╌>

GM, Ford, And Others Want to Make Working on Your Own Car Illegal

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  screminmimi  •  11 years ago  •  10 comments

GM, Ford, And Others Want to Make Working on Your Own Car Illegal

1862_discussions.jpg

Jeff Perez April 22, 2015

One of the inherent rights of owning a vehicle is the ability to get on ones backside a wrench in one hand and a grease rag in the other, and just tinker to your little hearts desire. Since the vehicle was invented, its been an important facet within the community of gearheads.

General Motors the same company responsible for 87 deaths related to faulty ignition switches, FYI wants to take that right away from you citing safety and security issues. Along with a few other big names.

Its called the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). Its been around since 2000 and started as anti-Internet piracy legislation. But automakers want to use it to try and make working on your own car illegal. Yes, illegal . The general premise is that unlike cars of the past, todays vehicles are so advanced and use such a large amount of software and coding in their general makeup, altering said code could be dangerous and possibly even malicious.

Listing the vehicle as a mobile computing device, the law would hypothetically protect automakers from pesky owners looking to alter any sort of technology in the vehicle that relates to the onboard computer. Flashing your ECU would be a big no no, which could also lead to all sorts of problems for aftermarket shops.

What GM, and even tractor companies like John Deere, argues is that you, as an owner, dont actually own your car. Rather, youre sort of just borrowing it for an extended amount of time and paying for the rights to use the technology. If it sounds ridiculous it is. But it gets even more ludicrous.

According to the Electronic Frontier Foundation , John Deere argued that letting people modify car computer systems will result in them pirating music through the on-board entertainment system.

Th

DMCA does give a little bit of leeway, though. While the act could hypothetically lock customers out of key safety features, it would still allow owners the ability to repair other areas of the vehicles onboard computer as they see fit. Its a slim compromise, but one that may be more closely based in reality.

As it currently sits, there are 13 (!) large automakers on the list supporting the DMCA. Want to know who they are? Of course you do:

General Motors Company
BMW Group
FCA US LLC
Ford Motor Company
Jaguar Land Rover
Mazda
Mercedes-Benz USA
Mitsubishi Motors
Porsche
Toyota
Volkswagen Group of America
Volvo Cars North America

Ironically, one of the brands that relies most on technology in its vehicles Tesla Motors in not in support of DMCA. While other American companieslike GM, Ford and Chrysler all agree that working on your own vehicle should be punishable by law.

Funny how three brands that pride themselves on American ingenuity dontwant customers to work on their cars.

https://www.yahoo.com/autos/s/gm-ford-others-want-working-own-car-illegal-160000229.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    11 years ago

This article has just about rendered me speechless... and that's hard to do.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    11 years ago

Wow! I thought you guys would be outraged at this one.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Finally, something I have experience with and can comment on! Smile.gif

Both BMW and Lexus have a program where those that work on these cars must be certified BMW and Lexus technicians. Their reasoning is that they use special methods and means of repair that are required so that the car meets the standards of performance and reliability as it was designed.

For example, BMW cars are made of aluminum, so that anyone who works the body of the car, (body shop repair after an accident), must be specially trained to weld aluminum in the "BMW way". Otherwise, BMW will not certify the repair, because they cannot guarantee the car will meet the original design specs. Having seen some of the repairs done by non-certified technicians, I can see why they do it. The finished cars are nowhere near spec-- doors don't align, hoods don't align with the quarter panels, etc. Some of these cars look like they were dragged out of a chop shop.

BMW and Lexus have specific standards to which they want their cars repaired-- otherwise they cannot guarantee the safety of the passengers within the car. I know that sounds silly, but if the hood doesn't line up properly, a car driving at 70 mph on the highway may suddenly have the hood pop up and then, what happens to the people in the car?

I do see some need for qualified people working on cars. On BMW cars, one must actually be able to know certain phrases in German, in order to repair the car according to specs. "Wasser ist Verboten" is on the radiator. (Water is forbidden.) Well, if you can't put water in the radiator, what do you put? Only a BMW-certified technician would know the exact coolant to use for the particular make and model of the car-- which is specially formulated per model and make.

So, while I do think this is going too far, I also see the need for someone who is qualified to make the actual repairs.

The problem is that BMW and all the rest have made cars so complicated, that it takes someone with a detailed knowledge of a particular make and model, and specialized equipment, to fix it. There are so many computer sensors in a car these days, and so many little things that can go wrong, it requires a computer to both diagnose which computer chip is registering a problem, or has gone bad, and, once fixed, clear the codes in the computer, or the car won't work.

I find this annoying, too. Some kind of air sensor went bad in my Chevy, years ago, and the whole car shut down. I was crossing a very busy intersection, and the car just came to a halt, suddenly. I had to get help to push it off to the side of the road, then call a tow truck to tow it into the shop where my husband worked, (the dealer), etc. People were waving their fists at me, as I pried my baby from his car seat, so the tow truck to get the car out of everyone's way... What was wrong? Nothing. The computer chip quit.

