╌>

Remember when Democrats Used to Support Religious Freedom?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  11 years ago  •  65 comments

Remember when Democrats Used to Support Religious Freedom?

Remarks on Signing the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993
November 16, 1993

Thank you very much, Mr. Vice President, for those fine remarks and to the Members of Congress, the chaplains of the House and the Senate, and to all of you who worked so hard to help this day become a reality. Let me especially thank the Coalition for the Free Exercise of Religion for the central role they played in drafting this legislation and working so hard for its passage.

It is interesting to note, as the Vice President said, what a broad coalition of Americans came together to make this bill a reality; interesting to note that that coalition produced a 97-to3 vote in the United States Senate and a bill that had such broad support it was adopted on a voice vote in the House. Im told that, as many of the people in the coalition worked together across ideological and religious lines, some new friendships were formed and some new trust was established, which shows, I suppose, that the power of God is such that even in the legislative process miracles can happen. [Laughter]

We all have a shared desire here to protect perhaps the most precious of all American liberties, religious freedom. Usually the signing of legislation by a President is a ministerial act, often a quiet ending to a turbulent legislative process. Today this event assumes a more majestic quality because of our ability together to affirm the historic role that people of faith have played in the history of this country and the constitutional protections those who profess and express their faith have always demanded and cherished.

The power to reverse legislation by legislation, a decision of the United States Supreme Court, is a power that is rightly hesitantly and infrequently exercised by the United States Congress. But this is an issue in which that extraordinary measure was clearly called for. As the Vice President said, this act reverses the Supreme Courts decision Employment Division against Smith and reestablishes a standard that better protects all Americans of all faiths in the exercise of their religion in a way that I am convinced is far more consistent with the intent of the Founders of this Nation than the Supreme Court decision.

More than 50 cases have been decided against individuals making religious claims against Government action since that decision was handed down. This act will help to reverse that trend by honoring the principle that our laws and institutions should not impede or hinder but rather should protect and preserve fundamental religious liberties.

The free exercise of religion has been called the first freedom, that which originally sparked the development of the full range of the Bill of Rights. Our Founders cared a lot about religion. And one of the reasons they worked so hard to get the first amendment into the Bill of Rights at the head of the class is that they well understood what could happen to this country, how both religion and Government could be perverted if there were not some space created and some protection provided. They knew that religion helps to give our people the character without which a democracy cannot survive. They knew that there needed to be a space of freedom between Government and people of faith that otherwise Government might usurp.

They have seen now, all of us, that religion and religious institutions have brought forth faith and discipline, community and responsibility over two centuries for ourselves and enabled us to live together in ways that I believe would not have been possible. We are, after all, the oldest democracy now in history and probably the most truly multiethnic society on the face of the Earth. And I am convinced that neither one of those things would be true today had it not been for the importance of the first amendment and the fact that we have kept faith with it for 200 years.

What this law basically says is that the Government should be held to a very high level of proof before it interferes with someones free exercise of religion. This judgment is shared by the people of the United States as well as by the Congress. We believe strongly that we can never, we can never be too vigilant in this work.

Let me make one other comment if I might before I close and sit down and sign this bill. There is a great debate now abroad in the land which finds itself injected into several political races about the extent to which people of faith can seek to do Gods will as political actors. I would like to come down on the side of encouraging everybody to act on what they believe is the right thing to do. There are many people in this country who strenuously disagree with me on what they believe are the strongest grounds of their faiths. I encourage them to speak out. I encourage all Americans to reach deep inside to try to determine what it is that drives their lives most deeply.

As many of you know, I have been quite moved by Stephen Carters book, The Culture of Disbelief. He makes a compelling case that today Americans of all political persuasions and all regions have created a climate in this country in which some people believe that they are embarrassed to say that they advocate a course of action simply because they believe it is the right thing to do, because they believe it is dictated by their faith, by what they discern to be, with their best efforts, the will of God.

I submit to you today, my fellow Americans, that we can stand that kind of debate in this country. We are living in a country where the most central institution of our society, the family, has been under assault for 30 years. We are living in a country in which 160,000 schoolchildren dont go to school every day because theyre afraid someone will shoot them or beat them up or knife them. We are living in a country now where gunshots are the single leading cause of death among teenage boys. We are living in a country where people can find themselves shot in the crossfire of teenagers who are often better armed than the police who are trying to protect other people from illegal conduct. It is high time we had an open and honest reaffirmation of the role of American citizens of faith, not so that we can agree but so that we can argue and discourse and seek the truth and seek to heal this troubled land.

