╌>

Warren Buffett Really Likes Oil Trains — Despite the Explosions

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sixpick  •  11 years ago  •  5 comments

Warren Buffett Really Likes Oil Trains — Despite the Explosions

July 29, 2014 |

Watch the VICE News documentary "Bomb Trains" here.

The people in the Musi-Caf had no idea what hit them. At about 1am on July 6, 2013, a train parked on a slope a couple miles away slipped its brakes. Seventy-two tank cars loaded with crude oil accelerated into the town of Lac-Mgantic, Quebec, and began to tumble off the tracks, detonating and burning with a force so powerful that it leveled several city blocks. Forty-seven people were killed most of whom were inside the Musi -Caf.

In the months that followed, Lac-Mgantic became a rallying cry, a bloody shirt waved by activists across North America who were growing increasingly concerned about a relatively new phenomenon: ultra-long trains loaded with a peculiar variety of crude oil.

Months later, after several other oil train accidents, Warren Buffett went on CNBC claiming that oil train explosions were very, very, very, very rare .

If Buffett sounded defensive, it may have been because he is the single most important person in the world of oil-by-rail, an industry that he dominates and that has proven to be highly profitable for oil companies and railroads and singularly dangerous to the public.

* * *

Depending on your definition of "rare," Buffetts assurances don't appear to mesh with reality. In November 2013, an oil train in rural Alabama derailed and burst into flames that could be seen 10 miles away; the cargo eventually ended up as a smoking oil slick in a marsh.

In December 2013, an oil train struck a grain train outside Fargo, North Dakota. It spilled 400,000 gallons of crude and burst into a towering mushroom cloud. Dumbstruck drivers captured the incident on video and posted it to YouTube.

In January 2014, another train exploded in a remote part of New Brunswick.

Then in April, an oil train passing through Lynchburg, Virginia jumped off the tracks. The resulting conflagration towered above town and burned so hot that office workers on the sixth floor of a building 200 yards away reported feeling the heat. The fiery oil tankers fell into the James River. If they had instead tipped over in the direction of town, there's no telling what could have happened.

Earlier this month, an oil train moving between rail yards in downtown Seattle derailed but this time, the tank cars did not breach. A railroad representative said there had been no danger to the public.

* * *

Although trains in North America have moved small quantities of oil for decades, it is only in the last several years that oil trains have emerged as a high-volume delivery device a rickety pipeline on rails.

The revolution started in the shale beneath western North Dakota, a region known as the Bakken formation. About five years ago, new fracking and horizontal drilling techniques unleashed a gusher of light crude into a region not well-served by pipelines. Railroads were quick to step into the breach, loading oil into just about any tank cars they could get their hands on, including a notorious model, the DOT-111, that federal safety investigators have been flagging as being unsafe for transporting hazardous substances for 20 years. By 2013, rail car shipments of crude were 50 or 60 times more common than they had been only a few years before, and railroads were moving the stuff to just about every corner of the continent.

Buffetts Berkshire Hathaway is owner of the biggest player in hauling Bakken oil by rail: Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railway (BNSF) . And it isnt a minor player in Berkshire Hathaway's impressive portfolio BNSF was the " largest purchase in Berkshire's history ." Last year, BNSF had revenues totaling more than $22 billion.

Last week, federal regulators proposed new rules that were widely heralded as a victory for public safety. But in reality, the oil-by-rail industry got most of what it wanted.

The company is no stranger to oil train problems. The oil train that tipped over in central Seattle was on BNSF tracks, as was the one that blew up near Fargo. Following that explosion, the Federal Railroad Administration revealed that since 2006 in the state of North Dakota alone, BNSF received 721 safety violations .

Buffett likes to maintain an avuncular and public-spirited image, but the railroad industry fights bitterly against better safety standards and often cloaks itself with intermediaries. In the regulatory arena, Berkshire-owned firms are represented by active membership in an alphabet soup of trade associations and industry lobbying groups, including the American Association of Railroads, the Railway Supply Institute, and the North American Freight Car Association.

Industry groups have opposed removing the outlet valves that protrude from the bottom of DOT-111 tank cars. Federal investigators have concluded that removing the valves would yield a significant improvement to tank car safety and could be easily accomplished. But because removing the valves would also necessitate modifying oil loading and unloading infrastructure infrastructure the oil industry is building at a breakneck pace the oil-by-rail industry has opposed reform.

Beleaguered by bad press about oil train explosions, in February BNSF announced plans to purchase 5,000 new, safer tank cars though the company declined to specify a timeline for when it might actually take delivery. Just two days earlier, BNSF had lobbied the Washington state legislature to oppose a bill asking for basic disclosure about oil trains. A few weeks before that, BNSF had lobbied in opposition to union-supported safety legislation to require at least two-person crews on oil and other freight trains. The explosion in Lac-Mgantic occurred on an oil train manned by a single crew member.

