The father of a black teenager murdered by an illegal immigrant asked do black lives really matter? in a House hearing to review the Department of Homeland Securityspolicies towards non-citizens unlawfully present in the United States.
That father, Jamiel Shaw, and Michael Ronnebeck, the uncle of another man murdered earlier this month by an illegal immigrant, testified at Wednesdays hearing in front of a subcommittee of the U.S. House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform.
Both men asserted that Immigration and Customs Enforcements (ICE) lax detainment policies contributed to the death of their family members. ICE came under intense scrutiny last year when it was revealed that in 2013 the agency had released over 36,000 convicted criminal aliens from its custody. Of those, nearly 200 had committed murder.
Shaw told of his son, Jamiel Shaw II, who in May 2008 at the age of 17 was gunned down by Pedro Espinoza, a 19-year-old illegal Mexican immigrant.
My familys peace and freedom were stolen by an illegal alien from Mexico. He was brought here by his illegal alien parents, Shaw told the hearing, chaired by Florida U.S. Rep. Ron DeSantis.
Shaw described that his son, a standout football and track star in Los Angeles, was walking down his own street when he was accosted by Espinoza and a friend.
Shaw said that it was proved in court that Espinoza who was in a Latino gang targeted his son because he was black.
Do black lives really matter? Or does it matter only if you are shot by a white person or a white a policeman? the elder Shaw asked during his testimony, referencing a phrase that became popular following the police-involved deaths of two black men, Michael Brown and Eric Garner.
Espinoza who was eventually sentenced to death in the murder had three gun charges on his record and had served only four months of an eight month sentence for assault with a deadly weapon and battery of a police officer. He was released from jail the day before he murdered Shaw.
Why was this violent illegal alien allowed to walk the streets of America instead of being deported? Shaw asked.
Why was ICE not called to pick up this violent invader? We were promised that the federal government would keep us safe from violent illegal aliens?
I see in here black politicians, black athletes, black stars say hands up, dont shoot," Shaw said referencing another slogan adopted by Brown and Garner protesters. My son was shot in the head by an illegal alien gangbanger while he lay on his back with his hands up. He still shot him through his hand and into his head and killed him.
The duty of the U.S. government is to always put American families first, Shaw concluded.
The House panel then heard testimony from Ronnebeck.
His nephew, 21-year-old Grant Ronnebeck, was murdered last month while working an overnight shift at a Mesa, Ariz. convenience store.
Apolinar Altamirano, a 29-year-old illegal immigrant who claimed to have ties to the Mexican Mafia, shot Ronnebeck in the face while purchasing a pack of cigarettes.
In Aug. 2012 he was arrested along with two others after kidnapping, sexually assaulting and burglarizing a woman in her apartment.
He pleaded guilty to felony burglary and was sentenced to two years probation and turned over to ICE.
But ICE released him on bond pending a deportation hearing.
In that time, he had two orders of protection filed against him one of which was by a women who claimed Altamirano threatened to kill her and pointed a gun at her boyfriend.
ICE was notified of the protection orders, but Altamirano was still allowed to be free in our country, Ronnebeck said
ICE should be doing its job for the American people with the America peoples safety and security first and foremost in mind, Ronnebeck said in emotional testimony.
Also testifying Wednesday was Jessica Vaughan, a policy director at the Centers for Immigration Studies, who called ICEs detainment policies and procedures nothing more than a catch and release program.
She also blamed the Obama administration for further weakening the agencys resolve to detain and deport dangerous illegal immigrants.
The vast majority of illegal aliens residing in the interior face no threat of deportation, regardless of when or how they arrived, or if they have been deported before, Vaughan said in a prepared statement. Many deportable aliens who are encountered and apprehended by Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers are released soon after, even if they have come to ICEs attention after being arrested by local authorities.
This state of affairs can be traced directly to policy changes put in place by the Obama administration. While administration officials claims that these policies are smarter and more effective and allow the agencies to better focus on aliens who represent a threat to the public, in reality the intent, and certainly the result, has been the dismantlement of effective enforcement.
The immigration issue has been on the front pages of the media and on the television and radio every day. But this story, and others like it have not.
This is the question many would like an answer to.
