CNN Host Destroys Alabama Supreme Court Justice in Epic interview: ‘Our laws do not come from God and you know that’
In a riveting interview on Thursday, CNN host Chris Cuomo grilled Alabama Supreme Court Justice Roy Moore over his efforts to defy federal courts by blocking same-sex marriage in his state.
Over the weekend Moore had advised Alabama probate judges to refuse to issue marriage licenses to LGBT couples, a move that was compared to Gov. George Wallace blocking desegregation in the 1960s. On Monday, same-sex marriage licenses were issued in some Alabama counties, but more than 50 judges followed Moores advice.
Moore told Cuomo on Thursday that he dissented from the federal court ruling because it was exactly like Supreme Court rulings that upheld slavery and segregation.
I would suggest that your refusal goes to what you believe marriage is about, and not just to the law, Cuomo noted. This is just like the Ten Commandments situation. You were told by the federal courts, remove the Ten Commandments from the public square. You didnt want to, and you wound up losing your job because of it.
Its not about my feelings, its about the law, Moore insisted. And my law, Alabama law, states that Im chief administrative officer of the judicial system and I must act when the jurisdiction of the probate courts is interfered with by one lone judge who has no power or authority to tell them how to interpret the federal Constitution.
Its about discrimination, Cuomo said.
Its about sexual preference overcoming an institution which has existed in our state, in our United States for centuries, Moore shot back.
Is equal protection a matter for the Supreme Court? Cuomo asked. The answer is, of course, yes.
According to Moore, Alabamas gay marriage ban provided equal protection because LGBT people had a right to marry members of the opposite sex like everyone else.
Our rights do not come from the Constitution, they come from God, Moore opined.
Our laws do not come from God, and you know that, the CNN host said. They come from man Our rights do not come from God. Thats your faith, thats my faith. But thats not our country. Our laws come from the collective agreement and compromise.
Youre citing that marriage is about a divine institution, Cuomo continued. Youre putting God before the laws of man. Youre making it about that. And its about your ideas of your faith about what marriage is.
When you take the rules of your religion and you put them on everybody else, that is not what we do in this country. Your definition of marriage is based on your faith, youve said it a hundred times, that it is derived from God. That is not how it works here, and you know that. Equal protection applies to all by compromise. And you would even need to have a rational basis for why it would need to be only between a man and a woman, and all you can say is, Because God said so. Its always been that way. Thats not enough.
Watch the video from CNNs New Day , broadcast Feb. 12, 2015.
Tags
Who is online
81 visitors

He is his own worst enemy.
Alabama was also a final holdout on desegregation and interracial marriage. It is happening again on gay marriage.
Judge Moore's move to block gay marriage in Alabama is drawing comparisons to George Wallace's "stand in the schoolhouse door" in 1963.
But school desegregation is hardly the only time Alabama has been among the final holdouts when it comes to social change, nor is it the only time the Wallace comparisons have been drawn.
Back in 2000, Alabama became the last state in the country to overturn its ban on interracial marriage. And despite more than three decades having passed since the Supreme Court ruled such laws unconstitutional (rendering such bans effectively moot), more than 40 percent of Alabamians still voted against overturning it. [ Source ]
Welcome to the 20th century Mr. Moore! We will work on getting you into the 21st century later.
The man (judge) sure knows how to make a fool out of himself on national TV..Keep it up Judge, your doing fine./s
"When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation.
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness."
That's what we need, a nit-wit like thispreachingtot Alabamians, making them dumber than they already are.
(Sorry Alabamians, you earned yourself the reputation, now you have to live with it)
Yeah, the favorite technique of mass murders and serial killers.
Although some of them say it's "voices in their heads". Either way, crazy is crazy.
We're not working on it hard enough for me.
Many people in this country, just like this nit-wit Judge, believe if a law or belief does not conform with theirinterpretationof the Bible, it violates Constitutional law.
Much like many Muslims that believe if a law or belief does not conform with their interpretation of the Quoran it violats Sharia law.
I agree our Rights are inherent, that concept was pretty much settled in the Magna Carta. But I don't believe Cuomo said our Rights come from man, he said our laws come from man. The Constitution, written by man, is the supreme law of the land, and as you said, is designed to protect our Rights.
Just so everyone knows, The rights mentioned above come directly from the Musings of John Locke, the father of the enlightenment, which is the basis of libertarian philosophy.
These are the only rights man has, the rest are created based upon those told of above and the social needs of the society one lives in. ALL laws are based upon the social needs of a society.
No one knows when the spark of intelligence and self awareness comes apparent in a human, that is between him/her and their creator.
But once it does they are entitled to all the gifts of such awareness.
Life, no matter how that life came to be.
Liberty, Freedom to be whatever your heart and ability can make of yourself.
....and from those two above stems...
The right to pursue (take action / make decisions) to whatever end makes you happy.
No one gave you those rights, they come from the natural course of being human, no one can take them away. They are permanently tied to each and every one of us just by being a human being.
That is what that statement says. GOD did not create those rights, The Government did not allow us those rights.
They are the rights we have natural and unfettered by any man. They are our INDIVIDUAL rights.
And we cannot be separated from them.
All else, is a creation of the mind of man. Any law that abridges those natural rights is an abomination on man and the society that propagates them. Any government that attempts to take those rights away from it's citizens is tyrannical to it's core.
The government of this nation was created to preserve and reserve those rights specifically, and make law based upon their precepts.
This judge is truly a nitwit and does not understand the basis of American law almost as much as he does not understand his bible.
Yes government are created by man to preserve order and protect the society that gave rise to it.
