╌>

Congress' Letter On Iran Was Leadership, Not Treachery

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  12 comments

Congress' Letter On Iran Was Leadership, Not Treachery

L et's put aside President Obama's ridiculous argument that the recent letter to Iranian officials signed by 47 U.S. senators constituted "wanting to make common cause with the hardliners in Iran." It was nothing of the kind.

This letter warned Iran and the world that the agreement being negotiated on its nuclear program will not be binding on the United States and may be rejected by the next president.

This wasn't a traitorous act. It was an act to exert adult leadership over a disastrous U.S. foreign policy that is on track to produce a deal with Iran that will be deeply destabilizing and could lead to a Middle East war.

The Obama team and its media supporters attack Republican signatories of the letter to distract from the president's capitulation to the Iranian mullahs to get a legacy nuclear deal.

He has conceded to Iran the "right" to enrich uranium and the "right" to build a heavy water, plutonium-producing reactor. Iran is on the brink of a nuclear deal that may last only 10 years even though it has never fully cooperated with International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) inspectors and shows no sign of ever doing so.

The danger from Iran's nuclear program has soared during the Obama presidency: Iran can now make at least eight nuclear weapons from its reactor-grade uranium, up from seven when the nuclear talks began. The nearby chart from the Center for Security Policy illustrates this.

Obama and Secretary of State John Kerry have repeatedly assured us that they will not agree to a deal that lets Iran build nuclear bombs. After six years of lies about ObamaCare, the IRS scandal, spying on journalists, Benghazi and other things, most Americans don't believe them.



Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials-on-the-right/031315-743429-congressional-letter-to-iran-was-meant-to-stop-a-deadly-mistake.htm#ixzz3U0NSm3Mk


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
treachery is secretly telling Iran not to sign a deal with the bush administration because if you are elected president you will give Iran a much better deal.

Treachery is not publicly discussing the constitutional powers of the Senate.
 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    11 years ago

We petition the Obama administration to:

File charges against the 47 U.S. Senators in violation of The Logan Act in attempting to undermine a nuclear agreement.

On March 9th, 2015, forty-seven United States Senators committed a treasonous offense when they decided to violate the Logan Act, a 1799 law which forbids unauthorized citizens from negotiating with foreign governments. Violation of the Logan Act is a felony, punishable under federal law with imprisonment of up to three years.

At a time when the United States government is attempting to reach a potential nuclear agreement with the Iranian government, 47 Senators saw fit to instead issue a condescending letter to the Iranian government stating that any agreement brokered by our President would not be upheld once the president leaves office.

This is a clear violation of federal law. In attempting to undermine our own nation, these 47 senators have committed treason.

Published Date: Mar 09, 2015

Signatures needed by April 08, 2015 to reach goal of 100,000

0

Total signatures on this petition

287,508

287,508 signatures and counting since March 9th 2015 that's (6) Six days...

Total number of signatures needed 100,000 in a 30 days period for the White House to even look at any petitions...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    11 years ago

This is an international agreement, Congress of course would be informed after the other nations have come to some understanding, that's when its appropriate of congress to be involved, not while negotiations are going on...That is the idiocy...They need to know International Laws...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    11 years ago

Of course the stupidity of GOP will say International Laws does not belong in the USA, when dealing with various nations, International Laws apply... Once again the GOP wants to be bullies on the world stage...

The Power and Purpose of International Law: Insights from the Theory and Practice of Enforcement

Mary Ellen O'Connell

International law supports order in the world and the attainment of humanity's fundamental goals of advancing peace, prosperity, human rights, and environmental protection. Yet, there have been voices for centuries attacking international law in order to promote the dominance or hegemony of a single nation. After 9/11, such advocates succeeded in getting America's leaders to invade Iraq, establish Guantanamo Bay and black sites, use waterboarding and other forms of torture and coercion during interrogation, and execute individuals in defiance of the International Court of Justice. This book reveals that to be persuasive, opponents of international law have misrepresented what international law is and how it works. Anti-international law voices have presented international law as powerless and unworthy of respect. To clear away the myths, the book draws on new developments in natural law, positive law, and process theory. The resulting new classical theory demonstrates that international law's power or authority is explained by the same theory that explains the authority of law within nations. International law has authority because it is widely accepted as law. Part of the evidence of that acceptance is found in the fact international law has forceful means of enforcement armed force, sanctions, countermeasures, and courts. The book provides many examples of international law in action the real international law with the power to support the interest of all humanity.

...

Signatures needed by April 08, 2015 to reach goal of 100,000

0

Total signatures on this petition

287,836
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Once again the GOP wants to be bullies on the world stage...

