What Patrick Moynihan knew about the Importance of Two Parent Families
In the mid-1960s, a social scientist noted something ominous that came to be called Moynihans Scissors: Two lines on a graph crossed, replicating the blades of a scissors. The descending line charted the decline in the minority male unemployment rate. The ascending line charted the simultaneous rise of new welfare cases.
The broken correlation of improvements in unemployment and decreased welfare dependency shattered confidence in social salvation through economic growth and reduced barriers to individual striving. Perhaps the decisive factors in combating poverty and enabling upward mobility were not economic but cultural the habits, mores and dispositions that equip individuals to take advantage of opportunities.
This was dismaying because governments know how to alter incentives and remove barriers but not how to manipulate culture. The assumption that the condition of the poor must improve as macroeconomic conditions improve was to be refuted by a deepened understanding of the crucial role of the family as the primary transmitter of the social capital essential for self-reliance and betterment. Family structure is the primary predictor of social outcomes, as Daniel Patrick Moynihan knew in 1965.
Fifty years ago this month, Moynihan, then a 37-year-old social scientist working in the Labor Department, wrote a report, The Negro Family: The Case for National Action, that was leaked in July. The crisis he discerned was that 23.6 percent of African American births were to unmarried women. Among the tangle of pathologies he associated with the absence of fathers was a continually renewed cohort of inadequately socialized adolescent males. This meant dangerous neighborhoods and schools where disciplining displaced teaching. He would later write: A community that allows a large number of young men to grow up in broken families, dominated by women, never acquiring any stable relationship to male authority ... that community asks for and gets chaos.
Academic sensitivity enforcers and race-mongers denounced him as a racist who was blaming the victim. Today, 72percent of African American children are born to single women, 48 percent of first births of all races and ethnicities are to unmarried women, and more than 3million mothers under 30 are not living with the fathers of their children.
In 1966, Sargent Shriver, head of President Lyndon B. Johnsons War on Poverty, was asked how long it would take to win the war. He replied, About 10 years. The conventional wisdom was John F. Kennedys cheerful expectation that a rising economic tide would lift all boats. America now knows that bad family structure defeats good economic numbers.
Today, a nation dismayed by inequality and the intergenerational transmission of poverty must face the truth that political scientist Lawrence Mead enunciated nearly 25 years ago: The inequalities that stem from the workplace are now trivial in comparison to those stemming from family structure. What matters for success is less whether your father was rich or poor than whether you knew your father at all.
Moynihan, undaunted by his shrill critics who stifled debate and research, brought his barbed wit to the subject, suggesting that an important determinant of the quality of American schools was their proximity to the Canadian border. That is, high cognitive outputs, measured by standardized tests, correlate less with high per-pupil expenditure than with a high percentage of two-parent families, which are not scattered randomly.
The election of Kennedy was celebrated in academia as the empowerment of the professoriate. Moynihan ruefully remembered the euphoric expectation of the direct transmission of social science into governmental policy. We still are far from fully fathoming all that has caused the social regression about which Moynihan was prescient. There has been what he called iatrogenic government, an iatrogenic ailment being one caused by a physician or medicine: Some welfare policies provided perverse incentives for absent fathers. But the longer Moynihan lived, the more he believed that culture controls more than incentives do.
The role of social science, he would write, lies not in the formulation of social policy, but in the measurement of its results. Not in postulating what will work but in demonstrating what does work. And, increasingly, what does not work.
Chastened by the obstinacy of things, Moynihan recalled a Harvard chemist defining the problem that exists, in the physical sciences and perhaps in social science, when, in Moynihans phrasing, the number of variables interacting with one another in any given situation makes that situation extraordinarily complicated and difficult to fathom. Moynihan asked the chemist at what number of variables this problem begins. The chemist replied: Three.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/what-patrick-moynihan-knew-about-the-importance-of-two-parents/2015/03/13/2cdf9bae-c9a4-11e4-aa1a-86135599fb0f_story.html

"Fifty years ago this month, Democrats made a historic mistake.