This state of affairs can be traced directly to policy changes put in place by the Obama administration. While administration officials claims that these policies are smarter and more effective and allow the agencies to better focus on aliens who represent a threat to the public, in reality the intent, and certainly the result, has been the dismantlement of effective enforcement.
Do legal U. S. Citizens lives matter to this administration?
Horrible situation! I feel so very sorry for that father and the family of the shot teen!
The system is broken.
"Broken" just means that it is not working, to me. Looking it up on the Merriam Webster dictionary, it does not necessarily distinguish it as an "accident"... It's a more complex definition, with many different subtleties.
The answer to that has been demonstrated several times.
Several of us have facetiously asked the question of what the administration would do when there arose a conflict between illegal aliens and blacks. Now we know.. it will be ignored as if it never happened.
There is something else this article demonstrates... we have been told several times that only non-violent aliens would be allowed to remain here. Lie. Another lie.
This immigration policy puts Americans in danger; he knows it. It has been demonstrated in courts, yet he insists on proceeding with it. That makes him irresponsible and careless at the least, and a traitor at the mos.
flameaway,
Your post implies that the Republican party is the only party that uses public information to further their own selfish agenda.
Touche!
Guess only Republicans want the law followed 'cause the Dems sure as hell don't.
"Also testifying Wednesday was Jessica Vaughan, a policy director at the Centers for Immigration Studies, who called ICEs detainment policies and procedures nothing more than a catch and release program.
She also blamed the Obama administration for further weakening the agencys resolve to detain and deport dangerous illegal immigrants." - Oops - is she really implying that this DEMOCRATIC administration is breaking the law????
BUSH DID IT - BUSH DID IT - BUSH DID IT!!!!
Typical liberal comment - thanks for being totally predictable.
How many citizens have been killed, raped etc by illegal aliens since Obama was inaugurated? Has the President ever said a word about that problem? Not that I can think of.
I have heard the President and his AG talk repeatedly about protecting Muslim Americans from supposedly vengeful American citizens. How many Muslims have been killed because of their race?
Does that make it acceptable? Illegals are arrested, not deported, released and kill citizens. How is that okay?
People freak the fuck out because a cop does his job improperly and kills a guy in NYC. when the government fails to do its job and fails to deport criminals and they kill numerous citizens you get silence. Those citizens were killed by the failure of government just as surely as that guy in NYC.
Blacks are NOT pro amnesty. 64% (previous article/thread) of the Blacks are totally against Obama's lack of immigration policies/enforcements because of the jobs they have no opportunity to apply for/fill because of the illegal-aliens.
Well, they do to me, but what has Obama, Eric Holder, Al Sharpton or Jessie Jackson have to say about this case?
Nothing you have said here changes the fact that these young men were killed by illegal aliens who had already committed felony acts and who the courts here had released to roam the streets and prey on citizens, flame.
Regardless of the motives of the Republicans, facts are facts. Obama lied when he said illegal alien felons would not be allowed to stay and that they would not be allowed freedom while awaiting deportation.
Is there anything at all you and a few others here won't excuse this administration for?
Nothing said changes the fact that the courts released illegal aliens known to have committed felonies.... something the people were assured over and over would not happen.
And the Obama administration.. you remember, the people in power?... have said no deportations.
The courts knew these were dangerous felons yet released them to roam and prey on citizens... knew they were illegal aliens yet released them instead of immediately deporting them.
Lies upon top of lies.
He's certainly got nothing on you, because you're trying to change the direction of the article.
The topic here is dangerous illegal alien felons being released into communities instead of being held for deportation. In one of these cases, the illegal shot and killed the young man two days after being released from jail (served eight months on a felony illegal weapons charge).
Didn't read the article, did you, bf?
That's about two (2) young black men killed by illegal aliens. One was actually an "A" student in high school with a bright future and other was holding down a night job in a convenience store.
Your comment indicates you have no concern for the number of felony criminals released onto the public by the administration's orders. One of these killers was released after serving only eight months for felony burglary, kidnapping, and sexual battery; two days later he killed one of these young men.
These two illegals are a representation of felonious illegals turned out on the public, bf. The actual count is in the hundreds.
Do you think there is a bigger issue for the families of these two young men?
@Six:
Not a word. Wasn't a white man who killed them, or a police officer.
