╌>

Kuwait paper makes up story of Obama threatening to shoot down Israeli planes

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  the-irascible-harry-krishner  •  11 years ago  •  24 comments

Kuwait paper makes up story of Obama threatening to shoot down Israeli planes

Opinion-- but what he says makes a lot of sense:

Al Jarida has a long history of making up absurd scoops.

Last year they pretended to have an exclusive interview with Egypt's Sisi immediately after he was elected president, which was immediately denied - why would Sis choose a Kuwaiti paper for his first post-election interview?

As I wrote in 2012 :

Now, if you were a high-ranking Israeli official, and you wanted to leak a spectacular news story, would you go to a Kuwaiti newspaper? Or would you call up Ha'aretz or the New York Times?

There have been dozens of "scoops" in Kuwaiti newspapers over the years, often about Hezbollah or the PLO. None of them that I remember have ever panned out. (Al Jarida reported that a Shalit deal was imminent - in 2009 ; that Israel was ready to bomb Iran - also in 2009 ; Israel was planning a series of assassinations of Hezbollah and Hamas figures - in 2008 . There are many more.)

The idea that Kuwaiti reporters have better connections in Israel or Lebanon or the territories than local media strains credulity.

I understand that news media want to sell papers, but they should do at least a basic sanity check on items like this. Whatever happened to getting two independent sources?

Articles like these encourage unsavory reporters (and, of course, unethical bloggers) to make things up or to bypass even the most elementary fact checking when breathlessly reporting scoops from anonymous sources. While there will always be unethical bloggers and reporters, it is the responsibility of the more respected media to do a modicum of verification before reporting a story like this - or, at the very least, to inform readers that Al Jarida has a track record of being spectacularly wrong in its scoops.

(LINK)


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    11 years ago

When reading news items, you should always be aware of the source. This is from a weblog that has a right-wing bias. So be aware that he's very opinionated.

However, that being said, my experience is that his actual facts are accurate. In addition, he is more knowlegable about the Middle-East than most weblogs, and in addition often breaks important stories before much of the media.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    11 years ago

I agree.

In fact he makes that very point:

Now, if you were a high-ranking Israeli official, and you wanted to leak a spectacular news story, would you go to a Kuwaiti newspaper? Or would you call up Ha'aretz or the New York Times?

When you think about it-- it seems obvious...

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

There is a article on the front page with this article as it's content. I didn't bother to comment because it's so far out there, that you'd need a space ship to find it.

Think about. If we did shoot down Israeli planes, (and who is to say that we would not get our planes shot down), we have just declared war on Israel. No body in their right mind would do such a thing.

Some people will post the most idiotic crap and than believe it. Talk about the dumbing down of American, this is a classic example.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Maybe you should have read it Kavika. Maybe you could have learned something. I'm inclined to go with this article, Elder, to me is a reliable source and as I stated in the other article I didn't know if it was true or not and didn't push it as being true. I even emphasized that in my comments. Sometimes the dumb downed in America are the ones who refuse to investigate, but rather prefer to remain ignorant.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    11 years ago

If it is so unbelievably stupid why did former SecState Brzezinski recommend it?

Brezinski Calls for Obama to Shoot Down Israeli Jets; "A Liberty in Reverse"

3:38 PM, Sep 19, 2009 By MICHAEL GOLDFARB

In a little noticed interview with the Daily Beast (presumably little noticed because serious people don't read the Daily Beast), Zbigniew Brzezinski suggests that Barack Obama do more than just refuse to support an Israeli strike on Iran's nuclear sites -- the American president must give the order to shoot down Israeli aircraft as they cross Iraqi airspace:

...

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

The first thing Six, is for you to learn how to read. I didn't say I didn't read it, I said I didn't comment.

