IRS Seizes First Asks Questions Later
By Robert O'Harrow Jr.
The Internal Revenue Service has routinely seized bank accounts from individuals in recent years without proof of criminal wrongdoing and only then asked the account owners about allegations of suspicious activity.
From 2005 to 2012, the IRS took almost a quarter-billion dollars in more than 2,500 cases, using authorities under federal asset forfeiture law. Thats the finding of a new study by theInstitute for Justice, [ 1 ] a libertarian-leaning civil liberties group. The groups study, Seize First, Question Later, focuses on IRS enforcement of a law that prohibits structuring, a type of banking activity intended to launder ill-gotten money or hide the source of funds.
Civil asset forfeiture efforts by local, state and federal authorities have come under fire in recent months. Critics across the political spectrum say that civil seizures are often unfair and an abuse of police power.
Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. recently announced curbs on a Justice Department program called Equitable Sharing that allows federal and local authorities to share in the proceeds of seizures. Holders order prohibits federal agencies from accepting seizures from local and state police into the program unless a federal agent has been directly involved. The IRS has said it would follow suit. The change leaves the path open for civil seizures cases related to joint investigations involving local and state police working with federal authorities.
The Institute for Justice found that in one-third of the IRS cases it examined, there was no claim of any criminal activity besides the allegation that someone had made transactions of less than $10,000, with the aim of evading federal reporting requirements. It took owners who appealed the seizures a year on average to get their money back. Almost half of the money was later returned, according to the study.
Its no accident the IRS overwhelmingly prefers civil forfeiture to criminal forfeiture, said one the reports co-authors, IJ attorney Larry Salzman. If they can seize the cash first with no real criminal investigation let alone a conviction why not?
In a statement Tuesday evening, an IRS spokesman said that structuring bank deposits to avoid the federal Bank Secrecy Act is a felony. The IRS pursue seizures only when there is probable cause that the money is subject to forfeiture and only after seizure affidavits have been reviewed by a federal prosecutor and authorized by a federal judge, the statement said. But the IRS said it is modifying its practices.
We recognize that small businesses and other taxpayers often make deposits under $10,000 without any intent to avoid the reporting requirements, the statement said. After conducting a review of structuring cases, the IRS concluded that it will focus its limited resources on cases where evidence indicates that the structured funds are derived from illegal sources.
Read the report here.
Tags
Who is online
81 visitors

The IRSs forfeiture activity exposes the rotten core of federal civil forfeiture law, says Institute of Justice Senior Attorney Scott Bullock. Allowing law enforcement to take property from people without convicting them of a crime and then profit from the seizure will inevitably lead to abuse.
The Fifth Amendment Integrity Restoration (FAIR) Act, was recently introduced to Congress by Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky., and Rep. Tim Walberg, R-Mich. The Bill, is aimed at reducing structuring-related seizures and correcting defects in the Federal Civil Forfeiture law. The law is currently unfair to Americans whose property is seized and enables law enforcement agencies to profit from those seizures.
If you should come across petitions supporting the FAIR Act, sign it.
I just always figured that the rule about the "$10,000 or more" was a Mickey Mouse rule to try and catch amateurs who didn't have the brains to figure out that if they continually deposited $9,999.99 in their accounts, the IRS would audit their accounts.
As for the act of seizing accounts first and asking questions later, I see that in the same line as arrest warrants. A person can be charged with anything at any time and a warrant issued by an accommodating judge and there is absolutely no way you can fight it even if you are innocent. You HAVE to allow yourself to be handcuffed, driven in the back of a squad car to the police station where you are photographed and fingerprinted, placed in a cell, maybe given a chance to call a lawyer before morning, if you are lucky a judge will be holding bail hearings within 24 hours, you will have to arrange bail.... and this happens all the time to innocent people who are harassed by irate x-spouses, idiot neighbors, vengeful in-laws... and you are out the expense, humiliation, and often time off from work.
Our justice system is not one of "innocent until proven guilty" it is one of "guilty until proven innocent," whether it is the IRS or the local police.
Another case of misuse of power.
Sadly this is becoming the norm in our country.
This article can also be seen in the Public Office Abuse & Misconduct group. Use the link to go to the group page to see more articles on this topic, if you're not already a member, you should sign up, membership is open.
Your're right about most of what you're saying mimi, The difference is, if you are unjustly arrested, although you do go through the hassle you have described, it usually can be straightened out in a short time. If you are completely innocent you will be able to have the arrest expunged from the records and have have your prints and photo given to you or destroyed.
You didn't mention the one thing that can be the most difficult to deal with which is the story that will likely be run in your local newspaper. Off course you can usually get them to run a retraction, but no one ever reads retractions.
However, in the case of asset seizure. That is done without warning and often freezes all of your assets, including whatever is in your account at the time of the seizure, leaving no money to cover checks that are outstanding.
These seizures, as it says in the article, can take a year or more to straighten out. By then most smaller businesses are forced to shut down. Lives are ruined, employees and debts can't be paid, thousands of dollars have to be spent on attorneys. (In the case of federal taxes you have to retain an attorney that is licensed to practice before the Federal Bar, an additional expense).
In short it's ufair, it's nightmare, and it'sunconstitutional.
I thought they always did this... If they didn't, it is truly news to me!
I think it's horrible and they don't have the right.
(?!) Why? Dark blue is the background color on NewsTalkers front page. That's why I post the text for my articles in blue. If you insist, you should be able to change the color to black with;
<font color="black">Text</font>
(formerstew did the same thing on another one of my threads and had no idea what happened.)
Anyway what's wrong with posting blue comments? It's better than all bold or all caps.
Btw, are you telling us you paid for 2 cheeseburgers with a check?
You are right, Jerry, no one reads the retractions. And while the humiliating details of the arrest and supposed criminal behavior is splashed across the front page, the retraction is rarely so easily found.
Another thing used to great effect and abused by the courts is punitive bail.
The purpose of bail is to reasonably ensure that the accused will appear for the court date. In the South, many judges use bail to "punish" the accused for the crime of being suspected and arrested, and as a measure to keep someone incarcerated.
That's nice, however many Judges have a highly arguableinterpretation of what is "reasonable".
"....becoming the norm...." Yeah, like since 1830 and Andrew Jacksons' "Indian Removal Act".
Been there, done that. Lousy food, worse bed.
The right?!
Federal agents make up their own "Rights".