╌>

A messy political U-turn in Indiana

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  randy2  •  11 years ago  •  11 comments

A messy political U-turn in Indiana

1994_discussions.jpg

The finance minister under the Sun King, Louis the fourteenth, came up with the best practical guide for taxation. He wrote: "The art of taxation consists in so plucking the goose as to obtain the largest possible amount of feathers with the smallest possible amount of hissing".

There is a similar skill required for the political U-turn. You need to perform it so elegantly and subtly that the passengers don't even notice that the steering wheel has been tugged. But outside the Indiana State House on Tuesday, there are black skid marks on the road and the distinct smell of burning rubber.

Having introduced the benign sounding - bland even - Religious Freedom Restoration Act, Indiana's Governor Mike Pence has found himself under sustained and ferocious attack - because it seemed as though this bill was a licence for the businesses and organisations of Indiana to be able to say to people "you're gay, and with my new religious freedom protection, I am not going to serve you." And so some shops around Indiana found it necessary to put up signs saying "we serve everyone" to make clear that gays and lesbians would still be welcome in their shops.

Then some of America's biggest companies got involved. Tim Cook, the chief executive of Apple said legislation like that mirrored the segregation laws of a bygone era. "These bills under consideration truly will hurt jobs, growth and the economic vibrancy of part of the country where a 21st century economy was once welcomed with open arms," he said.

Other large employers in the state had expressed their opposition to the bill, but signed into law it was.

And pro-gay groups picked out some of those standing side by side with Mr Pence when the bill was signed into law and noticed that many of them were, so called, traditional family values campaigners.

Now let us fast forward a week. And as I write the governor has just finished giving a rather extraordinary news conference in which he has blamed "sloppy reporting", "wilful misrepresentation" and lies for the furore.

Really? Did Tim Cook and all the people in the Apple public affairs team and press office not understand what the legislation was about? Ditto the pharmaceutical giant Eli Lilly? And what about all those other organisations and public bodies who have been raising serious concerns? Perhaps more damning, if Mr Pence thought the law was being misrepresented why didn't he get out and say so from the get go. It would have taken him a nano-second to call a news conference. But the impression was allowed to persist, and doing great damage in the interim.

Mr Pence was asked at the news conference whether he had been surprised by all the fuss the legislation has provoked. He said he was amazed. Needless to say many remain unconvinced by that explanation.

All of which leaves broadly only two conclusions. Mike Pence is a knave or naive. And that is not a good place for a politician to be.

But at least the U-turn has been performed.

Source Link


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Messy is a big understatement. Pence and the Indiana legislature shot themselves in both feet...and then kept firing.

The religious right can spin this anyway they want, but Pence and the Indiana legislature caved to pressure from other Governors, big business and commonsense. This "fix", this "U-Turn" is at least something, but the truth is the law should be thrown out completely and no it does not mirror the Federal Law because the Federal Law doesn't extend to private people's transactions, only government ones. Some of the other states will change too and those who don't will find themselves increasingly isolated by other states and by companies who don't believe in discrimination. They will lose hundreds of millions of dollars in business and many new jobs. That's their choice to make.

As predicted on this site by myself and others, there will be a "clarification" (read amendment) on Pence's desk to sign, specifically saying this bill can not be used to discriminate against the LGBT community and sign it he will. He has no choice. I mark this as a partial victory (an overturn would have been better and will come sooner or later), but there is still more work to go to prevent people from trying to foist their own religion on this secular country.

All of which leaves broadly only two conclusions. Mike Pence is a knave or naive. And that is not a good place for a politician to be.

I vote, incredibly for a politician of his extensive background, naive.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

I'm sure that they didn't anticipate this type of reaction.

Nave, no, just catering to the religious right.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

And what a reaction! Even NASCAR has come out against this law and say the well consider holding no events in Indiana until law is either fixed repealed. NASCAR! They're just about the most conservative sporting organization in the country.

