for granted. We turn on the faucet and we get good, clean, quality water," said Will Williams, head of asset management for the engineering firm Black & Veatch and an expert on water infrastructure.
When failures happen, help can be hard to come by.
Without big changes in national policy, local governments and their ratepayers will be largely on their own in paying for the upgrades. The amount of federal money available for drinking-water improvements is just a drop in the bucket.
Cities and utilities have historically been reluctant to raise rates sharply or to incur high levels of debt to pay for them, although both are increasingly happening.
"That's the key that Americans have to understand: If they want this system, they are going to have to be willing to finance it, to pay for it," said Greg DiLoreto, past president of the American Society of Civil Engineers.
The group's 2013 report warned of a looming funding crisis and a future with more equipment failures that will disrupt water service, transportation and commerce.
"Not meeting the investment needs of the next 20 years risks reversing the environmental, public health and economic gains of the last three decades," the report said.
The largest source of federal assistance is the Drinking Water State Revolving Fund, which goes largely to small towns and mid-sized cities. Some communities that need the most help shun the program because it offers mostly loans, not grants. A new program authorized by Congress to attract private investment in larger, big-city projects has yet to get off the ground.
___
THE IMPORTANCE OF PIPES
More than a million miles of underground pipes distribute water to American homes, and maintaining that network remains the largest and costliest long-term concern.
Some pipes date back to the 1800s. As they get older, they fail in different ways. Some split and rupture, with an estimated 700 main breaks occurring around the U.S. every day. The most devastating failures damage roadways, close businesses and shut off service for hours or days. If pipes are particularly bad, they can contaminate water.
Utilities have long struggled to predict when to replace pipes, which have vastly different life cycles depending on the materials they are made from and where they are buried. Some might last 30 years, others more than 100. Sophisticated computer programs are helping some water systems prioritize the order in which pipes should be replaced, but tight budgets often mean the fixes don't come until it's too late.
Replacing a single mile of water main can cost from $500,000 to more than $1 million, but doing so is far more disruptive to customers if it fails first. Experts say a peak of up to 20,000 miles of pipe will need to be replaced annually beginning around 2035, up from roughly 5,000 miles currently. Des Moines Water Works alone has 1,600 miles of distribution pipes.
The Philadelphia water department, the nation's oldest, is already spending tens of millions of dollars more per year to replace its worst pipes. Yet the city saw more than 900 water main breaks in the most recent budget year. In June, two massive breaks forced evacuations and damaged cars, homes and businesses.
New Orleans once boasted about not raising water rates for two decades. But in 2012, the city approved 10 percent increases on water bills for eight straight years as part of a plan to fix a crumbling system. The average household's monthly water-and-sewer bill will climb to $115 by 2020. The extra money will help replace deteriorating mains damaged by Hurricane Katrina.
The massive main break that flooded the UCLA campus in Los Angeles in 2014 ruining its basketball court and inundating buildings and fields with millions of gallons of water was widely seen as a wakeup call for failing infrastructure. But a year later, the city's response illustrates how large of a problem many systems face.
The Los Angeles Department of Water and Power is moving from a 300-year replacement cycle to a 250-year cycle for its 7,200-mile water distribution system, still far slower than the 100-year cycle many experts recommend. The department is proposing a 3.8 percent annual water rate increase for five years, which would go largely toward system improvements and gradually raise the typical household water bill by $12.30 per month. Heavier users would face steeper increases.
___
MORE UNAVOIDABLE COSTS
Pipes aren't the only components in need of big investments. Many water-treatment plants are 70 to 100 years old and need to be replaced or rebuilt with new systems at a cost of tens of millions of dollars even in small cities. Adding to the price will be new valves to control water flow, new pumping stations to keep up pressure and new tanks to store water.
To make matters worse, the need for new investment comes as revenue is falling, in large part because Americans are using less water and installing more efficient toilets and showerheads.
Many households affected by drought have cut their usage, either voluntarily or because of mandatory orders. Even after the drought ends, their old habits often never return. That is good for conservation but means less money for water systems, which charge customers based on the amount used.
To deal with the loss of income, many water districts have been forced to raise rates. So in essence, customers are paying more for using less.
Some big cities and small towns are losing residents too, further contributing to the declining number of paying water customers.
Costs are also rising to accommodate federal regulations that require removal of more potentially harmful contaminants, including arsenic and disinfectant byproducts.