100% correct!!! Their idea of American exceptionism is that the rest of the world has to do whatever the America GOP says that have to do.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    11 years ago

White House Issues Saturday Night Iran Deal Warning To Senate

Jessica Schulberg

DENIS MCDONOUGH

WASHINGTON -- In an effort to reassert control over the domestic political debate surrounding sensitive negotiations on Irans nuclear program, the White House penned a letter Saturday night warning senators to hold back on legislation that would detract from the presidents ability to affect and approve a final agreement with Iran.

The letter, written by White House Chief of Staff Denis McDonough to Senate Foreign Relations Committee Chairman Bob Corker (R-Tenn.), reiterates a veto threat of the bill, while insisting that Congress will have a say in reviewing and affecting the ultimate outcome. But in far more detailed and foreboding terms than normal, McDonough lays out the administration's concerns should Corker's Iran Nuclear Agreement Review Act of 2015 end up becoming law.

The bill, he writes, would "likely have a profoundly negative impact on the ongoing negotiations -- emboldening Iranian hard-liners, inviting a counter-productive response from the Iranian majiles; differentiating the U.S. position from our allies in negotiations; and once again calling into question our ability to negotiate this deal."

"Put simply," adds McDonough, "it would potentially make it impossible to secure international cooperation for additional sanctions, while putting at risk the existing multilateral sanctions regime."

Coming just days before the March 24 deadline for a political framework for the final nuclear agreement, the Saturday night letter -- three pages, single spaced, in length -- is the latest indication of rising tensions between the White House and the Hill. At times assertive and, at others, combative, the letter warns Corker that his bill, which would give Congress the right to vote up or down on the final nuclear agreement, would cripple U.S. negotiators and lead Iran and international negotiating partners to question the U.S.' ability to follow through on its end of the bargain.

It comes after months of Congress trying to insert itself into the negotiations between Iran, the U.S. and five partner countries. While the White House maintains it is nearing an agreement that will ensure Irans nuclear program is for peaceful purposes, lawmakers have insisted that President Barack Obama is prepared to sign a bad deal" that will leave too much of Irans nuclear facilities intact, allowing it to covertly develop a nuclear weapon. These concerns have been echoed by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who, against the wishes of the White House, delivered a contentious speech on the House floor, warning that the current deal will all but guarantee Iran nuclear weapons.

Matters came to a climactic point this past week, when Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) drafted a letter , signed by 46 other Republican senators, to Iranian leadership. The letter warned that any agreement could easily be reworked by Congress, or even overturned by a future president. The White House and Democratic lawmakers slammed the letter as a blatant attempt to undermine negotiations and the credibility of the White House.

Notably absent from the signatories was Corker, who had been trying to recruit Democratic senators to build a veto-proof majority for his bill. Cotton's letter appears to have complicated those efforts. McDonough's letter -- from a wildly different philosophical vantage point -- is designed to shelve it entirely.

"The Administration's request to the Congress is simple: let us complete the negotiations before the Congress acts on legislation," writes McDonough. "We understand that Congress will make its own determinations about how to respond, but we do not believe that the country's interests are served by congressional attempts to weigh in prematurely on this sensitive and consequential ongoing international negotiation aimed at achieving a goal that we all share: using diplomacy to prevent Iran from developing a nuclear weapon."

At the heart of the administration's concern with Corker's legislation are two separate issues. The first is the overarching message that the final vote of approval on the deal is within the purview of Congress. McDonough, in his letter, concedes a Republican concern: that the United Nations will have a role in implementing a final agreement. But that, he notes, is because the U.N. is the only entity with the authority to terminate the U.N. Security Council's sanctions on Iran.

McDonough also assures Corker that the Senate will play a role -- "and will have to take a vote" -- in any final agreement. But that vote, he says, should come further down the line. There is ample precedent for a non-legally binding international treaty premised on political commitments, McDonough argues. And much of his letter is spent listing prior cases, the most recent being the U.S.-Russia framework to remove chemical weapons from Syria.

The second concern in the letter is that Corker's bill eliminates one of the primary tools at the president's disposal to make sure that any Iran deal is successful. Under current law, only Congress can eliminate the statutory sanctions regime against Iran. The president, however, has the power to suspend them through waivers. Corker's bill would complicate that, prompting administration concerns that they'd lose a critical tool to make the final framework work.

"The deal we are negotiating will allow us to retain significant leverage, as Iran would face severe consequences for any violation since we would have the capacity to swiftly re-impose punishing sanctions if Iran does not meet its commitments," writes McDonough.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

This is an international agreement, Congress of course would be informed after the other nations have come to some understanding, that's when its appropriate of congress to be involved, not while negotiations are going on...That is the idiocy...They need to know International Laws...

Absolutely. An international binding resolution by the Security Council (the big five) can not be affected by the Congress of the United States and is binding upon the United States. They do not have the legal ability to over-ride it.

 
 

Who is online