FCC Commissioner EXPOSES Obama Net Neutrality plan, BLASTING him for hiding it from American people
Feb 6, 2015
Today, FCC Commissioner Ajit Pai released a statement on Obamas Net Neutrality plan to regulate the internet and blasted Obama for not releasing the plan publicly.
Last night, Chairman Wheeler provided his fellow Commissioners with President Obamas 332-page plan to regulate the Internet. I am disappointed that the plan will not be released publicly. The FCC should be as open and transparent as the Internet itself and post the entire document on its website. Instead, it looks like the FCC will have to pass the Presidents plan before the American people will be able to find out whats really in it .
He continues on to explain this horrible plan and it is a MUST READ:
In the coming days, I look forward to continuing to study the plan in detail. Based on my initial examination, however, several points are apparent.
First, President Obamas plan marks a monumental shift toward government control of the Internet :
It gives the FCC the power to micromanage virtually every aspect of how the Internet works. Its an overreach that will let a Washington bureaucracy, and not the American people, decide the future of the online world. Its no wonder that net neutrality proponents are already bragging that it will turn the FCC into the Department of the Internet. For that reason, if you like dealing with the IRS, you are going to love the Presidents plan.
Second, President Obamas plan to regulate the Internet will increase consumers monthly broadband bills :
The plan explicitly opens the door to billions of dollars in new taxes on broadband. Indeed, states have already begun discussions on how they will spend the extra money. These new taxes will mean higher prices for consumers and more hidden fees that they have to pay.
Third, President Obamas plan to regulate the Internet will mean slower broadband for American consumers :
The plan contains a host of new regulations that will reduce investment in broadband networks. That means slower Internet speeds. It also means that many rural Americans will have to wait longer for access to quality broadband.
Fourth, President Obamas plan to regulate the Internet will hurt competition and innovation and move us toward a broadband monopoly :
The plan saddles small, independent businesses and entrepreneurs with heavy-handed regulations that will push them out of the market. As a result, Americans will have fewer broadband choices. This is no accident. Title II was designed to regulate a monopoly. If we impose that model on a vibrant broadband marketplace, a highly regulated monopoly is what well get. We shouldnt bring Ma Bell back to life in this dynamic, digital age.
Fifth, President Obamas plan to regulate the Internet is an unlawful power grab :
Courts have twice thrown out the FCCs attempts at Internet regulation. Theres no reason to think that the third time will be the charm. Even a cursory look at the plan reveals glaring legal flaws that are sure to mire the agency in the muck of litigation for a long, long time.
And sixth, the American people are being misled about what is in President Obamas plan to regulate the Internet :
Tags
Who is online
104 visitors

Ajit Varadaraj Pai
As much traveling around as I do I really like it when I see my mobile phone is on some WIFI connection as I realize I'm not paying for it and I'm not using up my GBs, but this is really something to think about as the freedom we have now without giving the FCC the ability to hinder that freedom.
Obama has hidden and lied to us about damn near everything, why should this be any different? I am sure the MSM will help him out by ignoring it like they always do.
Good vids Six. Especially the second. It explains what is at stake well.
Oh no ... not again . Where is Pelosi to make that announcement ?
Petey, I like the internet just as it is now. The term "net neutrality" sounds good, but it reminds me of naming your white dog Blackie. It sounds like a good thing, but it is starting to feel like the little old lady with the candy house. It reminds me of a title that doesn't fit the book.
I won't a government to protect us, but I really despise a government that controls us. I'm not against government at all, just overreach by government.
It really does seem like they want to pass it to find out what is in it to me.
The Obama supporters seem to be avoiding this article. Go figure.
I realize the appointment to the FCC are for 5-year terms and selected by the President, but aren't they an independent commission reporting to the Congress? What prevents the commission from publicizing the President's net neutrality report?
The internet providers are starting to remind me of the telephone companies of days gone by. Creating monopolies leaving the consumer at the mercy of their exploits.
Curious how often we have to find out from someone else what the president is doing isn't it. Especially from someone who promised us transparency.
I would think if the president believed he was saving us from the evil monopolies and corporations he would be bragging about it. Wouldn't you?
