╌>

The False Evidence Against Scooter Libby

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  11 years ago  •  9 comments

The False Evidence Against Scooter Libby

A revelation in journalistJudith Millers new memoir, The Story: A Reporters Journey, exposes unscrupulous conduct by Special CounselPatrick J. Fitzgeraldin the 2007 trial of I. Lewis ScooterLibby.

Ms. Miller, a former New York Times reporter, writes that Mr. Fitzgerald induced her to give what she now realizes was false testimony. By withholding critical information and manipulating her memory as he prepared her to testify, Ms. Miller relates, Mr. Fitzgerald steered her in the wrong direction.

Ms. Millers inaccurate testimony helped Mr. Fitzgerald persuade a Washington, D.C., jury in 2007 to find Mr. Libby, former chief of staff to Vice PresidentDick Cheney,guilty of obstruction of justice, making a false statement and perjury.

Mr. Fitzgeralds conduct warrants revisiting not only to set the record straight about Mr. Libby, but also to illustrate the damage that can be done to national security by a special counsel who, discovering no crime, generates through his investigations the alleged offenses he seeks to prosecute.

According to the conventional view, in the summer of 2003 Mr. Libby compromised national security by unlawfully outing a covert CIA agent. Mr. Libbys supposed purpose was to punish the agents husband, who challenged President George W. Bush s assertion in his 2003 State of the Union address that the British government learned that Iraq had sought to purchase African uranium. According to the standard anti-Bush account, when Mr. Libby became enmeshed in a federal investigation, he lied to conceal his crime and protect Mr. Cheney.

RELATED ARTICLE

A more extensive account of the new evidence in the Libby case and its consequences can be found here .

This account is false in all essential respects, as Mr. Fitzgeraldsince 2012 a partner in the Chicago office of the Skadden Arps law firmhad reason, as well as an ethical obligation as an officer of the court, to know.

Scooter Libby did not out CIA employeeValerie Plame.That was done by then-Deputy Secretary of StateRichard Armitage,a critic of the conduct of the Iraq war. Mr. Armitage disclosed to columnistRobert Novakthat Ms. Plame, who at the time held a desk job in the CIAs Counterproliferation Division, urged the agency to send her husband, retired Ambassador Joseph C. Wilson, to Africa in early 2002 to investigate whether Iraq had sought uranium. Presidential aide Karl Rove and then-CIA Director of Public Affairs Bill Harlow confirmed Mr. Armitages disclosure for Novaks July 14, 2003, column. (Novak died in 2009.)

Mr. Fitzgerald didnt charge anyone with leaking Ms. Plames identity or disclosing classified information to reporters. From the moment he took over the FBI leak investigation in December 2003, he knew Mr. Armitage was the leaker but declined to prosecute him, Mr. Rove orMr. Harlow because the disclosure of Ms. Plames identity wasnt a crime and didnt compromise national security.

Mr. Fitzgerald nonetheless pressed on for someone to prosecute, eventually focusing on Mr. Libby, whose trial became a contest of recollections. The excruciatingly inconsequential question on which his conviction turned was whether, as Mr. Libby recalled, he was surprised to hear NBCs Meet the Press hostTim Russertask him about Ms. Plame in a phone call on July 10 or 11, 2003. In November 2003, Russert (who died in 2008) told the FBI that he didnt recall mentioning Mr. Wilsons wife to Mr. Libby, but couldnt rule it out. By August 2004 Russert had changed his story. Under questioning by Mr. Fitzgerald, he insisted he could not have mentioned Ms. Plame.

Despite the many reasonable doubts that Mr. Libbys lawyers raised about Russerts recollection, Mr. Libby was convicted for what he said about a phone conversation during which the prosecutor himself insisted Ms. Plame was not mentioned.

Although the case centered on conflicting recollections of a four-year-old phone call, Judge Reggie B. Walton denied the defense request to present scientific testimony on the unreliability of memory. Jurors might have welcomed it: During deliberations, according to jurorDenis Collins, they lamented their lack of expert knowledge. In any event, Mr. Libbys and Tim Russerts differing memories shouldnt have mattered since Mr. Armitage disclosed Ms. Plames CIA employment.

Still, Mr. Fitzgeraldwho declined to respond to written questions for this articlesought a conviction, and he went so far as to jail Judith Miller for 85 days to obtain evidence against her sources, one of whom was Mr. Libby.