The dumbing down Six, is the people that will believe or postanything, no matter how far out there, as long as it something derogatory about Obama. You fit the bill.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Well, then if you read it and made the comment you made makes me doubt your ability to comprehend. I posted it and it was posted by many of other sites, one being the Jewish Press which plainly stated in the title the lack of verifiable evidence, which you failed to understand, I guess.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Don't bother Len. We have some real dummies here. Even if they heard Brezinski in person they wouldn't acknowledge it at this time, which he did make that recommendation.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Bought the lie. Got caught with the lie, Now deflecting from the lie

2272_discussions.jpg?width=721

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Len, that's great, shoot down an Israeli aircraft or more than one. What in the world makes you think that anyone would do such a thing. What's more, it seems to be a given that the U.S. would not suffer loses. Israeli planes would respond to any attack, and there is a good chance that American planes would be shot down.

Is that what you want?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

The inability to understand is on your shoulders Six. That's evident from your posts and comments.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

We sure do Six, it's evident from your posts.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Actually what Brzezenski said when asked about how should we deal with Israel if they decide to have an air strike on Iran was "We're not exactly impotent little babies. They have to fly over our airspace in Iraq. Are we just going to sit there and watch"? Believe it or not, that is what he said. He didn't actually say shoot them down, but what does the above comment imply to you by Brzezenski?

Although you are correct he was a private citizen in 2009 when he said that in an interview.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

There is one aspect to consider that pretty much invalidates the entire article.

Israels Air Force is really not capable of effectively striking the nuclear facilities in Iran.

  1. The targets in Iran are disbursed at best setting the Iranians back only a few months if struck.
  2. The reactor in Iraq was pretty much a single target. 990nmi in range. It took 8 strike aircraft carrying two Mk-84s (2000-pounders) with the rest of the hard-points carrying fuel to strike the one target.
  3. To strike Iran, you better figure 1800-2000nmi distance.
  4. While they do have some tankers, they would have to make use of a maximum effort.
  5. Without enough tankers, the US would need to augment them to the point to where we just might as well do it ourselves.
  6. The SAM density in Iran has to taken into consideration, and it is considerable requiring additional aircraft for SEAD strikes, and tankers to support them.
  7. The blind spot along the Saudi border that Israel exploited in the Iraqi radar systems on their ingress and egress routs was found by accident.
  8. Knowing what Israel did with the single target in Iraq, Iran will be keeping a better watch, and will be looking at their air defense systems to minimize weakness.

I could continue with the list of challenges, but given a single sneak strike opportunity, Israel isn't going to hit enough targets with enough bombs to make a difference. So why would they even consider a one-and-done strike given all all the political hell they would have to pay for minimal results? A protracted air campaign would be needed to strike a larger number of suspected facilities, act of war declared, rights to airspace granted. If Israel were to do so, Iran would consider it justification to try to build a nuclear bomb.

My reserve unit back in the 1980s went through very similar strike planning exercises related to Iran. With that little bit of experience in the matter, it is my opinion that Israel would risk losing more than they would ever hope to gain in such an attack. As such, taking this approach of capability vs returns, I would rate this article as a fabrication at best.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

William Randolph Hearst, the father of modern "Yellow" journalism. Used his newspaper to push America into a war with Spain under the ideal of creating a worldwide American empire of influence.

Today, we have come full circle. Politics owns the media and uses the principles of human behavior to drive public opinion. Which is not what Hearst really wanted.

The fact that "Yellow" journalism from another country is being used to foment opinion in this country is a sure sign that the political media leaders in this country have completely gone off the edge of the world.

How anyone could even give this "Story" ANY credibility is just as insane as Hearst was.

Israel does not have the capacity to effectively strike at Iran, Iraq, Yes, but not Iran.

Does the US have the ability to prevent them from doing such an insane action? Absolutely.

But then they go off and SPECULATE on how they would go about doing it, and conclude that American airplanes would enter and undertake offensive military engagement to prevent such.

They speculate to pure fantasy.

The American response would be over the telephone or teletype (if they still use those antiquated machines) and wouldn't involve one single sortie of any American military force.

It would tell them that they are being cut off from all military and economic intelligence information gathered by the US.

It would stop them in their tracks. Israeli intelligence is good, VERY good, but not as good without building upon US support. It would be much more difficult for them to defend themselves without such information. And if that wasn't enough to stop them, have a single AWACS in the air, tracking the attacking force of aircraft, and flip one switch and put their IFF repeaters on every traffic control scope in the region identifying nationality and type of aircraft.

