╌>

Connecticut's Governor Doesn't Understand How his Own RFRA Works

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  11 years ago  •  2 comments

Connecticut's Governor Doesn't Understand How his Own RFRA Works

In case you needed more proof that the recent backlash against religious freedom laws is grounded in pure ignorance, look no further than Connecticut Gov. Dan Malloy. Malloy, a Democrat, just announced on Twitter that he plans to sign an executive order banning state travel to Indiana due to the midwestern states recently enacted Religious Freedom Restoration Act.

Because of Indiana's new law, later today I will sign an Executive Order regarding state-funded travel. -DM

Governor Dan Malloy (@GovMalloyOffice) March 30, 2015

When new laws turn back the clock on progress, we cant sit idly by. We are sending a message that discrimination wont be tolerated. -DM

Governor Dan Malloy (@GovMalloyOffice) March 30, 2015

BREAKING: @GovMalloyOffice announces he'll sign executive order banning travel to Indiana after Gov. Pence signed "religious freedom" law.

Max Reiss (@MaxReiss) March 30, 2015

I dont know how many staffers, lawyers, and advisers currently work for Malloy, but its a real shame that not a single one of them told the governor that Connecticut has had an expansive RFRA on the books for over two decades. Thats right: Connecticut passed its own RFRA law on June 29, 1993 . You can read the law for yourself here . The inanity of Malloys move doesnt stop there, though. What makes his grandstanding particularly absurd is the fact that Connecticuts RFRA provides far greater religious liberty protections than Indianas or even the federal governments.

If you dislike Indianas RFRA , then you should loathe Connecticuts. The difference comes down to a single phrase: substantially burden.

Both the Indiana law and the federal law declare that the respective governments may not substantially burden a persons exercise of religion[.] In other words, the laws require the courts to analyze cases brought under these laws using the strict scrutiny standard. Under the Indiana and federal religious liberty laws, government can burden religious exercise, but it cannot substantially burden it. Thats a key distinction.

Connecticuts law, however, is far more restrictive of government action and far more protective of religious freedoms. How? Because the Connecticut RFRA law states that government shall not burden a persons exercise of religion[.] Note that the word substantially is not included in Connecticuts law.

The effect of the absence of that single word is enormous. It states that Connecticut government may not burden the free exercise of religion in any way. That makes it far more protective of religious liberty than the Indiana law that has so outraged Connecticuts governor.

If Connecticut Gov. Dan Malloy wants to blatantly discriminate against states with religious liberty laws on the books, thats his prerogative. But if he doesnt want to look like a completely ignorant hypocrite who has no idea what hes talking about, he should probably examine his own states laws first.

UPDATE : A number of commentators have suggested that none of this matters because Connecticut has laws banning discrimination based on sexual preference, while Indiana doesnt. Unfortunately, these commentators do not have the mental wherewithal to grasp that that argument doesnt undermine my point. It actually strengthens it.

For the sake of argument, lets assume that the Indiana doesnt ban discrimination claim is true and that this distinction is what makes Indianas RFRA terrible and Connecticuts RFRA perfectly acceptable. If thats the case, then its literally impossible for Indianas new RFRA law to legalize discrimination based on sexual preference. Why? Because its allegedly already legal in Indiana. Furthermore, if anti-gay discrimination is what is truly animating those voicing opposition to RFRA, why on earth are they focusing on Indianas RFRA and not on enacting the anti-discrimination bans that are in force in states like Connecticut?

If I didnt know better, Id be left to assume that the voices agitating to repeal a 20-year-old legal framework that was not even remotely controversial until last week were more interested in outlawing religious liberty than they were in preventing discrimination.

http://thefederalist.com/2015/03/30/connecticuts-governor-doesnt-understand-his-own-states-rfra/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

I know there has been way too many posts on this subject, but the Connecticut governor's ignorance about his own state's laws is just funny to pass up.

So much hatred directed at a non-controversial law that has been effectively in place for generations because some liberal activists want to scare their base and raise money.

 
 

Who is online



154 visitors