The Troubling Implications of Believing our Rights don't Come From God
CNN anchor Chris Cuomo recently declared: "Our rights do not come from God." Then this week, Sen. Ted Cruz's assertion that "our rights don't come from man, they come from God Almighty" came under scrutiny when Meredith Shiner, a Yahoo reporter, tweeted: "Bizarre to talk about how rights are God-made and not man-made in your speech announcing a POTUS bid? When Constitution was man-made?"I am astounded by how many people in this country (and particularly in the media) don't believe the Declaration of Independence's assertion that all men are "endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights." The Declaration of Independence also refers to "The Laws of Nature and of Nature's God." Believing that our laws are God-given, and not man-made, has become something that secular liberals seem to take joy in openly mocking. As if there were something inherently funny or backwards about faith. As if there were something hollow and foolish about believing in God.Obviously, I believe very strongly that the opposite is true.This might sound like a pedantic point to make, but nearly all of our political discord comes down to fundamental differences in our worldviews. Two very good people can start out with two very different philosophies of life and inevitably come to two very different conclusions on a nearly innumerable amount of problems. Sometimes the consequences are profound. And that's the case here. Rejection of this foundational principle of God-given law would inexorably lead someone to come to vastly different conclusions about any number of things compared to someone like me who embraces this premise. When liberals and conservatives differ over whether or not the state has the right to usurp this or that right, dig deep enough, and you will often find the root of the disagreementI believe very strongly that our rights come from God. And I believe nearly as strongly that the implications of believing that our right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness are granted by the state are potentially catastrophic. Ideas have consequences, and while some might see quibbling over such esoteric and grandiose ideas to be a waste of time, the truth is that where one comes down on such fundamental questions will likely predetermine where one comes down on a wide range of modern-day "hot-button" issues. When you consider how much of the current political debate hinges on fights about individual liberty and the size and scope of government, this makes sense.Set aside religion and consider this: If our fundamental rights are merely granted by the state, then they can be taken away by the state. What is more, the state would have no moral compunction not to rob us of our rights. The state is not particularly moral or special or better than people. The state is people. If they don't have some larger, higher moral code that guides them, then assumptions about what constitutes the "good" are, at least to some degree, arbitrary. Absent an immutable standard, why wouldn't the law of the jungle rule? In nature, predators prey on the weak. Can we honestly convince ourselves that people are better than that? Some are, sure. But many are not.Without an absolute law that transcends the whims of man, the very concept of "rights" metastasizes into a definition having more to do with the current and often capricious preference of the majority. Oppressed minorities have long found comfort (and, in fact, seized the moral high ground) by pointing out that there is a greater law, a universal sense of right and wrong, that transcends the will of the majority.The majority can be wrong. The majority can be in the wrong. History is littered with examples of the folly of man-made law, of man-made injustice. (This is not to say people haven't done terrible things in the name of God they have!)Consider Martin Luther King Jr.'s "Letter from a Birmingham Jail": "We have waited for more than 340 years for our constitutional and God given rights," he wrote. "To put it in the terms of St. Thomas Aquinas: An unjust law is a human law that is not rooted in eternal law and natural law."More and more, the secular left seems to want to entrust human law to always be just. That's fine when it is. But what happens when it isn't? http://theweek.com/articles/546457/troubling-implications-believing-rights-dont-come-from-god
Tags
Who is online
154 visitors

Again John, the right to property existed before government or paperwork to make things "legal," because the concept of legality or illegality didn't exist. But people, in a state of nature, will accumulate property and a system develops to recognize personal property, without government.
It's through the social contract that some of those rights are voluntarily transferred to a government in order to make life easier and further protect the right. If a government fails to respect the natural right of property, it loses its legitimacy and any duty to obey it, for its broken the contract that provides for the government's existence.
History teaches us the potential dangers of badly built governments . There is a reason why a republic can be better than a pure democracy ... for example .