Daniel Patrick Moynihan, at the time a federal official, wrote a famous report in March 1965 on family breakdown among African-Americans. He argued presciently and powerfully that the rise of single-parent households would make poverty more intractable.
The fundamental problem, Moynihan wrote, is family breakdown. In a follow-up, he explained: From the wild Irish slums of the 19th-century Eastern seaboard, to the riot-torn suburbs of Los Angeles, there is one unmistakable lesson in American history: a community that allows large numbers of young men to grow up in broken families ... never acquiring any stable relationship to male authority, never acquiring any set of rational expectations about the future that community asks for and gets chaos.
Liberals brutally denounced Moynihan as a racist. He himself had grown up in a single-mother household and worked as a shoeshine boy at the corner of Broadway and 43rd Street in Manhattan, yet he was accused of being aloof and patronizing, and of blaming the victim"
It's much easier to blame everything on "racism!" That way, they never have to look in the mirror and take accountability.
I'm not trying to throw cold water on your wonderful article, Sean, but I don't honestly think we can pin the blame for all of society's ills on any one political party. The times have changed. Poor Sergeant Shriver was a brilliant man, who died of Alzheimer's, could only think of how he could help-- he wasn't responsible for the breakdown of the family. He believed that economic progress would benefit everyone. I can't blame him for that, but, as usual, there are no easy answers to anything...
I agree that the breakdown of the family has been one of the worst detriments to society as a whole. But, I don't honestly know what to do about it-- and blaming people isn't going to make it better.
My husband and I have both been married 3 times, and we've been married to each other for 17 years, soon to be 18 years. Our son has always had 2 parents, thank God, and seems to be a fairly steady individual. Of his friends, several others have both parents handy-- and many of his friends have step-parents, or are from households headed by single mothers. Several of the friends with both parents have what I would consider to be severely dysfunctional families. And I should know what dysfunctional means-- I'm the child of a narcissist and an alcoholic. I don't know any of my son's friends whose parents don't work at all. I know of several people who are on disability, but they still work at what they can do, albeit not much.
My son's friends are of several "races" for lack of a better word, and some are from different nationalities, if that word helps. But, he also has friends who are African American, as we all do. They are just as welcome in my home as anyone else, by the way. I grew up in a family that was dysfunctional, and I don't honestly know if it is better to be reared by one crazy parent or two. Daddy, although an alcoholic, was the sane one... Back then, there was no question that had my parents divorced, I would have been with my narcissistic mother. (Shudder!) Now, times have changed. When I married my husband, he had full custody of his daughter, and we reared her together.
We have a show on TV called Kentucky Deadbeats, where they advertise the people's faces who are severely behind in their child support payments-- behind to the tune of thousands of dollars. The majority of them are men, but there is an occasional woman on there, as well. The show has done a really good job of finding people who have moved on, but not found by the courts, and making them pay child support, plus their debt. Looking at the pictures posted, mostly arrest records, I can only feel sorry for their children, and want to thump the women who married such obvious creeps-- except that they are likely poor and don't have much hope to begin with. I mean, if you're raised in a dysfunctional manner, it's really hard to know what normal is. May I state categorically that my husband is a good man, and normal, and I never cease to be grateful for him.
Yet, I also know what it is to live with someone who suddenly decides that doing drugs is the way to go, or slides into alcoholism, or any number of awful things that are difficult to put up with, and NOT good for children. Sometimes, you have to leave-- to save your own life, and those of your children.
I think it all boils down to personal responsibility. People just aren't responsible for themselves, any more, much less for their children. I don't know how to fix that.
Thanks for listening, and I know that it is likely not what you wanted-- which is the "big picture". I'm not a social worker, or someone in the front lines of dealing with all of this. I can only offer my own experience, and it is anecdotal evidence.
Take care!
Interesting seed, Sean.
(Be careful when you cut/paste big chunks. You included some stuff that isn't part of the Will article.)