I get the whole transparency issue, what I don't get is why this unhappy commissioner doesn't release the plan. After all it's the President's plan presented to the FCC. Obama is not implementing through Executive Order.
Maybe Obama supporters have a social life BF, why not try it, you may like it...
What Is Net Neutrality?
The ACLU Answers the Key Questions
Protect your right to access what you want and how you want it on the Internet
The Internet has become so much a part of the lives of most Americans that it is easy to imagine that it will always remain the free and open medium it is now. We'd like to believe it will remain a place where you can always access any lawful content you want, and where the folks delivering that content can't play favorites because they disagree with the message being delivered or want to charge more money for faster delivery.
But there are no such guarantees.
If the government doesn't act soon, this open internet and the "network neutrality" principles that sustain it could be a thing of the past. Profits and corporate disfavor of controversial viewpoints or competing services could change both what you can see on the Internet and the quality of your connection. And the need to monitor what you do online in order to play favorites means even more consumer privacy invasions piled on top of the NSA's prying eyes.
Don't let it happen. Read on to learn more about how you can help protect your free and open internet.
Q. Have there been any actual instances of service providers interfering with the Internet, or is this just all theoretical? A. Real abuses have happened consistently over the past decade ( see Abuses below ).
...in order to preserve its freedom and openness. Common carriage prohibits the owner of a network, that holds itself out to all-comers, from discriminating against information by halting, slowing, or otherwise tampering with the transfer of any data (except for legitimate network management purposes such as easing congestion or blocking spam).
Important Fact: Common carriage is not a new concept these rules have a centuries-old history. They have long been applied to facilities central to the public life and economy of our nation, including canal systems, railroads, public highways, and telegraph and telephone networks. In fact, common carrier rules have already been written into the Telecommunications Act of 1996 by Congress; they just need to be applied to broadband Internet communications by the FCC.
Now, if like the AOLs of yore the broadband provider is also providing information, tools to access the Internet or various types of multi-media content itself, it has the First Amendment right to control that content. Just providing "dumb" pipes meant to move data from user to user, however, is quintessential common carriage.
Q. What can I do?
Take action! Tell the FCC that it can and should immediately move to protect free speech, consumers and network neutrality either through reclassifying broadband providers as telecommunications services or acting to promote broadband deployment.
YOU HAVE TO CLICK ON THE ABOVE LINK TO BE TAKEN TO THE QUESTIONS THAT HAS ANSWERS SAYING (more)
CM, I'm with you! Have been trying to stay on top of this issue. The #1 priority for me is to NOT allow the communications conglomerates to rule the internet.
Lynne, If the FCC does not regulate the internet it will become like Ma Bell the old AT&T monopoly..
I will attempt to decipher the analysis of commissioner Aji Pai it is apparent to me that those are Republican views and not in the best interest of the consumer at large...
Using words from the Republican's Anthem regarding Obamacare..
So, this commissioner has not studied the details, but ready to give an analysis of a plan he has no details on..
First, President Obamas plan marks a monumental shift toward government control of the Internet:
More Republican talking points, nothing new he has to say, just repeat what he thinks the conservatives wants to hear..
Second, President Obamas plan to regulate the Internet will increase consumers monthly broadband bills:
What guarantee does this Republican Commissioner has that costs for internet access will not go up, it goes up every year, with competition costs is usually lower..
Third, President Obamas plan to regulate the Internet will mean slower broadband for American consumers:
Fourth, President Obamas plan to regulate the Internet will hurt competition and innovation and move us toward a broadband monopoly:
More Republican DRUMBEATS, Can they not come up with something more original???
Fifth, President Obamas plan to regulate the Internet is an unlawful power grab:
I don't know anything about the legal aspects, but from my view, this Commissioner is not willing to put in the hard work required for that the American Consumer could be the winners in the internet world...
And sixth, the American people are being misled about what is in President Obamas plan to regulate the Internet:
Yea, your opinion to which you are entitled..
It's just an expansion somewhat like Medicaid where everyone gets internet. Now I'm not against that, but it's just one more free phone paid by the tax paying individuals in my opinion as far as I can see.
I'm sure there is someone who actually knows more than I do about this. I would truly like to know more about it than I do. I can see the big companies not wanting to allow easy access into this area of business as a possibility.
