╌>

The "Catastrophic Shutdown Of America's Supply Chain" Begins

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  11 years ago  •  37 comments

The "Catastrophic Shutdown Of America's Supply Chain" Begins

Submitted by Tyler Durden on 02/12/2015 23:20 -0500

One week ago, when previewing what may be the first lockout of the West Coast Ports since 2002, we cited the Retail Industry Leaders Association who, realizing that failure to reach an agreement between the dockworker union and their bosses, the Pacific Maritime Association representing port management would lead to devastating consequences for the US retail industry, had several very damning soundbites:

"a work slowdown during contract negotiations over the past seven months has already created logistic nightmares for American exporters, manufacturers and retailers dependent on an efficient supply chain. A complete shutdown would be catastrophic, with hundreds of thousands of jobs at risk if Americas supply chain grinds to a halt."

"A west coast port shutdown would be an economic disaster."

"A shutdown would not only impact the hundreds of thousands of jobs working directly in Americas transportation supply chain, but the reality is the entire economy would be impacted as exports sit on docks and imports sit in the harbor waiting for manufacturers to build products and retailers to stock shelves."

And the punchline: "The slowdown is already making life difficult, but a shutdown could derail the economy completely."

Just so readers have a sense of what is at stake, this is what the average dockworker makes: $147,000 a year in salary, plus $35,000 a year in employer-paid health care and an annual pension of $80,000 (according to an association press release). It is the overtime compensation to the total shown here, which grosses to over a quarter of a million dollars, that dockworkers are negotiating to raise or else the key US supply-chains gets it.

Incidentally, the demands of the dockworker union and their leverage is precisely the reason for the dramatic discrepancy we showed in the following chart:

In any case, as of last night, the choking of the US supply-chain has officially begin, when as the LA Times reported last night, "West Coast ports including the nation's busiest in Los Angeles and Long Beach will partially shut down for four days as shipping companies plan to dramatically slash dock work amid an increasingly contentious labor dispute."

Terminal operators and shipping lines said that they would stop the unloading of ships Thursday, Saturday, Sunday and Monday, because they don't want to pay overtime to workers who, they allege, have deliberately slowed operations to the point of causing a massive bottleneck. Thursday is Lincoln's Birthday and Monday is Presidents Day, which are holidays for the workers.

Slowing down work "amounts to a strike with pay, and we will reduce the extent to which we pay premium rates for such a strike," said Wade Gates, spokesman for the Pacific Maritime Assn., the employer group representing the shipping companies. The local union in Los Angeles and Long Beach has denied using slowdown tactics.

Accoring to the LA Times, it is not clear if the partial shutdown foreshadows a total closure of the ports. Fears of a lockout of dockworkers, who have been without a contract since July, have risen in the last week and the two sides haven't held talks since Friday. SF Gate was far more clear on what the dockworker action means: "West Coast ports to shut down 4 days amid labor dispute."

Work delays and stoppages over the past three months have caused mounting problems for Bay Area importers and small-business owners, who say they are losing money as trucks line up daily outside the Port of Oakland waiting for container ships anchored in San Francisco Bay to unload.

The shutting down of port operations is ironic because itll make the situation worse, said union officials who claimed the association canceled a negotiating session Wednesday and has not been available since last Friday.

This is an effort by the employers to put economic pressure on our members and to gain leverage in contract talks, said Robert McEllrath, president of the longshore and warehouse union. The union is standing by ready to negotiate, as we have been for the past several days.

Regardless of who is at fault for the (partial) shut down, one can't blame dockworkers for doing what Greece is actively doing at the same time in its own negotiations with Europe: maximizing its leverage. Because as Bank of America showed yesterday, in a piece dedicated precisely to this topic, nothing short of 3.5% of marginal US GDP is at steak, which translated into CAGR terms, means that the fate of America's estimated 3% growth in 2015 is suddenly in the hands of a few thousand port workers, and with that, whether or not the US has a recession.

Could port activity grind to a halt?

Due to continued unsuccessful contract negotiations between West Coast port employers (Pacific Maritime Association) and workers (International Longshore and Warehouse Union), there is a growing risk of a shutdown/lockout at West Coast docks, possibly within days. This past weekend, ports temporarily halted operations, adding to uncertainty.

In our view, although a port strike/lockout could weigh on operations and profitability in some industries, the economic fallout of a one-week strike is likely to be limited to a loss of $0.8-1.8bn, representing a 0.1-0.2% hit to annualized GDP growth in 1Q15.

Size matters

Since the fall, a notable disruption in activity at the ports has materialized, and the risk is the current delays could spiral into full-blown gridlock, or that employers could lock out workers. West Coast ports are an important component of US trade. As cited by our Transportation Analyst Ken Hoexter, the value of total traffic at West Coast ports (waterborne, air and land) accounts for 12% of GDP. However, drilling down specifically to goods arriving/departing by water vessels (and hence, impacted by the labor dispute) reveals a much smaller share, only 3.5% of GDP or roughly $600bn, as of 2014.

