╌>

The fiddling with temperature data is the biggest science scandal ever -- New data shows that the “vanishing” of polar ice is not the result of runaway global warming-- The Telegraph

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  11 years ago  •  22 comments

The fiddling with temperature data is the biggest science scandal ever -- New data shows that the “vanishing” of polar ice is not the result of runaway global warming-- The Telegraph
The vanishing of polar ice (and the polar bears) has become a poster-child for warmists. Photo: ALAMY

Two weeks ago, under the headline How we are being tricked by flawed data on global warming , I wrote about Paul Homewood, who, on his Notalotofpeopleknowthat blog, had checked the published temperature graphs for three weather stations in Paraguay against the temperatures that had originally been recorded. In each instance, the actual trend of 60 years of data had been dramatically reversed, so that a cooling trend was changed to one that showed a marked warming.

This was only the latest of many examples of a practice long recognised by expert observers around the world one that raises an ever larger question mark over the entire official surface-temperature record.

Following my last article, Homewood checked a swathe of other South American weather stations around the original three. In each case he found the same suspicious one-way adjustments. First these were made by the US governments Global Historical Climate Network (GHCN). They were then amplified by two of the main official surface records, the Goddard Institute for Space Studies (Giss) and the National Climate Data Center (NCDC), which use the warming trends to estimate temperatures across the vast regions of the Earth where no measurements are taken. Yet these are the very records on which scientists and politicians rely for their belief in global warming.

Homewood has now turned his attention to the weather stations across much of the Arctic, between Canada (51 degrees W) and the heart of Siberia (87 degrees E). Again, in nearly every case, the same one-way adjustments have been made, to show warming up to 1 degree C or more higher than was indicated by the data that was actually recorded. This has surprised no one more than Traust Jonsson, who was long in charge of climate research for the Iceland met office (and with whom Homewood has been in touch). Jonsson was amazed to see how the new version completely disappears Icelands sea ice years around 1970, when a period of extreme cooling almost devastated his countrys economy.

One of the first examples of these adjustments was exposed in 2007 by the statistician Steve McIntyre, when he discovered a paper published in 1987 by James Hansen, the scientist (later turned fanatical climate activist) who for many years ran Giss. Hansens original graph showed temperatures in the Arctic as having been much higher around 1940 than at any time since. But as Homewood reveals in his blog post, Temperature adjustments transform Arctic history, Giss has turned this upside down. Arctic temperatures from that time have been lowered so much that that they are now dwarfed by those of the past 20 years.

Homewoods interest in the Arctic is partly because the vanishing of its polar ice (and the polar bears) has become such a poster-child for those trying to persuade us that we are threatened by runaway warming. But he chose that particular stretch of the Arctic because it is where ice is affected by warmer water brought in by cyclical shifts in a major Atlantic current this last peaked at just the time 75 years ago when Arctic ice retreated even further than it has done recently. The ice-melt is not caused by rising global temperatures at all.

Of much more serious significance, however, is the way this wholesale manipulation of the official temperature record for reasons GHCN and Giss have never plausibly explained has become the real elephant in the room of the greatest and most costly scare the world has known. This really does begin to look like one of the greatest scientific scandals of all time.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Scientists Befuddled by El Nios Absence

Global climate models have pointed to an El Nio event for nearly a year, but the massive weather event has yet to materialize. Scientists are now hard at work trying to understand why Gaia has defied our best expectations. Bloomberg reports :

Since last March, forecasters have said an El Nino was on the way. The only trouble is, it hasnt arrived. Call it the period of the phantom El Nino, a shimmering siren of weather patterns yet to come that has been seen fluttering in the sparkling waters of the equatorial Pacific Ocean. []

One thing that stands out on this [El Nino/Southern Oscillation]is how wrong the models were in predicting a major event in 2014, said Matt Rogers, president of Commodity Weather Group LLC in Bethesda, Maryland.

Time and time again weve seen computer models fail to predict what comes next for our planets weather and climate patterns. And no wonderits hard to say what a system as incredibly complex as our planets climate is going to do next.We can understand certain facets of it, like the fact that surface temperatures are gradually rising, that theyre doing so in part because of increased greenhouse gas emissions, and that humanity has had a role in that increase.