So today I ask you to also think of that. We are a people of faith. We have been so secure in that faith that we have enshrined in our Constitution protection for people who profess no faith. And good for us for doing so. That is what the first amendment is all about. But let us never believe that the freedom of religion imposes on any of us some responsibility to run from our convictions. Let us instead respect one anothers faiths, fight to the death to preserve the right of every American to practice whatever convictions he or she has, but bring our values back to the table of American discourse to heal our troubled land.

Thank you very much.

http://thefederalist.com/2015/03/26/remember-when-democrats-used-to-support-religious-freedom/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

The Indiana law mirrors the federal RFRA. It simply extends the protections offered by the federal RFRA to actions by the Indiana state government and privateindividuals. 31 states have similar protections in place.

Everything else is just whining and scare mongering by those who have no idea what they are talking about.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Ed Morrissey puts the Indiana RFRA in context.

"Over the last twenty-plus years, RFRA statutes have a clear track record of careful jurisprudence, because they dont protect ad-hoc discrimination on any basis. Thats true on both federal and state levels, and we know this in part because the hysterics shrieking over the law in Indiana offer nothing but ignorant hypotheticals. They cannot point to a case where RFRA has been used to justify broad discrimination, because it never has.

Cases decided under RFRA get strict scrutiny on threetests. First, the religious belief has to be sincerely held, and not just a pose to make a point. Second, the state interest in overriding the religious belief has to be compelling. Last, the action taken by the state has to be the least intrusive that still satisfies the compelling state interest. Courts have been using these tests for more than two decades to separate real cases of state infringement on religious practice from simple discrimination. "

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Remember when Democrats voted to repeal the 1st Amendment?


They hate the idea that people may think differently than they do. Dissent is simply not legal in their view. You can have all the free speech you want, as long as it doesn't upset "liberals" or challenge their orthodoxy.

So yeah, people who believe in the principles of the First Amender

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Barack Obama's spokesman was asked today what is different between the Indiana law and the one Barack Obama voted for while a state senator in Illinois. Unsurprisingly, he couldn't articulate a rational response, because the laws are functionally identical.

If progressives were consistent, they'd be denouncing Obama as a supporter of "hate crimes" in the most vitriolic language possible. Luckily for Obama, progressives have no intellectual consistency. They just spew hate in whatever direction their leaders dictate and never bother to think.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

They won't do it because its harmless. They just like to have it to fire up the less intelligent members of their base and fund raise.

The Democrats thrive on fear and ignorance, this is one more avenue for them to exploit.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

First, the religious belief has to be sincerely held, and not just a pose to make a point.

Who determines "sincerity"?

On what criteria?

Alito found that even a SCIENTIFICALLY, MEDICALLY INCORRECT BELIEF WAS TRUMPED BY RELIGION BECAUSE THE BELIEF WAS SINCERELY HELD!

Fuckin' psychotic insanity!

The majority decision, written by Justice Samuel Alito, held that if Hobby Lobby's owners believe that the contraceptives at issue cause abortions, the mandate is a burden on their religious beliefs: "[W]e must decide whether the challengedregulations substantially burden the exercise of religion, and we hold that they do," Alito wrote. "The owners of the businesses have religious objections to abortion, and according to their religious beliefs the four contraceptive methods at issue are abortifacients."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

They hate the idea that people may think differently than they do.

You mean the way RIGHT-WING RELIGIONISTS do when they pass laws that make it legal to discriminate against

PEOPLE WHO THINK DIFFERENTLY THAN THEY DO?

Wake TF UP!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
Bill Clinton and Barack Obama are right wing religionists?
 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

The federal law is as flawed as the state. Both of them assume that the rights of a religious person trump the rights of a non-majority person who might be considered abnormal due to some perversion of logic.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
30 some states, including Illinois thanks to the support of Barack Obama, offer the same protection to its citizens. If this is such a threat, please provide an example where the rights of religious person have trumped the rights of a non majority person in any of those jurisdictions.

In fact, the statute has been overwhelmingly been invoked by the non-majority( Indians, Muslims, amish etc. etc.)You seem to be arguing for the Scalia position, which was rejected 97-3 by the Senate with the passage of the RFRA
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
Amac, as a lawyer, I think you would know that since it's inception the Supreme Court has refused to assess the validity of religious beliefs. Do you honestly Believe federal judges should determine what are " proper" religious beliefs? Talk about ignoring the separation between church and state, you appear to be arguing that the federal judiciary should be the de facto popes of all religions.
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

2005_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

I suppose it will depend on the law. If the law is the least restrictive means of accomplishinga compelling governmental interest the religious person will have to follow it. Thus a person with a sincerely heldreligiousbelief that paying taxes violatestheir religion will be forced to pay taxes.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

The parallels between the hive mind of progrssives resembles stalinst era Bolsheviks without the violence, yet. Woe to the person who doesn't switch his position on a subject at exactly the right time. A couple weeks early or late on an issue and you were denounced as a counter- revolutionary and shot. Didn't matter if you were parroting Stalin, if Stalin had moved from that position.

