Can We Forgive All Student Debt?
| |
| It's time to end the student loan crisis, once and for all. Student debt burdens over 41 million Americans. Many young people live in a kind of servitude, their choices limited by student loans. It adds up to $1.3 trillion national emergency. Only a few decades ago a college education was almost free. Jeb Bush paid just $100 1 a year in tuition at the University of Texas in the early 1970s. Today an in-state undergraduate pays at the same school pays over $18,000. 2 It is time to forgive this debt and set our students, their families and our economy free. Since most student loan debt is held by the federal government, it can be forgiven by government action. We owe our young people the chance for a better future. Student debt mortgages the as-yet unearned wealth of each new generation and stifles the prosperity of the future. This is a moral question. Its time to take action to liberate the 41 million Americans carrying over $1.3 trillion in student loan debts. | ||

Seems to me we have a problem that needs to be addressed.
I agree. That is taxpayer money and when these same people who want their expensive educations for free are the same people who are clamoring for amnesty for illegal aliens who are going to need millions insocial services while at the same time bitching about wanting to cut or do away with Social Security, not only no, but HELL NO!
There is no bank willing to "forgive" house loan debts because people have lost jobs due to the economy they couldn't do anything about. Suck it up and make arrangement to pay off the first major debt of your life. It's good for your character.
I don't care if they have to pay $20 per month the rest of their lives and die still owing the balance and the government can attach a lien to their life insurance policies... learn a life lesson about borrowing money.
Well, I've got a student loan of $36,000 for law school. The rate, from the government, is 6.75% with a tentative payoff in 22 years at $254.00 a month which equates to a total payment/loan value of $67,056.00.
And this is a Stafford Subsidized Loan which means the government picks up .00025% of the loan - $9.00. I'm impressed.
My daughter will never take out a loan even if I have to sell the house for her college.
Good grief, 1stwarrior! Did you ever screw up!
I mean... you're an INDIAN! A bona fide registered INDIAN! Everybody knows that Indians get everything for FREE and don't pay taxes and... and.... everything!
You should just call,tell them you're an Indian and they'll wipe the debt out for you!
The problem isn't that student loans have gone through the roof, it's that university and college tuition have gone through the roof!!! Then there's lab fees, Housing, Food!. It's obscene the prices they're charging! THAT'S who the government should be going after! Granted they can't do much about private schools, but if we spent the same for colleges and universities as we do one war, I'm not just talking about the defense budget in general, bout ONLY in war, everyone could afford college.
I don't think they did. They were under the impression the education they were buying would get them jobs that would enable them to pay back the loans, because that's what they were told.
There is no "Student Loan 101" in high school, so how were they to know what they were getting into?
Who do you think's paying for it now? The students default, destroying their credit, which makes it difficult for them to contribute to the economy, the free loading banks turn to the governmentthat guaranteed the loans, for their money, which means you and I cover the losses .... with interest.
Wrong. It's good economics.
In general I approve of the concept but I'm not too sure of the "Total Debt Forgiveness" part. Working the debt off through a National Service programs, (like joining the military, AmeriCorps, Peace Corps or VISTA, etc...), is more in tune with my line of thinking.
That said, forgiving the Student debt would be one hell of a National stimulus program! All that money getting spread through out the economy instead of just going to one institution, (the banks), hell yes I'd be for that.
Back in the early 1800's our Country decided that education should notjust be for the children of the rich so we started public schooling programs. Just a few years of public schooling to start but by the end of the 19th century the Country recognized the benefits of a literate workforce so we uppedthe educational years tocontinue through High School.
Perhaps here, in the 21st Century, it's time to extend the public education/tranning of our future workfoce another4 years, for the good of the Nation?
My thoughts only of course.
I couldn't add anything to your post except to say bravo well written and 100% correct!
Why stop there?
Let's forgive all mortgage debt while we are at and I am sure folks wouldn't a discount on what they owe in credit card debt.
When a person takes out a loan, he/she gives his word (his signature) that he understands what he/she is doing and that he/she will pay back the debt according to the terms he/she is agreeing to in the contract.
There is less and less emphasis on people being accountable for their actions in this country and how we should tell them that contracts and their word of honor mean nothing.
Sure sounds like a good idea
Sure sounds like a good idea
What part of working the debt off through national service did you ignore? Or don't you know what that means? Are you able to grasp that concept?
How can universities, that are public institutions, and receive federal funding, justify the continued increases in cost?
