╌>

"Police Transparency Will Have to Wait"

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jerry-verlinger  •  11 years ago  •  12 comments

"Police Transparency Will Have to Wait"

A bill that would have made public the names and disciplinary files of suspended county police officers was deferred until 2016.
logo-flat.png?width=150
FEBRUARY 27, 2015By NICK GRUBE

A Hawaii senator who is backed by the states powerful police union hit the brakes on a bill Friday that would have made public the names of officers suspended for misconduct.

HPD-Honolulu-Police-Department-1188x792.jpg?width=250 The measure had support from several lawmakers, including Sens. Will Espero and Laura Thielen, who have advocated for more police accountability in response to a number of highly public cases involving officer wrongdoing.

But Sen. Gil Keith-Agaran, who heads the Judiciary and Labor Committee, defered Senate Bill 497 with no discussion, effectively killing the measure in the current session. Keith-Agaran is one of only two senators who have were endorsed by the statewide police officers union in the 2014 elections.

Its disappointing, Espero said after the hearing. I wish we could have sent it over the House. I think it would have sent a strong message.

Senate Bill 497 would have overturned an exemption in the states public records law that allows county police departments to keep secret the names of officers who are suspended for misconduct. All other public employees are subject to public disclosure when they are suspended or fired. The only time officer names are released is when they are terminated.

Civil Beat examined the exemption and its consequences in a 2013 five-part investigative series , In the Name of the Law. The new outlet found that there is little accountability when it comes to officer misconduct. In fact, its rare that bad cops are fired, including in numerous incidents in which they themselves break the law.

Keith-Agaran, however, told Civil Beat after Fridays hearing that its too soon for the Legislature to act. A case pending before the Hawaii Supreme Court will take up the issue after a lower court ruled last year that the names of suspended cops and details about the incidents should be made public. He noted that the measure is not dead. Its only delayed until 2016.

If the Supreme Court says the lower court was correct in reading the statute and says that there was no privacy right implicated then its settled, Keith-Agaran told Civil Beat. If the court rules, though, that the lower court was wrong then that clarifies that this is within the purview of the Legislature and then we can go back in and change the language.

Civil Beat filed a lawsuit in November 2013 after the Honolulu Police Department refused to release the disciplinary files of 12 officers who had been suspended for 20 days or more for serious misconduct between 2003 and 2012. Those officers were disciplined for beating up citizens, assaulting co-workers, drunken driving and falsifying police reports. One officer received a 626 day suspension for hindering a federal investigation.

Hawaii Circuit Court Judge Karl Sakamoto ruled in February 2014 that police, like all other public employees, do not have a right to privacy when they get in trouble. Sakamoto based his ruling on a 1996 Hawaii Supreme Court decision that said essentially the same thing. He also cited a 1997 opinion by the Hawaii Office of Information Practices that concluded the publics right to know about police misconduct outweighs any privacy interest an officer might have.

But SHOPO, the statewide police union, filed an appeal before HPD could release any of the records. The case has since been expedited to the state Supreme Court.

The union has been the driving force behind keeping officer wrongdoing under wraps. Although a case on police disciplinary records was pending before the Supreme Court in 1995, SHOPO lobbied lawmakers that year and succeeded in getting the exemption written into the law. Since then it has vigorously defended the privacy issue.

In fact, this year as lawmakers seemed inclined to toughen laws requiring better oversight of police the union organized dozens of officers, many from Hawaii County, to submit testimony opposing SB497. Most of the testimony follows the same line, that it would be embarrassing to the officers and their families to have their wrongdoing made public. They also argued that it could cause them to freeze up during life or death situations because they will be more concerned about getting in trouble than doing the right thing.

Keith-Agaran said deferral of the measure had nothing to do with the strong union opposition to the bill. Hes one of only two senate candidates endorsed by SHOPO, the State of Hawaii Organization of Police Officers, during the 2014 election. The other was Republican Richard Fale, who lost to Sen. Gil Riviere in November.

Keith-Agaran said SB497 should be approved if the Supreme Court sides with Sakamotos ruling because it will clarify the public records law. He was less certain as to what should happen if the court goes the other way, saying it will be open for debate among his colleagues.

The status quo for most employees is disclosure and for the police the difference is theres no disclosure, for disciplinary purposes, short of dismissal, he said. So the question that will come up is: Are the police so different in terms of the kind of work they do and the kinds of pressures theyre under that they are entitled to different treatment.