Look at the ruckus over gay marriage. In 2008 Barack Obama would tell anyone who listened that his faith informed his opinion that marriage was between a man and woman. Less than 3 years ago, that was his position on the subject.

But the second he "evolved" progressives were viciously attacking anyone who held their dear leaders' opinion from a couple weeks earlier. Look at how quick they turned on chick-filet for holding the same position as President Obama did. Progressives tried to destroy chick filet for holding the same stated position on gay marriage that their leader claimed to have! The hate and fury they direct at others for holding the same positions they espoused days before is staggering.

The RFRA is just another example. Barack Obama can vote for identical RFRA's and be applauded. Mike Pence signs the same law and he is a hate monger signing hate laws.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Exactly. When you don't have anything else to offer, I guess they have to do whatever gets them by.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Democrats still support religious freedom and to say otherwise is a vicious lie and the per saying it knows they are lying or they are ignorant of the truth. All we want is to make sure that Christians don't try to turn this into a Christian nation, because it is not. It is a secular nation and there is a separation of church and state as there should be. We re just defending that separation. I don't try to pass laws to make everyone and atheist, and you don't have the right to pass laws that force everyone to follow Christian beliefs either. The Constitution says you can not, any more then I can.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

I'm not a lawyer, Sean I've explained my background on a number of occasions but in answer to

Do you honestly Believe federal judges should determine what are " proper" religious beliefs? Talk about ignoring the separation between church and state, you appear to be arguing that the federal judiciary should be the de facto popes of all religions.

I'm arguing no such thing. I'm asking who is to determine "sincerity" if that is the standard for "legally" allowing discrimination on the basis of religion.

Alito wrote in the Hobby Lobby case

" the mandate is a burden on their religious beliefs: "[W]e must decide whether the challengedregulations substantially burden the exercise of religion, and we hold that they do," Alito wrote. "The owners of the businesses have religious objections to abortion, and according to their religious beliefs the four contraceptive methods at issue are abortifacients."

"Burden the exercise of religion"? EVEN IF THE PREMISE BEHIND A GIVEN BELIEF IS VERIFIABLY FLAWED?

What next, Sean.

How about, a man enters a restaurant in Indiana and is refused service because the restaurant owner says, "We don't serve gays!"

The man says, "I'm not gay."

The owner says, "Well, you look gay and my sincerely held religious beliefs and Indiana law mandate my right to refuse you service."

"YOU LOOK GAY?" "YOU LOOK JEWISH AND BEING JEWISH, YOU DON'T ACCEPT CHRIST AND MY SINCERELY HELD RELIGIOUS BELIEFS AND INDIANA LAW, etc., etc.

This is the start of the Fourth Reich, Sean. Assume for a moment that neither the "gay" man nor the "Jewish" man were either gay or Jewish. Under Indiana Law, in order to be served in that restaurant, do they have to verify their "straightness" or their "Christianity"?

What's next ARM BANDS?

2006_discussions.jpg 2007_discussions.jpg

Who decides who is in violation of someone's "sincerely held religious beliefs" if the "violator" claims not to be a violator the restaurant owner, A COURT OF LAW?

Talk about a slippery slope this is how the madness gets started.

No bullshitting around, Sean, I responded directly to your question and I expect you to respond directly and specifically to mine.

While I find your politics bad news, I respect your intelligence. So, lets have a debate -- no pissin' contest.

Answer the questions.

_____________________________________________

FYI: I am not an attorney; I was an ombudsmen, elected to office and appointed under the authority of that office to write contractual language, enforce ratified agreements and represent individuals either having legitimate grievances, or, being the subjects of an adverse actions.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Democrats still support religious freedom and to say otherwiseis a vicious lie

right, they are now calling RFRA's hate crime bills even though the first RFRA and model for the Indiana law was sponsored by Chuck Schumer and signed into law by Bill Clinton. Democrats have flipped 180 degrees on RFRAs and now spew hatred at anyone who holds what was the mainstream democratic opinion from just a few years ago.

. All we want is to make sure that Christians don't try to turn this into a Christian nation


Well opposing speed limit increases will accomplish just as much towards that goal as opposing RFRAs. Actually, you should concentrate on opposing speed liimit increas, because that will have no effect. Getting rid of RFRA's would make it much easier to turn this country into a christian nation.