I know what that means for sure and would like to see everything citizen committed to a minimum of two years national service or one type or another and in return to have college paid for completely
But that is not how this will turn out, there will be exceptions and exceptions and exceptions and ultimately the goal is to write off the debt which I do not agree with.
They gave their word to pay the debt back, the money they borrowed - where I come from a person's word means something.
And the portion of the comment you quoted, you obviously did not understand - the "good idea' sarcasm was to the forgiving of all other types of loans for those that decide it is just too hard to keep their word and honor their responsibility to pay their debts.
I agree but that won't stop the Dems from making a campaign promise out of it.
Why is it that Democrats feel other taxpayers should bail out those who make stupid decisions? First let's bail out Dumb-asses who bought gas guzzlers by giving them $4500 for a new car. Then let's bail out the dumb-asses that bought houses they couldn't afford. Now let's bail out dumb-asses that took out more student loan than they can afford. When the hell can we start expecting the dumb-asses in this country to quit being dumb-asses? When it stops PAYING to be a dumb-ass. That's when.
Besides, paying this debt will just encourage higher prices and encourage more people to take out huge student loans. It will perpetuate the problem..
THAT is where we need to start. Not by paying the exorbitant rates and thereby perpetuating it.
interesting concept, but (and there is always a but) if the person who signs a contract is NOT responsible enough to make the payment in FULL upon the agreed contract,...just what make you think the person will work off the debt.....
"There is no "Student Loan 101" in high school, so how were they to know what they were getting into?"
If a person can NOT understand or does NOT understand that they must pay back a LOAN when they sign a contract,....then maybe they aren't college material. Ignorance of the law is NO excuse....
Good point and that debt should hang around their neck until they choose to pay it off.
There is a big difference between making a 'stupid decision' and making a wrong decision based on misinformation. These kids were told the degrees they would earn would be enable them to get jobs that would pay enough for them to pay off the loans.
That didn't happen, most of them areworkingat jobs that hardly payenoughto coverdecentliving expenses.
The problem is being perpetuated anyway, because nothing is being done to solve the problem.
Typical thinking of a Right Wing cynic.
I would imagine if such a plan were to be put in place, it would include controls that would limit future increased cost or borrowing. You, of all people, should know the government never gives anything away without taking something back in return.
I'm sure they understood the loans were to paid back, and I'm sure they were under the impression the degree they were paying for would allow them to earn enough to pay the loans. Basically, because that's what they were told would happen.
Fine, you can remain 'unforgiving' and stubborn if you want, but in the meantime this loan debt is preventing people fromobtainingcredit to buy things like cars, furniture, appliances and homes. Purchases like that have a positive effect on the economy, .... your economy.
On the other hand, not doing anything does have a positive effect ...... it earns buku interest for the banking industry, which does nothing to help your economy .... unless you're in the banking business.
"I'm sure they understood the loans were to paid back..." then there is NO reason to forgive the obligation they agreed to.
"and I'm sure they were under the impression the degree they were paying for would allow them to earn enough to pay the loans." like buying a car it is buyer beware. Know what you are buying BEFORE you sign on the dotted line....there are NO guarantee when it comes to buying an education or a car......
They pay the proffs and presidents ridicules comp packages .
The Chronicle of Higher Education has previously compiled salary data for the presidents of public institutions, which was available for 2011. Those figures showed three public university presidents earned more than $1 million in 2011, led by Gordon Gee of Ohio State with total compensation of just under $2 million.
The Chronicle reports this year that half the institutions that employed the 50 highest-paid college presidents in 2010 used a practice called "grossing up," adding additional cash and benefits to compensation packages to make up for the taxes recipients pay. The practice has been largely abandoned at publicly traded companies due to shareholder criticism, but appears alive and well in the non-profit sector.
I'mwithyou onthatArky!
Yeah it would be good for the nation! It would also help bring our education system into the 21st century!
However, Idon'tthinkwe would ever get the Right Wing to go for four years, it's hard enough right now to get the to even discuss extending free public ed an additional two years.
Not a good point.
I said this same thing above, that debt they have 'hanging around their neck'is preventing them fromobtainingcredit to buy things like cars, furniture, appliances and homes. Purchases like that have a positive effect on the economy, .... your economy.
On the other hand, to not doing anythingdoeshave a positive effect ...... it earns buku interest for the banking industry, which doesnothingto help your economy .... unless you're in the banking business.
Basically these kids were duped into thinking they would be able to get jobs that would pay them enough to pay off the loans.