Ms. Millers new memoir recounts that after her conditions had been met and Mr. Fitzgerald asked the court to release her from jail in September 2005, she was summoned to testify before the grand jury. While Mr. Fitzgerald prepared her, she recalls, his pointed queries led her to believe that a four-word question regardingJoseph Wilsonsurrounded by parentheses in her notebook(wife works in Bureau?)proved that Mr. Libby had told her about Ms. Plames CIA employment in a June 23, 2003, conversation (well before Mr. Libbys phone conversation with Russert). She so testified at trial in 2007.

Three years later, Ms. Miller writes, she was reading Ms. Plames book, Fair Game, and was astonished to learn that while on overseas assignment for the CIA Ms. Plame had worked at the State Department as cover. This threw a new light on the June 2003 notebook jotting, Ms. Miller says, since the State Department has bureaus, while the CIA is organized into divisions.

Ms. Miller, who had spoken to many State Department sources around the same time she spoke to Mr. Libby, says in her memoir that she then realized she must have begun her conversation with him wondering whether Mr. Wilsons wife worked at the State Department. Ms. Miller also now understood that If Libby, a seasoned bureaucrat, had been trying to plant her employer with me at our first meeting in June, he would not have used the word Bureau to describe where Plame worked.

Mr. Fitzgerald, who had the classified file of Ms. Plames service, withheld her State Department cover from Ms. Millerand from Mr. Libbys lawyers, who had requested Ms. Plames employment history. Despite his constitutional and ethical obligation to provide exculpatory evidence, Mr. Fitzgerald encouraged Ms. Miller to misinterpret her ambiguous notes as showing that Mr. Libby brought up Ms. Plame.

If Ms. Miller had testified accurately, she would have dealt a severe blow to Mr. Fitzgeralds central contention that Mr. Libby was lying when he said he was surprised to hear Russert mention Ms. Plame.

Dismayed that her inaccurate testimony may have helped convict an innocent man, Ms. Miller did what a reporter does: She investigated. She learned from Mr. Libbys lawyer,Joseph Tate,that, as she recounts in her book, Fitzgerald had twice offered to drop all charges against Libby if his client would deliver Cheney to him.

Harvard psychology professor Daniel L. Schacter, author of The Seven Sins of Memory and one of the nations leading memory experts, told Ms. Miller that the jury lacked the information it needed about memory failure to assess fairly Mr. Libbys statements.

And in a 2013 interview, Mr. Cheney told Ms. Miller that in the summer of 2003as the Plame affair erupted, criticism of the White House mounted and post-invasion Iraq deterioratedMr. Libby took the lead within the Bush administration in arguing for a counterinsurgency strategy. In 2007 Gen. David Petraeus successfully implemented the surge. It is painful to contemplate how many American and Iraqi lives might have been spared if Mr. Libby, the foremost champion inside the White House in 2003 of stabilizing Iraq through counterinsurgency, had not been sidelined and eventually forced to resign by Mr. Fitzgeralds overwrought investigation and prosecution.

On Oct. 28, 2005, at the news conference on the day of Mr. Libbys indictment, Mr. Fitzgerald accused him of harming national security by throwing sand in federal investigators eyes. The allegations against Mr. Libby were grave, the prosecutor argued, because the truth is the engine of our judicial system.

Yet it was Mr. Fitzgerald who threw sand in the eyes of Ms. Miller and the American people, and in the gears of the U.S. legal system. As special counsel he placed his quest for a conviction above the search for truth and the pursuit of justice.

http://www.wsj.com/articles/peter-berkowitz-the-false-evidence-against-scooter-libby-1428365713


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Ftizgerald was a prosecutor in search of victim. His conduct was abominable and a prime example of the dangers of a prosecutor on a political witch hunt.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    11 years ago

Despicable, and such far reaching consequences...

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Libby was always Cheney's fall guy, but he was up to his ass in it too. If you want to pardon Libby, then you need to prosecute someone else, namely Richard Cheney because someone has to take the fall. Cheney was Livid when Bush wouldn't pardon Libby before the end of his term. I don't think anyone really wants to bring it all back up again. I mean Libby is hardly on death row and there is still enough political connections with Cheney to block any further investigation. Until then Libby hs a felony on his record. Life's a bitch when you swim with the sharks.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

You'd think with all his BIG connections he could afford a BIG DEFENSE or is the special prosecutor beyond the reach of mere mortals ?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Mr. Fitzgeraldsince 2012 a partner in the Chicago office of the Skadden Arps law firm

He should have been the one indicted. Have they ever had a governor who didn't serve time in prison?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

by was always Cheney's fall guy, but he was up to his ass in it too


Up into what? There was no underlying crime.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
When you enter the state, there's a flashing sign counting the days since the last indictment of a governor. It's a state holiday when they reach 1,000.
 
 

Who is online



130 visitors