RFRA's primarily protect minorities. The overwhelming majority of claims for protection under RFRA's are made by non-Christians. Without RFRAs, it would be much easier for a majority Christian government to pass laws that inhibit non-Christians. To go back to the original RFRA claim, the government would be free to jail any Indian who violated drug laws as part of a religious ceremony.

u don't have the right to pass laws that force everyone to follow Christian beliefs eith

No one is trying to do that. As should be obvious from the text of the law, RFRA's make it harder to do that.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Beat me to it.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Progressivism and thinking is a major oxymoron.

Write your own material I've posted that with regard to you guys as far back as NV.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Explain that to me, Sean. Make the case with specifics for me.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The RFRA was held unconstitutional as applied to the states in the City of Boerne v. Flores decision in 1997, which ruled that the RFRA is not a proper exercise of Congress's enforcement power.

However, it continues to be applied to the federal governmentfor instance, in Gonzales v. O Centro Espirita Beneficente Uniao do Vegetal because Congress has broad authority to carve out exemptions from federal laws and regulations that it itself has authorized. In response to City of Boerne v. Flores , some individual states passed State Religious Freedom Restoration Acts that apply to state governments and local municipalities.

Further

This law reinstated the Sherbert Test , which was set forth by Sherbert v. Verner , and Wisconsin v. Yoder , mandating that strict scrutiny be used when determining whether the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment to the United States Constitution , guaranteeing religious freedom, has been violated. In the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, Congress states in its findings that a religiously neutral law can burden a religion just as much as one that was intended to interfere with religion; [2] therefore the Act states that the Government shall not substantially burden a persons exercise of religion even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability. [3]

The law provided an exception if two conditions are both met.

First, the burden must be necessary for the "furtherance of a compelling government interest ." [3] Under strict scrutiny, a government interest is compelling when it is more than routine and does more than simply improve government efficiency. A compelling interest relates directly with core constitutional issues. [4] The second condition is that the rule must be the least restrictive way in which to further the government interest.

Now, someone please explain to me how "strict scrutiny" and "sincerely held religious belief" jibe in this pile-of-bullshit circus which, on the one hand, involves pandering to religious la-la-land residents, while on the other, tap dancing around it to satisfy "compelling government interests."

When government makes policies that defer to religious belief, conflict is inevitable since one is based on "perceived realities" while the other IS SUPPOSED TO BE utilitarian (I'll leave it to the individual reader to decide which is which).

Beyond this, what if the religious freedom of two separate individuals clash in the public space where one, a "Christian," believes in the tenet

" thatye love one another; even as I havelovedyou, thatyealsolove one another."

while simultaneously using the law to void that tenet (fuckin' ironic ain't it?), and the other individual, a non-Christian, takes the position

'"That which is hatefuluntoyoudonotdoto your neighbor. This is the whole of the Torah." (Judaism)

Talk-the-talk but don't walk the walk! Religion preaches love, then separates one from the other, creates unnecessary and often violent conflict and doesn't even actually believe its own bullshit.

The Constitution does not use the term "freedom of religion," and, by acceding to religious "sincerely held dogmas," government establishes a de facto religious understory which violates the very Constitution it uses to "justify" in order to violate it

and only gets away with it because of damned fools who do dumb shit like vote their religion, race, gender, etc. !

Ain't it a bitch when critical thought comes into play?

No bullshit, one-liners please, just address the specifics.

IMO, RFRA no matter which party uses it to fuck over people, was a time bomb from day one.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Neither are "OK" as I have explained instead of making a pronouncement, address the specifics I have posted.

You just love that "Hussein" shit don't ya'? Do you think no one but the demagogue-club gets that?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Barack Obama's spokesman was asked today what is different between the Indiana law and the one Barack Obama voted for while a state senator in Illinois. Unsurprisingly, he couldn't articulate a rational response, because the laws are functionally identical.

Funny how Obama did it first is ignored by those who's favorite line is Bush did it first isn't it?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Even funnier how my questions about the implementation of such laws go unanswered.

Aside from which, unlike what Bush did and when he did it, Obama was but a single vote at the time it wasn't his law nor his administration. Even had it had been, the laws are a mine field as I have explained and, indicated where RFRA was ruled "unconstitutional."

When you guys are finished with the finger pointing, address the substantive issues I posted and challenged anyone herein to answer. Regardless of how any of these laws came to be is irrelevant with regard to the problems of their implementation.

Yeah, Obama voted for such crap got it. IMO he was unwise to do so. Now let's deal with the law itself shall we.

FYI: The Illinois Law DOES NOT DISCRIMINATE AGAINST GAYS.

And some 20 or so legislators who voted for RFRA, no longer support it.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

I predict the law will fall /be repealed, or, will be modified well beyond its original potential to discriminate against individuals interacting in the public space.