There are LOTS of reasons.
Putting that money back into the economy were it is needed to stimulate jobs, is one of them.
NOT putting that money into the hands of the Money Changers where it will do nothing but provide multi-million dollar salaries for Wall Street CEO's is another.
"Putting that money back into the economy were it is needed to stimulate jobs, is one of them."
You want to forgive a loan the student took out for an education so that the student could get a job, so you can create a job for the student who can NOT pay for the education they agreed to pay for.....(wonder how many years of college it took to come up with that idea..... Oh wow, did I say that out loud....)
SUCKER!!! That's what it would say.
I have yet to see anything left to the government become cheaper. Having the government as the responsible party to pay off a loan is a ticket to riches for the universities. Anytime the government gets involved the price goes up. Remember all that equipment in the military and the parts? You could buy all this stuff from for private sources and not have it paid by the government and it may cost you 10% of what they would charge the government for the same things.
Maybe this lady can give you some advice for teaching a couple of classes a week at Harvard.
Elizabeth Warren Income and Net Worth
I have to tell you first, she talks a big game kind of like some others we know, but if you read this you will see that's all she does is talk.
I think the problem has come about because of the way the cost of a College education has out paced the ability of the avarage American to afford it, (with the traditional grants and low wage jobs).
When I got my degree in the 1970's I had no debt because I had access to the GI bill money &matching grants from the company I worked for, pluss the cost for a year at a public university was around $1,200 @ that time.
These days we're still telling our Highschool grads to get their College or risk their futures but now the average cost is $13K a year and grant money is becoming ever more scarce, which has lead to 7 out of 10 Grads comming out of College owing $30K or more and moving into a job market that often doesn't offer a wage that supports that kind of debt, (on top of all their other living expenses).
Personaly I think it's past time we pull an Ike and consider our education systemto bean importantpiece ofour National Securty and set up appropriate, long term funding for it. (That's how Ike got Congress to fund our current National highway system)
I don't post much but sometimes I can't help but to speak out especially when something is as ridiculous as this. I have no issues with trying to fix the problems that currently exist with the cost of education and interest rates, but the people that currently have student loans should not get full forgiveness. Some assistance such as refinanced loans at much lower interest rates would be fine. Forgiveness should not be in discussions.
Let's look at the Jerry's reasoning. "It will help the economy". Using this reasoning you could argue to forgive all debt based on this premise. Just borrow a ton of money from China, forgive everyone's debt and watch the economy soar! I don't see any downsides, do you? <s>
Next reason, "The students were lied to about job availability". Just go to college, get any degree and you'll be fine! This is an epic whopper of a lie and very piss poor reasoning to forgive one's debt. There are tons of jobs available in this country with the "right" degree. Who's responsibility is it to determine which college degree should be obtained? There are millions of American's getting basically worthless liberal arts degrees and there have been people screaming from the hilltops that those degrees basically are indeed worthless. So you didn't do the research necessary to determine the proper degree to obtain that would have a good job waiting for you when you finished? No problem, your debt is forgiven.......
The last thing I'll say is this. Even if you forgive the debt, these people are still in a position where their degree doesn't get them much. So now what? Give them another free education? Trust that they'll make proper decisions this time?
smh
That's ridicules.
The premise for forgiving student loan debt is based on a very special set of circumstances, and would help the economy only because of those circumstances.
If you were to give the issue some thought, it's possible you would be able to understand the logic.
interesting concept, but (and there is always a but) if the person who signs a contract is NOT responsible enough to make the payment in FULL upon the agreed contract,...just what make you think the person will work off the debt.....
They can join the military for 4 years or if given civilian jobs to do to work of the debt, they can so with the understand that if they quit (unless it for a reason they couldn't help. like......say being drafted to help invade Iran...or Pakistan.... or who ever the fuck a GOP President lies us into into next) then their student debt loan's interest rate doubled for every year they don't work.
How about taking the profit out of student loans, (instead of total forgiveness), as a first steep toward fixing this problem?
Make all student loans interest free but, (until the debt is paid), every paycheck receivedby the loan holders will have an automatic deduction taken out that goes straight to paying off the loan balance.
A student loan withholding of say 1 or 3% of their paycheck till the loan is cleared, with no penalty for early payoffs.
If it takes em 3 years or 30 years, as long as they are working the loan is getting paid down, with no penalty building up when they are between jobs.
Not forgiveness but a little relief at least.