With Elizabeth Warren Saying No to 2016, Bernie Sanders Eyes Populist Mantle
Washington No. No. A thousand times no. Elizabeth Warren is still not running for president.But if not the senator from Massachusetts, then who might don the liberal mantle in 2016? Sen. Bernie Sanders , perhaps?
The independent senator from Vermont has been traveling the country testing the waters.
On Monday, he laid out his agenda at the Brookings Institution think tank. His shock of white hair and often-rumpled appearance contrast sharply with the trim and energetic put-togetherness of Senator Warren but they certainly read from the same political page.
Today, in my view, the most serious problem we face as a nation is the grotesque and growing level of wealth and income inequality, he said, railing against a government of the billionaires, by the billionaires, and for the billionaires.
Sanders swings as hard left as Warren does: Social Security needs to be expanded, not reduced (he would pay for it by raising the payroll tax cap); the big Wall Street financial firmsare beyond reform and they must be broken up; health care for all is a right, which should be provided by a Medicare-like single-payer plan. A big infrastructure program would create millions of jobs, and free college and graduate education would give the workforce competitive chops.
Theres only one problem with this ersatz Warren theory. Nobody can replace her, because, as Amy Walter of the independent Cook Political report puts it: Elizabeth Warren is the only Elizabeth Warren of the race (even though shes not in it).
Warrens appeal is not that shes the anti-Hillary, or that the Democratic base is yearning for a more liberal voice, says Ms. Walter. Its her sparkliness.
Shes shiny and shes new and shes fresh and shes engaging and shes motivating. So I dont think thats a slot that you can just sort of interchange with any other Democrat.
Sanders seems to recognize this.
I knew Elizabeth Warren before she was Elizabeth Warren back when she was merely a brilliant Harvard law professor with an ability to explain complicated issues in an understandable way, he said on Monday. She blew me away.
And Hillary Rodham Clinton blows everyone else away, whether its Warren or Sanders.
In the February poll by Bloomberg Politics-St. Anselm College, Mrs. Clinton buries these two like a blizzard and right in their own backyard. The former secretary of state, senator, and first lady is the top choice of 56 percent of likely voters in the New Hampshire Democratic primary, according to the poll. Warren comes in a distant second at 15 percent; Sanders and Vice President Joe Biden tie for third at 8 percent each.
Clintons name recognition is about 10 times greater than mine, admitted Sanders, but then again, hes faced such odds before. In the 1970s, he ran twice for governor of Vermont and twice for the US Senate once setting a personal best of 6 percent of the vote. In 1981, the socialist finally emerged victorious as an independent running for mayor of Burlington, Vermonts largest city, challenging a five-term Democrat.
Nobody, but nobody thought that we had a chance to win, Sanders said at the start of his talk.
He crossed the finish line after a recount by a mere 10 votes.
Of course, the national stage is hardly the shores of Lake Champlain or the dairy farms that produce the states famed cheddar cheese. In underdog cases like this, sometimes candidates run to influence the primary debate. Others run as third-party or independent candidates and then become spoilers in the general election think Ross Perot or Ralph Nader.
Sanders says hes still sorting out whether to run, and if so, whether to run as an independent or a Democrat. Voters sick of both parties value the independent label, but it takes gobs of money and organizational prowess to get on all the state ballots.
Sanders made clear, however, that he has no desire to be a son-of-Nader.
I will not be a spoiler, he stated emphatically.
If he wanted to debate Clinton in the primaries, he would have to register as a Democrat. To be sure, he offers a more left-leaning message, but not one that would make much of a difference, according to political observers.
Says Democratic pollster Celinda Lake: What he speaks to is an agenda. And he brings forth those ideas. But much of that agenda Hillary Clinton supports, too.
http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/DC-Decoder/2015/0209/With-Elizabeth-Warren-saying-no-to-2016-Bernie-Sanders-eyes-populist-mantle-video
Tags
Who is online
81 visitors

Since Senator Sanders views on most issues have little chance of actually becoming part of a Clinton Agenda, can he or will he play a significant role in 2016 politics?
If the answer is, YES please tell us how.
If the answer is NO, please tells us why
Thanks.