I have written a number of articles and commented numerous times regarding the use of organized economic boycotts to effect change particularly as that change applies to voter suppression and "legalized" discrimination.

I believe we are about to see just that, imminently and going forward.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I don't see any doubt whatsoever that it will be overturned or radically modified. Right now, as you said, it can be used to fuck people over on both sides. It can not stand as is.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

m not a lawyer, Sean I've explained m

My apologies, I was under the impression you were.

m asking who is to determine "sincerity" if that is the standard for "legally" allowing discrimination on the basis of religion

Validityand sincerity are two different things. The court's have beendeterminingthesincerity of someone's beliefs for decades in all sorts of cases, such asconscientiousobjectors. Applying them in religious cases is not new. The standard is borrowed from the Supreme Court.

ow about, a man enters a restaurant in Indiana and is refused service because the restaurant owner says, "We don't serve gays


he same thing would happen in Indiana, Illinois and pretty much every state. The man would file a complaint, therestaurantownerwould claim hisreligionandthecourt would find against himbecausethe state has compelling interest inpreventingdiscrimination inrestaurants.

There's a reason no one hassuccessfullyused an RFRA to justify discrimination.

Under Indiana Law, in order to be served in that restaurant, do they have to verify their "straightness" or their "Christianity"?

No more than they would under federal law or New York law. You have been misled if you believe RFRA's will suddenly allow restaurants in Indiana to act differently than restaurants in other states.

Who decides who is in violation of someone's "sincerely held religious beliefs" if the "violator" claims not to be a violator the restaurant owner, A COURT OF LAW?


Of course it will be a court of law, just like it has been for generations under the RFRA and First Amendment cases pre-Smith. And restaurant owner will lose, just like they always have under RFRA cases.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Validityand sincerity are two different things. The court's have beendeterminingthesincerity of someone's beliefs for decades in all sorts of cases, such asconscientiousobjectors.

I respectfully disagree, Sean. The evaluation of one's "sincerity" is at least in part, based on the validity demonstrated with regard to the one(s) who claim such before the court.

Agreed that determining "sincerity" is subjective to a degree, but the behaviors and life style of the claimants SHOULD BE TAKEN INTO CONSIDERATION.

While justice is allegedly "blind," on the matter of "sincerely held beliefs," I sincerely hold the belief that judges are ultimately beholden to political parties remember how Republicans have spoken disparagingly about "activist judges."

You have been misled if you believe RFRA's will suddenly allow restaurants in Indiana to act differently than restaurants in other states.

And I say that you have been misled into failing to believe that some businesses will not use such a law to discriminate. How many states have laws permitting the firing or hiring discrimination of gays, or, no laws that prevent it?

We disagree but I am glad we have done so respectfully of one another.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
I have remained silent on the current events involving legalized discrimination based on religion, which admittedly is uncharacteristic of me. Frankly, I'm too busy laughing at the hopeless stupidity that brought us to this manmade controversy ... ie belief in an omnipotent anthropomorphic creator who has always existed and has no choice but to continue to exist for eternity, yet has zero ability to provide a shred of evidence that it actually does exist.

Beam me up Scotty ... there's certainly no intelligent life down here.
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

And is in constant need of more and more and more money from his followers...Grin.gif

And what in hell does he need the money for?

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

If the person is refused service in the name of this law, then that makes their rights trumped. They may sue for compensation, but their rights have been denied. I don't care how or what 30 some states, or the US congress, or the President thinks about it, either.

Name a good reason why someone should be denied service, and then show me how the compelling reason is tied solely to their minority status.

BTW, in the interest of full disclosure and if you haven't already known, I think that people should put their religion where the sun don't shine. Namely, in a box on the shelf with their books of fairy tales and baby teeth.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Yea, that was pretty funny. He probably wasn't aware he had evolved or maybe he isn't aware his mind is not his own any longer and the hive controls it now.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

I remember when they boycotted Chic fil a I was out and about. I know I went by a half dozen restaurants and their parking lots along with the adjoining parking lots were full. They had the biggest day in the history of the company.

And it was all for the owner believed in marriage between a man and a woman, the same belief Bill and Hillary Clinton along with Obama held. No one got upset about them. But the big difference was Bill, Hillary and Obama were liberals.

Liberals, the religion of tolerance can do the same thing as others and there is no problem. They aren't fooling anyone. They want to get rid of Christians, only some of the Democrat Christians aren't aware of it yet, but one day they will come to realize this is true.

It's not normal Democrats, it's the radicals as it always is who have lost their ability to reason, can only see one side of anything and it is always the side that puts them in the position of being a victim.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Examples of where there was a need for RFRA and where it has been applied.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Law professor: Why Indiana needs 'religious freedom' legislation

I am a supporter of gay rights, including same-sex marriage. But as an informed legal scholar, I also support the proposed Indiana Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA). How can this be?