But allow me to remind everyone that believes in a supreme being.
Give unto God what is god's and give unto Caesar what is caesar's.
Government's deserve your loyalty as long as they do what they were created for. they are created by MAN and are supposed to serve it's citizens. but, any government that fails in it's obligation to serve it's citizens is government that deserves it's fate at the hands of it's citizens.
No citizen is obligated to a government that usurps the natural rights of it's citizens.
That was the overlying point of the Declaration of Independence, and it's oft quoted main statement. It was the reason the colonists rebelled against the sovereign and his government and the reason we exist as a nation today.
I pray we can keep it.
EXACTLY!!!!
What page are you on Sean?
Cuomo said;
Our laws do not come from God, and you know that, the CNN host said. They come from man Our rights do not come from God. Thats your faith, thats my faith. But thats not our country. Our laws come from the collective agreement and compromise.
Exactly what?
Emphatic agreement with the post I responded to.
The US Constitution is the Law of the Land, not theDeclaration of Independence. When the Founding Fathers wrote the Constitution, while allowing for the freedom of religion, theydeliberatelyseparatedtheChurch and State, and designed the Constitution to reflect the laws of a secular nation.
Well said NM.
The bill of rights does not "GRANT" anything.
It RESERVES those rights FOR us.
It is an expressly stated LIMITATION on government, not an expanded privledge of citizenship.
The question is not so muchthedefinition of our Rights, but where they come from. Judge Moore seems to think they are granted to us by God. I would assume Moore bases that opinion from these words in the 'Declaration", "We hold these truths to be self evident that all Men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, .....", their "Creator" meaning God in the mind of the Judge.
However, the more pragmatic among us, who may question the existence of a God, interpret that line to mean, "....are endowed by their creation .....". The Declaration goes on to say, "That to secure these Rights, Governments areinstituted among Men,deriving their just Powers from the Consent of the Governed ....."
So whether 'certain Rights' are endowed by a "God' or simply by creation, is a moot issue. Because those Rights are not secure until the people form a government and the governed consent to certain Rights being granted.
Personally I always figured that line to be a fine piece of propaganda/rationalization for what the Colonist were doing. Remember at that time Royalty had gotten away with their crap for centuries because the people believed a God or Gods had put them in place to rule.
The American insurgents had to find a way to make it OK to rebel against the agent of God on earth, as royalty was seen by most at that time. Announcing that human rights are inherent at birth for all, not a boon from a King was an important first step in defining the conflict as a fight among equals not heathens fighting the will of God, which most Colonist would not have rallied around.
But hey, what do I know since I also always suspected that the 2nd Amendment, ("A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."), was more about a poor, weak, very new Government trying to come up with a way to insure that they would have a fighting force on the cheap, one that could be called on as needed, than it ever was about giving the OK for everyfuture American citizento have their own tank which no one can say spit about it.
Nice hyperbole, it says, and intended nothing of the sort.
If you read what the people who wrote it say it's meaning should be you would stop spreading ideologically false claptrap.
Every American has the right to own and possess those weapons that would be standard for an infantryman to use in battle by himself.
So, I know that US infantrymen are supermen, but carrying an abrams in their back pocket is kinda stretching the point a bit?
Crew served weapons are pretty much eliminated also aren't they. That's what I thought, makes sense.
Oh, one other minor little point, they actually believed all men were created equal. Not that you will ever get a tory to agree with that.
True enough Nowhere Man, I was stretching the point quite a bit, though my core thought, that the Founding Fathers were looking for a way to insure a cheap fighting force, still holds true for me.
If it was up to me every gun owner would be required to go through the same weapons training the military put me through before they could own a gun and that training on use and safety would need to be renewed from time to time like all our professional gun users do, (Military - Police, etc..).
My only beef is how the flood of guns in America has washed them into the hands of too many folk that don't really know what they're dealing with.
I agree, our educated Founding fathers, well versed in the tenets of the Age of Enlightenment did strive for that belief, (though of course you were more equal if you where a white, male, land owner
, but they had to rally much of the country that did not. As you noted. 
Again, these are just the musings of an old hermit.
Nothing I can argue with brother, I agree with all your musings stated here.
Just didn't want to have people get the idea that everyone from Arkansas was a raving lunatic.
We now know at least one that isn't. (I suspect there are more, but they have to stop being Hermits to be heard)
Peace brother.
Back at ya N M, back at ya.
How is that? You're saying Cuomo said our Rights come from man. I corrected you by pointing out he said our laws come from man.
Please show us where Cuomo said our Rights come from man.
I don't think so.
A U.S. 2nd Infantry Division soldier pulls security on top of a roof using an M240B with an attached M145 and AN/PEQ-2.
TheM240is the US military General Purpose Machine Gun [GPMG] that has been used by the US military since the late-1970s. It is used extensively by infantry , most often rifle companies. [ Source ]
Last Sunday John Oliver did a number on Moore on his show "Last Week Tonight" he also attacked our practice of electing Judges to office, pointing Bolivia is the only other country in the world that elects Judges to the bench.
Watch the video;
I've alway wondered about the wisdom of electing Judges to office, but I didn't know that we are the only country on the world ..... besides Bolivia .... that followed the practice.
It seems to me that it's a problem we need to address. I'll bet Olivers hilarious dissertationenlightened a lot more people besides me about the pitfalls of electing judges.
It also seems to me that lawyers should never be allowed to contribute to the campaign of any judge. (I never even suspected it would be allowed)
Can you imagine being involved in a case where the judge hadreceiveda generous campaign contribution from the other guys attorney?