Could your regular backyard mechanic know exactly which chip went bad? Could he realize it was the chip, and that the rest of the car was running just fine? Would he know where it was located, in order to plug in a new one? Very doubtful.

So, yes, I'm outraged that any car manufacturer would take the position that my $20,000+ investment is just a loan of technology. Yes, I'm outraged that cars have become so very difficult to deal with. But, I've been outraged about that since about 1980...

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    11 years ago

ROFLMAO...

blue, you have made my day!

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    11 years ago

I can understand them not wanting to certify the repair unless it is made by a licensed repair person, but to make it "illegal" seems a bit much. And really, the bank already owns the vehicle until it is paid for, now the car manufacturer wants to say it owns the technology... what the heck are we paying for????

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Once the warranty expires, all bets are off. If they want to arrest or sue me for playing around with MY car after that then fuck 'em, go for it.

If they don't want me to work on it or play around with it, then give me a bumper to bumper lifetime warranty, or go to hell.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Dowser,

There are devices that read these codes, tell you what they mean and allow you to test components. Dealers use these devices because the cars are too complicated even for them to figure out and this device tells them what is wrong with the car or at least narrows it down to a few suspects.

Could your regular backyard mechanic know exactly which chip went bad? Could he realize it was the chip, and that the rest of the car was running just fine? Would he know where it was located, in order to plug in a new one? Very doubtful.

The fact is that anyone mechanically inclined with access to said device (or similar) can do the repair as good or better than the dealer. I am a backyard mechanic and haven't taken my car in for anything other than a wheel alignment in over a decade. (and I have replaced transmissions and head gaskets) If you know what you are doing and have the right tools and equipment you will probably do 10x a better job yourself than a "trained technician" that doesn't give a bloody rats about you, your car, or if it runs. BTW you can get the devices that read the codes and guide you on what to replace for as low as $200.00 for a simple one.

What they are trying to do is total BS and I would not buy a car off any shyster that tried to force me to only get it repaired by their dealer.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

I don't blame you, but the computer that my husband uses is more like $10,000-- it's not the smaller hand-held device that you are describing. He is a BMW and Lexus certified body repair technician, the only one in the state. And, please, I have had those repairmen that don't give a crap-- plenty of them. I also used to drive a 1965 Mercury Comet, so simple, I could work on her! I was taking her in to have her carburetor adjusted and the technician told me her "fuel injection system was bad." HUH? Just about anything awful has happened to me with car repair...

Anyway, my husband does care-- to the point that he loaded up the computer and drove two counties over to check on some woman's BMW whose car roof was leaking-- repaired by a non-certified tech. On a Saturday. Did he get paid extra? Nope. The woman's husband had just died and she was a customer, so he went and dealt with it.

If something works for you, that's fabulous and wonderful, and I certainly have no problem with it! I don't know what you drive. In the BMW world, if you don't have your car repaired by a certified technician, they will go so far as to take your car out of their system, and void the warranty.

As far as not buying the technology in your car, well, BMW technology, computer-wise, is about 15-20 years behind ours-- or so sayeth my husband, who works on them. He has spoken with the head of the BMW operations here in North America about it, it bothers him so much. He says that Lexus has much better computer technology than BMW, and that American cars have the best computer technology. Personally, I think not buying the technology-- that's a bunch of BS. Also note: my husband is the one they call when THEY can't fix a car at the Greenville, NC plant. He seems to be the only one around that can actually repair one of those sun roof thingys...

There is one kind of BMW that, in order to remove the bumper, you have to completely replace the front camera system in order to make the repair, because the camera system is designed so that there is less than 1" of play in the wires leading up to it. And you can't just plug in new wires-- it is a single component. My question: what German knucklehead designed that?

I agree that it shouldn't be illegal. I mean, REALLY. And if you want to work on your car, I don't blame you and applaud you! I can't, but fortunately, my husband can. So could my Daddy and Grandpa. I have a real soft spot for backyard mechanics...

However, I also would like my husband to be paid for all this training he has undergone, and the care he takes, and for his specialized knowledge, and recognize that the knuckleheads that designed these cars have designed them to meet certain specifications. (Example, it requires a certain number of spot welds on a door shell to get it to stick right, placed at exactly these spots...) My husband has been working on cars since 1973, and I trust him to know his business. Smile.gif He should be answering this, not me!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

I just got stuck behind one for 20 minutes on a winding country road... What fun! That guy was rocking, I'll say!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Cars are increasingly becoming more like a computer on wheels . If car mfgs. don't offer a low tech version without the excessive computerized snooping , we should all buy cars from a more primitive culture ... maybe the Yugo ?

 
 

Who is online




162 visitors