Gauging the economy-wide risk during a shutdown

The economic fallout of a port shutdown is challenging to measure and depends heavily on the technique of analysis. Economic impact studies of West Coast port shutdowns have yielded loss estimates as high as $2bn per day. However, analysis by Peter Hall of the University of Waterloo and by the US Congressional Budget Office criticized such techniques as they fail to account for the ability for firms to substitute to alternative transportation routes, resulting in inflated loss estimates. Instead, according to research published by the CBO in 2006, the fallout is likely much lower, roughly $65mn to $150mn per day if Los Angeles and Long Beach ports were to shut down for a week in 2004. To get a sense of what the risks are in today, we gross that figure up to account for higher trade volumes, and include all West Coast ports. Our back of the envelope calculation suggests the daily loss to GDP would be $150-350mn per day, or $0.8-1.8bn per week. That would represent 0.1-0.2% hit to annualized 1Q15 GDP growth.

Learning from the past: short-term pain is likely

If history is any guide, a temporary port shutdown would acutely hurt the trade sector in the short term, but would not threaten to derail the recovery. In 2002, port workers at 29 West Coast ports were locked out for roughly 10 days in October, before President Bush invoked the Taft-Hartley Act to reopen the ports.

What could go wrong?

We highlight two key scenarios that may lead to greater downside risk relative to our base case:

A protracted disruption could trigger non-linear (accelerating) economic costs as temporary contingency measures run their course, resulting in worsening supply chain disruptions. President Obama could intervene by invoking the Taft-Hartley Act as was done in 2002, but it is not clear if or how quickly the White House would be willing to step into a labor dispute this time around.

There is uncertainty regarding the capacity of alternative transportation routes. Extensive use of air freight and Canadian/Eastern ports may lead to capacity constraints at those sites, limiting the ability of industry to successfully substitute to alternative supply chains for an extended period.

So the bottom line is that nobody really knows what will happen if the "partial" stoppage becomes a permanent one, as dockworkers try lever their influence on the US economy (which according to financial comedy TV is so strong, it should have no problem to meet their demands, right?), but it is safe to say that the final outcome will be somewhere between the "catastrophic" devastation for the economy which the retail industry predicts, and anywhere up to a 3.5% hit to the GDP, which in turn means an economic recession, if only temporary.

One thing, however, about which there is no doubt at all, is the unprecedented congestion that has slammed the Port of Los Angeles and Long Beach harbor: that is very much real,

From his blog:
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-02-12/catastrophic-shutdown-americas-supply-chain-begins-stunning-photos-west-coast-port-c


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

One guys look at what is going on in the California ports, with a little historical perspective and a look to the future of what might happen.

If you follow the link there are some magnificent photos of shipping and the ports which are well worth looking at

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

A protracted disruption could trigger non-linear (accelerating) economic costs as temporary contingency measures run their course, resulting in worsening supply chain disruptions. President Obama could intervene by invoking the Taft-Hartley Act as was done in 2002, but it is not clear if or how quickly the White House would be willing to step into a labor dispute this time around.

President Obama has dispatched the Department of Labor to facilitate a solution - how long will he wait for a solution is a question yet to be answered along with when and what broader effects will be felt in the economy?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Thanks for your perspective which has an obvious pro labor slant to it

Smile.gif

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Hyperbolic yourself there a bit aren't you?

I think the point is that a protracted obstruction / stoppage of imports could lead to other adverse effects which could seriously harm the economy

Thanks for your perspective on the mater

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Something about the wage scale here is not quite right here Robert.

I just checked Indeed for compensation scales in Long beach for forktruck operators, warehouse workers, and the like, and their wages are in the upper $20K range. Glassdoor for San Diego is in the lower $30s. The $147K reported in this article seems to be......"out there.".

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

It may be interesting to note that in the past, when railroad was the main transporter of goods, the railroad personnel went on strike, and several presidents intervened.

As far as the dock worker's strike-- they deserve to be paid for their labors. I believe that they do a dangerous job, and it does require skills to operate the machinery. Perhaps, what they want is more respect for their work.

But, they shouldn't shut down the country. Nor did past presidents allow the strikes shut down the country.

Right before I was born, the railways went on strike. My Grandpa worked for the Louisville and Nashville railroad and went on strike with them. When I was a kid, he told me it was the stupidest thing he'd ever done. Ike or Truman stepped in and that was that.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

FLY

Both sides in a labor dispute tend to hyperbolize statistics to make their case - I am sure that the upper 20;s is too low (with overtime and all) and the 147,000 is probably likewise way too hire.

I posted the article for the overall look at the issue and the scenarios of what might happen or what could happen rather than to debate the statistics, which are the authors and I have not researched their validity.

Thanks for pointing out the potential error in the data though

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Dowser

I agree neither side of the issue is right or wrong, and both are going to have to back off some of their positions/demands in order to get this thing settled.

There is indeed precedent for federal government intervention and it is a distinct possibility of the Dept of Labor cannot facilitate a solution between the parties in a fairly short time

Thanks for your feedback and perspective

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Thank you for your article-- living in KY as I do, several states away from any sea port, I had little idea that this was going on or what was a stake. Thanks for the information!