Stories of people killed by illegals are suppressed on purpose (wonder why) the only reason there was a story on this one is because the kid was black and one of his parents had the opportunity to make a statement in front of the media.
...
yep, instead of deporting criminals like this even after they are caught committing a crime. BO want's to give them all jobs/citizenship and let them stay. It is maddening that this dirt bag was not deported.
Yeah - and you still don't know how to read an article and discuss it.
Nope - just deport them.
36,000+ criminal illegal aliens were released to the "public" yard by Ohama - and the damage has started.
Read the article.
The felons should be jailed until they can be deported. Do you have a problem with that, flame?
flame, Obama's administration's policy is to release them. He has sent word to ICE and federal judges to release them.
What part of that is so difficult for you to understand and accept?
Thank you for trying to help flame with his "social studies" 1stwarrior. Seems to be a losing endeavor.
flame only reads what he wishes to read and it has to be from a leftist liberal swinging republican hating white dominating dominatrix site.
Actually, 96, it was two dirt bags. And one of them killed one of the young men two days after being released from jail after serving eight months for breaking into a woman's house, kidnapping, and sexually assaulting her. Imagine, just eight months, he was an illegal alien and was released back into the community. Two days later he robbed the convenience store when this young black man was working and shot him in the face.
The other illegal shot and killed an "A" level high school student walking home who was also an athlete with a good future in store for him. The boy was on the ground with his hands up begging, "Don't shoot!" when the illegal shot through his hand and the round passed on into his head.
This is kind of like "one mans trash is another man's treasure". Sure you and I think it is "broken" but as Robert has pointed out, this is by design. There is a reason you don't hear stories about the THOUSANDS killed every year by illegals. The numbers are alarming when you take into consideration how many stories you hear about it. The average is about 4800 people in the US killed PER YEAR by illegals.
This is an accurate and to the point summation Mimi.
They are certainly "trotted up" to massive media coverage. What difference does the geographical location of the coverage make?
Not a damn peep. That could throw a wrench in immigration and amnesty plans.
Yea I tried to change that line but for some reason it wouldn't accept the changes. the sad facts are that this shit happens to the tune of about 4800 people per year killed by illegals. Check some of the links I have put in other comments. I think those that do will be shocked.
You got it half right. He released them. I am sure, however, given his track record, that he had absolutely no clue how many of them were criminals
No excuse for the "catch and release" of illegal aliens committing crimes.
What is despicable is that you won't/can't discuss the issue of the thread without turning it into YOUR agenda.
I was, but for those on the other side of the political spectrum? it is what they expected, and with current policy shifts, it is what they WANT.
So no I don't think it will shock them.
Good question Max!
When Trayvon Martin was murdered, then Michael Brown and all the others when the same question was asked the white tap dancers couldn't keep their feet still.
Of course black lives matter, but to some, only when killed by another minority and then the pontification begins.
My answer to the question
Any innocent life taken by a criminal act represents a tragedy and an outrage.
Really?
Interesting we're having this discussion as Republicans are about to cause the furlough of, among others, BORDER PATROL AGENTS.
Oh, one more thing, was there a GUN involved in this killing?
The best way to get rid of illegals is to
1) Indict, send to trial, convict and shut down the business that knowingly hire illegals to fatten their bottom lines like the Republican-backing corporate farms foe example.
2) Legalize the drugs that are now sold illegally fuck the politicians that either look the other way, are in on the deals, or, pander to the holier-than-thou-prohibitionist-moralists.
Obama has deported more illegals than his predecessors.
POSTING THIS AGAIN SO THAT PRETENDING IT NEVER APPEARED WILL BE MORE DIFFICULT.
flameaway,
You are probably correct, but they cannot honestly say they weren't shown the error of their assertion.
'Course, what do they honestly say?
when you call out a political party to be the sole cause of society's ills, it just makes you appear ignorant, but, hey, go for it, you always do.
interesting that you capitalize "democrat party" but fail to spell the word correctly, it's democratic party, robert, not "democrat party". but you knew that.
For the umpteenth time, murders of all kinds are predominantly "opportunistic," that is, where demographics are comprised of same-race killers-victims, PROXIMITY is a major component. In other words, the killings are not race-hate motivated.
BUT WHEN KILLINGS ARE RACE-RELATED, THEY NEED TO BE CALLED OUT FOR WHAT THEY ARE.
