Tell the NRA: Stay Out of Our Doctor's Offices
It's a doctor's duty to ask questions about things that affect their patients' health and well-being. That's why the medical community considers talking to parents about safe firearm storage just as important as discussing the risks associated with swimming pools, second-hand smoking, and riding without car seats or seat belts.
NRA-backed bills have been introduced all over the country to punish pediatricians who ask parents whether they have guns in their homes and to prohibit doctors from recording this information in medical files. The American Medical Association, the countrys biggest association of physicians, has come out against these gag order laws because research has shown that parents who talk about gun storage with their childrens pediatricians are more likely to adopt safe and responsible gun storage practices.
Keep the NRA out of doctor's offices. Sign the petition and ask your governor to allow pediatricians to have life-saving conversations with parents about safe gun storage.
[ SIGN THEPETITION ]
We trust our pediatricians to care for the health and well-being of our children.
Pediatricians should be allowed and encouraged to talk to parents about anything that affects children's health -- including how to safely store a firearm in the home.
The American Medical Association agrees that a good preventive medicine practice includes conversations about gun safety, along with discussing the risks associated with swimming pools, second-hand smoke, and riding without car seats or seat belts.
I hope you will do everything in your power to stop any legislation that would silence or punish physicians for having conversations about gun safety.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The NRA apparently has decided to lobby against absolutely anything that involves legislation involving firearms. A position that is typical of the narrow minded attitude of its base supporters.
It seems analytical thinking, logical evaluation and just plaincommon sense, requires too much brain power for the narrowly focused minds of our friends on the Right Wing of the political spectrum.
Why would an organization intentionally strive to keep people ignorant about gun safety in their homes? The NRAleadership isn't even in step with it'smembership.Although, maybe they've received thousands of calls from armed parents who wantpediatricians to stop talking about child safety/s!!
The NRA oppose anything that they think can be construed as restricting the use of firearms in any way.
The NRA doesn't care about it's membership. Their concern is focused on theenormous funding the gunmanufacturersprovide them. Their logic is based on the premise that any form of gun regulation could have a negative impact on gun sales.
The NRA has convinced gun advocates that the 12,000 Americans killed by gunfire every year is 'the cost of freedom'. (I've actually seen people post that very concept right here on NewsTalkers)
I don't even own a gun and if I did it's none of my Doctors business! Fuck the NRA!
Wow , mickey and I actually agree. I have run into that question on Drs questionaires and intentionally left it unanswered only to be asked in the interview with the dr later the same question, with my answer being a polite im not here for a gunshot wound so the answer to that question is none of the drs business.
not many people know there are actually 2 sides to the NRA, but demonize the whole when only one side deals with politics, the NRA-ILA is the legislative action part , the other half which most members IMHO join for is the educative side, that side is the side that offers the training in safe gun handling and storage , and by far trains the majority of LEO with classes.
12000 annual? ok whats the breakdown of that number? how many are LEO related in the line of duty? how many of that number is suicides, someone bent on that act doesn't need a gun , its just the quickest and most expiedient method and someone bent on taking their own life is going to do it anyway.
how many of that 12000 is criminal activity related ? gang bangers offing each other? how many is the lawful use in self defense ? if your going to throw a number , its best to have the break down , unless the intent is simply to be a political agenda driven whoremonger like the ILA side of the NRA.
I don't expect an answer , and absent that there is no reason for discussion .
There's a mixed message for you.
What I don't understand, is why is it that if, ".......the medical community considers talking to parents about safe firearm storage just as important as discussing the risks associated with swimming pools, second-hand smoking, and riding without car seats or seat belts."... why doyou object to them talking to parents about safe firearm storage?
Unprotected swimming pools are dangerous, second hand smoke is dangerous, not using car seats and seat belts is dangerous, .... unstored guns are dangerous!
What's the objection? Is it that guns are the only one of those things protected by the 2nd Amendment? Does the 2nd Amendment somehow make unstored guns safe to have around children?
There's a mixed message for you.
It's not a mixed message in any manner. Going to my doctor and having him ask me about gun safety would be the same as going to him and have himgive me advice on how I use my power drill at home. There is a complete, 100% disconnect between the two.