But scientists run into trouble when they attempt to get much more specific than that. There are so many variables and relationships between said variables, and to quote Donald Rumsfeld there remain plenty of known unknowns. El Nio is a relatively well-known global weather event that researchers have had plenty of time to study, yet it remains frustratingly capricious. The kind of climate change were so concerned about deals with much larger time scales and is even more difficult to predict.

Greens should take note: the vagaries of our planets weather and climate systems are far from settled science.

~Link~

Looks like Al Gore made the right decision after all buying a mansion with a water front view with all that Global Warming money.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Report: Temperature Data Being Faked to Show Global Warming

A British journalist is questioning the method used to by scientists to calculate the earth's climate change, calling it "one of the greatest scientific scandals of all time."

Christopher Booker writes for Britain's The Telegraph that climate data from stations in South America have been adjusted since the 1950s to give the impression that the earth's temperature is rising more than the original data showed.

Booker cites Paul Homewood's Not a Lot of People Know That blog where Homewood compares raw data with adjusted temperatures to show the graph trend was reversed from a cooling trend to a warming one.

Homewood checked the data on three weather stations in Paraguay and found that all three had their initial raw readings adjusted to show lower temperatures in the 1950s and higher temperatures today.

Following reporting by Booker two weeks ago, Homewood checked more stations in South America and found the same thing had occurred at them.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Thanks To The IPCC, the Public Doesnt Know Water Vapor Is Most Important Greenhouse Gas

~Link~

Very interesting results from test.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

This is what explains the large number of meteorologists who dispute the CO2 based climate models . That's because their daily & weekly forecasts must take into account the effects of cloud cover on the close future temperature ... It is an huge factor .

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

So what.....

The point of contention is a peer-reviewed study published last year by Green, a chemistry professor at Michigan Technological University; John Cook, a research fellow at the Global Change Institute at the University of Queensland in Australia; and 10 other scientists who blog under the collective name of Skeptical Science . The scientists examined 4,014 abstracts on climate change and found 97.2 percent of the papers assumed humans play a role in global warming ( ClimateWire , May 16, 2013).

The latest surveys show that 89 percent of Democrats, 79 percent of independents and 70 percent of Republicans already believe global warming is happening and is at least partly caused by human actions.

...

Feel free to delude yourselves with tabloid articles from the likes of "The Telegraph", or "Newsmax". You and your opinions are in the minority, as are the scientists that you want to use to push your minority opinions.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

That piece from the perpetually propagandistic "Skeptical Science" is anything but skeptical . Let me know if you want to read any material by the many climatologists who don't toe the party line ...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Fly, no one is saying that the earth isn't getting warmer and a portion of that is suspected to be caused by humans, but there are so many factors one thing can change everything. What percentage of the atmosphere is CO2 Fly?

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

That piece from the perpetually propagandistic "Skeptical Science" is anything but skeptical

The fact that it was published in Scientific American does hold sway. I'll read just about anything Petey. But please note that I find articles published in scientific journals, or professional magazines to have more credibility than those published by Newsmax, or The Blaze.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Easy numbers Six....

Primary composition is 99% N/O2. CO2 accounts for .043% at 2014 concentrations.

As an engineer I understand that humans are changing the environment. Also as an engineer, what we don't understand is the impact. For all we know we may be improving things to where we have more areas to grow food in.

My beef is with those that deny that we as humans are not impacting the air and water on this rock.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Sorry to break it to you Fly ... SciAm ain't what it used to be . It has sold out for popularity.

I'll read just about anything Petey. But please note that I find articles published in scientific journals, or professional magazines to have more credibility

OK , here's a journal article for you . It was one of the most important meta articles published about climatology . It features a large list of research done in this field summarizing their results :

...

BTW , it may take you a while to get through it . If you'd like to hear my take on it just let me know ... or you can just attack the source in a typical leftist tactic .

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Thanks for the paper, and I will take time to read it during lunch today. That being said, I would suggest caution in making references from papers that are this old (+10 years).

Secondly, I did already scan the conclusion portion of the paper and found the publishers to state:

"The lack of unusual warmth in the 20th century does not argue against human impact on local and regional scales."

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

I think you'll find the meat of the article is in the summary of multiple researcher's work . There are some that find support for warming but many who don't . If nothing else it disproves the statement about 97 % of climatologists being in agreement .

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

If nothing else it disproves the statement about 97 % of climatologists being in agreement.