George Will is a clever man... but not always straightforward. His title , "What Patrick Moynihan knew about the Importance of Two Parent Families", is not really a reflection of the Moynihan extracts he cites. Moynihan underscored the problems of economically deprived single-mother families. I don't think anyone would imagine that children in general, and boys more particularly, would prosper in such a context...
And then... Once we have agreed that deprived single-mother homes are not desirable... What shall we do? This is the nitty-gritty.
We can blame the single mother. "She should never have gotten pregnant." What then?
Blame the father? Who probably came from the same sort of home...
Of course... We could just wash our hands of the whole mess...
It's a messy subject. But interesting...
don't honestly think we can pin the blame for all of society's ills on any one political party.
I don't think that's what Will or the liberal Kristoff is suggesting. I agree with the liberal to the bone Moynihan that culture, not politics, is the culprit. "The most difficult fact for white Americans to understand, is that the circumstances of the Negro American community in recent years has probably been gettingworse, not better, Moynihan wrote despite all advancements in civil rights. The stable black families of the 1950s disintegrated much more rapidly than whites families did withdisastrousresults.
Where I do believe Democrats do deserve the blame is for the abuse they heaped on Moynihan for spotlighting the problem. Rather than addressing the issue when it was nascent, they stigmatized discussion and thought they could remedy it by passing policies that just furtherincented absenteefatherhood. Over the decades, as the effects became even more pronounced, they continued to do everything in their power to shut down discussion on the topic. Witness the ridicule directed atDan Quayle simply for saying that Hollywood shouldn't glamorizesingle parenthood.
As onesociologistwhose name I can't recall put it, all of the policy suggestionschampionedinWashingtonare theequivalentof rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanicunless progress is gained in the culture at large is made. Nobody really wants to talk about the subject but the differences in outcomes are staggering. As Lawrence Meade said,The inequalities that stem from the workplace are now trivial in comparison to those stemming from family structure. What matters for success is less whether your father was rich or poor than whether you knew your father at all. It's easierpoliticallyforDemocratstoblame "racism" than to address issues that might make their political baseuncomfortable.
d I know that it is likely not what you wanted-
I thought your post was interesting and on topic. I'm not a real big believer in tight controls on discussion. The most interesting takes are often those that use the article as a starting point.
A couple of things to take into consideration. The article is from 1965. Since that time there have been changes in what is considered the norm.
In the time period of 1965 there were ''shotgun'' weddings, no longer. Also in that time periodthere werevery few people, ''living in sin''...Today we find that the number of people cohabitating is very high, but if they have a child, they are considered ''single, unwed''.
IMO opinion that will change the numbers in not only the blacks, but all races.
Maybe I've been looking at it too long, what part shouldn't be in there?
Sean, are you addressing me?
I agree with you that they shouldn't have tried to quiet him-- it wasn't the right thing to do, and the man has proven to be correct, in many ways. In fact, I've heard much of the same thing from some of my black friends. They hate Martin Luther King, Jr., and think he was the worst thing to happen to them in a long time. Sigh...
I'm not trying to sweep "race" or "racism" under the rug, nor to ignore it's effects, because I do think it has a detrimental effect on people, in more ways than economically. Nor am I trying to declare that it's the only problem. I can only report what I see as being true.
Here in KY, we have many counties where the number of people from other races is very low-- many of them have less than 1% of any other race. Some counties a lot less than 1%. So, we have large swaths of the state where the areas are basically rural and white, and there are no other races or nationalities. Bosnians don't go there, for example, either, or Croatians, or anyone else. Not many immigrants go there at all-- there isn't much work for them to do-- little farming because the land is not suitable.
Yet, there seems to be a sort of "subculture" in these areas where young women think it's "cool" to have a baby out of wedlock and rear it on their own. They even sort of form "baby clubs" to see who gets to be the most popular in having a baby. This is not restricted to teenaged girls, but also includes young women in their 20s. It is also not limited to women who are uneducated, because there are college women in these groups, nor is it limited to the poor, because there are middle to upper income level women in the "clubs".