Hal
Thanks for the perspective.
A question for you - DO you think a Warren/Sanders ticket would have a chance of winning either as Democrats or as a third party ticket?
I agree that history supports your prognostication on third party tickets, but if there is ever to be a viable third party in the U.S. won't some candidate have to be the first to run and win?
Secondly, do you think that Hillary might bungle her run? What might she trip over, do you think?
He doesn't stand a chance and is already making excuses for why he will not win. No way the USA is going to elect another socialist after the failures of the current one.
But the 73-year-old Sanders isn't even sure if it can be done, or if he'll try.
In a candid answer to a question about his political viability Monday, he lamented the "absurd" amount of resources he would need to mount a serious campaign, both in the primary and general elections.
Even if he raised $100 from 2 million people for a total of $200 million he worried it wouldn't be enough.
David and Charles Koch the libertarian billionaires commonly referred to as the Koch brothers reportedly have earmarked nearly $900 million of their personal fortune for the 2016 campaign, on behalf of one or more Republican candidates.
The average contribution to Sanders' last Senate campaign was $45, he claimed.
[ ALSO: Budget for Koch Network: Almost $1 Billion for 2016 ]
"The gut feeling that I'm going to have to reach is whether there is that willingness to stand up and fight back. And if there's not, I don't want to run a futile campaign," he said.
The tactical admission from Sanders about his own odds must come as a disheartening reality for progressives, who are yearning for a voice in the 2016 process and have spent months attempting to draft Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., into the race . (She has repeatedly and emphatically demurred.)
Dean
Thanks for the perspective
The questions were whether Sanders and/or Warren will play a role in the 2016 elections, whether either or both actually run for president, is ancillary to that question.
By the way, you info about the funds being dumped into the election process by the Koch brothers might be seen by some as an excellent reason for one or both of them to run and win for the good of the country.
p.s.
No matter how many times you say it or how loudly you say it - Obama is not a Socialist, left of center with tendencies of the European style Social Democrat, but not a socialist
Thanks again for the perspective
As for Hilary bungling, I have no idea what would make that happen, other than to say it wouldn't be the first time someone perceived as a shoo-in fell from grace.
Yes, he will play a very small role by persuading a very tiny portion of the electorate the extreme far left to stay home and not vote.
And Senator Warren?
And isn't that the same role that someone like Ted Cruz will play - making a small portion of the far right stay home and not vote? And perhaps even Senator Paul is in the same boat?
Indeed, one need only look at 2008 for that, oh and that was Hillary wasn't it?
Sounds like you vote for the candidate you think is best suited for the office not the likely winner. I feel the same way and respect that view.
Sen Paul will make noise in the primary, but that is about all. He will appeal to the far right while making all the other voters sick to their stomachs. There is no support for him with moderates, and moderates are whom determine our presidents with the rare occasion, of the SCOTUS.
Could you see Senator Paul as #2 on a ticket for the Republicans?
Warren will probably support whomever the democratic primary winner is possibly in return for a cushy cabinet position. I expect her to support Hillary.
I think it would be as detrimental to the Republican ticket as the running mate Johnny Mac selected in 2008. Thinking about it, it would be worse.
I don't think Rand Paul will accept the #2 position on any ticket.
He is acting like he is going to take a run at it.
With Warren officially out, there is no longer a reason for me to consider a democrat ticket.
The only hope we have now for a real leader is a republican.
What is a real leader? Who on the right has those qualities you state?
We see plenty of people that have been making negative comments about the occupants of the Oval Office since 2000, and before as not being leaders. I don't think either side knows how to stop.
N M
I tend to agree with you on Sen Paul, but I also think he has no chance of getting the nomination
A leader has yet to emerge on the Republican side either
FLY
A leader is one whose goal is to unite the two sides for the greater good, over pushing a single ideological agenda
And you are right a lot of blame has been thrown around and no real leaders have appeared I recent years
Perhaps you are right but her "platform" would appear to be at odds with Hillary in many ways
Agreed.
And we are fusked until we find one.
Could Paul be a leader? unknown at this point. His Father would have been. But I don't think that has rubbed off on the son.
