╌>

Moral Bullies and the Laws That Enable Them

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  5 comments

Moral Bullies and the Laws That Enable Them

How Did We Get Here?

Our public accommodation laws have been too broadly expanded and need to be scaled back, argues Scott Shackford at the libertarian Reason in an article I find compelling:The outpouring of support for Memories Pizza certainly reflects what Schackford notes:

Maybe instead of arguing who should or shouldnt be exempt from certain public accommodation laws, perhaps we should be looking more closely at whats included in public accommodation laws. Thats really where the wiggle room is. Do gay couples have a right to make a photographer shoot their wedding? Maybe we should ask if anybody has a right to make a photographer shoot a wedding? Even though a majority of Americans now support gay marriage recognition, a Rasmussen Poll from last summer found that 85 percent of Americans believe that wedding photographers have the right to decline to shoot a gay wedding.

What we should take from that is that perhaps our public accommodation laws are too broad. There is a place in the American consciousness that allows for respect for property rights and freedom of association even if it leads to behavior many agree is bigoted. Title II of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (which doesnt include sexual orientation) classifies hotels, restaurants (or any place food is served), gas stations, and entertainment venues as places of public accommodation. Thats actually it. Ideas of what is classified as a public accommodation have been expanded further by additional federal legislation (like the Americans with Disabilities Act ) and state laws. Arizonas public accommodation laws include banks, medical offices, and health clubs, for example. The state does not include sexual orientation as a protected class in its public accommodation laws, though some cities within the state do. Oregons definition of public accommodation is much vaguer than the federal governments, encompassing nearly all businesses that serve the public and including sexual orientation among the forbidden categories of discrimination. Oregon is where a bakery ran afoul of these laws by refusing to bake a wedding cake for a gay couple and ended up shutting its doors.

If we were to say that goods and services like wedding cakes or wedding photography are not public accommodations then the reasons for refusal wouldnt matter and there would be no reason to have to develop special carve-outs for who could or could not discriminate. Nobody would have a right to demand a baker make them a wedding cake for any reason. It wouldnt matter if the customers were a gay couple, interracial couple, white supremacists, or the bakers ex-wife who dumped him for some loser.

Even the lefty Atlantic seems to be offended by the attack on small businesses like Memories Pizza.Conor Friedersdorf argues::

The owners of Memories Pizza are, I think, mistaken in what their Christian faith demands of them. And I believe their position on gay marriage to be wrongheaded. But I also believe that the position I'll gladly serve any gay customers but I feel my faith compels me to refrain from catering a gay wedding is less hateful or intolerant than let's go burn that family's business to the ground .

And I believe that the subset of the gay-rights movement intent on destroying their business and livelihood has done more harm than good here -- that they've shifted their focus from championing historic advances for justice to perpetrating small injustices against marginal folks on the other side of the culture war. "The pizzeria discriminated against nobody," Welch wrote, "merely said that it would choose not to serve a gay wedding if asked. Which it never, ever would be, because who asks a small-town pizzeria to cater a heterosexual wedding, let alone a gay one?" They were punished for "expressing a disfavored opinion to a reporter."

Much of the weeks punditry concentrated on Indianas Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) and how it followed or departed from the federal law signed by President Clinton or the laws in many other states that have them, but they miss the point I think. Our concept of what constitutes a public accommodation has, like so many other policies, laws, and regulations, seriously diminished our constitutional freedoms in the wake of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. They need to be pared back if we are to continue as a free people with the right to free speech, free association, and the freedom to practice our religion. If we dont, we open the doors to totalitarians that decide what we can do and mobs like the Chinese Red Guards enforcing this weeks cultural fashion.



Read more: http://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2015/04/moral_bullies_and_the_laws_that_enable_them.html#ixzz3WVTm6768


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

There used to be a time when businesses could post a notice that said they can refuse service to anyone they choose to . How did that get to be a crime ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

So you equate businesses rights to refuse service to lynching or equally heinous acts ? What kind of mental delusions do you harbor ? There is NO comparison .

Taking a simple rule for businesses and making it complicated so it will be "fair" for all is nothing but government meddling with the expected side effects .

 
 

Who is online