There are issues with whichever side you take:
1. God
Which god gave us these rights and how do we determine what those rights are?
Is it Allah, YHWH, The Great Spirit, etc, etc?
Even if we can make a final determination as to which God, who is his spokesman?
2. Man
Do they come from government or from a "social compact"?
Either way, is it by majority vote or brute force?
There seems to be a general consensus that humans have rights. After that, it is pretty much up in the air.
Sean said:
Rights are arbitrary and at the whim of the most powerful. It used to be that rights were assumed to be the kings: They were blessed by divinity, and the largest armies, and from thence drew their authority.
When Jefferson wrote the Declaration of Independence he was writing it not only as a statement of our rights and for reading not only by the colonists, but also as a statement that could be read by the kings and people alike asseparatingthe divine right of kingsfrom the kings and transferring it to the people. Basically, in 1776 if you didn't point this transfer of authority, the several powers in Europe who might be convinced to give us aid might also be convinced not to.
If you need a higher power to show you what is right and wrong, you are in terrible shape, morally.
I wont hold my breath, either, waiting for the "natural god"to come and straighten out the terrible acts that are being committed by fuckking asshole bastards across the face of the planet in the name of some mythical omniscient being.
If you deny all religious concepts to establish your morality you are in worse shape . Having no basis in the past is a sure direction for smacking hard face first into reality ...
I'm in your camp Steve.
When I hear some yahoo spout garbage like, "our rights don't come from man, they come from God Almighty", it grates on my ears as much hearing other peckerwood's going on about how "There is no morality without religion".
Our laws are built on history and a consensus of the population.
No deity said, "Only white male property owners have the right to vote", old white rich duds did that, and it took about 150 years for the rest of the country to get them to sit-down and scoot over, because we all have a stake in what happens in America.
Strip all the political and religious bullshit away, the only right anyone has is the right to survive....... even that has to be earned.
Religion and politics are all man made fabrications, and are easily dispensed with when it comes to survival.
ome yahoo spout garbage like, "our rights don't come from man, they come from God '
I'll let you fight the Thomas Jefferson is a yahoo fight on your own.
ur laws are built on history and a consensus of the population.
I'm talking about rights, not laws. They are two different things.
It appears that one mentions God people lose their collective shit. The argument made by Locke, Madison, Jefferson and similar "yahoos" is that our rights are sacred and are inherent in our humanity. Saying they come from "God" is merely shorthand for claiming they are immutable and not subject to the whims of man.
If you believe our fundamental rights (life, liberty etc) are favors granted to you by the state, then you also accept that those rights can be just as easily be taken away by the state at the state's whim.
Your rights are what you are willing to fight for.
I guess this is there the saying "to liberals government is God" came from.
Of course, this is verifiable based on empirical information and the FACT that bad things never happen to good people.
And here I've been saying all along that much of religion is comprised of psychotic phenomena giving the illusion that the insecure nature of Reality can be mitigated by living dogmatically.
What do I know? I mean do we ever see "religious" people get caught up in hatred, discrimination, wars based on religiosity
Oooops.
I love when the proponents of "Voter ID/Suppression," the removal of environmental protections of GOD'S EARTH, the repudiation and rights-erosion of certain human beings, that despite John 13:34
cry about THE STATE -- THE RADICAL RIGHT WING REPRESENTATIVES THEREOF WHOM THEY PUT AND KEEP IN OFFICE AND SUPPORT but pretend to worry about the state -- those same legislators "TAKING AWAY THE RIGHTS THAT COME FROM GOD!"
There are no bigger frauds and hypocrites.
THESE ARE MUCH MORE TROUBLING IMPLICATIONS.
There is no god. Rights and laws are all man made, for better or worse and usually for worse. Let's stop blaming our fuck ups on a fairy tale.
Robert,
Exceptionally well put.Cmon, Petey. Can't you muster up more than that?