And if a toddler accidentally blows mom's head off with her "gun-that-doesn't-kill-people-people-kill people-.38-left-loaded-laying-around-the-house" because NRA dickheads prevented i.e. her family physician from speaking common sense to her
FUCK THE NRA!
I disagree Mac. It's not his/her job. I think it should be up to the schools. Force them to teach gun safety, not MD's.
IMO, it's the job of all entities that deal with the education and health of communities.
And if a school/school district mandated gun safety education as part of its curriculum, the NRA would be lobbying and paying legislators to make it illegal to do so.
It's neither about physicians nor education -- it's about a powerful lobby that buys legislative whores/pimps!
We have to agree to disagree. You will never convince mefirearms education or warningshas anything to do with my Doctors office. I will never convince you that it does.
Impasse.
Agree on IMPASSE.
What happens in gangland Chicago , Detroit and East L.A. are not typical of the rest of the country ...
A doctor does not have to ask if a patient owns any guns, and it is not likely that they would, the Dr. only needs to point out, IF there are any guns in homes where there are children, it is important to keep them safely secured, and show them the CDC statistic regarding child deaths and injuries resulting from unsecured firearms.
A study, led by researchers at the Yale School of Medicine,published inthe medical journal Pediatrics , indicate a review of hospital records found that firearms cause over 7,000 hospitalizations among children younger than 20 every year, another 3,000 die before they can even get to a hospital, making the total around 10,000 children killed or hospitalized due to gunfire every year.
Investigators found more than half of the gun injuries involved an attack on the child, but nearly one-third were unintentional. (Others were of undetermined causes or from suicide attempts.) Three out of four hospitalizations of children younger than 10 have resulted from accidental injuries.
(?!) That was not a good thing to say. This article and my comments are simply a presentation of facts and events, you can place it on whatever side of the political spectrum you feel it belongs.
Another misguided comment! You know me better than that Mark. I always have an answer, and the stats and sources to back them up.
As for the breakdown for the 12,000+- deaths by gunfire in America every year, I have over 50 Bookmarks with statistics directly related to the issue.
By LEO deaths do you mean LEOs that died in the line of duty from hostile gunfire?
So far this year - 6. In2014 - 47 [ Officer Down Memorial Page ]
To date the most reliable data anyone has about law enforcement killing of civilians in the U.S., is the FBIs statistics on homicides by law enforcement.
But there is a problem.
Those numbers are voluntarily given to the FBI by police, and many jurisdictions simply dont hand over this information, thus making an accurate accounting of exactly how many people police have actually killed each year extremely difficult to ascertain.
For instance, the killing of Eric Garner would not be included in the FBIs 2014 statistics because New York doesnt participate in the voluntary program.
However, there is a new means of aggregating how many people are being killed by law enforcement. This new tool for accountability is the website www.killedbypolice.com .
Take a look at it, it is not easy to read and I do not vouch for the numbers, but it is showing much higher numbers than what the cops are telling us.
Its basically a spreadsheet that lists every person killed by cops in the years 2013 and 2014. In addition to naming those killed, it also provides a link to media reports for each of the killings, age, sex and race if available.
The information available on the site begins in May of 2013 and runs through now. The novel idea of monitoring the number of police killings through news reports has shown to be a much better accounting of deaths at the hands of cops than the voluntary FBI system.
The FBIs stats show that in all of 2013 there were 461 people killed by cops, but when using the new site, which only shows from May 1 to Dec. 31, 2013, police actually killed 748 people. Keep in mind, 748 is drastically more than the feds claim police killed the entire year but only accounts for 8 months of 2013.
The site shows 2014s total number killed by police to be at 1,029 with a few weeks left in the year.
How many of the 12,000+- homicides were suicides? None.
According the the Pew Research Center , in 2010 there were 19,392 suicides by firearm compared to 11,078 homicides by gun, 35% of all firearm deaths. (Gun stats from almost any year will show 60-65% of all gun related deaths are suicides.)
It really makes no difference how or why the remaining 12,000+- deaths by gunfire occur, because they all involve guns. Granted a small percentage are accidental and a few are justifiable, but the vast majority are outright murders.