That this reality does not fit neatly into your selective outrage model is either because you don't want it to for political reasons, or, because you simply can't grasp it.
AND YOU NEVER MENTION THE GUNS INVOLVED IN THESE KILLINGS.
Straw man time. The reality is that Republican-supporting Corporate Agriculture is the single, largest employer of illegal workers.
Nothing about this Front Page pisses me off more than when I post (multiple times) facts that debunk the myths on any number of subjects -- ONLY TO HAVE THE SAME MYTHS/LIES REPEATED IN THE SAME THREADS AS IF THE FACTS WERE NEVER POSTED!
And again
The best way to get rid of illegals is to
1) Indict, send to trial, convict and shut down the business that knowingly hire illegals to fatten their bottom lines like the Republican-backing corporate farms foe example.
2) Legalize the drugs that are now sold illegally fuck the politicians that either look the other way, are in on the deals, or, pander to the holier-than-thou-prohibitionist-moralists.
Obama has deported more illegals than his predecessors.
POSTING THIS AGAIN SO THAT PRETENDING IT NEVER APPEARED WILL BE MORE DIFFICULT.
And
Pat,
There are people here who are regularly, on almost every comment they make, accusing and calling out the republican party for every societal ill in this country and every problem around the world.
I'm surprised it even bothers you at this point.
The question asked by the BLACK man at the hearing is the point of the article, not the party holding the hearing.
Mac,
Guns are not the point of this article.
Illegal aliens... with violent felony histories... who were released back into society and quickly committed murders, are the subject of this article.
This president promised that felons would not be given amnesty, that felons would be quickly deported. This president and his administration have lied to the people of this country about illegal alien felons. There is no getting around it.
Again, GUNS are not the subject of this article.
flame,
getting tired of your "hate" accusations when things don't go your way in threads such as these.
Hate has nothing to do with the FACT that Obama and his administration promised that dangerous felons would be quickly tried and deported.. NOT RELEASED BACK ONTO THE STREETS AND INTO SOCIETY TO KILL.
One more "hater" comment from you on this article and I will ask a moderator to kick you off it.
You can hate the killer illegal alien, but calling commenters here who hate the killers will not be tolerated any more.
Show me the specifics on that Sean.
When I post a statement, I post information that has been placed ON THE RECORD BY A SOURCE. When sources go "on the record" rather than making pronouncements, they do so to indicate their credibility and willingness to stand by their assertions.
ON THE RECORD
All the right wing blather about fudged numbers come as pronouncements but, all right, show me the particulars and we'll go from there.
Otherwise, I will assume that the usual smear crap is in play.
That is your interpretation Mac.
Those instances were disputed by commenters here because of the circumstances of their deaths. Like it or not, not everyone around the country agreed with each other about those circumstances.
We will not debate Martin and Brown's deaths on this article.
Again, this article is about illegal aliens WHO HAVE COMMITTED VIOLENT FELONIES BEING RELEASED BACK INTO SOCIETY INSTEAD OF BEING DEPORTED. which is not what Obama and his administration promised the people of this country when discussing his amnesty program.
Sorry mimi, no, it's not. It's about
Do Black Lives Really Matter?
I didn't write the headline. I just provided information addressing it.
mimi - as usual, flame is trying to turn YOUR thread/article into HIS thread/article.
He just "hates" it when others show better discussions skills than he - (as if he had any).
36,000+ CRIMINAL illegal aliens released and this administration just can't seem to understand why folks are upset about it. Yup - "if I had a son . . . . . ." - don't think barry would be talking like that if either of his children were at the end of a criminal illegal aliens weapon - do you?
Duuhhhhh - c'mon A. Mac, read the damn thread. BOTH kids were killed by guns carried by criminal illegal aliens - betcha neither one of them bought them "Legally" either - how 'bout you?
And you didn't read the article either - obviously.
I am telling you, flame, to stick to the subject of the article.
It is about criminal illegal aliens, violent illegal alien felons, who were turned back into society and who killed almost immediately upon release.
They are not the only ones. They are just two who happened to be mentioned in this article.
Stick to it.
Yes, that's the title, which leads into the entire article being about illegal aliens who committed dangerous felonies, being released into society with a slap on the hand, and killing almost immediately, instead of being deported.