Young men in the area feel it is a notch in their belt to impregnate as many women as possible, and strut around, proud of their manhood-- at least until the county government comes along and they have to pay child support.
This happens despite the fact that the churches, which are very vigorous, condemn the young women AND the babies. The only people they don't seem to condemn are the men who get them that way. But, I guess the county does that, in it's own way, by making them pay for their children...
I don't know how to fix this. The churches are having little to no effect. Parents are stuck with rearing their own children and grandchildren. In these areas, abortion is not readily available, and any form of birthcontrol, other than a condom, is not readily available, either. What do you do with people who have babies because they are lonely and have nothing else to do? Some of these places don't even have a public library, much less anything to do that is "fun".
Maybe we should post this in all public restrooms in the state, next to condom machines.
Thanks for your kindness!
Well done!
It's gone...
I don't think the two can be separated. They are a chicken-or-egg choice. If there is no work/money, the family structure is impacted. And if the family structure is weak, the probability is high that employment conditions will be bad. It's an infernal downward spiral, with the two aspects reinforcing each other... in the wrong direction.
If we wish to improve the situation (a very big "if"), then this subject is critical. Programs must be found that encourage family stability, and also employment. If we only act on one side, the other will ensure failure.
Actually Sean, the ''out of wedlock'' births for single black women has been on the decline for a number of years. In fact, the ''out of wedlock'' births for whites women has been increasing.
The are a number article on it, with stats.
Here is a link to one of them...In addition, the CDC has more stats on this, it's a pdf file that I can't download.
...
Good point, Bob.
irths for single black women has been on the decline for a number of years
No. it hasn't. The illegitimacy rate among black children when Moynihan wrote the article in 1965 was 26%. At the time the Atlantic article you cited was written in 2009, it was just under 70%. By 2012, it was 72%. Over 7 out of 10 black babies are now born to single parent families. That's a massive, massive increase since WWII.
You are mistaking the birth rates for unmarried black woman with illegitimacy rates. Birth rates are irrelevant to a discussion concerning the effects of illegitimacy on those children who are actually born. The ever increasing percentage of illegitimate births is vital because, as the literature on the subject demonstrates, there's a multiplier effect of negative consequences when children grow up in a community lacking stable families.
t, the ''out of wedlock'' births for whites women has been increasing.
Yes. It's a huge problem. Charles Murray wrote an excellent book that details the havoc that plays on the white working class.
to quote the NYT review:
"Using a statistical construct he calls Fishtown inspired by an actual white, blue-collar neighborhood of the same name in Philadelphia Murray sorts through demographic data to present a startling picture. Women in Fishtown now routinely have children outside of marriage. Less than a third of its children grow up in households that include both biological parents. The men claim physical disability at astounding rates and are less likely to hold down jobs than in the past. Churchgoing among the white working class has declined, eroding the social capital that organized religion once provided.
Illegitimacy, crime, joblessness these are not merely the much debated pathologies of a black underclass, Murray finds. They are white people problems too."
Sean, what is the difference between a ''unmarried black women'' having a child, and one that is illegitiment. The difference escapes me, since both are born out of wedlock.
Since we both seem to agree that both white and black one parent families are a problem. Should we not look at the other aspects that I mentioned above? To actuallybring more context to the numbers.
rograms must be found that encourage family stability, and also employment.
I don't think programs are much of an answer. Certainly, the Great Society which was supposed to be the solution, only exacerbated the problem. Along with Moynihan, I believe it's a culture question. There has to be widespread buy in on the individual level about the importance of having two parents. Without it, you are just whistling past the graveyard.
The out of wedlock rates (which would include co-habitation) have been increasing for decades and the results are just as dire. I've not seen any studies on it, but my guess is that co-habitation parenting is probably more transitory than traditional marriages and the children born into such situations end up with similar results to the classic picture of the father abandoning the mother at birth or shortly thereafter.
It's an interesting quesrion and I'm going to look into it to see if any studies have been done.