It's because despite all the rhetoric the bill has little to do with same-sex marriage and everything to do with religious freedom.

The bill would establish a general legal standard, the "compelling interest" test, for evaluating laws and governmental practices that impose substantial burdens on the exercise of religion. This same test already governs federal law under the federal RFRA, which was signed into law by President Bill Clinton. And some 30 states have adopted the same standard, either under state-law RFRAs or as a matter of state constitutional law.

Applying this test, a unanimous U.S. Supreme Court recently ruled that a Muslim prisoner was free to practice his faith by wearing a half-inch beard that posed no risk to prison security. Likewise, in a 2012 decision, a court ruled that the Pennsylvania RFRA protected the outreach ministry of a group of Philadelphia churches, ruling that the city could not bar them from feeding homeless individuals in the city parks.

If the Indiana RFRA is adopted, this same general approach will govern religious freedom claims of all sorts, thus protecting religious believers of all faiths by granting them precisely the same consideration.

But granting religious believers legal consideration does not mean that their religious objections will always be upheld. And this brings us to the issue of same-sex marriage.

Under the Indiana RFRA, those who provide creative services for weddings, such as photographers, florists or bakers, could claim that religious freedom protects them from local nondiscrimination laws. Like other religious objectors, they would have their day in court, as they should, permitting them to argue that the government is improperly requiring them to violate their religion by participating (in their view) in a celebration that their religion does not allow.

But courts generally have ruled that the government has a compelling interest in preventing discrimination and that this interest precludes the recognition of religious exceptions. Even in the narrow setting of wedding-service providers, claims for religious exemptions recently have been rejected in various states, including states that have adopted the RFRA test. A court could rule otherwise, protecting religious freedom in this distinctive context. But to date, none has.

In any event, most religious freedom claims have nothing to do with same-sex marriage or discrimination. The proposed Indiana RFRA would provide valuable guidance to Indiana courts, directing them to balance religious freedom against competing interests under the same legal standard that applies throughout most of the land. It is anything but a "license to discriminate," and it should not be mischaracterized or dismissed on that basis.

Daniel O. Conkle, professor, Indiana University Maurer School of Law

~Link~

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

God doesn't need money Mickey.

Give unto Caesar what is Cesar's; give unto God what is God's....

That is why I don't give to churches or any organized religions. When a church asks for money, what are they claiming to be? and don't ever forget, when they pass that basket, they ARE asking.

Before I quit going to churches, we, the congregation, was asked to donate for a roof to be put on a new house the community was building for a family of ten that had been burned out. I went to the pastor and asked how would the money donated get to the project. The pastor told me that the money would be deposited in the churches general fund and when enough was collected it would be disbursed to the group doing the building. So I asked what happens to the overage. He didn't have an answer. then I pressed him, What happens to the OVERAGE? Well, he replied, I believe that we use it to reimburse the church for the work in collecting it and managing it until we get sufficient funds to get what needs to be done finished.

So in other words, they drop the funds into the bank, take the interest for a while or use it to their own ends before giving it to the project.

Greedy bastards.

So I asked who the General was on the project, I was told.

the next day I went down to his offices and asked how much the roof was going to cost and he gladly showed me the estimates. I asked him if he had received anything from the church yet? he said no. (they had been collecting for over a month) So I asked his which of the estimates he was most impressed with and he told me. They had been waiting on the roof for a month and a half, and they were at a standstill until it was dried in. (you cannot do interior work on a house until the roof is complete)

So they had been sitting there doing essentially nothing to finish the house for almost a month and a half waiting for the church!!!

So I called the roofer, and asked when they would be able to get the roof done, I was told that all the materials were ready to go and in fact they were donating the materials, but the labor had to be covered. I asked him how much that would be and he told me. (about 3,000 dollars) I asked how long it would take and he told me, (one day) I asked could he do it tomorrow? he said sure he had four days until the next scheduled job and this would be the perfect time to get it done.

I told him to come meet me at the house the next day with his crew and materials, I would take care of the funds.

He met me, I showed him the thee thousand in cash, and he went to work. by late afternoon they were finishing up the site cleanup and gave him the cash.

Guess what? the church never gave the money they had collected to the project.

I never went back there, ever, but I did let some of my friends who did go there know what was happening, and most of them stopped going also, within three weeks they lost two thirds of their parishioners, the church never recovered.

Give unto God what is Gods, cause you damned sure can't fool him....

