╌>

Movie 'Selma' Distorts History by Airbrushing Out [White] Contributions to Civil Rights, The Forward, by Leida Snow, 1/2/2015

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  11 years ago  •  5 comments

Movie 'Selma' Distorts History by Airbrushing Out [White] Contributions to Civil Rights, The Forward, by Leida Snow, 1/2/2015

Film's Portrayal of Lyndon Johnson Is Not Only Inaccuracy

50 Years Ago: Ava DuVernay’s new film arrives on the 50th anniversary of the civil rights marches of 1965.
selmamovie.com
50 Years Ago: Ava DuVernays new film arrives on the 50th anniversary of the civil rights marches of 1965.

When filmmakers choose what to include or exclude from the stories they tell, their choices often have repercussions beyond the drama on the screen. In films based on real-life events, omissions can seriously distort the way we remember the past. Selma, a film directed by Ava DuVernay, offers an ambitious portrait of Martin Luther King by zeroing in on a pivotal moment in the black voting rights struggle. The negative way in which President Lyndon Johnson is portrayed has already sparked significant controversy, but the narrative strategy of the film leads to a glaring omission that has not yet surfaced: the contribution that thousands of white people, many of them Jewish, made to the Civil Rights Movement.

The film arrives on the 50th anniversary of the Selma to Montgomery, Alabama, marches, with Oprah Winfrey as one of its lead producers. The screenplay, by Paul Webb, reveals Dr. Kings media savvy, as he embraces the Selma setting as one most likely to cause confrontation and result in wide coverage. In another scene, we witness the doctrinal and tactical splits within the civil rights movement between the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee and Malcolm X. Most powerfully, we watch the unfolding of Bloody Sunday, March 7, 1965, when the marchers are attacked by the Selma police on the Edmund Pettus Bridge.

The marchers are turned back to return another day. It was in fact a day of heroism in the face of brutal oppression. But those marches actually built on momentum generated by thousands of local efforts during the preceding months and years. Among the most significant were the 1964 Freedom Rides, in which well over a thousand volunteers, mostly white, and over half of them Jewish, risked their lives riding into Mississippi to face intimidation and harassment that included arrests, beatings, and murder. Among those providing support for the coalition of the Mississippi branches of the four major civil rights organizations were volunteers from the Medical Committee for Human Rights, the American Civil Liberties Organization, and Christian and Jewish clergy and divinity students recruited by the National Council of Churches, who provided traditional religious support while also engaging in protests, recruiting voter applicants, and going with them to register.

National outrage after the murder of the black Mississippian James Chaney, and two Jewish New Yorkers, Andrew Goodman and Michael Schwerner in June of 1964, helped lead to passage of the Civil Rights Act. I can still remember the day I learned that their bodies had been found. I wept for the young men I didnt know, for all the Freedom Riders, and for my country, a place where such a thing could happen.

The American legacy of slavery, Jim Crow, and segregation is a wound so deep it may never fully heal. The constant efforts to de-legitimize President Barack Obama underlines this countrys entrenched racism. Current events like the failure to indict white police officers in the deaths of unarmed black citizens have outraged many. As a white person, I can barely imagine the daily indignities, humiliations, and dangers black Americans routinely faced 50 years ago and often face today, even though, as a woman and a Jew I have personally experienced some discrimination.

The struggle for African-American civil rights was primarily one led and suffered by black Americans. Some black activists may have felt embittered because the national media turned its full attention to black suffering only when white students were killed. Nevertheless, white contributions to the ongoing war against discrimination should be noted.

The black-Jewish relationship is complex, with many changes over time, but the historical record is clear. One of the founders of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) in 1909 was Henry Moskowitz. According to the Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism, Jewish philanthropy was responsible in whole or in part for the founding of more than 2,000 primary and secondary schools and twenty black colleges (including Howard, Dillard and Fisk universities).

But white and specifically Jewish involvement in the Civil Rights Movement went far beyond institution-building fund-raising. Arnie Aronson was an important organizer of the 1963 March on Washington where Rabbi Uri Miller recited the opening prayer and Rabbi Joachim Prinz spoke before Dr. Kings historic I have a dream speech. The civil rights confrontations in St. Augustine, Florida, came to a head in the spring of 1964, when three wives of Episcopal bishops joined northern college students to take part in civil rights activities, during which Dr. King was arrested. From jail, he wrote to his friend, Rabbi Israel Dresner in New Jersey, urging him to recruit rabbis to come to St. Augustine, resulting in a huge mass arrest of the rabbis who responded.