Without the freedom we now have on the internet we wouldn't know about the IRS, NSA or several other things that have been brought to our attention. Of all the thousands of stations in this country, we only have 3 or 4 owners of all those stations, so the freedom we've had to receive good and bad information at least has allowed us the freedom to decipher what is true and what is not, disproving many of the mainstream media's lack of integrity in their reporting.
I honestly don't know enough about it to make a decision at this time. It does remind me of Obamacare and Nancy Pelosi's statement. Anything coming from the ACLU doesn't exactly make me take it for the truth, sorry.
Still I want to know more about this "Net Neutrality".
May not like the ACLU but they are there to protect the rights of individuals..
Not according to that Republican Commissioner of the FCC in Sixpick's article, he is trying to say Obama is lying and with the intervention of the FCC things will be bad for the consumer, he is not been truthful, just another GOP bait and switch...
I don't really know about that CM. Remember how everyone was going to get a $2500 reduction in premiums before we passed it? You can't take anything as being truthful from this liar, which has been proven so many times over. I don't want to pass it to find out what is in it. I wasn't one of the stupid Americans Grubber was talking about, remember.
Remember about all that transparency? All bills were going to be on the internet for 7 days or so for the American people to see them?
Lobbyist were going to be a thing of the past. Well that hasn't come to fruit at all. Just last week Obama met with a bunch of Muslim leaders privately. Obama supported Mursi in Egypt and right after the election the Muslim Brotherhood started Sharia Law.
The rich are getting richer 4 times as fast under Obama as Bush. The man's a liar and a fraud. He's basically a Muslim Brotherhood member in my opinion. Egypt is now doing business with Russia because of Mursi's ouster from office because we wouldn't provide anything to the Egyptians until the Muslim Brotherhood regained control.
I could go on and on about his lying and deceiving. He's the ice cream man and the stupid Americans are his subjects.
Just as I have said Sixpick, everyone is entitled to their opinion as crazy as some people's opinions may sound...they still have that right..
Yes you are absolutely correct. I do not care for liars and deceptive practices.
I don't know that much about "Net Neutrality" so I would like to see more about it. I haven't kept up with it. It sounds by the title a great thing. I would like to know my internet speed isn't being slowed down and someone else is faster although I can understand if someone else is paying more then I can understand why their speed would be faster, no different than someone paying more for a suit should get a better made suit.
If the cost of providing that faster speed is more expensive than a slower speed then I see no reason for not charging for that extra cost. If there is no extra cost to the provider then I see no problem.
I think most of us receive about the same speed as it is now as individuals. To pass the cost of increasing our speed to someone who is paying for the faster speed would seem to be similar to the free college, which most of us, I hope would know there is no free college, someone is going to pay for it.
Now if that extra cost is passed on to us for the faster speed then I see no problem in doing it. But I think some think we should get the faster speed at no additional cost, kind of like the "We're all born with different talents and abilities we either use or waste them, but in today's world we're all supposed to end up at the same level in life as a redistribution of benefits of our individual efforts.
Don't Extend the Dead Hand of the FCC to the Internet
Entrusting the FCC with broad and ambiguous regulatory powers was, and remains, a grave mistake.
No I don't and have made that clear. I don't know enough about it to make an intelligent decision on it at this time, but I would hope to learn more about it, so I put up the article. You say it is crap, but anyone can say that from either side of the issue. It isn't as simple as providing equal speed for all of us or is it? You tell me.
It's Time to Break Up AT&T,Verizon, Comcast, Time Warner and the Rest of the Telecoms
Today's telecoms provide overpriced and inferior service, and are systematically overcharging the hapless American consumer.
By David Rosen , Bruce Kushnick
At the dawn of the 20th century, the oil pipes defined America. As the 21st century emerges, the information pipes define America and the world.
A century ago, a courageous muckraker, Ida Tarbell, wrote a series of articles that lead to the breakup of Standard Oil, which had become a trust controlling the energy and associated industries to fix prices, restrict competition and harm the nation.