According to CONSERVATIVE POLITICS ;
" There are roughly 32,000 gun deaths per year in the United States. Of those, around 60% are suicides. About 3% are accidental deaths (between 700-800 deaths). About 34% of deaths (just over 11,000 in both 2010 and 2011) make up the remainder of gun deaths and are classified as homicides. "
I think that gives us plenty of reason for discussion.
I don't think Doctors are asking, or care, if you own any guns. The suggested requirement is simply for Doctors to point out the dangers of unsecured firearms to parents, the same as they are required to point out other child safety hazards.
It amazes me how you guys get all bent out of shape whenever the subject of gun safety comes up. I would think you would want to promote any program that helps keep children out of harms way.
In general I would agree with that sentiment MM. True there'sno needfor a Doc to bring up gun ownership if you're there for a cold or because you smashed your thumb doing a little DIY. However,just off the top of my head, I can come up with three scenarios where a Dr should be talking to their patients about guns.
Depressions.
Since guns play a big role in American suicide deaths, then when a patient presents with symptoms of depression asking if they own or have easy access to guns would be a prudent heath measure for a Dr to take? Perhaps even recommending that the patent temporally hand their guns over to a friend . I don't see much difference in that kind ofquestioningVs asking you about your diet or level of exercise if you're there because of high blood pressure or a heart problem.
Parents with new children in their home.
While the is Dr discussingthe thingsnew parents should do to keep theirlittle onessafe, like locking away household poisons or putting gates at the top of stairs and around pools, asking themif they have guns and if they've made proper arraignments for keeping them away from the kids seems reasonable.
Spousal Abuse.
Since guns often play a lethal role in abuse casesifa Drsee's signs of abuse during a medical exam, why shouldn'the be allowed to ask if there are gunsaround, asa way of gauging aknown health risk to their patient?
Perhaps there aremore but the three above lead me to think it's silly to pass laws forbidding Doctors from even bringing the subject of gun ownership up under any circumstance.
Just my personal thoughts of course, but I have had the experience of scraping brains off the celling in the aftermath of a depressed family member using a rifle in his suicide.
There's always the chance that if his Doctor had advised him to get the gun out of his home during his treatment he might be alive today.
It wouldn't be so bad if they only killed themselves, but most of the time, the idiot is holding the gun...
Petey,
Here's what happens; because of all the illegal guns in those parts of the country and the failure to control the flow of such guns into those part of the country, one of the resultant phenomena is the sad reality that
So, here's a thought go after the sources of these illegal guns and do what is possible to control/mitigate their sale/distribution to whatever extent is possible.
Or, are you implying that those areas need more cars so that we can stop worrying about the gun thing?
Please clarify for me.
Now, let's get real on the doctor thing; THIS ISN'T ABOUT DOCTORS BEING THE ONES TO EDUCATE INDIVIDUALS ABOUT THE POTENTIAL DANGERS OF, I.E. GUNS IN THE HOMES, OR,THE REALITY THAT MORE FAMILY MEMBERS AND KNOWN INDIVIDUALS ARE KILLED IN BY GUNS THAN THOSE KILLED WHILE PERPETRATING A CRIME OR ACTUALLY POSING A THREAT TO THE SHOOTER OR VICTIM!
This is about the NRA doing whatever it can to discourage educating people about such things so that gun sales just keep-on-keepin'-on.
Schools, gun clubs and parents should all beequallyconcernedabout gun safety, but the Doctors arethe ones that have to treat those that are wounded, and now that the number of those deaths and serious injuries have reached the levels they are now at, the medical profession deems the use and storage of firearms to be a national health issue.
Of course if you do not consider a gunshot wound as being detrimental to your health, I suppose you may have an argument.
So if a kidfindsa loaded, unlocked gun andaccidentallyshoots his sisterin the chest, she should be rushed to the nearest NRA office?
MM, if you were a doctor and that 'sister' was beautiful little 6 year old that died in your arms while you were trying to save her life, don't you think it would have an effect on you, and possibly cause you to want to warn parents about the danger of improperly stored firearms?
I agree, Having been trained in Firearms use and trained others.
Keep the doctors out of my Gun Safe!
(?!)
What the hell is that supposed to mean?!
YOU'RE WRONG PETEY!! Chicago, Detroit, East L.A., South L.A, and the rest of L.A., Miami, Ferguson, Baltimore, New York, Seattle, St. Louis, New Orleans, West New Jesus, East Bumfuck .... they ARE the rest of America!
