Carson Says Immigrants 'Don't Get to Change Who We Are'
Republican presidential candidate Ben Carson said Wednesday he welcomes immigrants to America, but they cannot alter "who we are."The retired neurosurgeon, speaking at a Christian college in his native Michigan, said he wants to preserve the U.S. as "Judeo-Christian." He has blamed political correctness for the fallout over his recent statement against electing a Muslim president, which he later clarified by saying he would be open to a moderate Muslim who denounces radical Islam."I have no interest in being like everybody else and giving away all of our values and principles for the sake of political correctness," Carson told a crowd at Spring Arbor University near Jackson, about 75 miles west of Detroit, where he grew up and launched his campaign in May. "There is such a thing as an American dream and the American way. Anybody is welcome to come to America, but they don't get to change who we are."Carson has been among the leading GOP contenders in recent polls.In his 30-minute speech, he told of rising from poverty with the help of his single mother. He accused Democrats of dividing Americans, calling the "war on women" a "phony thing" and "all hype." He said his life was "shaped and made successful by women."The Detroit area has one of the largest Middle Eastern populations in the country, with Arab-Muslims representing the largest ethnic group of Muslims in the area.Carson pointed to nations where women are not allowed to drive, their court testimony is worth less than men and they are treated like "chattel.""We do not want to import that type of ideology into America," he said to sustained applause. http://www.newsmax.com/t/newsmax/article/692984
Tags
Who is online
92 visitors

Immigrants have always changed who we are as Americans and as a nation. That's their function. That's why we have immigration. That's why we must always have immigration. To constantly keep America being reborn again and again and again, always to be at least a little bit different each time. Immigrants not only get to change who we are as a country, they have a responsibility to. We need them. Every wave of immigrants has had small to profound impacts on our country and always will. That's why they should be welcomed. They have all added to the rich tapestry of America.
No country needs or wants to remain stagnant but neither does it need to be "reborn" again and again and again.
As Americans, and America, we do have a culture and traditions born from the struggle to establish this country as the United States of America; we have many things we've done that we are proud of, and many that we are deeply and profoundly ashamed of... and out of both have been born a distinct culture and traditions. Some of those traditions are national, such as the Fourth of July celebrations and Christmas holidays and Easter celebrationsand there is no reason to change them. Many traditions are on a regional level, specific to certain areas of the country.
If new immigrants don't care to join in these celebrations they certainly don't have to, no one will twist their armor force them at gunpoint to do so... although I would question an immigrant not celebrating Fourth of July. But trying to abolish these celebrations because they "offend" the religious sensitivities of new immigrants is offensive to those of us who view them as part of our cultural traditions; they aren't done as an assertion of superiority or even as a display of religion.
Christmas has the story of the birth of Christ, but it also has the totally whimsical myth of Santa Claus; Easter has the story of the rise of Christ from the grave, but it also has the inexplicable tale of an "Easter Bunny" who lays eggs.
It's good to learn of the other cultures from which the immigrants come, but it doesn't mean America is obligated to change itself into those cultures, casting aside over two hundred years of what assimilating immigrants before them have created and made their own.
Exactly. And Illegal immigrants definitely should have no bearing on the change unless it is a revolution being promoted.
Evidently you've never been to China Town, Korea town, Little Saigon, Little Italy etc etc.
You really should get out in the world XX.
We don't have any of those around here but we do have a bunch of Mexicans in a little trailer park.
We have the trailer parks were as well Dean, except that their meth heads and not Mexican.
You've been to ''those kinds of places in San Francisco''...Seems you didn't learn anything.
In every experience I have ever seen with immigrants their influence has been positive in the end. Sure there have been some problems and some criminals have come along with every wave of immigrants in our nations entire history, with the immigration waves that involve just about every American and without a doubt some of the waves of some of the forefathers of many of the members of this site. Still they have always helped much more then they have harmed. They have given much more then they have taken and we need a constant flow of new blood to keep this country moving. If we close our doors and say "Well now that we're here, no one else gets to come in because we are afraid of them" then this county will wither and die and rightfully so.
In the case of every one of your ancestors wave of immigartion, the people who were already here hated and feared you and bitched that you would assimilate. In every case those that were here were wrong and those that are here now who are afraid and bitch that they won't assimilate are just as wrong too.
I am suspicious of any social system that combines religion and politics . Any such approach would attempt inevitably to violate the US constitution .
I've been to those places and they are all wonderful to experience in their ethnic individuality... the language, the shops, the people, and OMG! the FOOD!
The difference in those immigrants and the ones are showing up today is that the early immigrants who maintained their ethnic cultures did not insist that Americans throw their own culture aside to emulate what the immigrants held dear. They were happy to be in the US, happy to be US citizens, and they set their culture before us to enjoy or leave, as we chose.
And I have not seen any other newer immigrants acting any differently. Give them time. The older ones will speak their native language and tend to cling together, but that doesn't mean they are not going to assimilate or force their culture on us. The next generation will speak both their parents language and American, because they know they have to be fluent in American to succeed. By the third generation they'll mostly be using American as their first language and be just as much American as anyone else.
I just hope they don't lose their culture along the way and add it to the many others that make up America. Their is no one American culture. There is a combination of dozens and dozens of different cultures, even within what is known as the American one. Isn't the culture of Texas different then the culture of Michigan and isn't that culture different then the culture of California? The Old South is different then the Mid-West or the North-West or North-East. The American culture is a conglomeration of many cultures, many of them who have been here for hundreds of years and some for less then a few, with none of them being dominate or identifiable as the American one.