How does a paper released in 2003, disprove anything about the opinions and thinking of scientists in 2013?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Until the papers in this meta article are refuted with countering evidence it stands as a strong display of dispute if not full disagreement . Find me some counter evidence & I'll be happy to look it over but not the general purpose follow the leader crap that salutes Dr. Michael Mann and his "hockey team" ...

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Petey.....

You know that the publication "Climate Research" regrets that the 2003 paper by Soon and Baliunas was published as it was, and concerns about their own internal critical review, ended with the resignation of several editors.

I went into your paper with an open mind. I would ask that you do the same as the more I look into it, I find multiple reputable climate scientists on record as stating the statistics used by Soon and Baliunas in their 2003 paper as faulty leading to incorrect conclusions. I find this paper soundly rejects their findings based upon very sound reasoning.

"On Past Temperatures and Anomalous Late-20th Century Warmth"

The evidence is there to question the validity of the Soon and Baliunas paper. But since you don't like the authors, I also found a 2006 paper:

"The Spatial Extent of 20th-Century Warmth
in the Context of the Past 1200 Years" by Timothy J. Osborn and Keith R. Briffa

This paper also refutes the statistical methods bySoon and Baliunas and comes to the conclusion that the 20th century was the hottest on record.

Do we really need to go into the details that Soon and Baliunas received $53,000 from the American Petroleum Institute at the time of their 2003 paper? That alone should lead one to question their findings.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

No Need to Panic About Global Warming

There's no compelling scientific argument for drastic action to 'decarbonize' the world's economy.

January 27, 2012

Excerpts:

Editor's Note: The following has been signed by the 16 scientists listed at the end of the article:

A candidate for public office in any contemporary democracy may have to consider what, if anything, to do about "global warming." Candidates should understand that the oft-repeated claim that nearly all scientists demand that something dramatic be done to stop global warming is not true. In fact, a large and growing number of distinguished scientists and engineers do not agree that drastic actions on global warming are needed.

In September, Nobel Prize-winning physicist Ivar Giaever, a supporter of President Obama in the last election, publicly resigned from the American Physical Society (APS) with a letter that begins: "I did not renew [my membership] because I cannot live with the [APS policy] statement: 'The evidence is incontrovertible: Global warming is occurring. If no mitigating actions are taken, significant disruptions in the Earth's physical and ecological systems, social systems, security and human health are likely to occur. We must reduce emissions of greenhouse gases beginning now.' In the APS it is OK to discuss whether the mass of the proton changes over time and how a multi-universe behaves, but the evidence of global warming is incontrovertible?"

In spite of a multidecade international campaign to enforce the message that increasing amounts of the "pollutant" carbon dioxide will destroy civilization, large numbers of scientists, many very prominent, share the opinions of Dr. Giaever. And the number of scientific "heretics" is growing with each passing year. The reason is a collection of stubborn scientific facts.

Perhaps the most inconvenient fact is the lack of global warming for well over 10 years now. This is known to the warming establishment, as one can see from the 2009 "Climategate" email of climate scientist Kevin Trenberth: "The fact is that we can't account for the lack of warming at the moment and it is a travesty that we can't." But the warming is only missing if one believes computer models where so-called feedbacks involving water vapor and clouds greatly amplify the small effect of CO2.

The lack of warming for more than a decadeindeed, the smaller-than-predicted warming over the 22 years since the U.N.'s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) began issuing projectionssuggests that computer models have greatly exaggerated how much warming additional CO2 can cause. Faced with this embarrassment, those promoting alarm have shifted their drumbeat from warming to weather extremes, to enable anything unusual that happens in our chaotic climate to be ascribed to CO2.

The fact is that CO2 is not a pollutant. CO2 is a colorless and odorless gas, exhaled at high concentrations by each of us, and a key component of the biosphere's life cycle. Plants do so much better with more CO2 that greenhouse operators often increase the CO2 concentrations by factors of three or four to get better growth. This is no surprise since plants and animals evolved when CO2 concentrations were about 10 times larger than they are today. Better plant varieties, chemical fertilizers and agricultural management contributed to the great increase in agricultural yields of the past century, but part of the increase almost certainly came from additional CO2 in the atmosphere.

