╌>

The Backlash to the Anti-Gay Backlash: “Religious Freedom” Bills Fail, As More People See What They’re Really About

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  hal-a-lujah  •  11 years ago  •  12 comments

The Backlash to the Anti-Gay Backlash: “Religious Freedom” Bills Fail, As More People See What They’re Really About

Source

2046_discussions.jpg?width=400

The anti-gay backlash backlash is here.

In the wake of advances for LGBT equality, conservatives across the country have rallied to pass religious freedom bills that would allow people and businesses to discriminate if they have a religious justification for doing so.

The poster children of this campaign are religious wedding photographers and cake bakers. But the real impact is far more serious: huge corporations like Hobby Lobby denying benefits, services, and recognition to same-sex families; Catholic hospitals disallowing longtime, same-sex spouses to visit one another; huge university systems firing janitors, basketball coaches, and secretaries because they are gay.

And then there are the unintended consequences: wife- and child-abusers offering religion as a defense ; Jews being turned away from hotels ; and more absurd consequences like Satanists advertising their religion in state capitol buildings.

At first, these advances flew below the radar. When I first covered this issue two years ago , it was still somewhat arcane, lost in a haze of legalese. Religious liberty is a good thing, right? No one knew how to pronounce RFRA. (Riff-ra, if you please.)

But then came the Hobby Lobby decision, and the Arizona Turn the Gays Away fiasco, and increasing attention to Religious Freedom Restoration Acts (RFRAs) in Mississippi (passed), Georgia (going down to the wire), and Indiana (same).

Now, signs of a backlash against the backlash are cropping up.

The heavily funded , far-right-written-and-coordinated cascade of RFRAswhat I believe I christened RFRA Madness has run into serious opposition.

In West Virginia, a bill identical to one that passed in Arkansas , which would forbid any municipality from passing anti-discrimination laws, died in committee .

In Michigan, a Religious Freedom Restoration Act failed late last year , though it may have another shot this year.

Perhaps most intriguing is Oklahoma, where yet another Religious Freedom Act died in the state House. Its not known exactly why Republicans shelved the bill, but it may be due to one of the most ingenious counter-efforts in the country , led by Democrat Emily Virgin.

State Rep. Virgins idea? Require any business that wont provide services to LGBT people to state so publicly. In the language of the amendment, Any person not wanting to participate in any of the activities set forth in subsection A of this section based on sexual orientation, gender identity or race of either party to the marriage shall post notice of such refusal in a manner clearly visible to the public in all places of business, including websites.

Said Virgin on Facebook, This would save same-sex couples the trouble and embarrassment of going into that business just to be turned away.

This, if I may say so, is brilliant. (The idea came in consultations between Virgin, the ACLU of Oklahoma, and the state advocacy group Freedom Oklahoma.) On the surface, yes, Virgins rationale makes sense. But we all know what would really happen if Chick-Fil-A or Hobby Lobby posted such a sign: outrage. Virgins amendment would act as a kind of public shaming for businesses who want to turn gays, blacks, Jews, or anyone else away.

To be sure, many businesses might display their bigotry as a badge of honoras Chick-Fil-A did. They might also benefit from doing so, at least in the short term.

But those Instagram pictures are going to be around for a long time. And in 20 years, theyre going to look a lot like Whites Only signs.

To many people, they already do. The fact is, while public opinion is still divided on same-sex marriage (about 55-45 in favor), its not on nondiscrimination. Over 75 percent of Americans believe that you shouldnt be fired for being gay , and while they might sympathize with an individual baker or florist, theyre not going to be keen on national chains saying No Gays Allowed.

Again, its not known if Virgins proposed amendment killed the Religious Freedom bill in Oklahoma. But something did.

And then there are our friends at the Satanic Temple , eager to take these religious liberty provisions to their logical conclusions. In Michigan, theyve proposed an amendment much like Virgins, and even printed some handy fill-in signs for bigots who want to get a head start . There and elsewhere (including, best of all, Florida), theyve successfully installed Satanic holiday displays, making use of Christmas-display laws that shrink the scope of the First Amendment.

The Satanic Temple (not one organization, but many) is doing street theater, of course. Most likely, they are preaching to the already-Satanically converted. But they have also succeeded at highlighting the unintended consequences of the new religious liberty.

More seriously, we are now beginning to tease fact from fiction when it comes to religious liberty. Individual florists, bakers, photographers, innkeepersthese are sympathetic poster children.

But how about multi-billion dollar businesses, hospitals, malls, and schools? How about the doctor who refused to treat the child of same-sex parents ? How about adoption agencies that receive federal money, but still wont place children with legally married same-sex couples? Or the football coach who gets fired when someone heard him mention his husband?

