╌>

Republican Religionist Governors … If You're Sincere About "Clarifying" Those Religionist Freedom Laws, There's Only One Way

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  a-macarthur  •  11 years ago  •  16 comments

Republican Religionist Governors … If You're Sincere About "Clarifying" Those Religionist Freedom Laws, There's Only One Way

IF YOU ARE SINCERE

All that is needed to clarify the Religionist Freedom Law is the following preamble or addendum (which the haters, bigots and homophobes will despise):

Nothing in this law shall be construed as "THE RIGHT OF ANY INDIVIDUAL, BUSINESS, ETC. TO DENY GOODS AND/OR SERVICES TO ANY/ALL PERSONS/GROUPS, NOR TO DENY ENTRY/ACCESS TO ANY PUBLIC, FOR-PROFIT OR NON-PROFIT ENTERPRISE NOR TO ANY/ALL OTHER PUBLIC SPACE (INCLUDING VIRTUAL SPACE), THIS ON THE BASIS OF RACE, RELIGION, GENDER, SEXUAL ORIENTATION, NATIONAL ORIGIN, ETC. ."

No nebulous language straight forward if these laws are not intended to discriminate, PUT THE LANGUAGE IN THE LAW THAT PROHIBITS DISCRIMINATION.

And while you're at it, tell why such a law is necessary, because, WHEN ONE'S RELIGIOUS BELIEFS TRUMPS ANOTHER'S RELIGIOUS BELIEFS, IT SHOULD BE CLEAR THAT SUCH A LAW IS A SELF-CONTRADICTION!


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Sounds good to me! Grin.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Disagree if you like, BUT DEBATE ONLY THE SPECIFICS OF MY PREAMBLE/ADDENDUM; no pronouncements or off-handed, summary dismissals.

If you can't explain why you think the language is flawed or impractical, you should be able to give a cogent explanation as to why.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

1. If the law is "no different" from the federal law, then why does the "get gubment out of our lives" crowd insist that it's necessary?

Because Federal Law is not incumbent on the states, this is why many states do what is known as "Codifying" federal law into their own statutes. Liberal states do it all the time without a whisper of discontent. So one has to ask why the question when a conservative state does it?

2. There are points where religion conflicts with the laws of man. When that happens, one must supersede the other.

Governments are the creation of man, god is eternal, the argument over which is supreme has been going on for thousands of years. Just as many different governments are created by man, so are there different gods created. The question of which should have supremacy is one that doesn't have an answer, never will have an answer, and shouldn't be answered.

The main difference is religion and it's laws are intended to rule the individual, a very good aim. the laws of man attempt to rule the crowd (ie. collective groups of men) also a very good aim.

The problem comes when one is applied to the other, in such case, they both become tyrannical in nature. Our constitution, in enlightened manner, attempted to devise a solution to this quandary. A method to make both philosophies work together. AS it is, it recognizes the importance of both to good governance of a nations citizenry and should work together. One never being supreme over the other.

The fight usually starts when one side tries to make one superior to the other and results in blowback. Never a good thing. When such is attempted we lose the benefits of both.

It was recognized that one should not trample the other, EVER. but as this nation ages, we lose sight of the obvious, and our children pay the price.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The Federal Law (the 1993 RFRA) excludes "For-Profits" -- a major difference from the recent, state versions. Essentially limiting actions based on "sincerely held religious beliefs" to private vs. public spaces.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

The question was, (at least the part I was responding to)

.....why does the "get gubment out of our lives" crowd insist that it's necessary?

For the same reason that the 'get gubment into our lives' crowd think it's necessary.

So basic, I don't know why it is even asked.

AS far as the differences in the Indiana, Arkansas and Federal laws? I have no opinion. Because to me it really doesn't matter. My philosophy of life, religion and belief in justice in the area being discussed superceeds anything any other organization could attempt to impose.

Do unto others as you would want them to do you you.

Is the only rule that really matters.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

My original response to both statements by you was to illustrate that both questions already have answers that were well defined hundreds of years ago.

Tell me why we need to re-invent the wheel?

Two part question, to answer the second part one must decide on the validity of the first part. To you, it is one question, but to the intelligent mind, it requires two decisions before an intelligent answer can be delivered.

The first part is thus...

If the law is "no different" from the federal law,

requires someone contemplating the proposition to answer this for themselves FIRST,

Then....

..... then why does the "get gubment out of our lives" crowd insist that it's necessary?

