Johnathon Chait: The Disastrous Clinton Post Presidency
The qualities of an effective presidency do not seem to transfer onto a post-presidency. Jimmy Carter was an ineffective president who became an exemplary post-president. Bill Clinton appears to be the reverse. All sorts of unproven worst-case-scenario questions float around the web of connections between Bills private work, Hillary Clintons public role as secretary of State, the Clintons quasi-public charity, and Hillarys noncompliant email system. But the best-case scenario is bad enough: The Clintons have been disorganized and greedy.
The news today about the Clintons all fleshes out, in one way or another, their lack of interest in policing serious conflict-of-interest problems that arise in their overlapping roles:
- The New York Times has a report about the State Departments decision to approve the sale of Uranium mines to a Russian company that donated $2.35 million to the Clinton Global Initiative, and that a Russian investment bank promoting the deal paid Bill $500,000 for a speech in Moscow.
- The Washington Post reports that Bill Clinton has received $26 million in speaking fees from entities that also donated to the Clinton Global Initiative.
- The Washington Examiner reports, Twenty-two of the 37 corporations nominated for a prestigious State Department award and six of the eight ultimate winners while Hillary Clinton was Secretary of State were also donors to the Clinton family foundation.
- And Reuters reports, Hillary Clinton's family's charities are refiling at least five annual tax returns after a Reuters review found errors in how they reported donations from governments, and said they may audit other Clinton Foundation returns in case of other errors.
The Clinton campaign is batting down the darkest and most conspiratorial interpretation of these stories, and where this all leads remains to be seen. But the most positive interpretation is not exactly good.
When you are a power couple consisting of a former president and a current secretary of State and likely presidential candidate, you have the ability to raise a lot of money for charitable purposes that can do a lot of good. But some of the potential sources of donations will be looking to get something in return for their money other than moral satisfaction or the chance to hobnob with celebrities. Some of them want preferential treatment from the State Department, and others want access to a potential future Clinton administration. To run a private operation where Bill Clinton will deliver a speech for a (huge) fee and a charity that raises money from some of the same clients is a difficult situation to navigate. To overlay that fraught situation onto Hillarys ongoing and likely future government service makes it all much harder.
And yet the Clintons paid little to no attention to this problem. Nicholas Confessore described their operation as a sprawling concern, supervised by a rotating board of old Clinton hands, vulnerable to distraction and threatened by conflicts of interest. It ran multimillion-dollar deficits for several years, despite vast amounts of money flowing in. Indeed, as Ryan Lizza reported in 2012, Bill Clinton seemed to see the nexus between his role and his wifes as a positive rather than a negative:
Regardless of Bill Clintons personal feelings about Obama, it didnt take him long to see the advantages of an Obama Presidency. More than anyone, he pushed Hillary to take the job of Secretary of State. President Clinton was a big supporter of the idea, an intimate of the Clintons told me. He advocated very strongly for it and arguably was the tie-breaking reason she took the job. For one thing, having his spouse in that position didnt hurt his work at the Clinton Global Initiative. He invites foreign leaders to the initiatives annual meeting, and her prominence in the Administration can be an asset in attracting foreign donors. Bill Clintons been able to continue to be the Bill Clinton we know, in large part because of his relationship with the White House and because his wife is the Secretary of State, the Clinton associate continued. It worked out very well for him. That may be a very cynical way to look at it, but thats a fact. A lot of the stuff hes doing internationally is aided by his level of access.
The Obama administration wanted Hillary Clinton to use official government email. She didnt. The Obama administration also demanded that the Clinton Foundation disclose all its donors while she served as Secretary of State. It didnt comply with that request, either.
The Clintons charitable initiatives were a kind of quasi-government run by themselves, which was staffed by their own loyalists and made up the rules as it went along. Their experience running the actual government, with its formal accountability and disclosure, went reasonably well. Their experience running their own privatized mini-state has been a fiasco.
Tags
Who is online
166 visitors

"But the best-case scenario is bad enough: The Clintons have been disorganized and greedy."
Yet, she is running for President virtually unopposed in her party. When a political party devolves into a fusion of cult like leader worship and dynastic succession it gets stuck with Hillary Clinton, the embodiment of everything the Democrats projected onto Mitt Romney, minus the competence.
"There is a 10% chance that there will be a backlash against the accusers who will be seen as anti-woman, "
Welcome to Barack Obama's America, where race and gender are the primary qualificationfor election to the Presidency.
Typical Democrat voter:
"She worked to help Putin control the world's uranium supply afterreceiving3 million dollars? Whocares? She's got a vagina and will keep the welfare spigot on, I'll vote for her! " That's not really fair. Most Democrats couldn't identify Putin.
The author/source of the allegations apparently cannot prove the allegations and vows to correct the errors regarding the allegations.
I would say that the "dupes" are those who advance the lies because they want to perpetuate them further, and, who, even after being corrected, double down on the lies regardless.
If anything is being "normalized," it's the systematic, intentional lying and the intellectually dishonest failure to back off, and worse, to knowingly continue the lying.