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Dowser

I thought the "opinion piece" was interesting, but remember it is only one guy's look at the situation and as flame pointed out he has a slant towards management

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

And thinking that one side is totally right and the other totally wrong in a situation requiring deliberation and compromise is also fantasy

Thanks again for sharing your opinion/perspective

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

flameaway

Keep you eye on the glass you see it half empty and I prefer to see it half full

We have different perspectives on life and events in that life which is okay

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

John

And your commentary is always totally objective and unbiased, which everyone appreciates immensely

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Thanks!

To me, it should have a slant toward labor-- stagnant wages, loss of jobs, the poor growth in any job sector but low-paying jobs, etc. Labor has taken a big hit, of late.

But, I don't think that labor should be favored over the detriment of the entire country. Maybe it will take a huge strike like this for the country to wake up and see where we're going... Maybe not, too. Maybe it will only solidify the resolve of big business to wipe all the little people off the map. Not a very comforting thought, that... Grin.gif

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

FLY

I saw this on line so at $25 per hour times 2080 = $52,000 per year without overtime, which it seems they get fairly regularly and without valuing the benefits. So as I thought the actual annual compensation level is somewhere between your lower 30's and the author's $147K

Uline Shipping Supply Specialists

"The people I work with are as passionate as I am."
"I came to Uline for a job. Instead, I found a career."

Uline is North America's leading distributor of shipping, packaging and industrial supplies. We're a family-owned company known for our incredible customer service and quality products. Our people make the difference.

We're looking for the best and brightest to take our Warehouse department to the next level. If you have passion and expertise in distribution, shipping and receiving, forklift operation, or picking and packing, Uline is the company for you. Click here to learn more.

Forklift Operator
Up to $25 per hour, based on experience
 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Good points, again thanks for your perspective

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

No, But we have read the communist manifesto.

You sure like to quote it.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

RIO, the wages being thrown around by the PMA are out of line.

FLY's ''forklift'' operator is too low for the ILWU wage scale. In fact there are very few jobs in the IWU that require a forklift operator.

Flames referring to Teamsters, is incorrect. The Teamsters are not involved in waterfront labor.

If wages are to be brought up, I would suggest that the shipping lines salaries are posted, along with the management salaries of the corporations importing the merchandise. Fair is fair.

Just a note of interest, all of the shipping lines are foreign owned. There are NO US flagged or owned containeroperators left.

American President Lines was the last of the US owned lines. They were purchased by NOL,a Singapore company.

What is the first thing they did, the retirement benefits of the employees of APL were ended, and they went to a 401K. Medical benefits were cut. etc etc.

Next the Captains of the vessels, all American's, were terminated and replaced with foreign Captains. It's cheaper.

Manyforeign vessel operating companies opened offices here and guess what. Did they hire Americans? NO THEY DID NOT, they brought in foreign nationals...with a couple of token Americans.

Now, why the hell should the ILWU buckle under to foreign companies?

I wonder how many of the American public knows these facts. Probably very few.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Kavika

Thanks for clearing that up and for all the information

And as to how many people know things to this level of detail about the situation, I agree it is probably small

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

What really pissed me off RIO, is the sale of both of the last of the American international container carriers.

We, the US, has NO heavy lift capacity. We now have to rent spacefrom Maersk, Danish who purchased SeaLand, and NOL, who purchased APL.

Thank you US government forapproving these sale's../S

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

I had seen something a while back about the U.S. not being the player in international shipping capability that it once was, but didn't realize that that all major international lift capability for sea transport was foreign owned.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

A shocker, isn't it RIO. Of couse the US government demanded that there be a provision that if needed they would have to give us space on the vessels.

First, the country will do what is best for them. The lift being used is money that is going to foreign companies, not back into US companies.

So all this BS from the PMA really needs to be looked at in the bigger picture. If they had their way, all the ILWU would be replaced with foreign workers....It's cheaper..

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

It was just an example of a salary for a fork lift operator in the area

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Those number sound about right. See, all those years of working in HR are paying off even in retirement.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

This is but another example of where the US has lost control in an area that could be vital to our national interest.

The nations national security is impacted by not having a heavy lift capacity. The bastards want to claim it will impact the economy. It already has by eliminating jobs for Americans.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

FLY

That is an excellent point

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Robert, they are not members of the ILWU. I don't know if they are a unionized operation or not.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

It wasn't about being unionized it was an example of the salary for a forklift operator in the area that is all

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Maybe a little

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Not sure if there is a contradiction or not, it may be apples and oranges but it is at least a number of opinions (and no exact numbers) on what some of the workers make. The answer is probably somewhere in the middle of the two extremes

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

From Fight Club as I remember, I figured it was someone's nom de plume, but I still found the article interesting

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

It was presented to stimulate a discussion, which it did and not as the definitive data on the subject at hand

It did that quite well

 
 

Who is online



68 visitors