These are the real faces of so-called religious freedom. And as their stories become better known, the scare quotes around that term get thicker and thicker.

Its telling that Oklahoma dropped its Religious Freedom bill when a legislator demanded that discriminators make themselves known to the public. Like repressed gays, prejudice has to hide in the closet.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
Its telling that Oklahoma dropped its Religious Freedom bill when a legislator demanded that discriminators make themselves known to the public. Like repressed gays, prejudice has to hide in the closet.

Ain't that the truth.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

I'm a firm believer is ''freedom from religion''.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Hal, thank you for this article! It has become obvious to me that I don't really understand what this religious freedom thing is all about, legislatively.

If I may-- I am for freedom of religion-- meaning everyone has a right to practice their religion, EXCEPT where it harms other people or animals. By that same token, I am for freedom from religion-- no one has the right to push their religious beliefs on me or anyone else.

I think it is a fine idea that any business that refuses to serve a certain segment of the population because of race, gender, creed, etc., must advertise their beliefs. I think most business owners will find it to be a double-edged sword.

By that same token, I have been thinking about opening up a wedding chapel. I can't legally marry gays in my state, at least not yet, but I could have blessing ceremonies. I've been thinking about a non-denominational chapel, where all are welcome. (I don't mean just the flavors of Christianity, but also other wonderful religions.) But then, I got to thinking about devil worshippers, and, I have to be honest-- it doesn't bother me a bit to refuse them service. How could I ask the devil to bless a union? I have no problem holding civil ceremonies, for those who don't believe in a God. I do have a problem with the devil, though. Somehow, I can't die and go to heaven and tell my Grandma that I called upon the devil to bless a union. I believe she would understand and even approve of joining Hindus, Buddhists, etc.

So, in trying to apply this to my life, I find that I sit upon the fence, yet again. I believe in both-- freedom of religion and freedom from religion. But I, personally, can't handle devil worshippers. So, I'm a royal hypocrite as well, and must somehow find a way to either adjust my feelings, advertise my personal bias, or abandon the idea. Smile.gif

BTW-- do you think that someone would be averse to being married by a short, gray-haired woman, who smiles a lot? Or they can bring their own minister...

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    11 years ago

"...and must somehow find a way to either adjust my feelings, advertise my personal bias, or abandon the idea."

a simple and legal solution would be to post a sign that says
We reserve the right to refuse service to anyone..."

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
Dowser, as you can probably imagine, an atheist sees no less value in a Satanist's beliefs than a religionist's beliefs. It's all a bunch of hooey to us. That said, I should think that it would be a very rare occasion that a Satanist would seek your services. My advice - keep an atheist on call to sub for you when the happy devil worshipping couple comes a knockin.
 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Smile.gif

I haven't had much time, lately, to practice! And, so far, every time the weather changes, the keys stick... SIGH. But soon! I hope!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

That would be good. Thanks!

Note: I'm looking for a new career...

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

That's good advice, too! Thanks!

Hal, I want atheists to feel welcome, too. Civil ceremonies as well as religious ones. Removable props, so to speak. I'm thinking of trying to find somewhere that's pretty, and have a good view. Smile.gif

I will need a Buddhist monk on call, etc., too!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Funny!

I don't feel that way, but it's still funny!

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
Well, if you're planning on a staff to cover for those who fall outside of your ecumenical toleration, you better include a Pastafarian too. The Flying Spaghetti Monster needs representation .... sauce be upon him. :)
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

As many know here (I have said it many times) that I am an atheist, so the religious belief of other people have no meaning me, until it begins to take some of my rights away when they shouldn't have the power to do so.

I am also the very proud father of a gay son and I certainly want his rights to be protected too and too much religion can take some of his rights away. Oh and the could also harm my son's husband (via legal marriage in CA (about damned time too)) who I think is great person, a fantastic addition to our family and I am proud to be his father in law.

Keep religion out of the government and law. It's always a poisonous combination.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Oh no, please don't misunderstand me-- I like, approve, enjoy, etc. Buddhists-- I think it may be wise to have one on call that can do the ceremonies right and make sure that people feel comfortable.

The only one that I have a problem with is devil worshippers... Other than that, I have no feelings other than understanding and respect for them. Does that make sense? I just want to do things right. It will be a place of peace. Smile.gif

Peace for those who don't believe as well. I want everyone to feel comfortable-- and will be as accommodating as possible. I want everyone to feel loved and valued-- everyone that is, but those who follow the devil... If God is love, then it is up to me to put that in practice, in any way I can. I said I was a hypocrite, because I can't have them there... Smile.gif Also, no animal sacrifice. Can't handle that...

 
 

Who is online