In the new film, Dr. King makes a dramatic appeal to people of all races and religions to come and join him in Selma. Hundreds do, as though for the first time, and Dr. King is shown embracing a Greek Orthodox priest. Also visible among many whites is a Catholic priest and a minister. This is a deeply moving and dramatically effective scene. But I looked in vain for the embrace of a man with a yarmulke, a scene that would reflect the historical moment when Dr. King marched with Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel, a leading Jewish theologian and philosopher widely respected beyond the Jewish community. He may be present in the grainy documentary footage at the end of the film, but he is not visible in the body of the film, nor are any other Jews openly recognized.

We can only marvel at the courage of everyday black Americans as they joined with Martin Luther King and other black activists to take on the bigots who would deny them their rights during the Civil Rights Movement. But there were many Jewish and other white Americans who supported them before, during, and after the marches from Selma to Montgomery, and Selma misses a great teaching moment by excluding them.

Leida Snow has worked for major Jewish organizations and has an extensive media and political background. Her website is www.leidasnow.com



Read more: http://forward.com/articles/212000/selma-distorts-history-by-airbrushing-out-jewish-c/#ixzz3TtiTqsYW


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Jewish Organizations Participate in Selma March Supporting Negroes

Representatives of national and various local Jewish organizations around the country, both lay and rabbinical, were participating today in the march from Selma, Ala., to Montgomery, supporting demands for equal voting rights for Negroes and backing President Johnsons proposal for legislation guaranteeing such rights, according to dispatches received here today.

The American Jewish Committee, in a call by its executive vice-president, Dr. John Slawson, urged all its chapters and members throughout the country to participate to the fullest extent possible in the Selma-Montgomery march. Dr. Slawson announced that the AJC has designated two men to represent the organization in the march, Brant Coopersmith, AJC area director for the Upper South, he said, headed the AJC delegation on the first leg of the march today, from Selma to the first overnight stopping place, 11 miles away. Later this week, Harry Fleischman, race relations coordinator for the AJC, will head the AJCs delegation on the final two legs of the march into Montgomery.

Three national Jewish religious womens groups sent a joint telegram to President Johnson, supporting his demand that Congress act promptly on the proposed voting rights bill. The organizations were the womens Branch of the Union of Orthodox Jewish Organizations of America, the National Womens League of the United Synagogue of America (Conservative), and the National Federation of Temple Sisterhoods (Reform).

Similar wires to President Johnson and to the Congressional delegations from New York were sent by the Farband-Labor Zionist Order and by the Brooklyn Jewish Community Council. Previously, every major Jewish national organization had sent telegrams to the President, taking the same stand.

A Selma Jew, Seymour Palmer, who had told newsmen in an interview in the Alabama city that northerners were at least partly responsible for the violence in Alabama by coming there to help defy authority, was answered today in a statement by Rabbi Seymour Siegel, secretary of the Rabbinical Assembly, the organization of Conservative rabbis. Dr. Siegel, who is associate professor of theology at the Jewish Theological Seminary of America, and Rabbi S. Gershon Levi, treasurer of the Assembly, led a group of Conservative rabbis who went to Selma last week to participate in the civil rights demonstrations there. Addressing Mr. Palmer directly, Rabbi Siegel stated:

We are both Jews whose ancestors taught the world the principles of justice. We are both Jews who have suffered too much for so long. Let us both Join in prayer and action to turn the hearts of men from hatred to love; from discrimination to acceptance of all men as brothers; and from passive indifference to constructive and courageous action on behalf of all who suffer.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

File:SelmaHeschelMarch.jpg

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
J
SelmaHeschelMarch.jpg (369 294 pixels, file size: 32 KB, MIME type: image/jpeg)

Summary:

Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel , second from right, participating in the civil rights march from Selma to Montgomery , Alabama , on March 21, 1965.

First row, from far left: John Lewis , an unidentified nun, Ralph Abernathy , Martin Luther King, Jr. , Ralph Bunche , Abraham Joshua Heschel , Fred Shuttlesworth .

Second row: Visible behind (and between) Martin Luther King, Jr. and Ralph Bunche is Rabbi Maurice Davis .