Last week, federal regulators proposed new rules that were widely heralded by the media as a victory for public safety. But in reality, the oil-by-rail industry got most of what it wanted. Even if the rules take effect they could be amended a great deal after the current 60-day period for public comment railroads will still be able to string together 100-car trains composed of older DOT-111 tankers for the next three years. The feds will allow bottom outlet valves, and effectively exempted short oil trains of 20 tank cars or fewer from any new regulations at all.

Do you live in a bomb train blast zone? Find out here.

Buffett is rightly regarded as a legendary investor, a man who has made many enormously successful bets, including the one he made when he bought BNSF in the midst of the Great Recession. (At the time, he referred to the acquisition as an all-in wager on the economic future of the United States.) Now he's betting with peoples lives with every oil train traveling on BNSF's network. There is nothing stopping Buffett and the tank car industry from decommissioning the outdated tank cars, running only new or retrofitted tank cars, and eliminating bottom outlet valves.

Nothing, that is, except for the profits those measures would temporarily burn.

~~Link~~


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    11 years ago

Somebody help me out. Didn't a train carrying oil set a river on fire in West Virginia in the last week or so?

You know how much Warren Buffett donated to Obama's campaign? Do you know for every day the Keystone Pipeline isn't operating Buffett makes millions since he owns most all the railways that are used to transport oil? For everything there is a purpose.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    11 years ago

Spilled Oil Keeps Flames Burning After a Train Derailment in West Virginia

February 17, 2015

~VIDEO~

BOOMER, W.Va. A train hauling millions of pounds of crude oil that derailed on Monday was still burning Tuesday night as oil poured from the wreckage.

Residents relied on bottled water that was trucked into town after the utility West Virginia American Water, fearing that oil had been dumped into the Kanawha River, closed a treatment plant downstream, in Montgomery, on Monday. The company reopened the plant on Tuesday afternoon, saying tests had shown nondetectable levels of the components of crude oil in the river. Still, aerial photographs appeared to show oil in a nearby creek, and the utility advised its 2,000 customers in the area to boil water before using it.

The CSX train, with 109 tanker cars and two locomotives, derailed about 1:20 p.m. here in the southern part of the state, sending fireballs ripping through the air. The governors office released a statement Tuesday saying that 26 tankers had derailed and that 19 of those tankers were involved in the fire.

Spills and fires in derailments have prompted concerns about the safety of transporting oil by rail. In 2011, the American Association of Railroads required that new tanker cars meet higher standards to resist rupture in accidents, though it did not require refitting older cars. CSX said the tankers in Mondays crash had all been built to the new specifications.

Scattered fires still burned in pools of oil late Tuesday, the dark plume of smoke visible from many miles away, and a bitter aroma of burning plastic filled the air. Several tankers were charred an oily black, all their markings obscured.

In the derailment, several tanker cars jumped the tracks entirely, piling against each other at odd angles or tumbling down the riverbank. There were multiple explosions, as flames shot hundreds of feet in the sky. Residents, some of whom were ordered to evacuate, said at least one house had burned to the ground in a few minutes, and firefighters from several surrounding departments fought the blaze in frigid conditions, with temperatures of 13 degrees or less.

It was like a 500-pound bomb going off, said Brandon Truman, 32, a veteran of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan who lives in this town, which is across the ice-clogged river from the crash site. You could feel the pressure and the heat.

He and his neighbors said the second blast had been the biggest, rattling their houses and their nerves. Residents noted the presence of chemical plants in the region and said their fear had initially been compounded by wondering what kinds of toxins might have been in the rail cars.

We ran because we didnt know what it was, Mr. Truman said.

Leslie Bowles, who lives on the same short street, said, It literally blew my door open. Ms. Bowles said she had loaded her two small children into a car driven by her father-in-law and just said, Go. Just said, Get out of here.

She and her husband, James, along with many of their neighbors, found their own vehicles stuck in the snow, and they fled on foot.

Cameron Sigmon, 12, said he and his sister had run down to the frozen road, without socks, carrying their dogs.

Heck yeah, I was scared, he said. I thought I was going to die.

About 200 to 300 people were ordered by the local authorities to evacuate on Monday. They took shelter in schools, a fire station and a community center, said Jennifer Sayre, the Kanawha County manager. The railroad has made arrangements for some families to get hotel rooms, she said.

Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin declared a state of emergency in Kanawha and Fayette Counties on Monday. CSX and local officials said that one person had been treated for possible respiratory trouble related to the accident but that they knew of no other injuries. It was not clear if any structures were damaged, but several hundred homes lost electricity.