Before you ran to the Clinton run Media Matters to find the talking points you feel compelled to parrot, did you bother to read the actual article I posted? Obviously, you didn't. Otherwise, you wouldn't try to rebut a book that isn't even discussed in the article.
Please read the article and rebut any mistakes you find there. This just makes you look desperate and uninformed.
e incompetence of the author isn't really in question A Mac, he was a Sarah Palin political consultant and worked for Breitbart after a
Johnathon Chait did not work for Sarah Palin or Brietbart. He's about as liberal as any pundit published by respectable outlets.
ABC News revealed the author's failure to prove allegations regarding Clinton conflicts-of-interests while Secretary of State.
As for the e-mails, stupidity and arrogance on Clinton's part, no argument.
So where were you and your friends when
I think this covers the "issues" in the article. If not, please specify those I failed to address (if unrelated to the ones I did address and I'll address those.
BC News revealed the author's failure
Please provide a link to the ABC news story debunking Chait's article, or the New York Times investigation into the Uranium deal, etc. etc. By all means, provide any information demonstrating the falseness of the New York Times reporting of the Russian Ukrainian deal?
ABC news says an unreleased proof of a book that is not the source of Chait's allegations contained in the seeded article had some factual issues. Who cares?
ABC DEBUNKS THE BOOK FROM WHICH CHAIT DRAWS HIS CONCLUSIONS
Further
Further yet
Sean,
I never bluff or hedge on my rebuttals.
Chait needs to do his homework and so do you and your echo chamber folks as well.
Chait's article is not based on the "book." The details in his article either predate the book or have been investigated independently by the Washington Post, the New York Times and Reuters. Your "rebuttal" doesn't rebut any of the reporting in those sources. I'll ask again, please fine one mistake with the Russian Uranium story. Just one.
I know you think the ad hominem logical fallacy is some sort of "gotcha." It's not. If you want to have an actual discussion, rebut the facts presented by Chait based on the reporting from the NYT, the Post, Reuters, etc. I'll spare you from ever opening your mind enough to consider something not written in an approved liberal source.
Actual rebutting requires specificity, not vague generalized denunciations. Your arguments are the equivalent of arguing that A couldn't have committed murder despite B's eyewitness account because C once jaywalked.
Seriously, when the defense of HRC boils down to
"everyone is corrupt" or there's a "book out there about her greed by a Republican" is about as weak a defense as can be imagined.
The allegations, from the book, from other sources as well, are nevertheless inaccurate.
Addressed in my comments are the NYT and the inaccuracies/falsehoods "reported" from the usual bogus sources and picked up by others without verifying. That the lies get legs and appear in the sources you/Chait cite, and the specifics with regard to their disingenuous origins is more than a "gotcha'". No matter how many places a lie appears, it's nevertheless a lie.
Take one-at-a-time and I'll debunk them ad seriatim. Take them out from the pile and lets have at 'em (although I've pretty much done it).
Here's the distinctions my sources vs. yours.
1) I rarely post an article or seed that is other than photography-related most of my political comments/posts are specific rebuttals to lies from coming from your sources.
2) You post almost exclusively, political/liberal-denigrating articles from right-wing sites, and, your posts are almost always intentional misrepresentations or outright lies (often based on "part of the story" with orchestrated, intended omissions of fact).
3) When I attack your sources, I give the history of those sources, the people behind them, their histories, their agendas, examples of the lies and the resultant adverse actions regarding those lies, along with
4) A detailed correction of and calling out of the lies in your post (from my sources) rather than an editorial masquerading as "news".
Copy this and save it so that each time you fail to recognize the sequence of dialogue and the ultimate, significant differences between your posts and mine
I won't have to go through this again.
Want to test this to see if it holds up? Next time you post one of articles/seeds, in your first comment, LIST ONE POINT FROM THE ARTICLE AND I'LL ADDRESS IT BY INDICATING THAT I CONCUR OR DISAGREE; IF I DISAGREE, I WILL GIVE SPECIFICS AS TO MY REASON(S).
That wasn't below the belt ... much !
I rescind "gang" make that "ilk" instead.
You are correct, Petey. The comment is deleted.
I reiterate without the reference.
Who takes which jab is of less significance and relevance than whether or not the jab is below the belt; until one stops posting the crap I have cited, AND KEEPS IGNORING THE CORRECTIONS AS IF THEY NEVER CAME -- OFTEN DOUBLING DOWN ON THE VERY UNTRUTHS THAT HAVE BEEN CALLED OUT -- ONE HAS NO CREDIBILITY HERE.
Who says what about whom is a separate matter from what "whom" writes without reverence for truth.
IMO posting tons of cut & paste without understanding is not "reverence for truth" . It is abuse . It is nothing more than a tactic .
And IMO, your O is flawed; providing documentation in order to substantiate a position is viewed as a "tactic" only by one who is too lazy to deal with detail and/or, biased, myopic and fearful of being shown to be on the wrong side of an argument.
I give the time, effort and respect to members as a way of offering more than just my point-of-view; and they are always free to disagree.
You don't display your righteous indignation towards those who CUT & PASTE ENTIRE ARTICLES AND SEED THEM VERBATIM!