Speaking of 'gangland', when is he last time you ever heard of a drive-by knifing?
Almost 20,000 American kill themselves with GUNS every year.
About 12,000 Americans are killed by other people with GUNS every year.
There areapproximately 350 MILLION GUNS in America.
Why are you people fighting over GUN safety????
Mike,
The Question Doctors Can't Ask
What's the problem with this, Mike?
To me,agreeingwiththe NRA and saying "Fuck the NRA", is a mixed message.
If 10,000 children were killed and hospitalized because of power drills every year, it would be just as serious a national health problem and there would be no 'disconnect' at all.
The only 'disconnect' is the lack of common sense in thinking doctors should not concerned about the number of children they have to treat as a result of injuries from firearms.
The doctors are not concerned about the fucking guns! They're concerned about the gun WOUNDS!
NRA personnel don't treat gun wounds, doctors treat gun wounds.
Thank you Arky!! That's exactly what this is all about, and that is all that this is allabout!
So, why is the NRA trying to pushlegislation making it illegal for doctors to discuss gun safety regarding children?
Anyway, a doctor does not have to ask, or even care, if a patient/parent owns guns, they only need to say:
"IF you, or anyone know owns firearms, please make sure they are properly stored when your kids are around them,.... because 10,000 children are killed or hospitalized every year from firearms"
What the fuck is wrong with you? Doctors know their role. Their role is to save the lives of the children that have been shot, and morn over the lives of the ones they could not save.
If they can help reduce the number of children that are killed by guns every year by ONE child, it is worth all the discussion in the world.
Are you saying you don't care if a doctor may be able to help save a childs life?
Why is it ok for a doctor to advise a patient/parent to use a car seat, or to advise them to gate their pool? But not ok to advise them about gun security?
"......but your side of the aisle pushing for gun control,..."
This does not have to do with gun 'control', it has to do with gun 'safety'.
I just want background checks for the purchase of all firearms no "collectors" passes. And, when the private owner of a legally-owned and properly licensed/registered firearm, sells, gifts, etc. that firearm to another individual, I want that buyer or transferee/recipient, to properly register it and himself.
That's it except for the ownership of any weapon or device that is capable of being a "WMD" so-to-speak, those should not be in the hands of the general public.
And if you object to any of this for fear of it leading to a gun-ownership database, the NRA's objection to this is hypocritical in that the NRA has such a database.
I will look for your SPECIFIC objections.
As for
When one donates blood, the equivalent of such questions are asked to protect the public. But, if the "pamphlet" is apart of a public-education program, I might agree.
What we have now aside from illegal guns (a separate issue), is the ability to purchase guns legally without the requirement of taking and passing a gun-safety course first.
Would you want people to be able to drive motor vehicles without any safety education beforehand?
It does NOT belong in the doctors office. I go there when my side hurts orI have a cold, etc. I don't go there to be lectured on gun safety, not even for ore children. It's not their job and I'll stop going to a doctor who tries to tell me about weapons in any form. The last I heard there were no classes on gun safety in medical school, nor should there be. The next thing you know you'll have the clerks at Wal-Mart required to give a lecture on weapons safety eve time they sell a pound of hamburger.
Ad your NRA agreement is pure shit, because you already know how much I hate the current NRA, so stop the fucking cheap shots and lies! Fuck off with that shit jerry!
IT'S NOT THEIR FUCKING JOB ANYMORE THEN IT IS MY MAILMAN'S! IT BELONGS IN THE SCHOOLS!
Of course if you do not consider a gunshot wound as being detrimental to your health, I suppose you may have an argument.
That's a load of hosrseshit argument and you know it. If I go to the doctor because I have a cold that doesn't mean I need a lecture on gun safety anymore then I need a lecture on crossing streets safely, unless of course I don't consider getting run over by a bus to be detrimental to my heath. What are they gong to be responsible for next? Waning parents to report open pot holes or a downed power line or not to walk in front of a truck or don't try to fly a fucking airplane! I consider getting bit by a rattlesnake to be detrimental to my health. Should my doctor be required by law to warn me about them too when I go there for an earache?