The train was carrying oil from North Dakota to a ship terminal in Yorktown, Va.

Such accidents have become more common as oil shipment by rail has soared with the boom in oil production from the Bakken shale formation underlying parts of the northern Plains states and central Canada. Before 2009, fewer than 10,000 tank cars of oil were transported by rail each year in the United States, according to the railroad association , but that traffic jumped to more than 230,000 cars in 2012, and more than 430,000 in 2013.

The federal Department of Transportation has proposed even tougher standards for tankers, and the Canadian authorities have required the retrofitting of older cars by 2017.

State, federal and CSX investigators were headed to the scene of the crash here to determine the cause and the extent of environmental damage.

It was not clear whether the unusually low temperatures or the snowstorm barreling through the region at the time had played a role in the accident.

~Link~

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    11 years ago

Look at all these disasters. It seems the Liberals are not concerned with disasters that are related to Liberals. That's where we differ. A disaster is a disaster whether it is tied to the left or right.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    11 years ago

Did Warren Buffett Railroad President Obama?

President Barack Obamas decision to withhold approval of the Keystone XL pipeline will hugely benefit one of his largest supporters Warren Buffett .

Buffett made a $34 billion dollar investment in the Burlington Northern Santa Fe railroad (BNSF) one year after Obama was elected. BNSF essentially invented the business of carrying crude oil by rail when it launched its first long oil train in 2009. Rail shipments from North Dakota have surged from fewer than 100,000 barrels a day in 2010 to 800,000 barrels a day last October.

No wonder Buffet has such a good friend in the White House.

President Barack Obama presenst a 2010 Presidential Medal of Freedom to Warren Buffett, Tuesday, Feb. 15, 2011, during a ceremony in the East Room of the White House in Washington. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster)

President Barack Obama presenst a 2010 Presidential Medal of Freedom to Warren Buffett, Tuesday, Feb. 15, 2011, during a ceremony in the East Room of the White House in Washington. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster)

Mr. Obama sites environmental issues as the key reason to hold up the Keystone XL Pipeline. But his rhetoric is more fiction than fact.

Three years of State Department environmental impact studies have found no significant impacts. The truth is that the pipeline poses a far smaller environmental risk than moving oil by train.

While most crude oil is transported by pipeline, rail transport has been steadily increasing from 9,500 carloads in 2008 to 407,000 carloads in 2013 according to the Association of American Railroads . Moving oil by rail has come under increased scrutiny since the derailment and explosion of a train carrying crude in Lac-Megantic, Quebec last July in which 47 people were killed. More crude oil was spilled in American rail incidents in 2013 than in the previous four decades, according to a McClatchy Newspaper analysis of federal data.

The Keystone XL pipeline was supposed to link Alberta, Canada to the Texas Gulf Coast, thereby increasing U.S. independence from Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries. Canadian crude imports by rail have jumped from 1.6 million barrels to 40 million barrels from 2010 to 2013.

The Keystone XL pipeline is a no brainer. It makes no sense to move this oil by rail when a pipeline can do the same job with far greater safety and at a far lower price.

AP Photo

AP Photo

Transporting crude oil by rail cost $10 to $15 a barrel compared to $5 a barrel by pipeline. Clearly the president is not concerned with the cost of transporting oil. He is far more concerned with making sure that his primary contributor continues to make millions from moving oil.

Mr. Obama professes to be a man of the people, but which people? The super rich continue to do very well with Obama in the White House.

The Keystone XL pipeline will help us reduce the need for Arabian oil. If we can break the hold of OPEC and gain energy independence, we can also change our footprint in the Middle East. Without the need of Saudi Arabian crude, we could let the Middle East drown in its oil. We could pull our troops out of Saudi Arabia and other Middle Eastern countries, thereby significantly reducing our military expense.

Like a ship without a rudder, we continue to flounder without the leadership necessary to secure our energy independence.

The president knows how to do one thing well campaign. Six years into his presidency, when he is not playing golf, Mr. Obama travels throughout the U.S. in search of money to secure his political aims. One thing he is not in search of is what it takes to be a leader.

Until we can elect a president with wisdom and foresight we will continue to muddle along in endless debates about how to secure our energy independence.

~Link~

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

In many of these instances, rail and roadbed conditions that these trains were running on were marginal. The lack of maintenance on these rail lines is mirrored in the age and need of replacement of pipelines moving oil, and natural gas.

When a company needs to make more profit, where is always one of the first areas cut.....preventative maintenance! This is true from aviation to zoo keeping.

 
 

Who is online


67 visitors