He refused to say how he would vote on the measure should the Supreme Court side with SHOPO.

Hawaii Sen. Laura Thielen, who introduced SB497, said its reasonable for Keith-Agaran to delay decision-making on the bill until the high court has an opportunity to act on the Civil Beat case.

If the court sides with SHOPO, she said, the Legislature should still pass the measure next year because she doesnt believe its fair that county police officers can remain anonymous when they get in trouble when all other public employees are subjected to disclosure.

We need to have parity and public access to this information, I think its imperative, Thielen said. Well wait to see what the Supreme Court says to see if we need to bring the measure back.

[ LINK ]


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

"[The] law that allows county police departments to keep secret the names of officers who are suspended for misconduct. All other public employees are subject to public disclosure when they are suspended..."

Why do I get the feeling the cops think they're in a position superior to everyone else?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

foxnews-logo.jpg?width=50 This article is also being discussed in the Fox News Nation group. Use the link to go to the group page to see more articles on this topic, if you're not already a member, you should sign up.

( I know what you're thinking, no, I haven't switched sides, I'm the groups token Liberal )

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

Why do I get the feeling the cops think they're in a position superior to everyone else? Because that's the way it is. We have ourselves to blame for allowing government to grow out of control and the libertarians are the only ones working to cut it down and return the power to the people. Right now we areexperiencingwhat Ayn Randwarned us about.

"We are fast approaching the stage of the ultimate inversion: the stage where the government is free to do anything it pleases, while the citizens may act only by permission; which is the stage of the darkest periods of human history, the stage of rule by brute force."

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

And come 2016, it will be deferred again, sadly.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Jerry

Should the disciplinary actions of all private and public employers be made a matter of public record so that we can review them and so that future employers can review them as well?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Good points

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

We have ourselves to blame for allowing government to grow out of control and the libertarians are the only ones working to cut it down and return the power to the people.

It's not the government that's out of control, it's the LEO's that are out of control. They've convinced themselves they have in absolute control over the citizens of this country. Forty - fifty years ago, is was a rare thing for cop to pull his weapon. Now it seems that's the first thing they do.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

Don't know. Do they make the laws in Hawaii? Like most unions, they try to get laws which are favorable to them passed and supported.

Actually I was beingfacetious, I do know the reason I get that feeling;

Senate Bill 497 would have overturned an exemption in the states public records law that allows county police departments to keep secret the names of officers who are suspended for misconduct. All other public employees are subject to public disclosure when they are suspended or fired. The only time officer names are released is when they are terminated.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

"Should the disciplinary actions of all private and public employers be made a matter of public record ...."

Not private employees, the public doesn't pay them. Cops are paid by you and me, and I have seen many cases where cops have been allowed to remain on the job inspite of numerous disciplinary actions which often include use of excessive force charges.

Many times cops have been firedbecauseof numerous charges of abuse, but because their files are kept secret they have been picked up by other departments where they continue to abuse andintimidatethe public.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

I wish people would spend just half the time seeking the same transparency and accountabilityfrom this corruptadministration, and Governmentas they do hassling LEO.

So do I. When is the last time you seeded an article involving public official corruption?

I seeded this one on January 27th.

"S heldon Silver, a Democrat who has served as the highest-ranking state assemblyman since 1994, was accused in a federal criminal complaint in New York, as authorities moved to seize $3.8 million in proceeds tied to the alleged corruption ."

I understand the need to hold those bad apples accountable for their actions but that doesn't mean you indictthe entire LE system and every good cop who wears a badge.

Why do you assume articles like thisautomaticallycloud the reputations of every good cop on the job? Is itbecausethebad apples do cloud the reputations of every good cop?

What are we supposed to do, ignore the actions of the bad cops, so as not to make the good guys look bad?

if the LEO's don't want their badges tarnished, they need do do a better job keeping the bad guys off the job!

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

Cops don't pass laws, or sign them.

A Hawaii senator who is backed by the states powerful police union hit the brakes on a bill Friday that would have made public the names of officers suspended for misconduct.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

So the disciplinary files of all public employees should be a public record easily accessed and viewed by anyone who wishes to do so

Is that your position

 
 

Who is online



76 visitors