Tell the NRA: Stay Out of Our Doctor's Offices
Tell them that weapons training does not belong in a doctors office! Keep weapons instruction out of our doctors office.
THAT IS KEEPING THE NRA OUT OF OUR DOCTOR'S OFFICE!!!!
MM,
Didn't we call "IMPASSE" on this? If not, I'll respond.
Iapologize for violating the impasse. Go ahead and say whatever you damned well please.
We have an Impasse...remember? I even deleted my responses.
You called the impasse and that's why I asked about it prior to responding. I will delete my response to you.
To be clear, either one of us can respond to others in this thread but you and I have agreed to disagree.
The response I deleted is the one I offered Mike earlier today.
I couldn't agree with your posts more NT #1!
To me,agreeingwiththe NRA and saying "Fuck the NRA", is a mixed message.
Thanks because I made the very understandable mistake of thinking that only the NRA would be assholes enough to try to make doctors into weapons instructors!
jerry you WERE on the right track when you said schools , parents even the police , gun clubs should be the ones promoting education and safety , but IMHO that's where it should stay, its not being for just ANY proposed thing , its being opposed to a form of back door registration via medical records. leave a loop hole and it will be exploited . if a family has a firearm in the house , its their responsibility , and duty to decide when its appropriate to start teaching , its also THEIR duty to make sure its secure as with anything else that is dangerous if misused .
Amac , actually those school districts that do allow firearms safety to be brought up as a seminar, actually usually use the local police whom usually , but not always the NRA Eddy eagle program , a teaching seminar geared age appropriately for different age groups. and what I mean by age appropriate is , certain ages are told and it is stressed to if a firearm is found , NOT to touch it , be it if its in a home , or outside , and to go get an adult , on up to older kids who are warned if they find one outside that it could be a weapon that was used in a crime, age appropriate so the subject can understand it right? you wouldn't go into a kindergarden class and be intending to explain the good touch bad touch and stranger danger , and get explicite on blowjobs right?
its not being for just ANY proposed thing , its being opposed to a form of back door registration via medical records. leave a loop hole and it will be exploited .
Exactly.
Amac , actually those school districts that do allow firearms safety to be brought up as a seminar, actually usually use the local police whom usually , but not always the NRA Eddy eagle program
They don't usually called the local AMA.
Now before you tear apart my post , here is a little background for you.
I am a 10 yr active duty vet, whom most of that time was a military policeman carrying a firearm every single day on duty. I have been an avid and active hunter since I was old enough o get a lic to do so , I also have shot inorganized competition settings. I have most likely had to qualify more than most LEO agencies and because I reload my own ammunition (I feel it preforms better than even the high quality match grade ammo and usually does because I can tailor make the round to the gun) so im acutely aware of where and how far its going to go.
To date None of the firearms I have , have accidently gone off by themselves, be it through a mechanical flaw or evil intent, so they haven't killed anyone just by themselves , but then again maybe im just lucky,
I have a couple handguns I have for different carry purposes depending on what im doing , and they haven't been used either of all the firearms I do own at the moment , only 1(one) has ever been used on a human beijng in my possession, and that's a single shot shotgun, in .410, (the smallest they make) that was loaded with rocksaly( the very coarse stuff) and discharged into the largest target area of a thief that was presented on a snowy winters night( that happened to be their posterior as they were bent over syphoning gas) now combine wet seat of pants with a downloaded rocksalt shotgun round and the thwap of the ass being hit was louder than the sound the gun made, but the subsiquint screams of pain running down the dirt drive were by far sounding like someone was being murdered.
morale of that story , I could have very easily switched to a buckshot round , AND ended the problem for good and permanently, but with the way it was done it ended for good and permanently because it got around , the choice to shoot was never in question , what to shoot at them was , it could be rock salt again or something else. I let them make up their own minds with what they knew had already happened.
Damn Mickey . you and I are agreeing too much , is there a moon phase going on Im not aware of ?
jerry to clarify the LEO attributed deaths , I meant how many were shot BY THE POLICE lawfully(for now) not how many police died in the line of duty.
I understand and read the available FBI crime reports , but they take some digging to get specific numbers , and the down fall is not every state and /or jurisdiction submits reports to them.
Stop can right there!