They are shown wearing Hawaiian leis thought to be provided by the influential Rev. Abraham Akaka who was then the Kahu of the Kawaiaha'o Church in Honolulu and a friend of Dr. King.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

From the Archive: In Selma, sold-out yarmulkes and Shabbat behind bars
By Gabe Friedman - JTA

This year, many of the conversations surrounding Martin Luther King, Jr. Day have involved the new movie Selma, about he historic marches from Selma to Montgomery in Alabama in 1965.

The film, nominated for the Academy Award for Best Picture on Thursday, has provoked discussion in some Jewish circles, with some having criticized Selma for leaving out mention of Jewish contributions to the civil rights movement and others calling it politically astute and concurring with its focus on African Americans.

Viewers may wish to supplement the film with JTAs coverage at the time, which, not surprisingly, zoomed in on the Jewish role.

After the Bloody Sunday march on March 7, in which many of the 600 protestors were beaten and hit with tear gas, Jews helped ramp up the pressure on President Lyndon Johnson to respond. On March 9, JTA reported that the National Jewish Community Relations Advisory Council (what is now the Jewish Council for Public Affairs) and seven of its affiliate organizations including the National Council of Jewish Women and the Union of Orthodox Congregations of America sent Johnson a telegram demanding that he take immediate action on voting rights legislation for African Americans, who JTA, in the style of the time, referred to as Negroes. Other Jewish organizations, such as the Association of Reform Rabbis of New York City, joined in over the next couple of days with telegrams of their own.

By the last of the three Selma marches, which took place on Sunday March 21 and into the 22nd and 23rd, it became clear that numerous rabbis and other Jews were not just supporting, but actually participating in, the marches inspiring some African American marchers to don yarmulkes in appreciation. JTA reported on March 22:

Hundreds of Negro freedom marchers today wore yarmulkes (skullcaps), in respectful emulation of rabbis who participated in demonstrations in Alabama as Jewish participation in the march from Selma to Montgomery.

The Alabama Negroes called the yarmulkes freedom caps. The demand for yarmulkes was so great that an order has been wired for delivery of 1,000 when the marchers arrive in Montgomery later this week for a great demonstration at the state capitol

While not assuming the Jewish faith, many Negroes adopted the yarmulke as a symbol of their movement.

Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel, who famously walked with Martin Luther King, Jr. at the front of the march to Montgomery, was not the only rabbi on the march. JTA reported that several rabbis were arrested for their participation:

Rabbis jailed by Selma police during the weekend for participating in demonstrations conducted Friday evening services in the Selma Jail, it was learned. Five rabbis recited Hebrew prayers behind prison bars. They have since been released on bond. An estimated 10 to 12 rabbis took part in the march which began yesterday.

Twenty years later, blacks and whites commemorated the events of Bloody Sunday by reenacting the momentous protest in Selma (peacefully this time, of course). JTA reported that Rabbi Alvin Sugarman of Atlanta, who had traveled to Alabama that morning on a bus packed to the limit with black and Jewish members of Atlantas Black Jewish Coalition, addressed the rally in front of the Brown Chapel church with moving words that symbolized how civil rights intersected with his Jewish life:

[Rabbi Sugarman] related an incident that happened only blocks from the Brown Chapel. One morning I came in and a buyer phoned in and said he was late. He came in with mud all over his boots and said, Im sorry son, I was late; I was out in the field beatin up a bunch of niggers. And he said that, Rabbi Sugarman added, as matter of factly as if hed had a flat tire. I never walked in that mans store again, and two years later I left the business world and entered rabbinic school.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

Are you surprised by the lack of acknowledgement given to anyone other than black participants, Len?

Have you ever heard blacks, or Hispanics for that matter, give any thanks to any whites for their help? When you do, please post it.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Somewhat surprised even as I have seen the movement become more racist and leftist. It reinforces the Obama/Selma seed in which I suggested that the Civil Rights movement has morphed to the Black Domination movement, part of the effort to transform America into a socialist state run by non whites.

This view is reinforced by other seeds like the movement's mouthpiece NY TimescroppingGeorge W. Bush out of the photo of the recent Selmamarch and the push to eliminate the Stars and Stripes at UC Irvine. The objective is to completely crop out American history andculture in the newnation.

It is analogous to the Arab maps of the Middle East that crop out Israel.

 
 

Who is online