I still think he is the best of the bunch, although with serious reservations.
TR was a leader, that was his best quality right wrong or indifferent. but he was also very publicly scathing of his indictments of both Taft (his hand picked successor) and Wilson.
Making negative comments over the opposition leader is no standard of judgment of leadership qualities.
Currently, I see no one that rises to the standard. The last actual leader we had was Slick Willie, and before him Reagan.
Leadership is not a political attribute.
But I do agree, the back biting has to stop from both sides.
F:Y
I think you are probably right, but that is the only outcome I see where he could be on the ticket and it is very unlikkely
N M
TR is history and focusing backwards is not going to help overcome the challenges of the present and future.
I voted for President Clinton - I thought he was a good president, though I had little respect for him as a man, husband and father with is extracurricular habits.
I also voted for Reagan and think he is greatly distorted by those that praise him (too much) and tear him down (too much) but that is the times we live in
N M
Perhaps but the worst thing that we can do is quit looking
One of the things I disagree with the the denigration of history as not relevant. If we forget our past we are doomed to repeat the mistakes of the past.
I've always said that history will be kind to Ol' Willie, no I didn't vote for him, but I think he was more of a leader than anyone likes to give him credit for even with all his mistakes.
And I agree that Reagan is pedestaled and villified way to much, after all he was human and made his own share of blunders. And ya I did vote for him three times.
Restating history is not focusing backwards, it is remembering from whence we came in the hope that we do not make the same mistakes we made in the past.
We can focus too much on where we want to go also, it is a huge fault of us as Americans, especially when we forget where we came from or, what got us here.
Failing the search, is the biggest mistake we could ever make. and we have been making it for too long by allowing others to pick our leaders for us.
If we need to stand up and be counted overseas, we should at least be willing to stand up and be counted here at home.
N M
Appreciate the perspective, but I think a focus from (and cognizant of the present), without forgetting the past but on the future is the most productive.
Pining for leaders of the past clouds the search for the best available in the present
Really appreciate all the back and forth on this topic thanks a lot
N M
Doing nothing is worse than falling short of a goal.
If we need to stand up and be counted overseas, we should at least be willing to stand up and be counted here at home.
I totally agree with that, I have a number of friends in Brazil and voting there is required by law, I do not know if we could or should go that far, but the pitiful percentage of eligible voters that vote compared to the number that bitch about hose elcted is truly alarming.
I guess expecting Holder to have further political ambitions is not in the cards . Barack Obama really was "the last black president" !
Oddly enough there are very few women senators & congress people even though the population is > 50 % female . Why do you think that is ?
Cultural bias
There are also more females submissives than dominatrixes . Cultural bias or biology at work ?
RiO:
we are probably a lot closer than apart in assessment of history in relation to today and the future. all I want is to not lose sight of reality in the hope for change.
Petey,
If you are suggesting that the disproportionate number of males in elected office is due to biology... Wait a minute! Let me sell tickets.
Mickey Petey, Broliver, John
Thanks folks for the excursion way off topic to discuss gender and racial bias in the election of presidents, which has little (if anything) to do with the topic.
Hope you enjoyed yourself
The seed is sufficiently derailed, your work here is done
Right of center or left of center is debatable for sure, but he is not a socialist.
I am not so sure that it is that hard to believe that Warren could be nominated (I agree on Sanders) or that it would be such a landslide loss if she was.
It might bring out a lot of folks on the far left and many democrats would vote for anyone but a Republican
Gosh, I hope nobody was harmed.
I really don't see anyone who I would vote for out there amongst the potentials so far. None of them represent the direction that I want to see the country head, except maybe a combination of Warren and Sanders, but they stand a snowballs chance in hell of getting nominated. I think the processes that are used for nomination should be revisited and changed to make the individual parties of less significance in our final choice.
Bro
No one was harmed
I would like to see open primaries, with the top two moving onto the general election regardless of party affiliation, but that is unlikely to happen either.
So I will continue to look for the right candidate for the right position and be surprised and happy by come and disappointed by others.
Appreciate you perspective on the issue
A few comments (about black presidents, gender and race) appear to have been deleted by they that made them so it appears you are correct at this point.