╌>

The Minimum-Wage Stealth Tax on the Poor -- WSJ By Thomas MaCurdy, Feb. 22, 2015

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  11 years ago  •  2 comments

The Minimum-Wage Stealth Tax on the Poor -- WSJ By Thomas MaCurdy, Feb. 22, 2015

When a fast-food business is forced to raise pay, it also raises prices. Guess who gets hit worst by the increase.

Imagine an antipoverty program with the following elements: a value-added tax in which the effective rate increases as family income declines. The tax revenue is distributed to families regardless of their income. Families below twice the poverty level get only one-third of the revenue, with only half of this amount going to families with children.

Most Americans wouldnt cheer this program, nor would most political leaders champion it. Yet that is what happens when Congress raises the minimum wage.

In a peer-reviewed study, How Effective Is the Minimum Wage at Supporting the Poor? (forthcoming in the Journal of Political Economy), I analyzed who won and who lost after Congress raised the minimum wage in 1996 to $5.15 from $4.25, a raise that occurred in phases over the period 1996-97. That would be comparable to raising the current minimum wage of $7.25 to nearly $8.80. The results show the failure of minimum-wage hikes as an antipoverty policy.

To be sure, companies on their ownsuch as Wal-Mart last weekdo raise the wages of their lowest-paid workers, typically when it is necessary to retain a stable, productive workforce. But this isnt the same as a government-mandated, economy wide raise. Still, most Americans favor such mandated increases because they believe it helps poor workers support their families.

One problem is that only about 5% of families have children and are supported by low-wage earnings; another is that higher minimum wages cause some workers to lose their jobs. Advocates of a higher minimum wage argue that the number of workers who gain far exceeds those who lose. Whatever the credibility of this calculus, there is yet another problem: If someones income is arbitrarily increased thanks to a legislatively mandated wage increase, someone else must pay for it.

Since economic evidence indicates that higher minimum wages dont significantly affect employers profit rates, advocates instead say that employers will pass on these increased labor costs by raising the prices of their goods and servicesand that society, or more affluent consumers, will pay these costs.

But will low-income families earn more from an increase in the minimum wage than they will pay as consumers of the now higher-priced goods? My research strongly suggests that they wont.

The first step in understanding why they wont is to recognize that minimum-wage workers are typically not in low-income families; instead they are dispersed evenly among families rich, middle-class and poor. About one in five families in the bottom fifth of the income distribution had a minimum-wage worker affected by the 1996 increase, the same share as for families in the top fifth.

Virtually as much of the additional earnings of minimum-wage workers went to the highest-income families as to the lowest. Moreover, only about $1 in $5 of the addition went to families with children supported by low-wage earnings. As many economists already have noted, raising the minimum wage is at best a scattershot approach to raising the income of poor families.

The second step is to consider who actually bears the burden of higher labor costs that are passed on through higher prices of goods and services.

My analysis, using the Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Expenditure Survey, showed that the 1996 minimum-wage hike raised prices on a broad variety of goods and services. Food purchased outside of the home bore the largest share of the increased consumption costs, accounting for 21% with an average price increase of slightly less than of 2%; the next highest shares were around 10% for such commodities as retail services, groceries and household personal services.

Overall, the extra costs attributable to higher prices equaled 0.63% of the nondurable goods purchased by the poorest fifth of families and 0.52% of the goods purchased by the top fifthwith the percentage falling as the income level rose.

The higher prices, in other words, resembled a regressive value-added, or sales, tax, with rates rising the lower a familys income. This is sharply contrary to normal tax policy. A typical state sales tax has a uniform ratebut with necessities such as food excluded, and this exclusion (which exists as well in countries with a value-added tax) is adopted expressly to lower the effective tax rate on consumption by people with lower incomes.

My analysis concludes that more poor families were losers than winners from the 1996 hike in the minimum wage. Nearly one in five low-income families benefited, but all low-income families paid for the increase through higher prices.

Consider a McDonalds restaurant, often cited as ground zero in minimum wage debates. To cover costs of a mandated increase in the earnings of McDonalds lowest-paid workers, customers pay more for the companys food. The distributional question becomes: Which group comes from the least well-off families: McDonalds customers or its lowest-paid workers? Economy-wide evidence shows that the customers disproportionately come from low-income families.

Mr. MaCurdy is an economics professor at Stanford University and a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

WSJ Letters

Hidden and Regressive Cost of a Minimum-Wage Rise

The real beneficiaries of a mandated raise of the minimum wage are government taxing bodies.

March 8, 2015 5:39 p.m. ET

Thomas MaCurdy points out how the costs of minimum-wage mandates are disproportionately paid by poor people, reducing their net benefit (The Minimum-Wage Stealth Tax on the Poor, op-ed, Feb. 23).

Many other government mandates impose stealth taxes on the poor. Californias mandate for boutique summer and winter gasoline blends increases gas prices. The poor are disproportionately affected by reduced net income when they travel to work. Mandates for green energy increase electricity costs, disproportionately forcing the poor to shiver and dim the lights. Californias mandated cage sizes for laying hens has sharply increased the price of eggs. Poor people are disproportionately forced to choose between a nutritious breakfast and hunger.

Elite activists who promote such mandates are well off. They congratulate themselves for having brought so much good into the world at such trivial costs. No wonder the more help poor people get from government, the more they seem to need.

Joseph Doll

Saratoga, Calif.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

WSJ Letters

The problem goes even further because the numbers quoted by Mr. MaCurdy leave out more than half of the increases that will have to be paid by both the employee and the employer. Consider these: All retail prices and services will increase, not just the ones in the industries which employ minimum wage workers. State sales taxes will increase on the retail price increase, paid by everyone. State income taxes increase the same amount, paid by the employee. State unemployment taxes increase as they are based on a percentage of total payroll), paid by the employer. Federal unemployment taxes increase the same as the state, also paid by the employer. Social Security and Medicare taxes will increase with more paid by the employee and matched by the employer.

Last but not least, workers' compensation cost will increase because it is based on a percentage of total payroll. It is increased even though there is no increase in risk. Sweet deal!

By the time workers are paid under the new wage, with all of the costs listed above, they wont have an extra nickel to their name on payday. The real beneficiaries of a mandated raise of the minimum wage are government taxing bodies.

Walter Musser

Geneseo, Ill.

 
 

Who is online