Although the number of publicly dissenting scientists is growing, many young scientists furtively say that while they also have serious doubts about the global-warming message, they are afraid to speak up for fear of not being promotedor worse. They have good reason to worry. In 2003, Dr. Chris de Freitas, the editor of the journal Climate Research, dared to publish a peer-reviewed article with the politically incorrect (but factually correct) conclusion that the recent warming is not unusual in the context of climate changes over the past thousand years. The international warming establishment quickly mounted a determined campaign to have Dr. de Freitas removed from his editorial job and fired from his university position. Fortunately, Dr. de Freitas was able to keep his university job.

More at:

Claude Allegre, former director of the Institute for the Study of the Earth, University of Paris; J. Scott Armstrong, cofounder of the Journal of Forecasting and the International Journal of Forecasting; Jan Breslow, head of the Laboratory of Biochemical Genetics and Metabolism, Rockefeller University; Roger Cohen, fellow, American Physical Society; Edward David, member, National Academy of Engineering and National Academy of Sciences; William Happer, professor of physics, Princeton; Michael Kelly, professor of technology, University of Cambridge, U.K.; William Kininmonth, former head of climate research at the Australian Bureau of Meteorology; Richard Lindzen, professor of atmospheric sciences, MIT; James McGrath, professor of chemistry, Virginia Technical University; Rodney Nichols, former president and CEO of the New York Academy of Sciences; Burt Rutan, aerospace engineer, designer of Voyager and SpaceShipOne; Harrison H. Schmitt, Apollo 17 astronaut and former U.S. senator; Nir Shaviv, professor of astrophysics, Hebrew University, Jerusalem; Henk Tennekes, former director, Royal Dutch Meteorological Service; Antonio Zichichi, president of the World Federation of Scientists, Geneva.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

In 2003, Dr. Chris de Freitas, the editor of the journal Climate Research, dared to publish a peer-reviewed article with the politically incorrect (but factually correct) conclusion that the recent warming is not unusual in the context of climate changes

Get a grip Len. The Journal "Climate Research" in a formal statement regreted publishing the 2003 study bySoon and Baliunas, because they did not do the critical peer review that should have been done. Chris De Freitas resigned from his editors post at Climate Research because of it. That same paper by the two named astrophysicists has been refuted by multiple climatologists in multiple papers which all have come to the conclusion that the two publishers used faulty statistical methods.

"The Spatial Extent of 20th-Century Warmth
in the Context of the Past 1200 Years" by Timothy J. Osborn and Keith R. Briffa

"On Past Temperatures and Anomalous Late-20th Century Warmth"

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Study: West Antarctic Glacier Melt Due To Volcanoes, Not Global Warming

Read more:

A new study by researchers at the University of Texas, Austin found that the West Antarctic Ice Sheet is collapsing due to geothermal heat, not man-made global warming.

Researchers from the UTAs Institute for Geophysics found that the Thwaites Glacier in western Antarctica is being eroded by the ocean as well as geothermal heat from magma and subaerial volcanoes. Thwaites is considered a key glacier for understanding future sea level rise.

UTA researchers used radar techniques to map water flows under ice sheets and estimate the rate of ice melt in the glacier. As it turns out, geothermal heat from magma and volcanoes under the glacier is much hotter and covers a much wider area than was previously thought.

Geothermal flux is one of the most dynamically critical ice sheet boundary conditions but is extremely difficult to constrain at the scale required to understand and predict the behavior of rapidly changing glaciers, UTA researchers wrote in their study , which was published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

The geothermal heat under the glaciers is likely a key factor in why the ice sheet is currently collapsing. Before this study, it was assumed that heat flow under the glacier was evenly distributed throughout, but UTAs study shows this is not the case. Heat levels under the glacier are uneven, with some areas being much hotter than others.

The combination of variable subglacial geothermal heat flow and the interacting subglacial water system could threaten the stability of Thwaites Glacier in ways that we never before imagined, lead researcher David Schroeder said in a press release .

Its the most complex thermal environment you might imagine, echoed co-author Don Blankenship And then you plop the most critical dynamically unstable ice sheet on planet Earth in the middle of this thing, and then you try to model it. Its virtually impossible.

Scientists and environmentalists have been pointing to Antarcticas collapsing western ice sheet as further evidence the planet is warming. NASA glaciologist Eric Rignot recently found that the western ice sheet collapse is unstoppable and could dramatically raise sea levels.