Add it up, and customers' water bills will need to climb rapidly across the country to keep the current level of service. Experts say the trend, which will disproportionately hurt the low-income, is likely to continue in coming decades.
"Infrastructure is the new frontier. Everybody knows there are issues, but it's like, 'What are we going to do?'" said Ed Moreno, water superintendent in Iowa City, where rates went up 5 percent this year to pay for infrastructure. "Because it's not going to be inexpensive."
___
THE DILEMMA IN DES MOINES
Many of these pressures are on stark display in Des Moines, where the decaying infrastructure is contributing to a planned rate hike for customers of about 10 percent for next year.
The biggest challenge for Des Moines Water Works has been nitrate levels that are far above the federal standard for safety in the two rivers that provide the utility's source water. The utility and scientists argue that the nitrates are largely the result of farm runoff that is tainted with fertilizer and manure.
Cleaning the water is expensive because nitrates are not addressed in the normal treatment process. Instead, the utility has to operate a separate nitrate-removal system, which recently ran a record 148 straight days this year at a cost of $1.5 million because of continued high levels in the Raccoon and Des Moines rivers.
The water agency has taken the unprecedented step of suing three major Iowa farming counties in federal court to try to limit the farm discharges. But the litigation provoked an intense backlash from Iowa's powerful agricultural industry, which argues that farmers are already taking voluntary measures to address the problem. A trial is set for next year.
If the problems persist, the plant's general manager said it will have to spend $150 million to build a nitrate-removal plant to replace the aging tanks and outdated technology currently in use. Officials worry that on a hot summer day during peak demand, the utility will be unable to treat enough water, forcing a temporary shutdown that would require customers to use bottled water. The existing nitrate-removal system can treat only about 10 million gallons a day, a fraction of what the region needs.
The treatment costs also leave less money to replace Des Moines' aging pipes. The utility budgeted this year for 345 main breaks, up from 285 last year. It spends about $6 million per year on maintenance, a figure Stowe said is less than half the amount needed.
The effects are felt by residents such as Mario Tumea, whose family's Italian restaurant was closed in May for a day and a half after a 12-inch cast-iron main from 1938 split and sent water gushing into the street. The restaurant's parking lot was damaged, and eight businesses were left without water.
"It's frustrating," he said. "But when you have old pipes and stuff like that, it's going to happen. We weren't happy with it, but we had no choice."
Tags
Who is online
84 visitors

The passage of a real, comprehensive infrastructure bill would create millions of jobs and we are in desperate need of it for our water systems, but also for our highways, bridges and electrical grid. Of course ideology is more important to the House in Congress right now then what's good for the nation. Party first and fuck America is the functioning motto right now.
It will cost between $384 billion and $1 Trillion over the next 20 years to replace and repair the water system in the U.S.
The cost of the wars in Iraq and Afganistan is between $4 and $6 trillion
While we piss away money on useless wars that are going to cost 4 to 6 times as much as repairing our drinking water system, we, the taxpayer are on the hook for it.
4 to 6 times the amount is being spent on the usewars instead of investing $1 trillion to fit our drinking water system.
Good going you useless frickin' politicians.
Yup, that's the bottom line Randy.
Don't know what 1/3 of the country sitting on their ass has to do with our drinking water delivery system.
Wait until the GOP get's back in complete control again and we are presented with a $10 or $15 trillion bill for invading Iran.
We need to stop invading and then rebuilding other countries for no damned good reason and fix our own country first!
Farming country & nitrate removal ... it gets expensive .
Not nearly as expensive asthe two wars that we are in petey.
The thing about spending federal tax $$ on local projects is , all the states will want some of that largesse .
All states have the same problem with their infrastructure, it's not a localized problem.
I'm not sure that there aren't some exceptions , are you ? As to the wars , they don't appear to be about to end , do they ?
I posted this article as well earlier this morning, Kavika. As yours has more comments, I will delete mine.
These are "out of sight, out of mind" problems that presidents and members of Congress do not have any knowledge of, do not care about, do not ever have to deal with in their own residences or place of business, and they have absolutely no concept of the dangerous diseases that can be released on a community when a water treatment plant fails and contaminates entire towns and cities with feces and all the other unmentionable things you flush down your toilet and never think of again.