Today, the "communications trust" -- AT&T, Verizon and the major cable companies of Comcast and Time Warner -- controls the two wires and the wireless networks that link the nation's homes, businesses, schools and other institutions. The communications trust has failed America. A few examples illustrate this failure:
AT&T has proposed a major rate increase, known as "broadband caps," on high-volume video distribution targeting initially heavy movie users. This sets the stage for a two-tier pricing model that could effectively end net neutrality. The full effect of these and many other actions by the trust, working through "captured" FCC and state public utilities commissions (PUCs), will be the erosion of Universal Service, further harming those most vulnerable.
This is the first in a series of articles to be published on AlterNet channeling the approach pioneered by Tarbell and her compatriots. This spirit needs to infuse 21st century journalism with a sense of critical engagement. It targets the telecommunications trust and has three explicit goals:
Divestiture will lead to increased competition, lower costs and better service. Two landmark precedents set the stage for the call to "break 'em up" -- the 1983 breakup of AT&T and the 1948 Paramount breakup of the Hollywood studios control over theatrical movie distribution. In short, it's time to break 'em up, again.
A century ago the U.S. was wracked by a profound social crisis initiated by unprecedented industrialization. Unbridled capitalism was triumphant; ordinary citizens had no power, politicians were bought & paid for by the giant corporate trusts. Amidst this climate of oppression, a band of radical muckrakers emerged to challenge -- and, ultimate, overturn -- some of the tyranny of the trusts. As the 21st century takes shape, it is time for a new generation of muckrakers to challenge the trusts' conglomerate power.
Among the leading original muckrakers were Ida Tarbell and Lincoln Steffens. At the turn of the 20th century, Tarbell and Steffens published groundbreaking investigative reports in McClure's Magazine that led to two seminal books, The Rise of the Standard Oil Company and The Shame of the Cities . These works culminated in, respectively, the breakup of Standard Oil and good-government reform throughout the country. An insurgent presidential candidate, Teddy Roosevelt -- who actually named them "muckrakers" -- championed their critiques and helped change American politics and business.
Trusts now dominate the major sectors of the American economy, be it finance and banking, pharmaceuticals and health care, extraction and energy, agriculture and food or communications and the media.
Sadly, the breakup of most of the trusts is unlikely to happen given the power the giant conglomerates exercise over national political life. For example, we are still reeling from the nation's gravest financial crisis since the Great Depression. The banks once deemed "too big to fail" have only gotten bigger and more powerful. The well-intentioned legislative effort at financial reform, the Dodd-Frank Act, is turning out to be a fig leaf that conceals crises still to come.
However, a breakup of the telecom trust is feasible. It will return competition to American communications and media, thus lowering charges paid by citizens and businesses for overpriced yet inferior service. In addition, it will enhance the performance of the nation's telecommunications infrastructure. Most importantly, it will strength popular democracy. There is no social downside to such a breakup; the only losers will be the overpaid corporate executives and institutional shareholders.
The telecom trust is systematic ripping off the American consumer. Three examples are illustrative:
Forgotten today, the breakup of AT&T took nearly a decade to wind its way through the courts. It began in 1974 with MCI's anti-trust lawsuit. The suit was picked up by the Carter administration; it charged AT&T with violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act. The suit charged AT&T with monopolizing long-distance service and equipment manufacture largely through the exclusionary practices of its local operating companies. At that time, AT&T was America's largest corporate and, in 1956, during the Eisenhower administration, it had successfully suppressed a similar antitrust suit.
The Reagan administration was fiercely divided over the breakup of AT&T, yet pursued divesture until it was accomplished. As with most matters of state, Reagan couldn't care less; however, his public identity was ideologically committed to "competition," thus putting him publicly on the side of the trustbusters. Nevertheless, many within his inner circle had close ties to AT&T and sought repeatedly to kill the court challenge. As Steve Coll shows in his informative book, The Deal of the Century, strong public and media pressure, a resolute anti-trust prosecutor and a committed federal judge sealed AT&T's fate.
Ironically, Reagan's antitrust push for "deregulation" was designed to "open the networks" to competition. Today, the telecom trust has turned "deregulation" on its head, embracing it to protect incumbents from competition and to keep the networks closed.
In every ad, Americans are told the nation's communication's system is the best in the world. The truth is quite different: we are getting inferior services at higher rates with less competition. Most disappointing, the U.S. Congress, the FCC and PUCs have been complicit in maintaining this fiction, thus facilitating the fleecing of the American public.