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

It doesn't matter anymore. The spark has been lit and there is a fire burning under Indiana. It doesn't matter if this law is the same or similar to laws in other states or the federal law or even if some people think it's about religious freedom (it's not). Indiana is anathema. No one wants to be associated with it any longer. Businesses are falling all over themselves to stop expansions and to not create jobs. Some are just plain leaving and conventions are being canceled. Even the NCAA says it's considering never hosting another tournament in Indiana because of this law. Celebrities and politicians (on both sides) are jumping at the chance to distance themselves from Indiana and Pence. Pence is practically begging the state legislature to write a "clarification" for him to sign to save his ass.

No matter how many law professors you get to explain how in their opinion the law means this or that. o mater how many times you read it. Right now and for the foreseeable future Indiana is going to be about as popular as Poison Ivy and no one is going to want to be associated with it. The same thing will happen to Asa Hutchison too. Read the law and explain it as often as you like. The public has spoken and the don't like it and they will fight it and they will win because the loss of hundreds of millions of business dollars is more important then that law. Indiana doesn't just have a legal problem with this law, they have a very shitty PR problem that is going to be just about impossible to overcome. They will be the butt of late night comics and an American joke. Pence said he was surprised at the blow back. Well the blowback has just begun. This is how public opinion works and right now it hates Indiana.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

I've quoted this one before, it is apropo here also...

You can safely assume you've created God in your own image when it turns out that God hates all the same people you do. --Anne Lamont

So all those people have set themselves up as god... Good for them. Make up a list so I know who not to deal with anymore.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I love that saying and the story below. We disagree on some things, but not on how some people set themselves as gods and how organized religion is fucked up.Grin.gif

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

That is a sad story NWM. Unfortunately it is not the only one I have heard either but there are still a lot of churches out there that do good works and are a great asset to the community. Whenever money is involved so should be due diligence. I always try to vet before I donate.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

God gave us a brain and expects us to use it, it's a damned shame that many don't.

God wants you to confront injustice, he said walk in my footsteps, follow me.

What did he do when he was here, confront injustice especially when it came to church leaders.

Stop sinning and follow me did not mean giving everything away and wearing sackcloth and sandals and trudging through the desert for the rest of your life like a brainless fool.

Although the powerful would like you to think such.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
Wait, you know what God wants? Jeez - how come we humans haven't appointed you to leader of the world yet? What are we waiting for?! Everybody seems to think that they know what God wants, when clearly only you do.The farce of religion is what will bring about humanity's demise.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

What did he do when he was here, confront injustice especially when it came to church leaders.

Do you know this painting by the Baroque Period artist, Caravaggio?

2008_discussions.jpg

Jesus Expelling the Money Lenders from the Temple

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Yes Hal we get it, someone who refuses to understand cannot be expected to accept or agree.

You lucky devil you...Grin.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

By the way

THERE IS A MAJOR DIFFERENCE BETWEEN RFRA AND THE INDIANA LAW

RFRA DOES NOT APPLY TO FOR-PROFIT BUSINESSES!

Need I explain the significance?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

YES! and rumor has it he was VERY angry when he did it, tossing them out physically also.

There is always a season, and a reason. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
Just saying that you are doing the same thing that so many religionists do - declaring that you know the unknowable. In my mind it is unknowable because there's nothing to be known in that realm ... not now and not ever.
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

It's not a refusal or inability to understand. It is understanding the truth that there is no god and never has been. Of course you certainly are free to spend your time, energy and even money pleasing a fairy tale. That's your right. Many people do the same thing. But just because Hal and I accept the truth that there is no god, does not mean we don't understand or are not able to. It is not a failure to understand. It's just a different understanding then yours.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

The farce of religion is what will bring about humanity's demise.

{chuckle} From Baal to Ogg, religion has been around this world for well over 5,000 years, it hasn't resulted in the destruction of humanity yet, and with that long to do it, I doubt it ever will.

So where does the farce lie?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

I understand brother, truth is in the eye of the beholder on certain issues, religion being the basic one.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I understand brother, truth is in the eye of the beholder on certain issues, religion being the basic one.

True words, brother. I agree with you again.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
One religious zealot with a nuke is all that it will take to start the chain reaction. That's not unrealistic, in a world where humans are capable of casually flying plane loads of people into buildings and mountainsides, for reasons religious or otherwise.
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
That's simply not true. The Supreme Court has never ruled on that.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The original RFRA (Clinton/Schumer) did not apply to for-profits.

We disagree, Sean.


1) Unlike the federal law, the Indiana bill explicitly protects the exercise of religion of entities, which includes for profit corporations.

The law

A highlighted section of the Indiana Religious Freedom

...