We have no more room in our resources at this moment for millions of illegals, refugees, migrants or even millions of legal immigrants at this point until we address our limitations as a "Please Dump Them Here" sanctuary country.
Without big changes in national policy, local governments and their ratepayers will be largely on their own in paying for the upgrades. The amount of federal money available for drinking-water improvements is just a drop in the bucket.
Cities and utilities have historically been reluctant to raise rates sharply or to incur high levels of debt to pay for them, although both are increasingly happening.
"That's the key that Americans have to understand: If they want this system, they are going to have to be willing to finance it, to pay for it," said Greg DiLoreto, past president of the American Society of Civil Engineers
Since it is the federal government that insists on dumping illegal aliens, refugees, and economic migrants on every state in the US there should indeed be a change in national policy in who has to fund these upgrades.... as federal money comes from taxpayers any way.
I'm reposting Dowser's comment on my article as I feel it worthy and don't think she would mind...
Louisville always has been and will continue to replace pipes-- some of which were originally made of wood and sealed with clay. Not to mention, replacement of residential copper and lead pipes that leach those metals into the water that we drink, per home . Many treatment facilities are outdated, old, and barely functioning. It is a huge expense!
Maybe we need to scrap plans for building a new aircraft carrier, and spend the money on our water infrastructure. No one seems to understand how very vital a water supply is, until they turn on the faucet and nothing comes out.
Sorry Mimi, I didn't see yours.
Yeah, and it's not just the delivery system. We are destroying our lakes and rivers, but that's OK, cuz it's progress.
Thearticle spoke to the US. Probably are some exception, like me, we have our own well.
War is a way of life in the US...We seem to be in one all of the time.
Oh we ain't seen nothing yet! Just wait until some moron gets the Keystone approved and we destroy the entire Ogallala Aquifer in the name of progress!
Or the proposed pipeline across ND, the Red River, across northern MN most pristine lakes and rivers. Within spitting distance of the headwaters of the Mississippi river down to Lake Superior..
Just frickin' great.
Decades of doing nothing, much like our electrical grid, Mimi.
They always find bullshit ways to spend money, except to maintain our infrastructure.
We have spent 4 to 6 times as much on the ME wars than it would take to repair the whole US.
Wars are good. /s
No problem, it happens.
The bad part is that the senators and representatives that sit on the committees to decide whether to pass legislation to clean up or protect the lakes and rivers do not have the first clue how toilet matter travels through the pipes, enters the sewage plants, is "cleaned" before it enters the waterways, or how it is dumped into those waterways without being cleaned when a big storm floods the pipe transportation systems with "clean" groundwater and the treatment plant operators have to open the valves and dump everything untreated so keep the precious algae from being washed out.
They know NOTHING about it, but are the people who vote on whether to allocate funds to municipalities to enable them to hire someone to fix the problem. Then there comes the fight between the contractors who say repairing/replacing the underground pipes is the answer, and the contractors who say building a bigger and more expensive treatment plant is the answer.
And no one really cares about the cause or the effect on the environment, they just care about who can get the most dollars for their company.
(In case you want to know, both scenarios are the answer... the underground pipes must be replaced/repaired to prevent "clean" groundwater from seeping/rushing in during storms, and larger treatment plants are needed due to the tremendous increase in population.)
In my article, I posted pictures from Des Moines, Philadelphia, Los Angeles UCLA... there were photos I didn't post from New York, Atlanta, Dallas, and other areas.
It is a problem all over the US. Every town and city is over populated relative to the water treatment plants they have... and in case you aren't aware of it, "water treatment plant" is the polite term for what used to be called the "sewage treatment plant."
The federal government keeps bringing in millions of additional people and dropping them off on communities that do not have the infrastructure to handle the influx... and the federal government doesn't even think about or realize what they are doing.
Do you think Obama stopped to think... "Hmmm, I wonder how many times these 80,000 "refugees" will flush a toilet and where all that shit will go and how the sewage plant will treat it.. that I want to dump on my people this year? "
He doesn't think about how many times HE flushes a toilet in a year.. neither do you. Every toilet flush takes multiple gallons of FRESH WATER. Towns and cities surrounded by water have potable water shortages and as long ago as four years and five years past were trucking in bottled drinking water and water to bathe in.
Being a dumping ground for illegal aliens/refugees/migrants is killing our environment. Natural resources are finite.
