Mr. Boehner’s resignation is a political cop-out
House Speaker John Boehner discusses his resignation in a news conference on Sept. 25. (Mary F. Calvert/Reuters)
HOUSE SPEAKER John A. Boehner (R-Ohio) insisted on Friday that he was resigning in order to forestall a tough vote on his leadership and protect the institution of the House. Protecting the institution, he said, is a speakers primary job. We respect his devotion. But a speakers primary responsibility is to the nation, not the House. And what the nation needs is a Congress willing to make compromises in the national interest compromises that Mr.Boehner may have favored but rarely had the stomach to promote.
From the start, Mr.Boehner seemed like a Republican leader for a different time, when serious policy could be hashed out in relative comity, over a drink and a smoke. The leadership challenge he was handed didnt demand deal-making skills as much as it required creating the space for deal-making to happen in the first place. That, in turn, depended on sidelining an insurgent right wing that has made the House dangerously incapable of compromise on major policy questions, except in the most pressing of circumstances. Instead, Mr.Boehner ultimately decided to sideline himself.
Its hard to know if someone else would have been or will be more effective managing a House with a bloc of Republicans who are more sensitive to the ideological preferences of their partisan districts than to the needs of the nation. Whats clear is that a loud faction in Mr.Boehners GOP caucus seems as hostile as ever to the process of governing in a democracy. The House will not deliver much until its leaders allow a simple majority of Republicans and Democrats to vote on budgeting, immigration and other crucial issues. Mr.Boehner was loath to call votes when he might need to rely on Democrats. The result was to hand the reins to the extremists.
We dont minimize the political risks of taking on the extremes, which will fight to keep their stranglehold on the legislature. But the way the House currently operates is bad for the country.
There is a long list of policies that reasonable people of both parties know Congress has to tackle. First, the government must be funded. Mr.Boehners departure at best buys the country a few weeks , forestalling a government shutdown over Planned Parenthood funding. Once it approves a temporary spending resolution, Congress must lift the unsustainable funding caps that shortchange both military and social programs. Later this year, Congress must raise the debt ceiling . Given the projected growth of the old-age entitlement programs, Congress needs to secure them with targeted reforms that dont hurt the needy and that help, along with tax reform, to deliver the revenue needed to pay for the government Americans expect. The nation needs comprehensive immigration reform that trades border security for a pathway to legalization for the undocumented. It needs to invest in its infrastructure and research. And so on.
There was a moment, during President Obamas first term, when he and the speaker might have delivered compromise in the national interest. Neither ultimately had the courage to challenge his own partys orthodoxy, the moment passed and Mr.Boehner hunkered down in a way that protected his job without getting much done. Its too soon to know whether his departure will offer another opportunity; whats certain is that the need is no less.
Tags
Who is online
84 visitors

Its hard to know if someone else would have been or will be more effective managing a House with a bloc of Republicans who are more sensitive to the ideological preferences of their partisan districts than to the needs of the nation.
Exactly 100% correct.
Bingo!!!!
The right wing of the GOP (including/especially the Tea Party) cares more about the right wing of the GOP then they do about the USA.
I can't find a single thing in your whole post to disagree with RW. Well said!
They are the most un-American Americans I can ever remember seeing in my life, in spite of trying to cover themselves in the flag. To them it's right wing/Tea Party first and fuck America. In fact, I don't think the have the slightest idea of what America is all about and it won't do any good to tell them because they want to stay ignorant and will deny whatever you do try to teach them. I gave up trying. They aren't worth the effort and will fall to pieces under the weight of their own rigidness just like the USSR (whose ideology they bear a striking resemblance to) did and be gone, so why bother anyway? They'll never get past party first and country second. They're just stuck there. They prefer their ideology over what's in the best interests of the nation. The only thing they really understand is hate.
Considering the gains they've made in the House and Senate it looks like the people are choosing to reject socialism and that is good for all Americans. The democrats presidential offerings are pathetic so it looks like they will be winning the White house too. Sorry libs you're just going to have to find a way to care for yourselves. America is about personal responsibility and freedom not sitting around sucking off the governments tit.
And until they do, they will never have another of their party sitting behind the official desk in the Oval Office.
Very true. As a rule they hate women, they hate the young, they hate Hispanics, they hate Blacks or at least they hate the rights of each of those groups. Their party base is shrinking and it's their own doing. There are simply not enough angry white men left in America to elect a national/Presidential any longer and they just don't seem to get that except on one, almost Neanderthal, level though. That's why there is so much voter suppression of those groups going on right now. They're philosophy is if you can't win based on what you have to offer...then cheat.
I believe that there actually still is a rational Republican Party out there somewhere (along the lines of an Eisenhower or Ford) and that they'll stop the lunatic fringe before it's to late. The establishment GOP is a whole lot more powerful the Donald, Ben or Carly and will not allow any of them to be the nominee. If anything the then the right-wing nuts and Tea Party members will split off an form their own party and I say more power to them. Split the GOP into pieces.