╌>

Hillary's Email Defense is Laughable

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  11 years ago  •  5 comments

Hillary's Email Defense is Laughable
thought when I retired from the Justice Department in 2007, I was done with records-related scandals. By that point, I had spent more than a quarter-century as founding director of the Justice Departments Office of Information and Privacy, effectively serving as the federal governments chief information-disclosure guru. In that position, I had weathered many a Clinton records scandal during the 1990sabout two dozen, all told, including two that amazingly have still never become publicand I thought I had seen the last of them. At the very least, I thought I had become immune to being shocked by anything in that vein.It turns out I was wrong on both counts.We now have former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton being revealed as someone who took the unprecedented step of arranging to use her personal email account for all of her official email communications. Whats more, she decided to use her own email server equipment, rather than a commercial Internet service provider, so that the records of her email account would reside solely within her personal control at home. And if that were not enough, she then proceeded blithelythough not uncharacteristicallyto present herself to the public, at a press conference held on March 10, as if there were really nothing wrong about any of this at all.Well, as the saying goes, reality is not her friend.For anyone considering this sad tale carefullyincluding the media, members of Congress and the public at large, whether from inside the Beltway or notsome basic points of both law and reality should be borne in mind.First, while it is accurate for Secretary Clinton to say that when she was in office there was not a flat, categorical prohibition on federal government officials ever using their personal email accounts for the conduct of official business, thats a far different thing from saying (as she apparently would like to) that a government official could use his or her personal email account exclusively, for all official email communications, as she actually did. In fact, the Federal Records Act dictates otherwise.That law, which applies to all federal agency employees who are not within the White House itself, requires the comprehensive documentation of the conduct of official business, and it has long done so by regulating the creation, maintenance, preservation and, ultimately, the disposition of agency records. When it comes to modern-day email communications, as compared to the paper memoranda of not so long ago, these communications now are themselves the very means of conducting official business, by definition.To be sure, this cannot as a practical matter be absolute. When Obama administration officials came into office in 2009, the Federal Records Act certainly allowed room for the occasional use of a personal email account for official business where necessarysuch as when a secretary of state understandably must deal with a crisis around the world in the middle of the night while an official email device might not be readily at hand. That just makes sense. But even then, in such an exceptional situation, the Federal Records Acts documentation and preservation requirements still called upon that official (or a staff assistant) to forward any such email into the State Departments official records system, where it would have been located otherwise.This appears to be exactly what former Secretary of State Colin Powell did during his tenure, just as other high-level government officials may do (or are supposed to do) under such exceptional circumstances during their times in office. Notwithstanding Secretary Clintons sweeping claims to the contrary, there actually is no indication in any of the public discussions of this scandal that anyone other than she managed to do what she did (or didnt) do as a federal official.Second, the official availability of official email communications is not just a matter of concern for purposes of the Federal Records Act only. It also makes an enormous (and highly foreseeable) difference to the proper implementation of the Freedom of Information Act (known as the FOIA to its friends, a group that evidently does not include Secretary Clinton). That is because the starting point for handling a FOIA request is the search that an agency must conduct for all records responsive to that requests particular specifications. So any FOIA request that requires an agency first to locate responsive email messages sent to or from that agencys head, for instance, is necessarily dependent on those records being locatable in the first place. And an agency simply cannot do that properly for any emails (let alone all such emails) that have been created, and are maintained, entirely beyond the agencys reach. Or, as it sometimes is said somewhat cynically in the FOIA community, You cant disclose what you cant find.In this case, which is truly unprecedented, no matter what Secretary Clinton would have one believe, she managed successfully to insulate her official emails, categorically, from the FOIA, both during her tenure at State and long after her departure from itperhaps forever. Nice work if you can get it, one might say, especially if your experience during your husbands presidency gives you good reason (nay, even highly compelling motivation) to relegate unto yourself such control if at all possible.Third, there is the compounding fact that Secretary Clinton did not merely use a personal email account; she used one that atypically operated solely through her own personal email server, which she evidently had installed in her home. This meant that, unlike the multitudes who use a Gmail account, for instance, she was able to keep her communications entirely in house, even more deeply within her personal control. No cloud for posterity, or chance of Google receiving a congressional subpoenanot for her. No potentially pesky metadata surrounding her communications or detailed server logs to complicate things. And absolutely no practical constraint on her ability to dispose of any official email of hers, for any reason, at any time, entirely on her own. Bluntly put, when this unique records regime was established, somebody was asleep at the switch, at either the State Department or the National Archives and Records Administration (which oversees compliance with the Federal Records Act)or both.Now, what Secretary Clinton would have one believe is that this is all just a matter of her choosing one available email option over another, that she really did nothing that her predecessors had not done before her and that she can be trusted to have absolutely confidence that what she did fully complied with every rule that [she] was governed by. In other words, the thrust of her March 10 press conference was: Everything was fine, nothing to be seen here, so lets all just move along.But having spent a quarter-century at the forefront of the governments administration of the FOIA, including its transition to electronic records and its involvement in so many Clinton administration scandals du jour, I know full well that both what Secretary Clinton arranged to do and what she now has said about that are, to put it most charitably, not what either the law or anything close to candor requires. At a minimum, it was a blatant circumvention of the FOIA by someone who unquestionably knows better and an attempted verbal cover of the situation (if not cover-up) that is truly reminiscent of years past.And I say that even as someone who, if she decides to run for president and is the Democratic nominee, will nevertheless vote for her next year.Read more: http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/03/hillary-clinton-email-scandal-defense-laughable-foia-116116.html#ixzz3Uha2srvt

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
Democrat Dan Metcalfe spent more than thirty years working at the U.S. Department of Justice, at which he served from 1981 to 2007 as director of the Office of Information and Privacy, where he was responsible for overseeing the implementation of the FOIA throughout the entire executive branch. He now teaches secrecy law at American Universitys Washington College of Law.
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

If you read the EF109 attached you will see if she signed it she broke the law. If she didn't sign it why not. It would be asinine to believe anyone who spent as much time as she has in government to not be familiar with the process. In fact she fired someone which part of the firing was for the very thing she was doing. I mean she was hacked. Just read the attachment.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
She didn't sign it, or at least State doesn't have a copy of it. State admitted that today.
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago
A lot of words that have absolutely nothing to do with the points raised by professor Metcalfe.
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Sure John, keep telling yourself that. Hillary's favorables keep plummeting but "no one cares."

 
 

Who is online