No, what I mean is, a Doctors' role is to savethelives of children that have been shot, YOUR role is to store your guns safely so children don't get shot.
No, they shouldn't have to ask you if you if you have a gun, they only need to tell you IF you have a gun you should store it safely. And it makes no difference if you have any kids at home, don't you ever have kids visit your home?
(?!) Why is that implausible? In your next sentence you implied that if you stored your gun safely as a result of a doctors advice, it might save a childs life.
You guys are always worried about what's next, instead of making a decision on what's now . Don't worry about what's next, if you don't like what comes next, just say no!
There is a time to say, " yes we agree with that ", and there is a time to say " no, we don't agree with that. " I don't understand the logic of saying no to an idea because you might not like the next idea. What's up with that?!
The last you heard?! Since when have you been checking what classes are included in medical schools?
For all you know, with 10,000 kids a year being killed and wounded from gunshots, training doctors to tell their patients about proper gun storage might be included in the current curriculum.
Now you're getting silly.
'snot my NRA agreement, I just seeded an article. (and I didn't know you hated the NRA) .... What "cheap shots"? What did I lie about?
The scenario of the 6 year old dying in your arms get to you MM? Do you get it now?
'sOK to admit there is a place for doctors to advise patients about gun safety, nothing wrong with modifying your position on an issue;
I'm glad someone gets it>
'SALL .....
(You would go to a doctor because you have a COLD?!)
10,000 KIDS A YEAR ARE KILLED AND WOUNDED FROM GUNSHOTS!!
NOT FROM POTHOLES, BUSSES, DOWNED POWER LINES, RATTLESNAKES .....
GUN FUCKING SHOTS!!
That's all we're discussing here, doctors talking about safe storage of gunS so they don't have to deal with 10,000 KILLED OR WOUNDED CHILDREN .... EVERY YEAR!
There ya go, with that Right Wing paranoia! I'm sure the lying pricks at the NRA are totallyexaggerating the proposal just to get you guys all riled up. Why do you always fall for that shit?
My doctor has all he can do to keep track of the results of my piss samples, let alone what caliber rifle I hunt with. Do you really think doctors are going to agree to post what firearms I own in my medical records?
Doctors are gun owner too, don't forget that. So, calm the fuck down, no one is coming to get your guns. They're simply trying to do something to reduce the number of child fatalities as a result of unsecured firearms.
Please don't be deleting comments because of an impasse breach, if someone has responded to a comment before it is deleted,it confuses everyone on the thread.
'sno big deal if someone violates an impasse. It's more important to keep the thread flowing smoothly..
Now it's WEAPONS TRAINING!?
We're just trying to help save a few lives here, if unsecured guns are part of the problem, and you want to resist measures to help solve the problem, then YOU become part of the problem.
The scenario of the 6 year old dying in your arms get to you MM? Do you get it now?
I have to go to bed sometime!
No, don't you fucking dare twist my words! Dead six year old or not the NRA and gun safety warning do NOT belong in the doctors office any more the warnings about airplane crashes do! I still disagree and nothing you can say can twist this into making any kind of sense. Gun safety information does NOT belong in a doctor's office! EVER!
When plane crashes start claiming 3,000 young lives and hospitalize another 7,000 every year, it might also rise to the level of becoming a national health issue.
It doesn't make sense to you thatbecause3,000 children die and another 7,000 are hospitalized every year, the people that have to deal with all that death and bloodshed should talk to their patients, and warn them of the dangers from the unsecured instrument that caused all that bloodshed?
I don't know, I would think this whole thing is over your head, but I know you're smarter than that.
Why?!
Poor gun safety results in serious injuries and death. Those deaths and injuries make doctors very aware of the problems caused by unsecured weapons. As I said, it is the doctors that have to deal with all the death andbloodshed. And it is the doctors that should warntheirpatients of the danger.
Wouldn't you agree if there is a flue epidemic spreading around, the doctors that have to treat those that become infected should warn their patients and advise themhow to avoid becoming infected?
10,000 deaths and injuries every year, from any cause, is certainly at epidemic levels and should be declared a national health issue, as it has been.
It is unreasonable to argue that the cause and prevention of any national health issue of epidemic proportions should not be discussed in doctors offices.