If it will keep things on topic, I can change the title.
(eyes flame and flame jr.)
OK, whatever -
I read Tucker Carlson's every word, 1st.
What's the headline?
Regardless of who kills whom, innocent lives matter regardless of race, religion, gender, shoe size, favorite color
The outrage expressed by the bigoted right regarding the unjustified deaths of minorities, only surfaces when a non-white or, in this case, an illegal immigrant kills a black person!
If we deported every illegal immigrant tomorrow, murders of every variety would continue.
Deport the f'n guns without them, it would be somewhat more difficult for "people to kill people."
Illegal immigration is a problem, NO ARGUMENT, but it's not due to Obama; it's due to their primary incentives to come to the U.S. -- to find work or sell drugs.
And I have posted twice, what to do about those incentives.
I answered you. Are we talking about whether or not black lives matter or what to do about illegals in the U.S. ?
I HAVE COMMENTED HEREIN ON BOTH.
How about we discuss what I write rather than summary dismissals that evade whate I write?
Duhhhhh
"The father of a black teenager murdered by an illegal immigrant asked do black lives really matter?
Apolinar Altamirano, a 29-year-old illegal immigrant who claimed to have ties to the Mexican Mafia, shot Ronnebeck in the face while purchasing a pack of cigarettes."
That is the subject matter of the thread A. Mac - not how many deportations of how great this administration has done in its dealings with illegal aliens. The answer to both has been discussed many, many times.
Let's stick to these two "victims".
Let there be no misunderstanding, I AM AS OUTRAGED AS ANYONE OVER TRAGEDIES SUCH AS THE ONE REPORTED IN THIS SEEDED ARTICLE -- BUT LET'S NOT USE IT TO AVOID THE REALITIES AND USE IT TO BASH OBAMA.
And now for some actual information
Fox Uses Misleading Report From Anti-Immigrant Group To Stoke Fears Of Violent Undocumented Immigrants
March 31, 2014 5:12 PM EDT THOMAS BISHOP
The source of the incendiary statistics often cited or alluded to in these kinds of article
Yes I copied and pasted it (I could only memorize the first few hundred words) IT'S INFORMATION don't attack the messenger because you don't want to be made aware of the message.
A. Mac - all we really need is your synopsis - we don't need the whole dissertation. In fact, we could "probably" understand it better without the dissertation.
Actually, what you want is to fire the shots without having any return fire.
Those who want to understand, logically want information not rhetorical, one-line pronouncements.
Synopsis? Tell you what
FREE KNOWLEDGE, BRING YOUR OWN CONTAINER.
BE IT A BUCKET OR A THIMBLE -- I WILL TRY TO FILL IT TO OVERFLOWING.
When people stop posting crap -- VERBATIM (COPIED AND PASTED YET -- BUT THEY BITCH WHEN I DO IT TO CORRECT THEM) SEEDED ARTICLES, WORD-FOR-WORD MISINFORMATION-LADENED BLATHER -- it won't be necessary to both call them out and provide the facts!
It's Newtonian; "for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction."
Post misinformation -- receive information.
I like to live in the fact-based world
and yet, I spend so much time casting pearls in La-la Land.
Go figure.
Don't care for lengthy truth? Then let's not have the lengthy lies interwoven in factual articles.
Don't believe you'll find more that four to six sentences in any of my comments. Part of my training - short, sweet and concise. Gets the point across so much easier - or so the prof sez.
The problem with brevity on these threads, is that when it represents an inconvenient truth, the ones it's directed at usually ignore it, dismisses it with a one-line, off handed quip or pronouncement and then go right back to posting the falsehood that started it all or go to another falsehood.
Knowing this, I prefer to carpet bomb with information then refer the recalcitrant one back to the full monty.
In an arbitration or other venue involving neutral third parties, I'll give all the synopses necessary, but here, we're dealing with folks who wrap the lies of their agendas in a somewhat factual package and then when challenged, insist on their detractors discussing ONLY THE PARTIALLY TRUE PORTION.
Sorry don't want an ass whoopin', don't post crap lies in a thin disguise.
NOTE: From time-to-time, I think it's important in these threads, to tell certain people that debate isn't personal and that we just disagree. So, 1st, I respect our ability to debate and still like and respect each other.