And

But Indiana's Law Is More Expansive Than The Federal And Nearly All State RFRA Laws

The American Civil Liberties Union Of Indiana : Indiana 's Law Is "Virtually Without Precedent." According to the ACLUof Indiana, the state's RFRAis written much more broadly than thefederalversion, because it allows "basically anyone" to use religious freedom as a defense in court:

Unfortunately, the Indiana law is written more broadly than the federal Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993. For instance, a critical difference is that SB 101 would allow for-profit businesses, employees and individuals--basically anyone--to assert a legal claim or defense of free exercise of religion in a legal proceeding, regardless of whether the government is a party to the proceeding. This is virtually without precedent. [ACLU of Indiana, 3/27/15 ]

The Atlantic : "The Indiana Statute Has Two Features The Federal RFRA -- And Most State RFRAs -- Do Not . " As Garrett Epps of The Atlantic explained, the Indiana RFRA is not only much more than thefederal RFRA, but also more expansive than nearly any other state RFRA:

[T]he Indiana statute has two features the federal RFRA -- and most state RFRAs -- do not.First, the Indiana law explicitly allows any for-profit business to assert a right to "the free exercise of religion." The federal RFRA doesn't contain such language, and neither does any of the state RFRAs except South Carolina's; in fact, Louisiana and Pennsylvania, explicitly exclude for-profit businesses from the protection of their RFRAs.

[...]

What these words mean is,first, thatthe Indiana statute explicitly recognizes that a for-profit corporation has "free exercise" rights matching those of individuals or churches. A lot of legal thinkers thought that idea was outlandish until last year's decision in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores , in which the Court's five conservatives interpreted the federal RFRA to give some corporate employers a religious veto over their employees' statutory right to contraceptive coverage.

Second, the Indiana statute explicitly makes a business's "free exercise" right a defense against a private lawsuit by another person, rather than simply against actions brought by government. Why does this matter? Well, there's a lot of evidence that the new wave of "religious freedom" legislation was impelled, at least in part, by a panic over a New Mexico state-court decision, Elane Photography v. Willock . In that case, a same-sex couple sued a professional photography studio that refused to photograph the couple's wedding. New Mexico law bars discrimination in "public accommodations" on the basis of sexual orientation. The studio said that New Mexico's RFRA nonetheless barred the suit; but the state's Supreme Court held that the RFRA did not apply "because the government is not a party."[ The Atlantic , 3/30/15 ]

Wash . Post 's Plum Line Blog : Indiana Law Expands RFRA Coverage To Individual Disputes. Asthe Plum Line's Paul Waldman explained, the Indiana RFRA isnot the same as other iterations of the law,becauseit "directly covers disputes between individuals" and for-profit businesses, while the 1993 federal law "only concern[ed] instances where the federal government is forcing a person to do something or not do something":

1. Is this the same law as the federal RFRA and versions in other states?

The answer is no, for a couple of reasons. First, there's the intent. When the federal RFRA was passed in 1993, no one was talking about gay marriage, and it wasn't about how private individuals deal with each other. The law was spurred most directly by a case calledEmployment Division v. Smith, which concerned whether two Native American workers could get unemployment insurance after they had been fired from their jobs for taking peyote in a religious ritual. It was that kind of private religious conduct that the debate revolved around at the time.

But more importantly, the Indiana law is different from other laws in its specific provisions. It not only explicitly applies the law to for-profit businesses, it also states that individual can assert their religious beliefs "as a claim or defense in a judicial or administrative proceeding, regardless of whether the state or any other governmental entity is a party to the proceeding." [emphasis added] The federal law, and most of the state laws, only concern instances where the government is forcing a person to do something or not do something; the Indiana law directly covers disputes between individuals.[ The Washington Post , Plum Line, 3/30/15 ]

ThinkProgress: Indiana's RFRA Applies To Disputes Between Private Citizens, Unlike All Other State RFRA Laws. ThinkProgress explained that Indiana's law goes further than nearly any other state RFRA because it applies "explicitly" to disputes between private citizens:

rfra.png

[ThinkProgress, 3/30/15 ]

...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

You bring some good points to the table A Mac.

Here are a couple more.

Indiana RFRA Law: Fact vs. Fiction

Pennsylvania

Current Law:71P.S. 2401-2407 (2002) Enacted: December 9, 2002

2401.Short title

Personally I believe if you want to deal with the public then you have to treat all customers equally.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Now that is the nail in the coffin so to speak,

It goes way too far.

In effect it allows individuals to tell others how they should act. In effect it legalizes discrimination.

AND corporations are NOT people, in fact they are only people for the express purpose of expressing political affinity in the form of unlimited campaign donations.

They should be excluded in this also.

This law as written, is tyrannical in nature.

no question about it.

 
 

Who is online



154 visitors