╌>

By the Numbers - SCOTUS to Hear Case on the PPACA

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  11 years ago  •  3 comments

By the Numbers - SCOTUS to Hear Case on the PPACA

On Wednesday, the Supreme Court will hear arguments in a case challenging Obamacare . The case, by the numbers:

4 : Words in the law that are in dispute ("established by the state")

34 : States using the federal health insurance exchange, where tax credits could be eliminated

9.3 million : People who would lose tax credits if the court sides with the law's opponents

8.2 million : People at risk of becoming uninsured

35%: Potential average annual premium increase for people using the federal exchange

4: Virginia residents who challenged the law in hopes of avoiding its individual mandate

8%: Percentage of income that health premium must equal to be exempt from the mandate

21: Briefs filed by groups aligned with Obamacare opponents

7: States siding with opponents

31: Briefs filed by groups aligned with the Obama administration

22: States supporting the Obama administration

906: Pages in the Affordable Care Act

60: Senate votes to pass the law in 2009

219: House votes to pass the law in 2010

36B: The section of the Internal Revenue Code establishing rules for the health insurance tax credits

3: Additional lawsuits making the same arguments pending in Indiana, Oklahoma and Washington, D.C.

5: Supreme Court votes needed to win the case the same number Obamacare received in 2012.

Source: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, Urban Institute, USA TODAY research \

http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2015/03/03/supreme-court-obamacare-numbers/24314265/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Regardless of which side of the issue you find yourself, these are interesting numbers that play a significant part in the PPACA, how it became law, why it is being challenged and what effects a decision against might have.

Numbers very interesting thing.s

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

It boils down to a fight over four words in the law: "established by the state." But its implications are mammoth to those with the most at stake:

Tax credits enjoyed by more than 9 million people could be lost if the justices agree with the law's opponents. That would make health insurance unaffordable for most of them. The subsidies are available to individuals and families with income up to 400% of the federal poverty level, or $97,000 for a family of four.

The law's individual and employer mandates would apply to fewer people if the subsidies are struck down. Insurance premiums would cost millions of families more than 8% of their annual income, entitling them to an exemption from the law's mandate that most individuals buy insurance. Many employers, too, would be freed from having to provide coverage if none of their employees was subsidized.

Insurance premiums would rise for those remaining under Obamacare as millions drop out of the market. Many of those remaining would be older and sicker people who require coverage. The average annual premium for people in states using the federal exchange would rise by an estimated 35%, according to the Urban Institute and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

President Obama would see the crowning achievement of his administration crippled. His administration would be pressured to come up with an alternative to salvage the law. Without a fix, his legacy in the area of domestic policy would be tarnished.

Congress would be pressured to devise a solution for the millions of Americans whose health insurance is put at risk. Moderate Republicans in the Senate have proposed a fallback plan, but it lacks support from conservatives and Democrats.

Governors and legislatures in the 34 states that do not operate their own health insurance exchange and have no timetable to do so would be under the gun to create a state exchange something that requires money, technology and political will.

The Supreme Court's reputation is on the line, as Chief Justice John Roberts no doubt realized in 2012 when he rescued the health care law by equating penalties for not buying insurance with a tax that Congress had the power to levy. If opponents win the case, it most likely will be on a 5-4 vote, all five votes coming from justices nominated by Republican presidents.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

The Supreme Court appeared closely divided Wednesday during heated arguments over President Obama's health care law, but questions from Justice Anthony Kennedy gave proponents hope the statute will be upheld.

...

That appeared to leave the law in the hands of two justices: Chief Justice John Roberts, who wrote the 5-4 decision upholding it in 2012, and Kennedy, who asked tough questions of both lawyers arguing the case. Roberts maintained an unusual silence throughout most of the debate.

...

Kennedy, often considered the court's swing vote, said he was concerned that the challengers' view of the health law would create "a serious constitutional problem." But he quickly hedged to say the challengers' view of the law's language may be correct.

The lawyer for the challengers, Michael Carvin, disputed that suggestion. And he returned repeatedly to the wording of the law itself. "This is," he told the justices, " a straightforward case of statutory construction where the plain language dictates the result."

A unanimous decision appears unlikely, according tooddsmakers handicapping the SCOTUS Smile.gif

 
 

Who is online



70 visitors