Which religion? What sect? There are plenty of religions to choose from, and most say they are religions of peace, and almost all of them say to follow a prescribed course of actions which are consistent with the cultural values at the time of their inception. Quite remarkably, most of these cultural values mirror each other across religions: Don't kill. Don't steal. Don't mess around with an ass that isn't yours... general rules to live by if one doesn't want some dude knocking on your door with a baseball bat.
When we realize the commonalities between religions mandates, one of the obvious questions that should arise to any rational, thinking person is: Why do religions have to try to kill, proselytize or cleanse through killing every other religion they come into contact with? Why, if they are all telling us to do the same general things, does that make one necessarily better than the other, up to the point of killing everyone who believes differently than Jesallaphat?
Morality can arise from other places , such as genetic factors. You can have a shortened allele dealing with serotonin in your brain and feel one way about a moral dilemma, or a long allele and feel another way.
Morality can arise from cultural, learned values. From societally accepted norms: At the time of the writing of the founding documents it was commonplace and thought of as moral to own people. Do we want to accept that as our morality of today? I think not.
which discriminates most against 3rd world nations ...
I have never confused Creator with Government, they are after all two separate entities. Of course the word Creator as used by the writers meant one thing to them and most people of the 13 colonies, it meant something different to the yet unconquered Spanish territories and the other 500 nations living on the continent.
Also please note that Jefferson was, by today's standards at least, certainly not a christian. He, and many of the others, were deists, which is not the same as a christian.
As to my analysis, I believe it stands as America is situated today. Why? I have yet to find within any religious text (if I have missed it, please direct it to my attention) any enumeration of human rights. There have many philosophical texts enumerating human rights, but we seem to be attempting to add more to the list (i. e. the "right" to water aka Detroit).
Let's take a look at the 'right' to water for a moment. Do we have that right because Moses struck a rock and water came forth, or do we have that right because humans can't live without it? Either way, humans need water to survive. I am not convinced it is a 'right'.
So, there still must be consensus of some type among humans whichever way you choose.
Hi Sean,
A well written piece. While I disagree with the premise of your article, you make some points that I agree with... for example this...
Regarding this...
I offer this from the Declaration of Independence... First there is the statement about rights being endowed by their creator
Of course, just because the authors of that declaration say these rights come from "their Creator" does not mean that is in fact where the rights come from... the declaration was, after all, written by men...
Then following that, a statement that addresses your concern that the state can take away rights...
So it points out that it is the responsibility of the "governed" to police the "Governments." Furthermore, whether or not those rights were granted by men or a Creator the state can still take those rights away... History has proven that true time and time again.
Regarding this...
I am an atheist... Since I have no belief in a Creator, fear of punishmentby said Creator does not factor into my thinking at all... yet,I feel I have a pretty darn good moral compass... We simply choose our behaviors... good or bad they are all just choices.
You tell me . You came up with a blanket rejection of all of them . Are there none you can find value in ? How about some of the more philosophically based ones ?
Whether one believes in God or not, we have come to believe as a culture that certain rights are inherent and the origin of that belief is rooted in religion. The Declaration of Independence begins by stating "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness." In writing these words, Thomas Jefferson meant to directly link the permanence of these rights to the permanence of the Creator himself. Therefore, the rights are inseparable from us and cannot be taken away. It essentially gives every man the God-given right to resist a tyrant (through rebellion). Obviously, you can resist a tyrant without religion but the idea, in my opinion, was to motivate believers to grab a gun and topple a tyrant themselves rather than wait for God to do it.
And there was some great discussion concerning what needed to go into that document, the Declaration of Independence. There was also great discussion concerning whether a Bill of Rights even needed to be a part of the Constitution.
I do not dispute that people of that time attributed those rights to the be a part of God's nature, at least as christians saw it. We have a more pluralistic society now, not all of whom have the same view of nature. I am not convinced that there can be no consensus among the views as to what rights humans have, I do believe a consensus as to where those rights came from would be more troublesome.
I see this as a direct reflection/extension of our political system today.