According to Open Secrets , the "telephone utilities" spent $43.2 million on lobbying in 2009. Corporate representatives and hired hacks have effectively taken over many "captured" federal and state regulatory agencies. With appropriate mea culpas to the public good, they blindly approve rate increases, massive tax breaks, accelerated depreciation allowances and mergers that further consolidate the telecommunications monolith. The FCC is effectively ending net neutrality.
Making matters worse, America is falling behind as a post-industrial nation, the result of the telecom trust's self-serving profiteering. In a June 2010 report, Europe's Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) ranked the U.S. 15th in "broadband" subscribers. Adding injury to insult, according to Akamai, a leading technology services company, the U.S. ranked 22nd globally in average connection data rate speed, averaging only 3.8 megabytes per second in Q-4 2009. In comparison, Korea's average data rate was nearly three times faster (11.7-mbp/s), Hong Kong's more then twice as fast (8.6-mbp/s) and even Romania had an average rate of 7.2-mbp/s. U.S. service is pathetic.
The consolidating "telecommunications trust" consists of the dominant duopoly of telephone and cable companies as well as the wireline and wireless content distribution conglomerates. It is ripe for disaggregation.
America's regulatory policy, which has promoted mergers and acquisitions rather than meaningful competition, has encouraged the trust to take over communications with harmful results. Two disturbing facts illustrate the power of the trust:
Making matters worse, 18 states outlaw municipal competition. The trust has had state legislatures adopt regulations prohibiting localities from upgrading their networks even though these corporations failed to do so after being paid billions.
Unfortunately waiting for the Congress, courts or regulatory agencies (e.g., FCC, FTC) to intervene on behalf of ordinary citizens being overcharged, let alone America's global competitiveness or popular democracy, is like waiting for Samuel Beckett's Godot. We'll wait till hell freezes over.
Like the good-old-days of the trusts, the Gilded Age, politicians are bought and paid for. Unless one puts a fire under their proverbial backsides, one knows that politicians -- along with PR shills, newspaper publishers, think-tank hacks and media blowviators -- cannot be counted on to stand up for what's right. Its time for a new generation of muckrakers to take up the challenge, incite popular rage and, hopefully, fuel political action.In a series of upcoming articles published on AlterNet, we will critically analyze the hold that the telecom trust exercises over the nation's communications infrastructure, the economy and, thus, American democracy. It's time to recall Reagan's monumental antitrust effort at "deregulation" and, once again, "open the networks" to competition.
Like vampires of legend, today's trusts not only provide over-priced and inferior service, but are sucking dry hapless American consumer by systematically overcharging them. Worst still, their inferior service is turning the U.S. into a second-tier industrial nation. Only a stake in the heart of a vampire will kill it. The call to "break 'em up" is such a steak.
Court Decision to Invalidate Net Neutrality Rules Will Impact Artists
A couple of weeks ago, a federal appeals court invalidated the Federal Communications Commission network neutrality or open internet rules. The rules prevented internet service providers from prioritizing certain applications or content, or blocking access to others.
Though the court affirmed the FCC's ability to regulate internet service providers and its option to redo the rules, the decision currently leaves both consumers and creators with no real regulatory protections. As the Writers Guild of America West noted in a statement on the decision, "The [ruling] is a blow to competition, consumers and content creators. An open Internet has already begun to offer myriad new sources for news, information and entertainment. To allow the Internet to succumb to corporate forces who seek to control what consumers can access undermines the open, democratic principles on which the Internet was founded."
The Internet has become the critical distribution channel for artists and their work. It has opened new opportunities to reach and engage audiences, reduced the need for gatekeepers and middlemen, and established powerful new fundraising channels. These have blossomed because artists, entrepreneurs, application developers, and web designers have all been allowed to "innovate without permission" and reach the public on a level playing field.
But the loss of network neutrality rules means that cable and telephone companies are now free to pick winners and losers online. They can prioritize traffic from one company over another, limit or prohibit the use of certain applications, or cut exclusive deals with content companies, while potentially blocking access to others. These practices will make it harder and more expensive for artists and creators to reach the public.