The highest storm surge from Hurricane Sandy, or Superstorm Sandy, was just under 13 feet, and a whole lot of places it was 10 feet or less, Penn State University glaciologist Richard Alley told Mother Jones Chris Mooney in a podcast .

And were looking at 11 feet, or something like that, from West Antarctica, Alley said. Plus a little thermal expansion [water expanding as it gets warmer] and some mountain glacier melting that are already on the table. And so you can sort of think of the storm surge of Hurricane Sandy, something vaguely in that neighborhood for most of the coastline of the world.

But reports of the western ice sheets collapse comes as Antarctic ice sheets continue to break records . At the end of May, Antarctic sea ice extent reached the highest level since measurements began in 1979.

Sea ice extent reached nearly 13 million square kilometers 10.3 percent above the 1981-2010 climatological average of 11.7 million square kilometers. The previous record was 12.7 million square kilometers set in 2010.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

The latest surveys show that 89 percent of Democrats, 79 percent of independents and 70 percent of Republicans already believe global warming is happening and is at least partly caused by human actions.

The Trenberth letter states: "Research shows that more than 97% of scientists actively publishing in the field agree that climate change is real and human caused." However, the claim of 97% support is deceptive. The surveys contained trivial polling questions that even we would agree with. Thus, these surveys find that large majorities agree that temperatures have increased since 1800 and that human activities have some impact.

But what is being disputed is the size and nature of the human contribution to global warming. To claim, as the Trenberth letter apparently does, that disputing this constitutes "extreme views that are out of step with nearly every other climate expert" is peculiar indeed.

One might infer from the Trenberth letter that scientific facts are determined by majority vote. Some postmodern philosophers have made such claims. But scientific facts come from observations, experiments and careful analysis, not from the near-unanimous vote of some group of people.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Pretty meaningless response Len.

The topic is validity of scientific data to support or refute global climate change. The 2003 paper by the astrophysicists Soon and Baliunas has been shown to be in error by many climate scientists in how they applied their statistics. In most scientific circles, the paper wouldn't have even met the requirement of peer review. But this is the paper (which was also funded by a $53,000 grant from the American Petroleum Institute) that science deniers/climate change deniers routinely hang their hat on.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

You complained about old papers even as you select a 12-year-old straw man.

The stuff I presented is far more recent. Unfortunately the copyright laws prevent a full copy and you need a WSJ subscription to access the links.

Now tell us how much each of the 16 authors received from the API for their article which is backed by many recent scientific papers.

Claude Allegre, former director of the Institute for the Study of the Earth, University of Paris; J. Scott Armstrong, cofounder of the Journal of Forecasting and the International Journal of Forecasting; Jan Breslow, head of the Laboratory of Biochemical Genetics and Metabolism, Rockefeller University; Roger Cohen, fellow, American Physical Society; Edward David, member, National Academy of Engineering and National Academy of Sciences; William Happer, professor of physics, Princeton; Michael Kelly, professor of technology, University of Cambridge, U.K.; William Kininmonth, former head of climate research at the Australian Bureau of Meteorology; Richard Lindzen, professor of atmospheric sciences, MIT; James McGrath, professor of chemistry, Virginia Technical University; Rodney Nichols, former president and CEO of the New York Academy of Sciences; Burt Rutan, aerospace engineer, designer of Voyager and SpaceShipOne; Harrison H. Schmitt, Apollo 17 astronaut and former U.S. senator; Nir Shaviv, professor of astrophysics, Hebrew University, Jerusalem; Henk Tennekes, former director, Royal Dutch Meteorological Service; Antonio Zichichi, president of the World Federation of Scientists, Geneva.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

You complained about old papers even as you select a 12-year-old straw man.

It is a paper that even one of your co-climate change deniers claims is the bedrock of your position today. On this very seed mind you....

To counter your 16 independent signatories to a WSJ article, I give you a statement by In 2005, which included the 2200 member of the INDEPENDENT National Academy of Science, the science academies of the G8 nations, plus science academies of Brazil , China , and India (three of the largest emitters of greenhouse gases in the developing world) signed a statement on the global response to climate change . The statement stresses that the scientific understanding of climate change had become sufficiently clear to justify nations taking prompt action

So I see your 16 signatories to a WSJ article and raise you by "X" number of thousands of scientists in support of an independent statement from the greater scientific community.

 
 

Who is online



114 visitors