The word is that they (the right wing and moderate Republicans in the Indiana state legislature) are trying to find a way to say that this law can't be used to discriminate against Gays and Lesbians, without saying those words. Without saying that it can't be used for that. However, even if they patch the law and actually said that it can't be used to discriminate against Gays and Lesbians, what about everyone else that it can be used to discriminate against. Suppose a person has a "deeply held religious belief" not to serve Blacks? Or Hispanics? Or Natives. Or Muslims? Once you take out a person's (which also means company, restaurant, store, etc.) religious right to refuse service to someone or anyone, this law has no meaning at all and might as well not exist.

As for Mike Pence, he looks like he's trying to recover from someone exploding a stick of dynamite in his face. He looks like he is is a burning house and is desperately trying to find a way out of it...and that's exactly where he is.Smile.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

As we say in Philly, "Money talks and bullshit walks."

I have written any number of times, that well-organized boycotts can be a powerful "mind-changer."

Shamefully, the traditional Democrat vote sat on its dead ass in 2010, and again in 2014, the latter resulting in the lowest mid-term election turnout in 42 years and a Republican Congress. Between that and voter suppression laws and gerrymandering, the only viable alternative for dems at the moment, is the ECONOMIC BOYCOTT.

Pence signed this "Discriminate in the Name of God" law in a closed-door ceremony surrounded by religionist haters. If one didn't believe in God before the boycotts, it appears that, if one now so chooses, one can posit that what Indiana and panderers to right-wing homophobes are finding out, is that ON THE ONE HAND, IRONICALLY THEY'RE CORRECT -- THERE ACTUALLY IS A GOD, AND ON THE OTHER, THAT HE'S KICKING THE SHIT OUT OF THEM WITH wait for it

THE ALMIGHTY DOLLAR!

What a friend we have in Jesus!

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

The world is watching as this is front page news on the BBC's website. What I posted was from the BBC also. The state of Indiana is becoming international joke and a touch stone for international anti-discrimination groups and movements Something was started in Indiana that will spread to every other state with a law like this. Here is more from today's BBC:

Indiana governor says he wants to 'fix' religion law

The governor of Indiana has said that he wants state lawmakers to "fix" a religious freedom law that has created a national outcry.

Critics of the law say it could be used to discriminate against gays and lesbians.

Governor Mike Pence said he wanted state lawmakers to add language to the law that clarifies its intentions, by the end of the week.

"This is a clarification, but it's also a fix," he said.

He stressed that the controversy was the result of a "perception problem" not lawmakers' desire to discriminate.

Under the law, the state can only infringe on a person's religious beliefs when it has a compelling interest, but it must do so in the least intrusive way possible. It defines "person" to included religious institutions, businesses and associations.

governor, who signed the bill into law last week, went on the attack after a number of famous names, corporations and sporting institutions warned that business owners now had a licence to discriminate against gays and lesbians.

Mr Pence said he "was proud to sign" the bill, but that he believes "it would be appropriate to make it clear that this law does not give businesses a right to deny services to anyone".

"I don't support discrimination against gays or lesbians or anyone else. I abhor discrimination," he said.

line

At the scene - Aleem Maqbool, BBC News, Indianapolis

"I could have handled it better," said Governor Pence after what he admitted had been a "tough week".

But with the humility came the insistence, time and again, that the backlash he had faced was because the media had misrepresented him and the law.

He insists that he did the right thing in signing the Religious Freedoms Act.

Those we have been speaking to on the streets of Indianapolis appeared to feel very differently, invariably saying they did not see the need for the bill and that they were embarrassed by the negative attention it had brought to the state and the damage it had done to Indiana's reputation.

line

Gay rights groups are calling on Indiana lawmakers to update their civil rights laws to specifically include protections for gay and transgender people.

Mr Pence said he doesn't support the extra protections and insisted that they are a separate issue.

"Fair-minded people across his state are demanding that those protections get on his agenda, immediately," Chad Griffin, the president of the Human Rights Campaign, said.

Critics believe it provides a way for opponents of gay marriage, which became legal in Indiana last year, to continue their opposition by other means.