....formulate a cogent answer to the second part.

The answer to the first part is plain, it is not the same, that is understood. To force a public answer is obtuse, and bad form. I answered the inquiry assuming that you understood the obvious adjudication of the first part.

Sorry, I won't make that mistake again.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

xcludes "For-Profits" -- a major difference from the recent, state versions.

That'sabsolutelyfalse. HHS made that argument in Hobby Lobby and it was explicitly rejected.

From Hobby Lobby:

(i) Nothing in RFRA suggests a congressional intent to depart from the Dictionary Act definition of person, which include[s] corporations, . . . as well as individuals. 1 U. S. C. 1. T...

Business practices compelled or limited by the tenets of a religious doctrine fall comfortably within the understanding of the exercise of religion that this Court set out in Employment Div., Dept. of Human Resources of Ore. v. Smith, 494 U. S. 872, 877. Any suggestion that for-profit corporations are incapable of exercising religion because their purpose is simply to make money flies in the face of modern corporate law.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

here are points where religion conflicts with the laws of man. When that happens, one must supersede the other.


Because the federal RFRA only applies in a federal lawsuit. If a citizen wants to assert a defense in a state action, the federal RFRA is meaningless. Hence you need a state RFRA to protect against state actions.

here are points where religion conflicts with the laws of man. When that happens, one must supersede the other.


Which isexactlywhy we have RFRAs. An RFRA sets up a framework for the court to weigh thecompeting interests of theindividualand the state. Prior to RFRA's the state won end of question. Hence, Indian users ofpeyotein religious ceremonies went to jail, no questions asked.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

That'sabsolutelyfalse. HHS made that argument in Hobby Lobby and it was explicitly rejected.

Sorry, Sean; it's absolutely true.

Regardless of what Alito and the gang ruled, the original RFRA excluded for-profits.

That's a fact.

I thought you guys didn't like activist judges.

The SCOTUS ruled in HL's favor DESPITE THAT ITS ARGUMENT WAS SCIENTIFICALLY INCORRECT! Alito acknowledged that but deferred yo "sincerely held religious beliefs" OVER REALITY.

In some ways, you have to hand it to Justice Alito. It is uncommon for a Supreme Court Justice to get every single question in a case wrong, but that is exactly what the newest member of the Courts conservative majority managed with the contraception mandate cases. Lets look at what Alito had to decide:

Do for-profit corporations have standing to sue under RFRA?

Did Hobby Lobby (or their owners) have a sincere religious belief here?

Was that sincere religious belief substantially burdened?

Was the mandate pursuing a compelling government interest?

Was the mandate the least restrictive method of meeting that interest?

Finally, should Alito have heard the case at all or should he (and other members of the Court) have recused himself?

Justice Ginsburg, in her dissent, expressed far more ably than I ever can the flaws in Alitos opinion. But lets recap a little.

Standing

According to the majority, for-profit corporations now have religious freedom rights. Commentators have been quick to point out that Alito sought to restrict this to closely held companies (which includes some of Americas largest corporations, such as Koch Industries and Bechtel) ; in the opinion the only thing he says regarding publicly traded corporations is he doesnt think they will apply for such exemptions.

Oddly enough this doesnt fill me with a great degree of confidence. The problem is, every piece of legislative history, and there is plenty of it, makes clear that RFRA was not intended to cover for-profit corporations. But the majority decided to play its textualist reindeer games, and subvert the clear intention of Congress (the elected branch) and instead impose its own view on the country, and elevate corporations to the same level, if not higher than, real people. I am not sure what will happen when Dell or Dole Foods attends your church next Sunday and sits in the pew next to you, but I cant imagine the parking situation will be improved. Anyway, through a breathtaking piece of judicial activism on the part of the conservative majority, corporations now have free exercise of religion. Or at least Christian owned ones do. We need to wait and see if a Muslim-owned corporation would have been given the same leeway by the Court.

Sincerity of Belief

The Administration didnt challenge Hobby Lobby here, and the government attorneys as well as the Court could not stop falling over themselves to congratulate the Greens, owners of Hobby Lobby, on their piety and devout beliefs. Well, it is time to call shenanigans on that. Hobby Lobby, as has been shown, has invested in excess of $73 million in companies that manufacture the very types of contraception the Greens claim are so offensive to them. So, in the Brave New World of corporate religious exercise rights, making money off something is just fine and dandy, but providing insurance for others to use it will damn you to hell. This belief doesnt bear up to scrutiny, and the case should have gone no further once it was clear that Hobby Lobbys desire here was scoring a point not defending a genuine belief.