This news article and ALL speculation emanating from it is one of the most blatantly egregious attempts to hoodwink idiots.

I thought most educated Americans would not be fooled by it.

Yellow journalism at it's finest.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

Popular mechanics wrote a story claiming they are capable.

This week the Israeli Air Force (IAF) held a ceremony spotlighting the "operational acceptance" of its biggest unmanned aerial vehicle, the 4.5-ton Heron TP, or "Eitan." The far-flying UAV, with a wingspan almost as long as a 737 airliner, appeared on the runway with a comparatively diminutive F-15 alongside it. The IAF already rushed this UAV into action during the 2008'09 war in Gaza, so the ceremony really served as a reminder to Iran that its drone fleets can reach the nation. But how will Israel use them?

The Eitan can carry a ton of payload and can reach Iran's nuclear facilities, which the United Nations last week determined is hiding an active weapons program. But that does not mean these will be used as bombers. The IAF has been buying and upgrading airplanes specifically for long-distance strikes such as a potential attack against Iran. At least 50 F-15 Raam and F-16 Soufa aircraft have been converted by installing extra fuel tanks for greater range and countermeasures to defeat radar and missiles. So maybe the warplane/UAV tag team presented at the "operational acceptance ceremony" speaks to how manned and unmanned aircraft will work together on missions: The drone provides information while the manned airplanes drop the guided munitions.

2273_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Very good point, and the Eithan is definitely a force multiplier, but only if you have unfettered control of the airspace. UAVs are meat on the table against most modern anti-aircraft systems. Their max speed is 150MPH making them unsuitable as a first strike weapon.

Any strike by Israel on Iran is going to be one of "Shoot and Scoot". The Eithan does not fit into that mission profile. The equation still came out being such that damage vs return was not favor of the Israelis undertaking any sort of strike missions against the twelve known nuclear related sites in Iran.

Politically it would be a decision that would cast them in very harsh light internationally. Something they would regret. Israel does well posing as a victim, thus not something they want to give up with strikes against Iran

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Amen NM.....

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    11 years ago

Zbigniew Brzezinski suggests that Barack Obama do more than just refuse to support an Israeli strike on Iran's nuclear sites -- the American president must give the order to shoot down Israeli aircraft

Well, he's certainly entitled to his opinion.

But let's keep in mind thatZbigniew Brzezinski is not the president of the United States.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

It is really amazing what you find amazing these days Robert.

For you to even consider to supporting what this purported news article claims as being true becomes the icing on the cake for your complete ignorance of facts, details, and capabilities in the entire matter. This is what happens when all you have to live for is to support your continued ODS. How pitiful.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Israel will not attack Iran (with conventional weapons at least), simply if for no other reason that they can't get enough bombs on enough targets. Balance that against what they would end up paying for in the eyes of the international community they would be fools to launch air strikes against Iran

Why are you so hell bent on wanting to attack Iran Robert? I thought you saved all your hatred to support your case of ODS.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

The invasion of Iran was never intended to happen on Obama's watch. The previous administration didn't go big enough when they invaded Iraq, and it set their timetable for the invasion of Iran off. They planned to have invaded Iran before the end of Cheney's second term.

The world had an enemy in Washington known as Neocons, that hailed from the great state of republicanism.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

I have to complement you Robert, you are one of the three best straw-man builders here on NT. Sean, and Six are the other two.

I just cant imagine how empty your life is going to be when Obama is no longer is in office. At one time I'm sure there were other things in your life other than hatred. I fear though in January of 2017, you are going to wake up and find out that hatred is all you have left. May it keep you warm.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

I judge him for what he is for what I'm told he is. Dangerous to us. To our country. Racist. Dangerous to our allies. A friend of thugs. Especially to Muslim thugs.

Since all you have are your opinions in these matter Robert, I though it be best to correct your statement to more clearly mirror reality. Hope you don't mind as it saves you the time.

 
 

Who is online



76 visitors