War is a way of life in the US...We seem to be in one all of the time.
And if we weren't we'd just make war on each other. We are a divided nation and a divided nation can not stand for long.
Well, it is very profitable for the Military Industrial Complex. Those who make war's weapons get richer by the day. That's the premise of the constant war in 1984 and it's the premise of constant war today. We need to have constant war, because we need to produce more weapons of war to replace the ones we're using in our constant wars. And on and on and on....
Hell one of the main reason to invade Iraq was because we were still way over loaded with weapon systems and didn't need to order anymore, so we needed to use the ones we had stockpiled up, so the manufacturers could sell us more. We fired off hundreds of Tomahawk cruise missiles during that war at more then $1.3 million each. And every one of them needed to be replaced and someone got richer building them. If we didn't use them, then they wouldn't be able to sell us any more of them. The same with all of our ordinance. Remember when we were using up so much ammo in Iraq we almost ran out here in the US? Someone made a fortune making more. Have to keep those production levels up and war is just about the only thing we produce anymore!
Sadly, that's pretty true Randy.
Sadly Randy, that's pretty accurate.
It's pretty stunning Max, to completely redo our water infrastructure is estimated at the high end $1 trillion. The two ME wars are going to cost us $4 to $6 Trillion...
Those figures just blow me away.
Many members of the right wing GOP caucus are warmongers who think America shows it's strength and greatness only by using the power of it's military to impose it's will on other nations. They take more pride in body counts then in peace. America's greatness has nothing to do with that. A strong American homeland is what shows our greatness. Setting an example for the rest of the world on how we take care of all of our citizens, rich, middle-class and poor, shows our greatness. Showing that Americans have class mobility shows our greatness. Our strength and what makes us great is mostly within our own country.
Any ignorant fool can start a war for no reason. Just look at President Cheney and his puppet George W. Bush for proof of that.
Nitrate removal isn't that expensive-- it just takes a layer of activated carbon on top of the filter.
Compared to a lot of other things, it's relatively cheap.
Whoa, wait a sec. A water treatment plant is NOT a glorified sewer treatment plant. The processes are entirely different! Many cities use groundwater and that is relatively clean, and pre-filtered. And those that use river water or lake water, also have a relatively clean raw water source.
Meaning absolutely no disrespect!
Dowser, it's the way the government and politicians chose to spend the money. War makes a lot of people rich, good ROI on their investment.
Making the country livable, not so much. Sadly the politicians are bought off by big business.
The one thing that we can't live without is water. I believe that we are going to find that out the hard way, when water becomes a commodity to be traded, bought and sold. It will be American's working class that pays the price.
It always is the working class that pays...
Please don't get me wrong! I have worked 35 years to find a clean, reliable water supply for many cities. It's complicated by the fact that human activities always have a negative impact on the purity of the water. Anything that goes on the ground, or in it, has a detrimental effect on the drinking water supply.
My only point was that nitrate is really fairly easy to treat for-- but that isn't the whole story. Treating for nitrate requires a 2' thick layer of activated carbon on the top layer of the filter. Louisville treats from 90 to 120 million gallons per day. When we added nitrate filtering to our treatment regimen, it cost $90,000 per year. So, it's really a cheap fix. It's what goes with the nitrates that is so expensive to treat. Atrazine, 2-4-D, and the newer class of nicotinoids-- all of them pesticides...
Nitrate enters ground water through leaky sewers, as well as farm runoff. There are other nitrate leaking agents, but they don't contribute as much as farm runoff.
We have a pretty unique situation here in Louisville-- our city owns our stock, so we are a private entity owned by a municipal agent. As such, we have independence, and regularly apply for increases in funding, to maintain our infrastructure. We ask the Utility Regulatory Commission. We just reworked all the filters at the Crescent Hill Filter Plant, some of which were originally constructed in the 1880s. As long as all of the filters are maintained and dealt with, (the filter medium replaced regularly, the filters backwashed daily), they work.
I have worked with municipal water supplies where one lightning strike could completely end their ability to make water. They only have one well, stuck way up in the air, and not very mechanically efficient-- meaning the well is on its way to failure. Trying to find the funds to add a well, or even clean the existing well, is next to impossible. Usually, it takes that lightning strike, to convince the Powers That Be, to actually do anything...
Thanks, Mimi!!!