Substantial Burden

Alito here is utterly dismissive of arguments made by the Administration that the separation between the provision of the service and the decision to use said service isolates the employer from responsibility. According to Alito, all we need to do is look and see if there is a monetary fine, and if so, we simply trust the religious group to say if they are burdened. No other area of law works in that way, and there is no reason to do that here. Religious groups should not be permitted to create their own realities. Just because the Greens believe that the drugs involved here cause abortions doesnt make it so, any more than Jenny McCarthy believing vaccines cause autism makes that the case. The Greens entire opposition to these forms of birth control is based on flawed, bogus pseudoscience. This should not be written into the law.

Beyond this, Congress consciously and deliberately added the word substantially to RFRA. Alito would have us believe this word is meaningless, and that any burden claimed by a religious group is sufficient. But words have meanings, and they are placed in laws for reasons. The idea that simply because a church claims it was burdened, it could be exempt from ANY law without consideration of whether there actually is an impact on peoples beliefs is so far from the original intention of RFRA it beggars belief.

Compelling Government Interest

Here Alito really shows his colors. Once again, the governments arguments are waved aside as irrelevant. The reams of facts and figures showing how women are discriminated against in health care, and pay 68% more out of pocket than men, and how reproductive health is perhaps the most central factor in equality for women is dismissed. All because a corporation that profits from making contraceptives doesnt want to provide them, and five men agree. In my years of reading legal opinions, I cant think of a dissent that so surgically eviscerates an opinion than Justice Ginsburgs does on this point.

Least Restrictive Method

Let the government pay for it! This was, for sure, not the cry many of us expected from the right wing of the Court, but there we have it. The problem is, as the dissent pointed out, the government can ALWAYS be called on to pick up the slack. By claiming this as a less restrictive alternative, the majority has created an opt-out clause for religion in every situation. It will always be less restrictive to have the government pay for it. Which, of course, means have other taxpayers pay for it. Which means subsidizing the religious beliefs of some with the public purse. I guess that Establishment Clause was there for decoration.

Should Alito have recused himself?

This is where things get really interesting. Given Alitos theory of causation, that providing insurance was a substantial burden on the Greens because down the road it could lead to the use of certain drugs, couldnt Alito (and Scalia, Roberts, Kennedy, and Thomas) be equally responsible? Had they upheld the mandate, they would be enabling women to use these drugs in precisely the same fashion as would the Greens. And these drugs are opposed by the Catholic Church, which views their use as a sin. Indeed, politicians who support their availability have been denied communion by the Catholic Church. So Alito (along with Scalia, Roberts, Kennedy, and Thomas) faced a decision as a practicing Catholic ruling against Hobby Lobby would expose his soul to eternal damnation. The idea that this would not lead him to prejudge the case is less than plausible. Unless, of course, he felt that his legal ruling was too attenuated from the decision to use a form of birth control that finding for the Administration wouldnt have been sinful

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

I believe you are changing the argument.

How was HL ultimately a state's matter?

Regardless, Sean, it does not change the point of my article, namely to challenge these Governors to ACTUALLY CLARIFY THE LAWS BY DOING SO WITH UNAMBIGUOUS LANGUAGE.

Let's not stray too far from that RFRA 1993 or 2015 -- doesn't matter if clarification for the purpose of renouncing "discrimination" is sincerely intended.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Regardless of what Alito and the gang ruled, the original RFRA excluded for-profits.

I have no idea what you are talking about. Alito's opinion dealt with the original RFRA. Moreover, the point is what the RFRA covers today, and you should have the grace to admit that it does in fact include coverage for for profits rather than moving the goal posts.

I've provided conclusive proof that the RFRA covers for-profits. Now we've moved the goals posts that the "orginal RFRA" whatever that is, excluded for-profits. But that is just as false. Either withdraw your claim or provide evidence of a change to the RFRA signed by Bill Clinton in 1993 or a Supreme Court case directly interpreting the Clinton RFRA in line with your argument.

Your source just claims Alito was wrong, it doesn't mention anything about an "original RFRA." My source is the law of the land. Your source is some guy who just thinks the Supreme Court was wrong.