A chorus of criticism has been growing for nearly a week, and the backlash has made allies of Hillary Clinton and Miley Cyrus, and Angie's List and Apple.

1995_discussions.jpg

In recent days the governors of Connecticut, Washington state, and New York have banned state-funded travel to Indiana and other states that simultaneously have RFRA measures and no balancing law to protect gays and lesbians from discrimination.

"When it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it's a duck," Connecticut Governor Dan Malloy told MSNBC's Morning Joe programme explaining his decision. "They knew what they were doing and what they were doing was deciding that they were going to make it legal to refuse to serve gay men and women."

On Tuesday, the Indianapolis Star ran a full, front page editorial calling on state leaders to enact protections for gays and transgendered people.

Many businesses across the state have posted placards and stickers saying they serve everyone, and the official tourism site for Indianapolis - the state's capital - features a rainbow graphic and a "LGBT guide to Indy".

Over the weekend, Mr Pence repeatedly refused to answer direct questions about how the law might be used against gay people in a nationally televised interview.

Referring to that interview Mr Pence said on Tuesday, "I could have handled that better this weekend."

Despite the national outcry, Arkansas is set enact a similar measure as early as Tuesday. Unlike leaders in Indiana, Arkansas lawmakers said they will not modify their bill.

"Arkansas lawmakers said they will not modify their bill."

Yes they will. Eventuality they will as business pull out or refuse to do business in that state. No conventions. No business from other states. No major sporting events, even NASCAR. Many are refusing to do business in any state with such a law and no modification. They will have no choice or lose hundreds of millions. Businesses hate these laws, even businesses run by republicans I suspect, because it mikes the state into a pariah and joke.will win.Then they can sit there clutching their discriminatory religious belief, in a dead state. In a clash between huge chunks of money and discriminatory religious laws like this, the money always wins. Always.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

add language to the law that clarifies its intentions, by the end of the week.

All that is needed is the following (which the haters, bigots and homophobes would despise):

Nothing in this law shall be construed as "THE RIGHT OF ANY INDIVIDUAL, BUSINESS, ETC. TO DENY GOODS AND/OR SERVICES TO ANY/ALL PERSONS/GROUPS, NOR ENTRY/ACCESS TO ANY PUBLIC, FOR-PROFIT OR NON-PROFIT ENTERPRISE NOR ANY/ALL OTHER PUBLIC SPACE (INCLUDING VIRTUAL SPACE), THIS ON THE BASIS OF RACE, RELIGION, GENDER, SEXUAL ORIENTATION, NATIONAL ORIGIN, ETC. ."

Feel free to disagree BUT ONLY WITH SPECIFIC REGARD TO THE LANGUAGE OF THE ABOVE CAVEAT.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

"Hands Up, Don't Shoot!" never happened, as recently admitted by Eric Holder's justice department. Of course, for months prior the left had been irresponsibly poisoning the public with a narrative based on little more than their own prejudices ( the bad white cop had to have murdered the innocent black angel). The myth became so pervasive that President's go to guy on civil rights led a mob chanting for cops to be murdered. When two cops were murdered for "revenge" significant parts of the left cheered.

When it became obvious that the hysteria was based on a myth so at odds with all actual evidence that it had to be admitted, the truth about what happened was still buried and hardly reported. I'd bet a significant portion of Democrats still believe the "hands up, don't shoot" lie. The only way anyone knows what actually happened is if you read the actual report or found alternative news sources that highlighted the actual evidence. Certainly the MSM downplayed it and the left wing sites ignored it.

The professional agitators on the left certainly learned a lesson about how easy it is to mobilize and manipulate a left wingers intent on destroying their perceived enemies. It's the lynch mob mentality brought to the 21st century. Facts are completely irrelevant when you want to put the left wing on the warpath. Simply scare them with unfounded claims of " legalized discrimination" and the hate will reliably coming spewing forth. Left wingers desperately want it to be the 50s again so they can make themselves heroes fighting injustice. So claims of "legalized discrimination" no matter how ridiculous set their hearts aflutter and they pat themselves on the back for being brave and standing up to the man.

