╌>

Time to End the Federal Subsidy for High-Tax States

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  4 comments

Time to End the Federal Subsidy for High-Tax States

The state and local tax deduction effectively encourages higher taxes by state and local governments. By requiring higher federal marginal tax rates to replace lost revenue, the state and local tax deduction further severs the link between taxes paid and services received, effectively forcing all federal taxpayers to pay, in part, for services provided to residents of other states. Federal tax rates could decline significantly by as much as 12.5 percentif policymakers eliminated the state and local tax deduction and replaced it with a revenue-neutral and distribution-neutral reduction in marginal tax rates.

Under federal tax law, individuals may deduct the income and property taxes that they pay to their state and local governments. In recent years, individuals have been allowed to choose between deducting their income tax or sales taxes. [1] Because federal tax deductions effectively spread the costs of these deductions across all taxpayers in the form of higher federal tax rates, the state and local tax deduction forces federal taxpayers in low-tax states to subsidize taxpayers in high-tax states. Distributional impacts within states force low-income residents to subsidize high-income residents.

If the state and local tax deduction were eliminated, federal income tax rates could be reduced by as much as 12.5 percent. Ending the federal subsidy of state and local taxes would help to improve the fiscal discipline and economic efficiency of state and local governments by forcing state and local taxpayers to bear the full burden of their governments costs.

The State and Local Tax Deduction

The state and local tax deduction has been around since the inception of the federal income tax in 1913. The rationale for it is that since state and local taxes reduce individuals after-tax income, the income used to pay those taxes should be excluded from federal taxation. That argument has merit.

In practice, however, the deduction allows states to raise taxes higher than they otherwise would and has significant perverse distributional impacts, redistributing income from the poor to the rich and from people in low-tax states to people in high-tax states. Despite some efforts to eliminate it, the deduction for state and local taxes remains one of the largest deductions in the federal tax code. According to The Heritage Foundations Individual Income Tax Model (HFIITM), the state and local tax deduction will reduce federal tax revenues by an estimated $90 billion in 2015. This makes the state and local deduction one of the largest tax preference items.

Economics of the Deduction

Any tax deduction reduces the tax base and therefore requires higher marginal tax rates to maintain the same level of tax revenue. Ideally, deductions should be kept to a minimum after the appropriate tax base has been established. Yet the U.S. tax code is littered with numerous deductions and exemptions as political and special interests have interfered with economically efficient taxation. The federal deduction for state and local taxes turns high-tax states into one of those special interests.

Who Benefits?

The federal deduction for state and local taxes creates both winners and losers.

States with High Taxes. States with higher income and property taxes receive the greatest benefit from the state and local tax deduction. According to the Tax Policy Center, New York and California received more than 30 percent of the value of the state and local tax deduction in 2011, yet their residents make up only 12 percent of the U.S. population. [2] Not surprisingly, New York and California place first and fourth, respectively, in total state and local tax burden. [3] Just 10 states receive 62 percent of the value of the state and local tax deduction. On average, taxpayers in these 10 states receive a $4,200 deduction while taxpayers in the remaining 40 states and the District of Columbia receive a $2,300 deduction. [4]

The state and local tax deduction effectively reduces states marginal tax rates, allowing them to collect higher taxes while shifting some of the burden from their own taxpayers to taxpayers in other states. For example, the state of California has a top marginal tax rate of 9 percent, but the state and local tax deduction reduces this to an effective 5.4 percent. This is because the federal government reimburses state taxpayers up to 40 cents of each dollar they pay in state taxes. Thus, while Californias government keeps every dollar of state tax revenue, only part of that revenue comes from California residents. The rest comes from the federal government in the form of reduced federal tax receipts.

Higher-Income Taxpayers and Itemizers. The deduction for state and local taxes creates winners and losers within states, too. Higher-income taxpayers win while lower-income taxpayers lose.

The state and local tax deduction is available only to taxpayers who itemize their deductions: single taxpayers with more than $6,300 in total deductions and married taxpayers with more than $12,600 in deductions for 2015. This means that more than 70 percent of all taxpayers receive no benefit from the state and local tax deduction. Those who receive no benefit tend to have lower incomes: Only 16 percent of taxpayers making less than $30,000 itemize their deductions while more than 95 percent of taxpayers with incomes of $200,000 or more itemize. [5] http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2015/03/time-to-end-the-federal-subsidy-for-high-tax-states


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc

Who is online



154 visitors