If you want to argue that for profits should be excluded from RFRA protection, that's one thing. Then your source would be relevant. But to cite an opinion to support your demonstrably false claim the Federal law excludes for profits is simply improper. You aren't entitled to your own facts, and it's indisputable that the the federal RFRA protects for-profits. You may not like it, but's absolutely true.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Compelling arguments Mac, albeit from a very liberal standpoint. Impassioned as well, I would judge by the tone that her argument is more than a legal one and devolves into an ideological one. the same type of argument that she claims Alito is making on an impassioned religious basis.

Her argument is that Alito should recuse himself or in the least upbraid his reasoning due to undue personal religious/ideological influence.

I would suggest that she should apply some of that belief to her own impassioned personal ideological beliefs.

HL was never going to be a decision that anyone really liked especially from the liberal side. and your not going to get reasonable interpretive analysis from one who is directly responsible for the decision and is so impassionately involved as Ginsburg.

Besides HL has no real bearing o the issue of codifying federal law into state codes. Apples to oranges. the argument is should the language be changed for the statute being codified to a substantial point where it changes the law.

I say no, it shouldn't be, obviously some think it should.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

I believe you are changing the argument.


I don't think I am. I was merely addressing why citizens might want a state RFRA to go along with the federal. Federal and state laws are different animals with different jurisdictions. The Supreme court held the federal RFRA only applies on federal cases, therefore states passed RFRAs for state level issues. Different jurisdictions require separate RFRAs.

ow was HL ultimately a state's matter?


It's not. HL is only relevant to show that the federal RFRA applies to for profit corporations as well, disproving the claim that Indiana's law is unique by doing so.

CTUALLY CLARIFY THE LAWS BY DOING SO WITH UNAMBIGUOUS LANGUAGE.

You are arguing for a non-discrimination law, which is a separate matter than RFRAS. If an explicit non-discrimination law is necessary to protect gays, than the Indiana RFRA doesn't change anything. Discrimination against gays is already "legal" in Indiana and every state that doesn't offer specific protection to gays. Wonder when Apple is going to attack every state that doesn't have a non-discrimination law?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

I continue to remind the righties who claim that the Illinois RFRA and the original RFRA are essentially the same, that they are incorrect.

If you want to argue that for profits should be excluded from RFRA protection, that's one thing.

I would argue that, but that's a separate issue from claiming "sameness."

But to cite an opinion to support your demonstrably false claim the Federal law excludes for profits is simply improper.

That Alito et al bastardized the reality of the 1993 and allowed religion to trump scientific fact are my issues overall. But for this discussion, it's the clarification issue.

Again, from my previous comment

every piece of legislative history, and there is plenty of it, makes clear that RFRA was not intended to cover for-profit corporations. But the majority decided to play its textualist reindeer games, and subvert the clear intention of Congress (the elected branch) and instead impose its own view on the country, and elevate corporations to the same level, if not higher than, real people.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
How does the Illinois RFRA differ?It Applies to corporations since it uses the same definition for " person" " that the federal RFRA does. Corporations are people Under the definition illinois uses.Legislative history is not law. Courts presume congress knows what it is doing. Trying to devine the mythical legislative intent is simply the excuse activist judges use to ignore the actual text of a statute so they impose their own values. As the Supreme Court has made clear, the text of the actual RFRA is crystal clear about the definition of person it employs.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

FYI:

The Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993 , Pub. L. No. 103-141, 107 Stat. 1488 (November 16, 1993), codified at 42 U.S.C. 2000bb through 42 U.S.C. 2000bb-4 (also known as RFRA ), is a 1993 United States federal law that "ensures that interests in religious freedom are protected." [1] The bill was introduced by Congressman Chuck Schumer ( D - NY ) on March 11, 1993. A companion bill was introduced in the Senate by Ted Kennedy ( D - MA ) the same day. A unanimous U.S. House and a nearly unanimous U.S. Senate three senators voted against passage [2] passed the bill, and President Bill Clinton signed it into law.

The RFRA was held unconstitutional as applied to the states in the City of Boerne v. Flores decision in 1997, which ruled that the RFRA is not a proper exercise of Congress's enforcement power. However, it continues to be applied to the federal governmentfor instance, in Gonzales v. O Centro Espirita Beneficente Uniao do Vegetal because Congress has broad authority to carve out exemptions from federal laws and regulations that it itself has authorized. In response to City of Boerne v. Flores and other related RFR issues, twenty individual states have passed State Religious Freedom Restoration Acts that apply to state governments and local municipalities. [3]

 
 

Who is online