The truth of the matter is RFRA's do not allow companies to turn away gays because they don't like them. The Indiana law applies the same test to determine a valid religious claim as the federal RFRA and states like Illinois. Those RFRA's didn't legalize discrimination and this one won't either. There's a reason why the agitators can't point to a single example of an RFRA that allowed a restaurant to deny service to a gay or anything similar. This Indiana law adopts the standards of the other RFRAs which in turn merely copied the Sherbert test, which was the Court's take on the first amendment for decades.

After the hysteria cools down, responsible leftist legal scholars will quietly admit that the whole fracas was based on nothing more than fear mongering. But for now, it allows companies like Apple that do business in countries where homosexuals are killed to make a public show of how progressive they are. Kill homosexuals or give them 250 lashes and Apple will gladly do business with you. But simply allow someone their day in court and Apple will lead the boycott charge.

Hatred is great business for the left. Liberals politicians get to pose and raise money off the hatred. The base gets all fired up and the media gives them uncritical attention. All the while, of course, the legal status of discrimination against homosexuals in Fort Wayne will not have changed a single iota since the RFRA was passed.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Right on! If the religious bigots want to drive themselves out of business let them. That said this issue has caught fire and major corporations all over America are pledging not to do business with or in states with these laws and all of the other states are lining up and drooling over those billions of business dollars. This law, in any state that has it, has become like the Biblical equivalency of Lepers. Not even sports stars don't want to be on teams in these states with these laws. The NCAA is considering moving right back out of Indiana, just liked they moved into it in 1999. There certainly will be no more tournaments in Indiana or any of these other states. NASCAR, one of the single most conservative sporting concerns in the country, says it wants nothing to do with Indiana and is looking at other events in other states with these laws. No one wants to be anywhere near them. The laws will go away or the states that keep them will show tat an entire state can file for bankruptcy. Religions walks and money talks.

Whatever the supposed intent of these laws were intended to be (discrimination ass covering laws) they have made the states with them the biggest pariahs in the country and it's not going to stop anytime soon. Those states like Indiana and Arkansas and te others get to choose. These religious discrimination laws or going broke.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    11 years ago

What's really going to be fun is watching these pandering right-wing asshats trying to figure out how to weaselaway fromthe firewithout pissing off the Bible-humping knotheads that elected them... Every photo of Pence in the past week looks like he's just finished shitting another brick and wiping his ass with barbed wire.

Can't wait to hear Hutchinson & Pence explaining... 'well, God is great and, um, religious beliefs are sacred, but after all, business is business, and when the rubber meets the road, righteousness is, uh, well--- negotiable'

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Speaking of the rubber meeting the road, I love the line in the article where it says "But outside the Indiana State House on Tuesday, there are black skid marks on the road and the distinct smell of burning rubber." Talk about a U-Turn! The same smell is wafting out of Arkansas where Hutchison's own son signed the petition to have their law vetoed.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

The only real way to "fix" the Indiana law is to repeal it completely. Once you forbid discrimination against anyone, the law is meaningless. It was written to discriminate any nothing else. It was written because some people want to claim a religious right not to serve people whose race, religion or lifestyle they don't personally like. This is an open door for bigotry.

A person is a racist and has a restaurant. He decides he doesn't have any want anymore blacks in his restaurant, so he refuses to have anyone wait on them take their order or serve them food. When one sues, as it's written now, he can use this law as a shield, hide behind it, as a valid defense in state court by claiming he has a religious belief that forbids him from associating black people. The judge looks at the law, has no way to disagree with this state law that supposedly is protect his religious rights and the racist wins. Well at lest temporarily until the black person or organization suing takes it to Federal Court where it doesn't even meet the laugh test and the Federal Judge will order him to serve all people in is restaurant. That he can not discriminate because of color. Well he also can not discriminate because some customers happen to be Gay or Lesbian either. Religious beliefs or not and the law is, in effect banned by the Federal court as a shield to discriminate.

 
 

Who is online



154 visitors